"one rider" horses

hobnob

Horse squasher!
Oct 31, 2006
65
0
0
45
lancashire.uk
www.clarzthingz.piczo.com
Is there really any way to stop a horse from becoming a "one rider" horse?

I have tried 2 other riders on my loan horse, one of the riders is 7 stone and a very light, balanced good rider. the other rider is about 11ish stone, a bit more noivicey, but still balanced and a quet rider.

yet both provocked a reaction from the horse of ears pinned back, planting, and buckling. as well as napping, spinning and trying to reverse.

i got on the horse before and after the other rider, and the horse was imidiatly more relaxed, supple and forward going.

why is this?

one of the riders was a rider i used as the first person to sit on the horse, so the horse does know her.

i am concerned as the horse is on loan to me for around 4-5 years, and i am worried she may not accept her owner riding her?

This woudl not be good. I have had this happen to me before with 3 other mares i have own. All 3 became one rider horses, and when it came to selling them it was almost impossible.

Why do you think it keeps happening? strangely it never happens with the geldings i have had.
 
yes, thats right becasue she is a youngster i have not lept at the opertunity to allow many peopel to ride her. The only reason in fact i allowed the 2 i have is becasue one was the first to sit on her and the other is a friend who i knew would ride her lightly and balanced, in both occasions both riders on asked for walk in the indoor school where the horse was used to being worked.

i suppose all i can do for now is to work on building the horses confidence forst and maybe allow another rider on her when she is a bit older.
 
Even just the different people walking on her will be helping. She probably just needs to get to trust her riders first, understandable in such a young horse. So for now id keep on asking other people just to have a walk on her, it wont do her any harm!
 
yes thats sounds a good idea.
i have to admit thought it was quite a shock to see such a violent reaction out of her, and goes to show i suppose that it is not nesseserily light riders that horses prefer over heavier riders. i suppose it depends on the style of riding and weather you have abond.
 
This might sound silly, but maybe she likes the security of knowing someones up there :rolleyes: That sounds daft actually, but its possible. Along with you having a bond with her, she may just feel safe :confused: :o
 
she is a very , very laid back mare. who is tottaly unphazed by everything.
she can be bargy to people who let her get away with it. she was very bargy when i got her, but once she realised she coudl nto get away with it she stopped being bargy with me.

it did look liek a major case of trying it on with both riders, even when the riders where firmer after askign nicely , she then decided it was war, and rather than say "ok i give in" her ears went back she she started to try and get the rider of her back. i have never seen her act this way,even when i had introduced new things to her.

if it is a case of her choosing me , well i feel priviledged.
 
I really think the only way to prevent it is to have an experienced rider get on. If a horse is always ridden by inexperienced riders, and then has one person who semi-knows what they are doing, chances are, they will perform better and prefer being ridden by the more experienced ones.

It's why when we start our young horses, they get professionally started, but also get little tune ups and go to clinics to have other more experienced people ride them
 
... or alternatively, it's because she doesn't accept someone on her back, with whom she has no relationship. I wouldn't. Perhaps she needs these 'random people' to talk to her mare-to-woman on the ground before she will accept that they are brave, honest and a good person to follow. Else she'll just kick them off, and go back to listening to what her Momma says.
 
I really think the only way to prevent it is to have an experienced rider get on. If a horse is always ridden by inexperienced riders, and then has one person who semi-knows what they are doing, chances are, they will perform better and prefer being ridden by the more experienced ones.

That's an interesting take on the situation, but I'm not sure I agree :cool: .
Well. . . actually. . . I don't disagree at all :p , it's more that I think there's much more to it than that.

Firstly, I tend to find that whilst the above point is absolutely true, the opposite is also equally viable :) .
For example - you frequently get riding school plods who happily take any amount of beginners yanking at them and booting them in the wrong place - as long as they're not required to work in an outline, or bend correctly etc.
Yet, the second a more experienced rider asks more of them, they're total nightmares!

Secondly, I think we have to allow a little for personal preference (the horse's - not the human's ;) ). Like people, perhaps some horses are just one person animals. I've certainly known afew who were that way inclined.
That's not to say the "problem" can't be worked around and improved upon, but if they're that type - they're that type.

Thirdly, I agree whole heartedly with Kate's point.
Ruby is not a "one person horse" - but she does need to get to know someone before she'll go well for them. She hates change - it makes her pannicky, and a new rider is enough change to cause upset.
I absolutely dread ever having to sell her! From experience of others having a go on her, I'd have to advise the viewer to visit her several times - the first few just to groom her, then to lunge her and let her adjust to their voice, then to catch and feed her, then finally (on about the tenth visit :p ) to try riding her.
Otherwise, they'd get an appaulingly bad picture of what she was like.

And fourthly, I believe you have to account for riding styles. It's not always necessarily that the horse dislikes others - it could be that they like to be worked a certain way (and by co-incidence more than anything - their current rider fits their criteria).
There's a horse at my local yard who (unlike the riding school ponies in the first example I gave) will work beautifully for anyone of any level. But if you tip your lower leg back he'll whizz off like a snake's bitten him! I'm not talking "kicking him" or "moving your leg back to his hindquarters", he's just very used to his rider riding with quite a still and forward leg (she's also very short so her feet don't reach his belly area ;) ).
 
Last edited:
Sugar is very much a one-person horse. She will only allow my husband on her back if I am present (not that we get to test that theory a lot!) and beyond that no one mounts. Even my instructor who she liked tried to get on and Sugar actually reared at her (small rear), which really shocked me. But she will tolerate a child of any age to get on and take excellent care of them when they are.

