"NH" and "Traditional" Methods

I'm not sure

I mean I thinck I have met dishonest horses

I find a way I always do, i tend to give two options and they go for the eeasyier one

but like sometimes a horse is just wrong .......surely ..............liek just wrong

they are all phsyically differant with their abilitys but mentally I question

in natural selection..taken away from horses in most circimstances, but in every species there is the evil

be it pig, sheep, hu,an or horse

I do belive that they all have their own mental levels of inteligence, and also honesty , just as any other speices

and since natural selection has almost been taken away , thier evolution is in our hands

yes sometimes mistakes are made by error of the handler, but sometimes the horse .....be it a bad day, or just wont try, does misbehave

just as my dog does when he knows he isnt allowed on my bed :)

they push boudaries , and so yes agreed its the handler to keep the line and not let it be crossed

but some try to cross more than others no??

and some you have to fight for your life in order to save theirs

in all cases I have got theer, but I always just think for the moment.........never down any avenue or system set out

as I feel this restricts my horsemanship

can you see what I mean or did that just ramble ?? its hard to explain :)
 
I would argue that in many instances the question is neither wrong in itself, nor being asked wrongly - rather that you shouldn't even be asking the question at all at that stage.

That's what I meant, only phrased differently; asking a question the horse isn't ready for is asking the wrong question. :p So I agree.

x
 
what about the ones that when you aks the question , nicely, but they are P taking

in my experience not every horse is honest...........

but its a pig headed horse.

Again there seems to be an assumption that asking 'WHY' means letting the horse walk all over you. It doesn't. It just means being curious about why your horse is behaving as he is.

For example, my horse stopped dead in the school a couple of days ago about 3 minutes after we would normally have stopped schooling. My 'why' was: does he need to wee? - nope. has something spooked him? - nope. Is he tired/hot?- Nope. Is he voting with his feet coz he wants his dinner? - Yup. My response. Tough mate, we stop when I say we stop. So we continued for a short while and finished soon after on a good note. Asking the why question just means you are more likely to use an appropriate/helpful strategy. Also asking the why question means you are less likely to treat your horse unfairly, as I think many people jump to unfair assumptions in their labelling of horse behaviour (he's stubborn, he's lazy etc).
 
I was not suggesting one should always be asking THE HORSE questions - just that the 'why' question should always be in one's own mind. This was in response to a post saying 'but what if the horse gives you an answer you can't do anything with?' My view is that understanding the why is always helpful.

I agree that sometimes knowing what not to ask of your horse - or when to recognise you are asking too much and backing off is important.

Ditto (as always!) I think that many people feel the need to put more pressure on the horse is the horse is not responding as they wish; i.e. kicking harder to get a quicker response, or pulling harder on the bit if the horse doesn't slow down with a slightly milder aid. But if the horse doesn't understand the aid in the first place, then a harder/bigger aid is not going to help. I think that, perhaps too ideally, that if the horse is physically and mentally able to perform the desired response, then s/he would (as in, is in an ideal mental state and not in pain, unfit, not too tired, bored, unfocused, unmotivated, confused etc). Many people underestimate the importance and effectiveness of using the concept "less is more" in their training methods, when necessary and at appropraite moments.

Be it right or wrong, I just cannot and do not think that the horse is ever "wrong" - horses don't even have concepts of right and wrong in temrs of feeling guuilt or a sense of injustice when they do something "wrong". There are just consequences and rewards. But anyway, in my eyes if the horse is unmotivated, bored, tired, stressed, unfit, confused, in pain ... whatever the reason is for the horse not performing the desired behaviour is the rider's responsibility. If the horse feels any of the above things then it is up to the rider, and only the rider, to do something about it to give the horse the best chance of doing what the rider wnats, as it is in the rider's nest interests - and not the horse's - that the horse behaves in that desired way. If you want something from a horse, then make it as easy as possible for him to do it for you. Why would you have it any other way? Blaming the horse, in my eyes, shows a lack of skill, understanding, empathy and sheer horsemanship in the rider.

