New Subs

Flipo's Mum

Heavy owner of a Heavy
Aug 17, 2009
9,549
1,491
113
Perthshire, Scotland
I appreciate we want to keep some areas private on here, but in order to attract new members, maybe we should all be more mindful of where we're posting threads. I think a lot of them end up in cafe or sofa, however we need to make use of the non private areas to tempt folk into the discussions. I know a fair bit of our threads are general chitchat, but even chitchat sometimes has a theme that is specific to something other than the cafe or sofa.


Ps. Only realised this when I went to post my road riding thread in the cafe and then thought to change it, so I'm very guilty of sticking with cafe as well!
 
That's a very good point and something I'm guilty about too. I never go into the forums - just use the 'New Posts' facility - so I'm not actually aware of where things are posted, but I never thought about how the site would look for a non-member.
 
Personally I think if I wanted to go onto a huge forum I would go onto H&H which I do subscribe to and which sometimes has a wider knowledge base for certain issues than our own lovely NR.

NR clearly felt that they needed to go the subscription only way, possibly not the wisest way to go if you want a large member base as there are many horsey forums that have a huge number of members that are free.

Inin my very limited and personal opinion think you either have a free forum with a huge members list or a paid for forum with a very tiny amount of members which are bound to get tinier as the years go on as the knowledge base and members base becomes ever decreasing.

Be it £10 or 99p, unless you are looking for information (which in my case at the time I was about treeless saddles and £10 seemed little to pay for a large (at the time) knowledge base, I was prepared to pay it.

I can't really see a 99p subscription fee getting people in unless there is something they are particularly interested in from the archives.

And I think with the lower subscription this will probably alienate members who are looking for an exclusive and small site.

Just my opinion, but I think NR is in danger of falling between two stools.
 
Personally I think if I wanted to go onto a huge forum I would go onto H&H which I do subscribe to and which sometimes has a wider knowledge base for certain issues than our own lovely NR.

NR clearly felt that they needed to go the subscription only way, possibly not the wisest way to go if you want a large member base as there are many horsey forums that have a huge number of members that are free.

Inin my very limited and personal opinion think you either have a free forum with a huge members list or a paid for forum with a very tiny amount of members which are bound to get tinier as the years go on as the knowledge base and members base becomes ever decreasing.

Be it £10 or 99p, unless you are looking for information (which in my case at the time I was about treeless saddles and £10 seemed little to pay for a large (at the time) knowledge base, I was prepared to pay it.

I can't really see a 99p subscription fee getting people in unless there is something they are particularly interested in from the archives.

And I think with the lower subscription this will probably alienate members who are looking for an exclusive and small site.

Just my opinion, but I think NR is in danger of falling between two stools.

Very good point!

I do come on here for a chit chat with people I feel I "know". I go on HHO to ask questions on subjects were I want a lot of view points because there are such a wide variety of people with vastly different experiences. I would prefer NR stayed a bit more closer knit than the likes of HHO.
 
I used to come on here before subs, it was always a smaller (though not this small) forum, with people you could get to know, I don't object to the subs but yes there has got to be a way to attract new members to keep things alive, perhaps if the cafe were public???? to get the interest going
 
  • Like
Reactions: Flipo's Mum
I think FM is right when it comes to where we post our threads though and I've been more aware of that recently, rather than just chucking everything in the cafe. I do like the fact we are closer knit but it would be nice to get a few more active members in. I don't want this forum to turn into the likes of HHO or TO but a bit more activity would be nice, somedays the place seems really busy and other times there are only a couple of new posts.
 
The subs I think were introduced to put off troublesome members. I remember the board being shut down due the volume of bully type people. We got talked about on HHO.
When the subs came naturally people stayed/people left.

I believe a forum was started by those who left? Then you had the NR Facebook group, which took members from here to there for free. I realise that NR has a page there now, and you can link posts to there, but perhaps its just a bit too late to bring oldies back? I am not on FB even though its free.

If you take the subs away because the original reason for their introduction isn't the case anymore, no trouble some trolls, you still have the regulars posting and other members not. You need active talking members to make a forum.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
We got talked about on HHO.

