Now stop worrying!

That's an interesting article, but poses at least as many questions as it purports to answer though doesn't it?

It would seem to me (based on nothing practical other than observation of the 3 livery yards in the village where I live) that to maintain the living conditions for the horse suggested (ie 24/7 turnout; free access to shelter as and when required by the horse; natural herds etc) would be difficult for the majority of leisure owners who use livery, though you'd hope the forage and hoof care management would be suitable wherever the horse lived. Surely to aproximate that ideal you'd need your own land with your own horses (plural) so that you can be in charge of every aspect of management. That's proposing a massive cultural shift in the horse keeping population (clumsily phrased, but you get my point I hope).

I do understand that an unclipped horse can keep itself warm in adverse weather very effectively. But working would seem to go hand in hand with clipping and rugging for the horses' comfort I would have thought? Are you (or the writer of the article to be precisie) therefore advocating turning horses away each winter?

No bone to pick - just interested. It's all academic for me!
 
even if you have your own land, often it is not enough to keep a horse out 24/7 without wrecking the pasture so that the horse would simply be standing in mud 24/7 - ours come in at night, so we are beyond the pale according to this.

I could leave them with their doors open so they could go out on the yard, but then if two horses get into same stable and have a disagreement and get injured, not sure I could go for that - I certainly couldn't trust Bud, Rose or Suze not to kick another horse as Bud tends to herd them. so I would have to convert all my stables to open fronted boxes so they couldn't get stuck in - but you get injuries even in field shelters like that where a horse gets bullied and cornered.

It might be possible in very rural areas where land is cheap, but that is not where the majority of horses are kept.
 
Very interesting i keep mine out 24/7 although they do have sheds they can wander in and out of. I think diplomatic raises a good point about paddocks becoming poached and turning into a sea of mud. I only have a couple of acres which is fine for one horse and one shetland it is also on a slight slope which means the water runs off, the gates are filled with rubble so they have hard standings where they tend to stand. Due to all these factors they are happier out than in, winter is not a problem because i just put out a full bale in a shed held in place with pallets tied together so their hay is ad lib. However, it is a personal choice and i would never get dogmatic about it but my preference is for them being out and i do believe they are better for it but that is only my opinion. Either way is fine as it is the overall welfare of the animal that is what counts and what they are used to. My friends horse waits at the gate at night to get brought in come winter while mines would kick the place to bits if they were kept in its hard enought doing this when they are ill or lame. If you listened to what all the experts said you would be too frightened to keep horses in case you were doing it wrong.
 
From the article
"Under human care that respects the horse's natural needs, and provides it doesn't make this animal a subject for anthropomorphism through stabling, changing eating habits, blanketing, clipping, shoeing, etc., the domestic horse is able to properly use its amazing natural thermoregulatory abilities exactly the same way as the wild horse.

Let's take a deeper look into how the thermoregulatory mechanisms work in the horse, and how it can be interfered with and damaged through unnatural care and keeping practices."




Jeez so everyone who owns a horse is damaging them, brilliant let's all abandon our hobby! Bad human I clipped, bad human I am using boots.

This is some of our grazing. She has access to about 45 acres, a mixed group, two stallions-not on my list of let's play with them! Access to man made and natural shelter at all times, varied terrain.

https://db.tt/BRKrQ8NU

It has to be remembered that our horse are NOT wild and are in fact living in captivity, born into such for most. They are talking about cold weather, we in the UK tend to get wet and cold.
I like the documentary I watched called Cloud, it clearly showed the weak ones didn't make it, there were no humans calling vets, they lived or died. With us we wouldn't leave a horse totally to its devices to see if it lived or oh I have a weak one and letting it suffer and die.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for posting Wally, I found it fascinating and am mostly pleased that Belle is kept as far as possible as naturally as possible.
I used to worry about her being wet and cold, I have seen and felt when she looks soaked, as in the article her hair next to her body is bone dry and toasty warm, I've also noticed that if she gets slightly sweaty from exercise if I leave her be she will go and stand at the top of the hill which is usually windy! I used to worry that she'd catch a chill but so far she's been fine, I also put her out after exercise as I also noticed that if she was left in the stable to cool down it took her a lot longer and in fact she sweated more, I have also noticed that now it's really chilly she doesn't really get sweaty anyway as we don't work hard.
I did consider clipping this year and upping her work load but have decided to stick with the little we do and leave her be.
I guess I am one of the lucky ones who despite being on a livery yard we can pretty much manage our horses as we like, the only thing I don't like is we have to have individual turnout :( I have even thought about getting her a companion which my YO would be fine about and I have enough paddock, but I just can't afford two neddys. Plus of course her breeding means she can cope pretty much with anything this country throws at her weather wise.
 