If a horse doesn't want to do something - be that a jump, or complying to the rider's aids for trot - then that is perfectly justified. After all, why should the horse do it? Should we punish the horse for not wanting to do the behaviour, or should we look to why the horse doesn't seem to want to? Could it be that the horse feels bored, does not respect the rider (again, the rider's responsibility - rather than 'fault') is tired, having an off-day, doesn't really enjoy jumping, unmotivated through overly-repetative/unhcallenging work? We know how much these things can affect a human being's performance and mental state, so why should the same not go for horses too? What will blaming the horse and punishing him achieve, except for encouraging him/her to become all the more unmotivated/disrespectful etc than before? It is up to the rider to encourage the horse to want to comply with the rider's wishes in performing unnatural and (in the horse's eyes) possibly unjustified/purposeless behaviour.
x
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure

I mean I thinck I have met dishonest horses

I find a way I always do, i tend to give two options and they go for the eeasyier one

but like sometimes a horse is just wrong .......surely ..............liek just wrong

they are all phsyically differant with their abilitys but mentally I question

in natural selection..taken away from horses in most circimstances, but in every species there is the evil

be it pig, sheep, hu,an or horse

I do belive that they all have their own mental levels of inteligence, and also honesty , just as any other speices

and since natural selection has almost been taken away , thier evolution is in our hands

yes sometimes mistakes are made by error of the handler, but sometimes the horse .....be it a bad day, or just wont try, does misbehave

just as my dog does when he knows he isnt allowed on my bed :)

they push boudaries , and so yes agreed its the handler to keep the line and not let it be crossed

but some try to cross more than others no??

and some you have to fight for your life in order to save theirs

in all cases I have got theer, but I always just think for the moment.........never down any avenue or system set out

as I feel this restricts my horsemanship

can you see what I mean or did that just ramble ?? its hard to explain :)

I do see what you mean - but I still do not believe that any mammal - other than primates, and perhaps some other monkeys and marine mammals - has the intellectual ability to be deliberately dishonest, for this involves the concepts of right and wrong.
You would also appear to doubt this by your saying
I find a way I always do, i tend to give two options and they go for the eeasyier one
This is a time-honoured, and very successful way of outmaneouvring a horse,so that it complies with your requirements - but what has it got to do with 'honesty'?
 
Last edited:
Horses are naturally, biologically, evolutionarily and instinctively compliant animals. It is in their nature to go for the easiest option that has the highest chance of safety and lowest risk of danger. It is not in their nature to be deliberately difficult. They live in the moment and behave instinctively. Whilst I agree that some horses can be playfully cheeky or put across their own views - is this such a bad thing, or do we wish to dictate what they can and can't think, as well as how they can and can't behave? This is not stupidity, but essential to the dynamics of the herd as if a horse chooses to oppose the others "for the sake of it" then that horse not only risks his own life, but also jeapordises the others' lives too.

Similarly, if a horse pushes the boundaries it is not because he seeks to hurt the riderr or make their life miserable. It's because the rider's leadership is weak and so the horse feels justified in wuestioning it. Should the horse be ounisehd for expressing these weaknesses int eh horse-rider relationsip and dymanics, or should the rider instead think to him/herself "How can I help this situation? What can I do to make the horse feel safe, secure and comfortabke enough toa ccepot my leadership and comply with my wishes willingly What is it I am doing that makes my horse feel the need to question my role as leader?"?

x
 
Last edited:
Puzzles - I agree with everything you wrote above, except that I would question whether horses actually need (or want) leadership in the sense of another horse or person telling them what to do.

I don't think horses can be dishonest either, for the reason given by Old Woman.
 
I do see what you mean - but I still do not believe that any mammal - other than primates, and perhaps some other monkeys and marine mammals - has the intellectual ability to be deliberately dishonest, for this involves the concepts of right and wrong.
You would also appear to doubt this by your saying

This is a time-honoured, and very successful way of outmaneouvring a horse,so that it complies with your requirements - but what has it got to do with 'honesty'?

not sure why this is..........but some horses dont need giving options, they give freely without question, yet other dont

so again does the horse giving freely have a more honest way of thinking, or just more primative, I really cant answer that question

but I know they are diferant in their minds

perhaps it relates to memory for them because in the past it worked

but you must agree feeling or not , you can take a rider with no feeling (you know what I mean there dont you) and you drill them on a horse, push here give not sit tehre, leg now , and the horse gains everything it needs to be perfectly at one with that rider, and rider well they cant feel any differance but you do it with them anyway

and then they give the aid say to half pass, but the horse ignores........is it because the belief in the riders brain isnt there, because the aid was, and the horse although you have riden it almost from the ground, is ready for the question, but yet tha answer is sometimes a NO

because I know I believe something the horse does, but i there is no belief down the rein or the seat, correct as it may be, the horse wont answer with a YES as you put it

so is this character less honest than the horse that answers with a yes, without the belief

its hard to know why that happens isnt it

either way I can see your point of weather it is benificial to them or not whether they answer yes or no

but sometimes I just see them in their eyes

like I already know because that eye is like a window to their soul.........unique, every single soul is unique :)
 
Puzzles - I agree with everything you wrote above, except that I would question whether horses actually need (or want) leadership in the sense of another horse or person telling them what to do.

