I think lots of horses have already "joined up" without us realising it happens, like NF said lunging is a similar action, and pushing them out of your space in the field, through a gateway etc, some don't need to do 50 laps before they choose to befriend a passive/assertive leader (their owner going about their business).As for join up. I read the book and liked the idea but I did not have access to a round pen so never tried it. Then one day I had a bolshy disrespectful 3 yo on loan. I was putting out a salt lick in the field and he charged me. I used very assertive body language and swung the leadrope at him to drive him away. He circled me bucking and making threatening gestures and I kept him away from me. After a while I noticed he had dropped his head and was doing the classic submissive gestures. So I dropped my assertive stance and invited him in. He then did the classic following me about. So I just thought 'great I'm now his herd leader, join up is fab!' So I set up a round pen for Charlie and decided to join up with him too. But his reaction was totally different. He seemed fearful and bewildered. Why was I sending him away? What had he done wrong? I soon realised he had no desire to join up at all. He was very keen to get as far from me as possible! And who could blame him? It took me a while to repair the damage to his trust. So I decided join up may have a place in horsemanship but I was not experienced enough to know when to use it and when to leave well alone.
I think we all assume an alpha role, that doesn't mean we bully the horse to submission, there is a difference between a passive/assertive alpha and an aggressive alpha. If we were not alpha would our horse (those who have not already been taught this lesson by whatever means) not question everything we ask? (survival instinct) The differences between Bo and Jess were huge, Bo was like a lost puppy, just wanted to please (for the most part until he got over excited then often forgot boundries