New Subs

Is it just me or has there been an increase in new members and in new threads over the last few days?

I would be sad to see old members leave if it because free again. It's something that I change my mind about on a daily basis! Sometimes I think that we should open it up to everyone, and sometimes I think that we should leave it as it is.

Also, I would like to be clear about what I mean by 'cliquey' because some people appear to be offended. I feel that a group of us 'know' each other so well that sometimes it's hard for those 'outside' the loop to join in the conversations. I fully admit to be part of and probably central to that clique. It's not necessarily a bad thing, it's nice to be able to log and chat to people who know about me and my horse. However, it is difficult for new people to crack into this and sometimes I think that it would be so lovely to hear from new people and read about new horses. It's all about making sure that we as a group (or clique) if you like, respond to everyones posts and make everyone feel welcome.

I am also beginning to dislike the 'like' button. When the odd disagreement arises which I have seen a couple of times over the last few weeks, I am not sure how helpful it is for members to 'like' other peoples comments which may disagree with someone elses. It creates a feeling of members ganging up and sticking together (the clique sticking together if you like) and could potentially be upsetting if your point of view happens to be different from everyone elses.
 
I didn't know any parts of the site were visible to non-subscribers, or that there's a Facebook page! I think it would be nice to attract a few more people and get some more threads and discussions going. I love it here and would like more to chat about!
 
I love the like button - I don't look on it as showing some sort of favour to a particular poster. I ten to use it if a poster has said something that I might have said myself, and rather than just repeat what they have said I 'like' it. I often read something, agree with its sentiments and click 'like' before I have even registered who posted it! I tried to be very unbiased and honest in my 'likes' !:p
 
I love the like button - I don't look on it as showing some sort of favour to a particular poster. I ten to use it if a poster has said something that I might have said myself, and rather than just repeat what they have said I 'like' it. I often read something, agree with its sentiments and click 'like' before I have even registered who posted it! I tried to be very unbiased and honest in my 'likes' !:p


Yes, I am the same, I just read and if I agree but feel I have nothing to add, I click like.
 
I am also beginning to dislike the 'like' button. When the odd disagreement arises which I have seen a couple of times over the last few weeks, I am not sure how helpful it is for members to 'like' other peoples comments which may disagree with someone elses. It creates a feeling of members ganging up and sticking together (the clique sticking together if you like) and could potentially be upsetting if your point of view happens to be different from everyone elses.

I think it is brilliant. I really don't see it as people ganging up on a person, that is certainly not my intention whenever I use it.

I like posts with loads of photos or a positive thread where I know it means a lot to someone and they want to share it with others. Sometimes I don't really have much else to say on the subject other than "nice photos" or "well done" and sometimes I'll reply if there is more I can say on the subject.

I like posts I agree with or even that I disagree with sometimes but feel it was an important point/well thought out etc

I like posts where someone has gone to the effort of typing out a helpful reply to me - it's just like me saying thank you to them.

I like posts that write out what I wanted to say or what I was thinking much more eloquently/concisely or with better explanations than I could have written. If the like button wasn't there I'd be likely to post the same thing (although not quite as well) as the person I agreed with anyway which could also be seen as me picking sides if I'm agreeing with another poster so it doesn't matter if you've got the like button or not. It is all down to personal interpretation of what is being written. I don't think I've ever felt ganged up on on NR although I've had someone disagreeing with me and other people disagreeing along with the original disagreer! I take the opinion on board and decide what to do with it, I don't take it as a sign I'm being cast out. If anything I prefer that many people like one post disagreeing with me than read several posts all disagreeing with me! (Obviously everyone should agree with me all the time anyway but I suppose we are all allowed an opinion:p)
 
I'm just thinking of things which could be interpreted a 'cliquey'. I am thinking of how other people who are not so well known to the group may think of it.

Personally, it wouldn't bother me if the whole forum 'liked' a post that disagreed with mine, but some people would be upset and put off by this. I'm not going to quote examples but if we as a forum want to attract new members and keep them, it's the little things that we all need to be mindful of.
 
I'm just thinking of things which could be interpreted a 'cliquey'. I am thinking of how other people who are not so well known to the group may think of it.

Personally, it wouldn't bother me if the whole forum 'liked' a post that disagreed with mine, but some people would be upset and put off by this. I'm not going to quote examples but if we as a forum want to attract new members and keep them, it's the little things that we all need to be mindful of.