I actually think that was quite an achievement........usually it is beneath H&H to even pass a comment on other horsey forums comings and goings. This place must have been on fire back then!:eek::D
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rubic
I just feel like we might be in danger of losing members little by little until there's no one left. I appreciate we don't want it to be some huge free for all with no relationships, but surely we need to attract a few more folk to keep this place going. I've seen some newbies about lately, and I'm trying to think of more enticing thread titles if I am going to post in the café or sofa areas.
I think we're at risk of getting too elitist if we refuse to encourage new folk to the place. Just my opinion though. I am fiercely loyal, but even I've been bored lately and frustrated, I've needed study distraction and I always loved this place for what I've learnt about all sorts of horsey stuff, but there just doesn't seem to be as much as that anymore. I appreciate folk want to post somewhere busier to get a bigger more varied response, but what harm would it do to just copy and post the same question in here so that we get to discuss it as well.
I do go and surf through HHO and a couple of others, but I'm just not interested because I don't know the people. I want to learn, and I want to see the progress of folk I know. Maybe I'd get to know them, maybe I'm looking for the best of both worlds and its not possible but please please please can we try?!
 
FM you have almost exactly voiced my thought on the whole issue. I do try to copy and paste anything I post on the FB group over to here, but the response is often miniscule and it is rather disappointing when you are genuinely looking for input and ideas. I am never particularly bothered about response to my 'Ooooh look what I did today' type posts, but lack of input to genuine questions and queries is a little off putting and does tend to send me off elsewhere in search of opinions and ideas.

I can remember when you could find an answer to almost anything on here with just one short post, and masses of ideas and input. ....very sad to say I think that might well be gone forever now.

I think that the elitist vibe is already here, not even something we can avoid - it IS part and parcel of this forum and unfortunately therein lies the problem. Until we all agree that keeping this a cosy little 'regulars only who pay their subs ' forum it is going to actually cause the possible demise of it altogether, then sadly there isn't much we can do.

I say do away with subs altogether and grow a pair and lets throw ourselves to the wolves...if we are all as friendly and helpful and supportive as we like to think we are, then we WILL survive and will go on to rebuild this forum to something like the first class and informative and useful place it once was.

So we might get a few trolls? So what, thats internet and forums for you, bring it on I say, I am more than confident that we have enough articulate and upfront members to send them packing, after we have perhaps had a bit of a laugh at their expense of course?:eek::D

The tumbleweed is blowing folks, and if we just sit about wringing our hands and trying to assure each other how lovely our close knit little forum is, we could end up with about 6 people occasionally passing the time of day when they can be bothered to log on.:(
 
How many members do we actually have that dont post?

We are no longer found on tap a talk, so the upgrade needs to be what brings in new people.
A lot of what I post is cafe post stuff, I share photos. I like looking at photos. Its the summer the forum tends to be quiet anyway.
 
Last edited:
We got talked about on HHO.

I actually think that was quite an achievement........usually it is beneath H&H to even pass a comment on other horsey forums comings and goings. This place must have been on fire back then!:eek::D

Yes and not in a good way due to our trolls. The subs then caused so many to leave that HHO had a welcome post going as people went there.
We never really got members back and I think that forum/site costs could be passed onto advertising-or its free but an upgrade is xx.
Like an app. I have free ones but for 2.30 its more memory/no adverts.
 
Last edited:
I don't like having adverts. I just find them annoying.

I just don't know, I like that fact we are a fairly close knit bunch but at the same time I'd love to see a bit more activity on the board.

I agree with FM and Cortrasna, I think we maybe do need to post more and ask questions but I think we need to make an effort to answer those questions too! I know I'm guilty of reading a post and thinking I have a suggestion but I just don't think my point is valid enough. I don't have heaps of experience and sometimes I feel like my point maybe isn't worth making. But from now on I will try to make more of an effort.

I do like the fact we have our cafe/sofa/diaries as sort of private and only available to those that pay but I think more content needs to be posted elsewhere so that new people who come on to see what we are like only see one or two posts and they think we are a quiet bunch with not a lot of knowledge or things to talk about. ;)
 
I am afraid to say that in my opinion the only reason people pay to remain on NR is because we are like a little family.

And be that£10 or 99p it will remain the same.

The knowledge base and members since it went payment is massively reduced, and to be honest, had I not been on here for years and got to 'know ' people, I wouldn't bother.

There are disagreements on here now about certain issues, show me any two horsey people who agree on anything - one thing is for sure, debate is healthy and in my humble opinion, if NR continues in this vein, this time next year, it won't be up and running.
 
Thanks for the further thoughts. I had also been thinking about the free/paid model. In that basic membership would be free but a subscription would bring extra benefits.

What do you think would be worthwhile benefits to tempt people to upgrade to a subscription?
 
newrider.com