I always thought this was due to her abuse by past owners. I didn't realize a well cared for horse would become so upset by a new rider.
 
Funnily enough my appaloosa is exactly the same, an angel for me and any kid, nightmare for anyone else who doesnt know their stuff (which I definately don't) crazy but strangely loveable. That said, it could be that you need to get new riders to work from the ground first and get some respect and a working relationship that way.

Good luck
 
I really think the only way to prevent it is to have an experienced rider get on. If a horse is always ridden by inexperienced riders, and then has one person who semi-knows what they are doing, chances are, they will perform better and prefer being ridden by the more experienced ones.

It's why when we start our young horses, they get professionally started, but also get little tune ups and go to clinics to have other more experienced people ride them

well i am her main rider and i am also the person who has taught her to lunge, longrein and everythign else. i am not sure what you mean by this statement?
i have been backing horses for over 10 years, as well as working with problem horses. are you saying i am inexperieanced? or am the person who semi knows what they are doing?

what do you call professioanlly started?
someone who has a sign on there frount door and has there nam ein a relephone book?
or someone who has worked with horses for over 17 years and has always worked with youngsters?


Just about every horse i have worked with that has had problems of varying types, where actually sent away to these so called professional yards.
 
Last edited:
i guess it's like with human parnetrs; you find your soulmate, ans that's that.
yes there is love afetr love, but often it's still n ot the same.
when i found my equine soulmate i knew instantly "this isspecial, this is different" but i have to face the fact that i will probably never see him again...he was never mine.
maybe its's like this with you two - and no other is second-best?
 
That's an interesting take on the situation, but I'm not sure I agree :cool: .
Well. . . actually. . . I don't disagree at all :p , it's more that I think there's much more to it than that.

Firstly, I tend to find that whilst the above point is absolutely true, the opposite is also equally viable :) .
For example - you frequently get riding school plods who happily take any amount of beginners yanking at them and booting them in the wrong place - as long as they're not required to work in an outline, or bend correctly etc.
Yet, the second a more experienced rider asks more of them, they're total nightmares!

But see, my take on that would be that they've been allowed to become that way. If they are CONSTANTLY ridden by beginners all their life, they probably will be resentful of anyone with a degree of experience. Which is why most schooling barns should (and most do) have one or two riders who school the horses, keeps them better in shape, and also keeps them fresh to the aids, and they respond so much better.

there's no question that personal preference plays a part. God knows there was this one horse who I hated-and he hated me as well. Bucked, reared, yet you could put anyone else on him, and he'd go along with a smile on his face :p but he and I did not mesh whatsoever, and it was a life lesson for me, because up until that point, I never worked with a horse who I couldn't get results from.

I honestly do not believe in one-person horses. Life isn't like the Black Stallion ;) You'll come across a horse who doesn't like a specific riding style, or come across one who just plain doesn't like you, but that doesn't mean someone else can't ride. You'll get difficult horses who need to be understood, definately...a while ago, I posted about an abused mare Vicki, who hated people working with her. I spent 1 month on the ground just working with her before I got on her, and then 4 months later, she was showing 1st level and is now sold to a Pony Clubber and doing beautifully. But I honestly have yet to come across one horse who cannot be ridden by another given a little bit of time.

Which is what prompted my "have an experienced rider get on"...and hobnob, it's not to say that you aren't experienced. Even Grand Prix riders have other riders get on their horses. The more a young horse is experienced to different riders-ones who still know what they are doing-the more willing they are to learn and accept new things without making a fight out of it.
 
i agreethat the fact she did notwrk with the ther rders and was allowed to get away with it, shoed that the riders mus not of been experienced enougth t deal with ther.
witch i why despite the fact that yes, ok i will hold my hands up and say , yes i may not be the worlds gratest rider. i dont allow hores to get away with tings. so that is hy i neverhave a problem with her.

i suppose i sould be gtting other experienced riders to ride her as well.
 
But see, my take on that would be that they've been allowed to become that way. If they are CONSTANTLY ridden by beginners all their life, they probably will be resentful of anyone with a degree of experience.
I honestly do not believe in one-person horses

I think that (whilst that is very often the case), there's also another "group" of horses who don't conform to that rule.

I've known (as I'm sure many of us have) extremely well schooled horses, (who've been in very experienced homes all their lives) be completely ruined by riding schools.
They've been sold/put on working livery mid-way through their lives, and despite their education having been "set" by their former, knowledgable owners, they still deteriorate.
That's not at all to say the riding schools were cruel (the horses didn't seem to mind one bit :) ), but after afew years of having mostly novices on their backs (who don't ask them to work hard - ie, in an outline, bending etc), they give the more experienced of riders real trouble.

Of course, one could argue that after being allowed to work badly for a while they don't have the muscle capacity to work correctly. But I'm not just talking "outlines" here (or anything fitness related for that matter) - any manner of things which require them to work harder/ do something they don't feel like doing can set them off.

I suppose the point is, that most horses are animals who like routine and learn by repetition. In the riding school case, they've learnt a new way of life and some don't like having that altered.
That's not to say it can't be "re-versed." It's not even to say that a horse who'd never had any experienced rider on them can't be trainind into a fantastic horse. Far from it.
But the above example is a classic one :) .

As for not believing in one person horses, if you look back at my original post you'll see I did actually say. . .
"That's not to say the "problem" can't be worked around and improved upon" ;) .
But I still stand by what I said - some horses (like people) do favour having just one rider. But you're entitled to your opinion :) .
 
newrider.com