Thank you. :) So would I! I suppose it depends on how you define "leadership": it doesn;'t have to be about telling someone what to do, but rather guiding them.

It may help to think of a role model in your life that you know, look up to and admire who you respect so that you try hard for them; perhaps a previous/current teacher or one of your parents/guardians. You know that they will keep you safe and will protect you before themselves, so you trust them. You know they will never ask you to do anything they don't think you're capable of. If you do as they ask, it is because you admire and respect them and want to be like them, rather than because you have to or you fear the consequences. This is how I see good leadership to be like, and I think a similar relationship can be transferred across between horse and rider. Good leadership should should be about choice.

x
 
not sure why this is..........but some horses dont need giving options, they give freely without question, yet other dont

so again does the horse giving freely have a more honest way of thinking, or just more primative, I really cant answer that question

but I know they are diferant in their minds

perhaps it relates to memory for them because in the past it worked

but you must agree feeling or not , you can take a rider with no feeling (you know what I mean there dont you) and you drill them on a horse, push here give not sit tehre, leg now , and the horse gains everything it needs to be perfectly at one with that rider, and rider well they cant feel any differance but you do it with them anyway

and then they give the aid say to half pass, but the horse ignores........is it because the belief in the riders brain isnt there, because the aid was, and the horse although you have riden it almost from the ground, is ready for the question, but yet tha answer is sometimes a NO

because I know I believe something the horse does, but i there is no belief down the rein or the seat, correct as it may be, the horse wont answer with a YES as you put it

so is this character less honest than the horse that answers with a yes, without the belief

its hard to know why that happens isnt it

either way I can see your point of weather it is benificial to them or not whether they answer yes or no

but sometimes I just see them in their eyes

like I already know because that eye is like a window to their soul.........unique, every single soul is unique :)

If a horse doesn't give freely, then I would argue that it was humans that made the horse like that in the first place.

:)
 
Ditto (as always!) I think that many people feel the need to put more pressure on the horse is the horse is not responding as they wish; i.e. kicking harder to get a quicker response, or pulling harder on the bit if the horse doesn't slow down with a slightly milder aid. But if the horse doesn't understand the aid in the first place, then a harder/bigger aid is not going to help. I think that, perhaps too ideally, that if the horse is physically and mentally able to perform the desired response, then s/he would (as in, is in an ideal mental state and not in pain, unfit, not too tired, bored, unfocused, unmotivated, confused etc). Many people underestimate the importance and effectiveness of using the concept "less is more" in their training methods, when necessary and at appropraite moments.

Be it right or wrong, I just cannot and do not think that the horse is ever "wrong" - horses don't even have concepts of right and wrong in temrs of feeling guuilt or a sense of injustice when they do something "wrong". There are just consequences and rewards. But anyway, in my eyes if the horse is unmotivated, bored, tired, stressed, unfit, confused, in pain ... whatever the reason is for the horse not performing the desired behaviour is the rider's responsibility. If the horse feels any of the above things then it is up to the rider, and only the rider, to do something about it to give the horse the best chance of doing what the rider wnats, as it is in the rider's nest interests - and not the horse's - that the horse behaves in that desired way. If you want something from a horse, then make it as easy as possible for him to do it for you. Why would you have it any other way? Blaming the horse, in my eyes, shows a lack of skill, understanding, empathy and sheer horsemanship in the rider.

If a horse doesn't want to do something - be that a jump, or complying to the rider's aids for trot - then that is perfectly justified. After all, why should the horse do it? Should we punish the horse for not wanting to do the behaviour, or should we look to why the horse doesn't seem to want to? Could it be that the horse feels bored, does not respect the rider (again, the rider's responsibility - rather than 'fault') is tired, having an off-day, doesn't really enjoy jumping, unmotivated through overly-repetative/unhcallenging work? We know how much these things can affect a human being's performance and mental state, so why should the same not go for horses too? What will blaming the horse and punishing him achieve, except for encouraging him/her to become all the more unmotivated/disrespectful etc than before? It is up to the rider to encourage the horse to want to comply with the rider's wishes in performing unnatural and (in the horse's eyes) possibly unjustified/purposeless behaviour.
x


I'm going to make a harsh statement now

but whatever the weather

the horse is domesticated and is a working animal. it does not have a choice

all be it as you say external factors can make a differance

that horse when I say jump says how high, and that is what I expect from my horse at all times when I work

I dont have to be cruel to get this dont get me wrong

but he does not get to choose

:)
 
If a horse doesn't give freely, then I would argue that it was humans that made the horse like that in the first place.