I suppose my thinking is that it isn't new member specific, but more down to how an individual (old or new) interprets things and there isn't much we can do about it like button or no, they'd feel the same if it was several posts disagreeing with them too. There have been a few new people recently and their posts have been liked. I don't really look at whose post I am liking but the content of the post itself and if the vast majority do that then I don't think there will be an issue. There are always going to be people who will feel left out no matter how much people try to include them and that doesn't just apply to forum-life either. I used to be a bit like that when I was a teenager, it wasn't actually other people excluding me but a mindset I was in at the time and the only person who could change that for me was ME! If I were to come here as a new member and introduce myself I'd feel quite welcome if people liked my post and why wouldn't people like a new members introductory post?

Perhaps we should start a new Introductions thread as the old one is possibly out of date/hard to follow now?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
How do you delete posts etc. you have started, commented on etc?

Sadly technologically lacking!

You edit.
I am not about to go through anything, as the cafe-we were told only stayed for thirty days?
Its only the diary that I will remove if it went public, which I have suggested it doesn't.
All other forums are totally public, we are the only one to offer private diaries and I like this.
 
Can someone please explain this clickey stuff? Where is it coming from?
Anyone new reading this would be put off, I seriously don't get it.
If you don't post you won't feel part of any forum, I admit that having a youngster I felt left out on my own yard! But you are responsible for how you feel, no one else, only you can change it. So I found people to chat to with youngsters.
Some people are shy about posting, that I can understand, I am just not one of them.:)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rubic and Cortrasna
I do wish some of the much newer members would post on this and give us a true idea of how we are perceived when you first come across the forum and read a few different threads? All we are doing now is going round in circles trying to guess what the issues might be or why not many people bother to actually join, or do join but don't join in.

So please if any one is reading this thread, who is relatively new to the forum - or is reading it but hasn't actually joined (can they read this if they haven't joined? can you pay for a month just to reply?) can you let us know how we appear to the outside world and where we are going wrong?;)
 
NF, I think we sorted out the clique idea earlier on as CFP's perception of being inferior because she doesn't have a horse - and we argued back at her that its total hogwash cause there's some right numpties who do have a horse, doesn't make them any better than her. I don't think you're the centre of a clique MP. There's just a collection of very prolific posters who know each other well. I'd say the clique is the new rider forum at the moment, and trying to welcome new folk in is important.

I'm still sitting on the fence with the whole free for all thing. I have no concerns (I don't think!) with my diary being viewable, I just feel that we need to find a compromise that suits everyone's feelings on the subject and clearly some folk don't want it free for all.
Could we try a half way house, see what results it produces to make the areas that are currently viewable to the public, also free for posting on, but leave the sofa, members diaries, and café areas subs only. It may entice a few more folk in. I think as some folk have already said, this makes it more aligned to how other forums operate.
I do see a lot more posts in the last few days. I am hugely protective of this forum and was really disappointed when I posted this thread originally and the first two replies I got, I perceived as telling me that they liked it as it is and went else where for real support. I will admit, I was in a very stressy place with exams at the time so refrained from writing what I really thought incase I was just being too sensitive (which I was aha!), but I get very passionate in defence of this place as it helped me so much with Flipo and I have learned so much, I don't want it to go to the dogs and I hate hearing that other people think it is going to end up closed in a wee while. I plan on being in here a lot when I retire, living precariously through all the young horsey folk!
I try and think up new ideas for posts, I tried 'question of the day' a while back, and I think the likes of Trewsers, and Cortasna do a heap to keep this place running. Quite frankly it p!sses me off to hear folk moan about how it is, but not get off their backsides and do something about it.
 
