Now stop worrying!

I think the word that got up my nose was the "damaging" one.

Every single person on here or that I know is in their view damaging the horse in their care, in some way.
I understand how horses have evolved, I understand their basic needs, I also know how they adapt-but I do not feel we are damaging them. So is bhs is teaching everyone how to damage their horse?

Sad to say I had instructor who would tell people to get a bike if they didn't do it all naturally! Its just impossible for every single horse to be out unrugged, we haven't the land, and the thin skinned would be unrideable due to rain scald, mud fever and other ailments.
Not all horses would survive if humans suddenly died off, the fittest would as is now.
 
I find it odd that it was taken in the hysterical manner some took it in. I read it as an interesting article addressing how an animal, who in now mostly domesticated copes in the wild and how, it is still able to cope in the wild should all the humans disappear from their lives.

If you are going to keep any animal and put him to work, is it not fair that you read a bit and try to get even the very basic understanding of how he has evolved for thousands of years, and they try your best to provide him with all the things he has evolved to need.
Horses in the wild die from bad teeth, nobody is going to deny them tooth and veterinary care because they would not get it in the wild....
As for breast is best....it is, even foals get raised on the bottle, but only in extreme circumstances.

Surely most would die if all humans disappeared from the world suddenly, as the majority are too domesticated to cope with a sudden return to the wild?(Assuming the landscape suddenly returned to some kind of natural state in this fictional apocalypse and all the horses weren't trapped in fields and stables!)

I shouldn't have mentioned the 'breast is best' thing even for metaphorical purposes - I'm just thankful those days are behind me! ;)
 
Very interesting so thanks for posting.

It has left me questioning how Bens body copes with having part of it covered in an increasingly thick winter coat, and half of it clipped off (as he is blanket clipped)?

Also, what exactly do they mean by 'forceful exercise'? I guess this is any exercise which isn't initiated by the horse, so therefore refers to all riding. If they are suggesting that horses shouldn't be ridden at all during the winter because we are interfering with their bodily functions, surely the same could be argued for the summer as well. The summer brings it's only challenges in terms of heat, flies, lack of grass etc. Are they really saying that horses should not be ridden and kept in big fields to cope on their own? This doesn't offer much in the way of practical advice for the average horse owner and I can see why some replies on this thread have felt annoyed by the lack of practical or realistic guidance.
 
Mp-your Ben will have a similar coat to mine, almost double thickness. Reading the article it says they don't cool down as easily as they can warm up. That's why I did a bib because she was coming in overcooked. She was sweating and overheating not being able to cool herself down. Now she only gets a bit sweaty, nothing like she was, so she is now able to cool down.
The view on my yard was that sweating is good and burns fat, no work does that but not if she collapses from heat exhaustion. If hot she is really really unhappy.
 
Last edited:
Very interesting, I dont clip or rug in winter, and he gets as much turn out as possible, and he more or less gets turned away, only light hacking once or twice a week in really dark winter.

But this is all by accident because this fits in with how I want to manage him. if I didnt have to work full time and basically only see him in the dark during the week I might be more inclined to ride and need to clip him, which means I would have to rug because he would sweat too much with a full Fell winter coat on.

As to shoes, we tried bare foot all round, but have gone back to front shoes as he never really stopped being footy after a nearly 9 months. He is much happier with his shoes back on.

I think we have to accept that we chose to keep horses, and there will always be a compromise between ideal conditions and what is acheivable in the real world, ie we have work and other commitments and the horses have to be kept in a way that allows it to be possible for us. As long as horse owners have an understanding of what the ideal is, and all do what we can to achieve it as far as practicable and what suits the individual horse, thats a fair deal for all concerned.
 
Very interesting so thanks for posting.



Also, what exactly do they mean by 'forceful exercise'? I guess this is any exercise which isn't initiated by the horse, so therefore refers to all riding. .

I took it mean exercise energetic enough to make the horse sweat. With Hebe, the most I can achieve is a slight warmth under the girth. I always get sweaty before she does ...:frown:
 
I took it mean exercise energetic enough to make the horse sweat. With Hebe, the most I can achieve is a slight warmth under the girth. I always get sweaty before she does ...:frown:

The stallions and colts will charge about and play and play until their sides are heaving and they are dripping with sweat!
 
I jumped Ben this morning, and despite being clipped he was dripping and steam was coming off him. I didn't work him excessively, but he loves his jumping and puts all his effort into it. I wouldn't have said he had any problem cooling down though - a 15 minute walk round the big field was enough to get him back to normal again, although his unclipped bits were still damp.
 
I couldn't leave Alfie unclipped, I would take more off if I could but it's going to be a slow process to get him to accept the clippers.

He's also rugged sooner than the others to attempt to slow his coat a little and that has worked this year. He doesn't get a thick coat his just grows long, which then means when he gets wet he doesn't have that undercoat that stays dry. When he was a yearling he looked terrible after being left unrugged so the following year when it was wet he wore his lightweight, otherwise he managed without.

All 4 of mine are out they have a big tree they can stand under as shelter and this serves them well. They stay out 24/7/365 and for as long as they manage that way they will stay as so. It has meant feeding two of them extra in the day as they aren't so good at keeping weight on but I'm hoping I won't have to feed them any extra once they are on winter routine as they will all be getting an extra 2 lots of hay in the day, as it is the grass is sustaining 2 of them well but not the other 2.

At the end of the day we don't all have the ability to keep them in perfect conditions. In the wild a horse would cover many miles to graze and keep warm, because they could. In domestic situations we don't have that ability and so we have to supplement them. Some people don't have the luxury of herd turnout or even shelters in the fields. Whether natural or not and so in the worst of it they have to come in.

We can't all keep them in an ideal situation and so we have to try and strike the best balance for them as possible.
 
We can't all keep them in an ideal situation and so we have to try and strike the best balance for them as possible.

...and you can only strike a balance once you have a good working knowledge of how they live in the wild, how their brain has evolved, their diet in the wild and their basic natural reactions to the environment they are given.
 
newrider.com