:)

your right in most cases like I say memory can play a big part

but sometimes they have never been mistreated, always handled fairly and correctly, its just in their head that they dont want to and some struggle more than others to submit

so sometimes a strength in character can be a disadvantage rather than an advantage

all be it the hardest one to win over, once as you say humans have placed their negativity onto its memory banks

the ones that fight had really really hard, end up making the ones that go the extra mile, that extra something that makes people point at it and say WOW!!

when you finaly win them over and get to ride from inside their head

so I'm still open to ideas, but at the moment still think that some have a sense of honesty about them , more than others :)
 
some horses dont need giving options, they give freely without question, yet other dont

Yes horses have different temperaments.

If a horse does understand what you want, and is capable of complying, some are more willing than others. BUt all horses can be 'what's in it for me' about things. For some, education/training is enough. If they know what you want they'll give. Others might need a better reason!

Horses are prey animals and have a strong self preservation instinct. In some this manifests as GOING - running away a lot, and being quite 'hot'. These horses may be forward going and willing.

Other horses try to self preserve by preserving energy wherever possible - in case they need it to run away later. These are more likely to be labelled 'lazy' but really they just want to make it till morning and how do they know they won't meet a mountain lion in the field later on. These horses need a reason to work. Incentives work well I think - as does having a good relationship with your horse and directing him with energy and conviction so he thinks 'maybe this is a good thing to do after all'. Or maybe this type of horse needs the 'do nothing' option to be quite hard work, so they choose the easier option.

I don't think 'honest vs dishonest' is that helpful as a concept for horses, for all the reasons exaplined by OW, FB and Puzzles.
 
not sure why this is..........but some horses dont need giving options, they give freely without question, yet other dont

so again does the horse giving freely have a more honest way of thinking, or just more primative, I really cant answer that question

but I know they are diferant in their minds

perhaps it relates to memory for them because in the past it worked

but you must agree feeling or not , you can take a rider with no feeling (you know what I mean there dont you) and you drill them on a horse, push here give not sit tehre, leg now , and the horse gains everything it needs to be perfectly at one with that rider, and rider well they cant feel any differance but you do it with them anyway

and then they give the aid say to half pass, but the horse ignores........is it because the belief in the riders brain isnt there, because the aid was, and the horse although you have riden it almost from the ground, is ready for the question, but yet tha answer is sometimes a NO

because I know I believe something the horse does, but i there is no belief down the rein or the seat, correct as it may be, the horse wont answer with a YES as you put it

so is this character less honest than the horse that answers with a yes, without the belief

its hard to know why that happens isnt it

either way I can see your point of weather it is benificial to them or not whether they answer yes or no

but sometimes I just see them in their eyes

like I already know because that eye is like a window to their soul.........unique, every single soul is unique :)

Calli - I agree with a lot of what you say - especially in your next post when you say that when you ask your horse to jump, you want it to respond 'How high?' And yes, I too believe that the horse was, is, and should be, and is better off as, a working animal.

Is English your first language? For I feel that is where we may be misunderstanding each other on the question of honesty. Even human beings do not develop the concept of right and wrong until a certain stage of their intellectual development, and the concept of right and wrong is fundamental to the concept of honesty.

I think in the example you give above, of the different riders, we are seeing the sensitivity of the horse come into play. It is nothing at all to do with 'giving freely' or honesty or any of the other human constructs which are so easy - but so wrong! - for us to use.

Despite your drilling, and the other rider's 'correctness' the aids WILL NOT be exactly the same and the horse will detect this with the greatest of ease. Some horses will be willing to 'give it a go' when they feel an aid which closely resembles one they already know well, some won't - for a variety of reasons, perhaps chief among them being lack of familiarity with different riders, and lack of confidence at 'giving it a go'.
 
Yes horses have different temperaments.

If a horse does understand what you want, and is capable of complying, some are more willing than others. BUt all horses can be 'what's in it for me' about things. For some, education/training is enough. If they know what you want they'll give. Others might need a better reason!

