New Subs

I also think (and please Candyflosspot, don't take offence) that the reason you feel this is slightly cliquey is down to your perception of being inferior because you don't have a horse. I think there's a good few plonkers out there (and in here) that do have horses, so dinnae be letting them intimidate you, you're a hell of a lot smarter for not running out and acquiring a stray without thinking through the consequences!

none taken :P. Yes i think you are right on some level-perhaps i feel like an outsider because i dont have my own horse.. however there was a definite clique on NR before everyone beggared off to the FB group or elsewhere. I think that must have been what i was referring back to.
I dont mind seeing posts about what peoples horses do though - its interesting to read about each individual horses quirky traits. :) Going forward i think MP's idea of having a 3 month no subs trial is a good one. It may help entice some new people who are having problems with their horses to come forward. I think if nothing gets done then it will be adios to NR in the end which would be a real shame. Its because of NR we became friends - I am sure other people have also made friends on the forum also.

I appreciate i havent been around that much this year so i will endeavor to make more of an effort to post more frequently on the forum.
 
I don't like fb groups for these type of conversations as my friends don't want to see every time I respond to a post, used some for a while but now stay away from them.
 
It seems the trend so far is to open it back up for free membership. With some extra moderators I'm sure we can keep it under control.

There are a couple of issues - what do do with the Sofa and Members Diaries? One option is to make access to that via a subscription that would offer other perks as well. Don't know if we can make that attractive enough for any sizable take up? If we don't then it would become a strange area where only a few subscribers would ever enter.

The other option is to open it all up, but give current members the time first to remove any posts they might have particular worries about if they became 'public'. I'm not sure how much of an issue this is as it was only ever private to the fee of £2 from anyone.

Once the new front end is built (started and on the way) comments on articles in the main site will also appear on the forum and replies on that thread on the forum will appear on the article, so it becomes a lot more dynamic and ties the front end into the forum a lot more.

How does that sound?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rubic and Jessey
Thats the point of the FB NR group being private Jessey - you don't inundate your friends and family with lots of horse talk and other stuff, your posts are only seen by other group members. If it isnt a private group then yes, of course the whole world can read your posts if they want to.

But this isn't about FB is it really, well only in that the group formation did have quite an impact on our membership here. It is about this forum and what is the best way forward to reinvigorate membership and interest, or do we just go on as we are and accept the inevitable slow but certain decline that is becoming more and more obvious as time passes.

Could we do some sort of poll, could we ask Mike to please shares his thoughts, is it even worth trying to revitalise it, perhaps long term plans aren't on the menu for this forum? Do we have any common ground that we can agree to help things improve. More posting obviously isnt the answer, as only existing members post so I cant see how that would attract new members.

The present members (myself included) who try and scurry up some new topics and reply to as many others as possible, really isn't cutting the mustard. And that also seems to be perceived as the same old stuff been churned out by the same old people. I shall certainly not be trying to post more now, it seems to just confirm that a few of us are tripping over ourselves to maintain life and enthuisiasm whilst others look on and interpret that as being part of a clique!:rolleyes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rubic and newforest
The other option is to open it all up, but give current members the time first to remove any posts they might have particular worries about if they became 'public'. I'm not sure how much of an issue this is as it was only ever private to the fee of £2 from anyone.

Once the new front end is built (started and on the way) comments on articles in the main site will also appear on the forum and replies on that thread on the forum will appear on the article, so it becomes a lot more dynamic and ties the front end into the forum a lot more.

The above gets my vote for sure.
 
I would be willing to pay a sub to keep my diary private. Members can read, but you pay xx to have a diary.

I like the sound of this article link.
 
The other option is to open it all up, but give current members the time first to remove any posts they might have particular worries about if they became 'public'. I'm not sure how much of an issue this is as it was only ever private to the fee of £2 from anyone.

Once the new front end is built (started and on the way) comments on articles in the main site will also appear on the forum and replies on that thread on the forum will appear on the article, so it becomes a lot more dynamic and ties the front end into the forum a lot more.

The above gets my vote for sure.

That sounds good to me too. Especially the idea of more dynamic front end; what's there now isn't much to draw people in at the moment (no criticism Mike I know how much time and effort has gone into it so far).
 
  • Like
Reactions: candyflosspot
I haven't posted much recently as I feel a lot of it just isn't that interesting to people, but the jist of the last month is I've done another couple of sidesaddle competitions with my grey hotse and put my new horse under sidesaddle. I think to be honest if this forum went public I would no longer post at all, I don't want everyone knowing my business. I definitely would not post pictures anyway. This is the only forum I use, I used to be on TrotOn and do occassionally comment on the odd thread but that went a bit dead and it was far too public to post my own threads on.
 
Apart from TO and HHO, all forums are small and quiet. One only had 35 members, these were open, free and public with no more activity than here.

I wonder if the forum as we know it is last century and something else will come along as we evolve with it? Blogs were the "must have in thing" at one stage. Though are diary is like a blog.
 
I haven't picked up any cliqueiness? Then again, I am not too tuned in to that sort of stuff. I still come on here every day. Sadly my postings are less now, as the economic climate and a big "look how much money you spend on your riding" row with OH means I've had to cut right back.

I love reading all about everyone's goings on, but as I personally ride less, and spend less time around horses I feel I have less to contribute. (No more diary of Dave and the projects. People who used to contribute to Riding School diaries thread - LBRider, Sophie33, etc. have now moved onwards with their own share horses and so on.)

It's been a year since I've gone from riding to twice a week to around once a fortnight. Very painful. There's not a day goes by when I don't miss it, and my RS friends. As it's all a bit touchy and traumatic I tend to keep myself to myself a bit more these days. Not deliberate - just the way life changes. Those of us who are not owners can feel a bit less involved as we tend to have less experience of many aspects of the horse world.

I would feel bereft if NR did dwindle away altogether though. It still feel like I 'know' many of you.
 
It seems the trend so far is to open it back up for free membership. With some extra moderators I'm sure we can keep it under control.

There are a couple of issues - what do do with the Sofa and Members Diaries? One option is to make access to that via a subscription that would offer other perks as well. Don't know if we can make that attractive enough for any sizable take up? If we don't then it would become a strange area where only a few subscribers would ever enter.

The other option is to open it all up, but give current members the time first to remove any posts they might have particular worries about if they became 'public'. I'm not sure how much of an issue this is as it was only ever private to the fee of £2 from anyone.

Once the new front end is built (started and on the way) comments on articles in the main site will also appear on the forum and replies on that thread on the forum will appear on the article, so it becomes a lot more dynamic and ties the front end into the forum a lot more.

How does that sound?

This sounds good to me - like the idea of just paying to keep the sofa/diary area for those that like to keep a record of their struggles/acheivments. :)
 
How do you delete posts etc. you have started, commented on etc?

Sadly technologically lacking!
 
The reason I joined was that it was and still is a small forum, with no trolls and no out of control arguments were Admin had to constantly delete posts. I joined a free forum and it got to the stage where you daren't post if case your advice or criticism found you up in front of the firing squad! I for one welcome people's advice and criticism and at the end of the day you either follow the advice or don't, but I certainly couldn't put up with constant negative criticism as I found on other forums. So I think you probably do need something to entice new members but what, I don't know ? Me being me I was happy to pay the subs because I wanted to know what I was missing when I couldn't read the other posts.
 
newrider.com