From the article
"Under human care that respects the horse's natural needs, and provides it doesn't make this animal a subject for anthropomorphism through stabling, changing eating habits, blanketing, clipping, shoeing, etc., the domestic horse is able to properly use its amazing natural thermoregulatory abilities exactly the same way as the wild horse.

Let's take a deeper look into how the thermoregulatory mechanisms work in the horse, and how it can be interfered with and damaged through unnatural care and keeping practices."




Jeez so everyone who owns a horse is damaging them, brilliant let's all abandon our hobby! Bad human I clipped, bad human I am using boots.

This is some of our grazing. She has access to about 45 acres, a mixed group, two stallions-not on my list of let's play with them! Access to man made and natural shelter at all times, varied terrain.

https://db.tt/BRKrQ8NU

It has to be remembered that our horse are NOT wild and are in fact living in captivity, born into such for most. They are talking about cold weather, we in the UK tend to get wet and cold.
I like the documentary I watched called Cloud, it clearly showed the weak ones didn't make it, there were no humans calling vets, they lived or died. With us we wouldn't leave a horse totally to its devices to see if it lived or oh I have a weak one and letting it suffer and die.

That article just annoyed me to be honest.

If only I had the unlimited funds to purchase that large area of well fenced natural terrain with natural shelter. Life would be grand for the boys OH sorry I live in Bucks were land is a premium and costs the earth.

Maybe I should turn them out on Dartmoor and hope for the best when I want to ride that I can find them, spend an hour brushing the mud off the main areas and hack/work them BUT only if they want to and if they let me with out causing further damage to them or their physy (SP) but again only in walk so they don't get hot as I can't cool them off.

What a bunch of :poop:, yes in the ideal world life would be perfect but hey it is not ideal and we do the best we can. Therefore I will clip out both boys, put and yes I do shout it out SHOES on them, rug them, use a horse walker, bring them in at night during the winter months and GOD FOR BID I RIDE THEM.

As interesting as the information is it I will not be made to feel guilty for the decision I make regarding my horses and if it was not for me they would both have been friends briefly with the meat man.
 
Interesting stuff - thanks for posting it, Wally. I think even for those of us who find it necessary to rug, clip and stable, it can be helpful to understand how the horse's physiology functions.

I was interested in the idea about working less when the weather is cold; Hebe seems to have read that bit .... And was there a bit about working less when it's hot as well?

I don't think any of this applies to donks, though - as far as I know, they're like goats don't have waterproof coats. Evolved for a drier climate, maybe?
 
Interesting stuff - thanks for posting it, Wally. I think even for those of us who find it necessary to rug, clip and stable, it can be helpful to understand how the horse's physiology functions.

I was interested in the idea about working less when the weather is cold; Hebe seems to have read that bit .... And was there a bit about working less when it's hot as well?

I don't think any of this applies to donks, though - as far as I know, they're like goats don't have waterproof coats. Evolved for a drier climate, maybe?

They have done tests on Icelandics and Shetlands in severe weather and have found that they can go into a kind of state of suspended animation to ride out storms that last several days.
Goats and Donks do not do well here with no shelter
 
I'm not sure I found any of the article offensive as such? If my horse is cold and I don't have the facilities to meet its natural needs - you just do your best unnatural methods ie rugging, and also how clipping effects the horses natural state. I found the piece interesting just in how their whole mechanics work with no human intervention, I dont feel it is criticising anyone?
 