Horses are prey animals and have a strong self preservation instinct. In some this manifests as GOING - running away a lot, and being quite 'hot'. These horses may be forward going and willing.

Other horses try to self preserve by preserving energy wherever possible - in case they need it to run away later. These are more likely to be labelled 'lazy' but really they just want to make it till morning and how do they know they won't meet a mountain lion in the field later on. These horses need a reason to work. Incentives work well I think - as does having a good relationship with your horse and directing him with energy and conviction so he thinks 'maybe this is a good thing to do after all'. Or maybe this type of horse needs the 'do nothing' option to be quite hard work, so they choose the easier option.

I don't think 'honest vs dishonest' is that helpful as a concept for horses, for all the reasons exaplined by OW, FB and Puzzles.

honesty

1. the quality or fact of being honest; uprightness and fairness.
2. truthfulness, sincerity, or frankness.
3. freedom from deceit or fraud.

I can see why you are arguing the term honesty

not sure what the right word is then

but some horses have the ability to hurt maim without provocation and with intent

perhaps I diddnt explain well but I was trying to point out (using an old fashined term for dealers :) )

that some horses will give themselves freely and others wont

they have differant levels of inteligence and differant characters

but even so sometime the electrical impulses in the brain just dont work as well in some animals than others

and no amount of prep, understanding will change that
niether will it make the evil horse into an angel

some never ever stop the fight, they simply become number 2 in the pecking order behind me :)
:D
 
If horses are not able, as we are, to look up the definition of a cpncept they have never been taught, then how can we use it against them or use it at all in a) our judgement of them, and b ) our training and handling of them?

x
 
Calli - I agree with a lot of what you say - especially in your next post when you say that when you ask your horse to jump, you want it to respond 'How high?' And yes, I too believe that the horse was, is, and should be, and is better off as, a working animal.

Is English your first language? For I feel that is where we may be misunderstanding each other on the question of honesty. Even human beings do not develop the concept of right and wrong until a certain stage of their intellectual development, and the concept of right and wrong is fundamental to the concept of honesty.

I think in the example you give above, of the different riders, we are seeing the sensitivity of the horse come into play. It is nothing at all to do with 'giving freely' or honesty or any of the other human constructs which are so easy - but so wrong! - for us to use.

Despite your drilling, and the other rider's 'correctness' the aids WILL NOT be exactly the same and the horse will detect this with the greatest of ease. Some horses will be willing to 'give it a go' when they feel an aid which closely resembles one they already know well, some won't - for a variety of reasons, perhaps chief among them being lack of familiarity with different riders, and lack of confidence at 'giving it a go'.

yes I'm a dealers daughter , its the oldskool term for submission I take it :)

not sure what they call it now

but I think we have very simelar methods for our equines

no english is my first lanuage, but I am dislexic and have always struggled with writtne word

although numbers ..yeah I can do really really hard sums ..so I dont worry too much about it i do accountacy instead of journalism :)

thanks for noticing :)
 
Last edited:
If horses are not able, as we are, to look up the definition of a cpncept they have never been taught, then how can we use it against them or use it at all in a) our judgement of them, and b ) our training and handling of them?

x

because it is for me to judge them as the leader, as it is not for them to try and become this as its something bred into them, not a choice.

and them to be put into that catagory or not as the case my be , by me for safety of others with less experience :)
 
although numbers ..yeah I can do really really hard sums ..so I dont worry too much about it i do accountacy instead of journalism :)

I like your style!

My grandpa - a farrier and horseman - used to label horses 'honest' or 'dishonest' and when my dad - a schoolteacher and amateur psychologist - took him to task on it one day, grandpa said that he used the words as a shorthand description, not so that anyone would really think the horse would pocket the money that had been saved for its shoeing, or tell lies about what it had been doing the night before that made it lose a shoe ... in his situation 'honest' meant, to all intents and purposes, reliably well-behaved for being shod.

I think there is a generation (or two) of people who - now deeply involved with horses - have not grown up with this sort of terminology, and who understand the words 'as they hear them' instead of 'as they are understood by the 'inner circle'/old horsemen'.

It behoves those of us who do understand this particular type of terminology to be very careful in its use.
 
true true

there are some old terms that I use soemthimes and people dont understand what I'm getting at them after discussion we get the the point that we mean the same thing :)

I do like your ideas on things tho and it has been refreshing to see so many people trying to understand horses and open to ideas and discissions on it :)
 
newrider.com