"one rider" horses

we have a 5 year old pony. She comes across as quite confident but we have had issues about going forward in the school that I believe are confidence related. At the end of the day, it didn't really matter why she was not going forward as the solution was going to be the same... but then I went to long reining her and that seems to have helped a lot.

Anyway, the long reining isn't the point... the other weekend we had quite a good session in the morning with her usual rider (not me, she is 12.2 and I am too heavy). In the afternoon we had a little girl and her mum visit. We have had little children on her before as lead rein and she is fine with that (gets the confidence from the leader). But this time the mum had a quick sit as well, and the pony reverted and showed clear signs of being worried and wanting to get back to a comfort zone (near a person) as soon as possible.

I wonder whether for youngsters or newly backed horses, their confidence is actually quite fragile and some horses struggle to adapt quickly to a new/different rider (where an older more experienced horse would adapt so quickly there would be no issue ?)

That or she might have been doing the dominant mare thing ? It is always the dominant horse who invites/initiates contact. So if this mare figured she was boss over these folks and they just approached her, she would do her best to see them off ? (over simplifying, but you get what I mean ?)
 
she is a dominant horse, she is very much in your face, and you have to ask her rather than tell her, however i have got to a point with her now where i ask and she says "ok".

It took time to build this realationship with her, becasue she was always used to having her own way, and hd never been stood up to by a human before.

She is strongly motivated by food, is very clever,but also very laid back. Cant see the point in runnign round the field with the other horses, when she can just stand and eat the grass.

She almost seems to look down on new handlers, like they are not even there, she will quite happliy barge past them, or walk over them not giving a hoot if she gets shouted at, ot gets a slap on the shoulder. she really is not worried easily.

she also tried to dominant all the horses in the field, and would rather graze alone than to submit to the boss of the field.

the boss of the field being a gelding and being boss over his 6 other mares, he had a shock when he decided to get kesera into his little group and she gave him hell.

every now and again you can see one of the mares leave the gelding group and go to be with kesera, much to the geldings hprror, who then goes to get his mare back. By witch point the mare is hiding behind kesera, who runs at the gelding with the most horrid look on her face.

I think it is becasue she knows where she stands with me, i am consistant with my rules. I think she finds comfort in that.
 
I think that (whilst that is very often the case), there's also another "group" of horses who don't conform to that rule.

I've known (as I'm sure many of us have) extremely well schooled horses, (who've been in very experienced homes all their lives) be completely ruined by riding schools.
They've been sold/put on working livery mid-way through their lives, and despite their education having been "set" by their former, knowledgable owners, they still deteriorate.
That's not at all to say the riding schools were cruel (the horses didn't seem to mind one bit :) ), but after afew years of having mostly novices on their backs (who don't ask them to work hard - ie, in an outline, bending etc), they give the more experienced of riders real trouble.

Of course, one could argue that after being allowed to work badly for a while they don't have the muscle capacity to work correctly. But I'm not just talking "outlines" here (or anything fitness related for that matter) - any manner of things which require them to work harder/ do something they don't feel like doing can set them off.

I suppose the point is, that most horses are animals who like routine and learn by repetition. In the riding school case, they've learnt a new way of life and some don't like having that altered.
That's not to say it can't be "re-versed." It's not even to say that a horse who'd never had any experienced rider on them can't be trainind into a fantastic horse. Far from it.
But the above example is a classic one :) .

As for not believing in one person horses, if you look back at my original post you'll see I did actually say. . .
"That's not to say the "problem" can't be worked around and improved upon" ;) .
But I still stand by what I said - some horses (like people) do favour having just one rider. But you're entitled to your opinion :) .

Mhmm, I can see your point. I know that most horses enjoy a routine more then anything. However, I think the intial problem is letting young horses becoming acclimatized to strictly one rider and one rider's style.

But as you said, it can be reversed, eventually.
 
newrider.com