I'm not sure I found any of the article offensive as such? If my horse is cold and I don't have the facilities to meet its natural needs - you just do your best unnatural methods ie rugging, and also how clipping effects the horses natural state. I found the piece interesting just in how their whole mechanics work with no human intervention, I dont feel it is criticising anyone?

I read it the same as you Gimp.

It's so very easy to anthropomorphise when it comes to horses. To pile on a load of rugs because WE feel cold for instance. I have ben guilty of that myself in the past! I just saw this article as a reminder that horses can cope a lot better than we can in the cold. They are better designed for it.

I found the article very interesting.
 
I read it the same as you Gimp.

It's so very easy to anthropomorphise when it comes to horses. To pile on a load of rugs because WE feel cold for instance. I have ben guilty of that myself in the past! I just saw this article as a reminder that horses can cope a lot better than we can in the cold. They are better designed for it.

I found the article very interesting.

Ive done that in the past to! Guilty as charged ! :yellowcarded:
 
Really interesting, but then of course you have naturally cold climate breeds like Icelandic and Shetland ponies in warmer climes, and thin skinned breeds in cold countries, due to the fact we've domesticated the horse. This wouldn't happen if they were left to their own devices.

I feel all these sort of articles are similar to the 'breast is best' ones you're inundated with when you've just had a baby. Sure, people in Africa (for some reason always held up as the models for extended breastfeeding) probably do breast feed for longer, but they've a much higher infant and maternal mortality rate, too. With horses, yes, as natural as possible is lovely, but again, horses would have a much shorter life span if left entirely to their own devices and could easily die in extreme weather conditions. It's swings and roundabouts with all this stuff.
 
I thought it was pretty interesting, as Gimp says, it was a succinct piece laying out their thermoregulatory mechanisms.

I have a degree in biology, so nothing came as a surprise to me (probably why I don't have such a problem with shivering, I see it as a mechanism), but it's good for owners to have a basic knowledge of how things work...doesn't mean I wont clip and rug though :wink:
 
All very interesting. But I struggle to argue with our beautiful old cob who at 24 I think has earned the right to come inside at night and be warm and dry. Pampered? Yes. And rightly so. I defy anyone to look into her appealing face when she stands in the wind and rain at the gate and "asks" to come in. Wherby we hear snorts of contentment and I believe happiness. Technically as a hardy cob she could live out but does not want to. And nor do I!
But horses for courses and all that, if she wanted to live out I would oblige. And I certainly don't knock anybody else for keeping out 24/7 if their horse is happy and healthy.
 
All very interesting. But I struggle to argue with our beautiful old cob who at 24 I think has earned the right to come inside at night and be warm and dry. Pampered? Yes. And rightly so. I defy anyone to look into her appealing face when she stands in the wind and rain at the gate and "asks" to come in. Wherby we hear snorts of contentment and I believe happiness. Technically as a hardy cob she could live out but does not want to. And nor do I!
But horses for courses and all that, if she wanted to live out I would oblige. And I certainly don't knock anybody else for keeping out 24/7 if their horse is happy and healthy.

I think old horses are rather different - horses in the wild never live to that sort of age. My two are out, unrugged, in all weather, but we had a very old pony whose coat was too thin to give her any protection, and we couldn't keep fat on her, so she was rugged all the time. She was fine and furry when she was younger, no problem.
 
I find it odd that it was taken in the hysterical manner some took it in. I read it as an interesting article addressing how an animal, who in now mostly domesticated copes in the wild and how, it is still able to cope in the wild should all the humans disappear from their lives.

If you are going to keep any animal and put him to work, is it not fair that you read a bit and try to get even the very basic understanding of how he has evolved for thousands of years, and they try your best to provide him with all the things he has evolved to need.
Horses in the wild die from bad teeth, nobody is going to deny them tooth and veterinary care because they would not get it in the wild....
As for breast is best....it is, even foals get raised on the bottle, but only in extreme circumstances.
 
newrider.com