Pete's Mum can I ask how you stumbled across us, and what exactly made you think it might be worth joining up? Have we lived up to your expectations or are we all a bit daunting (until you get to know us of course!:eek:) ;)
 
I don't think it's cliquey actually. There are some prolific posters but it's a small site so there's really only one big clique, in my experience of truly cliquey sites, there tends to be much more of an 'us' and 'them' mentality.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
I don't think it's much quieter now than it was when I first joined so I'll say what I thought :p It came across as a little community as opposed to a sea of many members who don't really know each other even a little bit. I felt very welcomed and because of the community feel it had it also felt familiar if that makes sense.
I don't worry about posting but know I should do more! I think there are a nice mix of people on here ,perhaps not as many as there were but I didn't know NR before subs. I have been given a lot of good advice on here some I agree with but some I don't as I am only human but it's still good advice from people who all share a common love, horses.
I too love the like button, it's nice to acknowledge a post when you don't have anything to say but someone has taken the effort to write it so its nice to let them know you have read it. As far as I'm concerned I love,NR the people have helped me on here more than they know and I feel part of a very warm,friendly, may not always agree, but always willing to help community and that's not always easy to find in the horse world without world war 3 :eek:
As for going ahead,I do t mind things been opened up but I feel it only fair to the long standing ,very loyal members to at least leave diaries only viewable to paying members. The cafe and sofa I think a trial of opening it up at least is worth a try as the cafe mainly is one of the buisiest places :)
 
Pete's Mum can I ask how you stumbled across us, and what exactly made you think it might be worth joining up? Have we lived up to your expectations or are we all a bit daunting (until you get to know us of course!:eek:) ;)

I think, I found you on a Google search - I had typed a question into google & NR came up as a response to that. I've no idea what the question was mind!

I'm a member of Horse & Hound online forum, but unless I've a specific question or can respond to one - I don't get involved much. I find it quite intimidating - there are lots of very opinionated ( dare I say, sometimes rude) posters or, very competitive riders that are out every weekend on there lovely horses but clearly live, breathe & sleep competing.

As a twenty-something, with a hairy native pony they paid not-a-lot for, that turned out to be nowhere close to how he was advertised but was too sentimental to send back or sell on & after being scared witless by him far too many times, I took to Parelli to help and now my main aim is to just have FUN with him and has every intention to ride at 7am on a weekend, but often has one too many shots on a night out & stumbled to the yard having been driven there by my amazing & long suffering now-horsey-by-default Mum (worried about the legalities of myself driving having got in at 3am, clearly more than a little merry) who also considers Pete part of the family at 9.00am with last nights make up and now streaky fake tan still on, the first vaguely horsey clothes they see clutching an extra large Starbucks coffee proclaiming they are never drinking again whilst dragging their pony out the stable to tack up who is somehow yet again covered in straw, feed (only Pete can manage to cover himself in his own feed?!?) with poo stained socks I've been meaning to wash all week but not had time with work & other life commitments ... it's hard to have anything in common with those horsey people that are up at 5am to compete their immaculate horses at some posh affliated event :D

I find HHO very geared up towards that - maybe I've got it pegged completely wrong & there are plenty of people like me on there, but it's SO big with SO many dramas it's hard to see past that.

So, I was looking for a slightly more down to earth horsey forum with the more 'average' owners - that is honestly meant in a good way & not as condascending as it might sound. I promise!

The 99p subscription appealed as if I hated it here, well it was only 99p and I seriously can't remember the last time I bought anything for that price.

As it turns out, I really like it :D

You all come across as normal, down to earth horse owners with a sense if humour & that just enjoy their horses :)
 
Last edited:
I know what you mean about the competing thing on HHO PM and they tend to be a bit snobby about cobs too :confused: BUT there are a whole lot of people in there and so I find it really helpful for getting extra info/advice on vet/hoofcare type things. With so many people you get such a pool of knowledge and many different experiences. The smaller a crowd of people the less that pool of knowledge is (not that the people are less experienced more the range of experience as a whole). It's not a slight on this forum because I love it here, I know I can come on here and have a chat about any horsey thing I want to and not feel like the elite are looking down their nose at me. But if I put up a post about barefoot hooves for example I'll only get info from the small handful of people on here who have had their 1/2 experiences with it, sometimes you may find no one has had a similar problem or did but never found the solution, on HHO there are so many people that there is bound to be at least one other person who has been through the same and found something that worked for them. I'd never post anything too personal over there and I don't feel "at home" there either. I'd love it if NR could find a middle ground with more people, different experiences yet still a nice friendly place to be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sjp1
Just coming back to this.
I logged out to see what the forum looked like.
Its a great idea to allow people to log in with their fb and twitter accounts. Everywhere appears to let you do that.
Its just one click and your set up.
Its says about the 99p trial, so again that's tempting. What can you get for 99p these days.
 
newrider.com