MY Posting Trot Questions Thread!

Try and walk forward by hopping from one foot to the other. You bounce up and down once with each side. Is this what you are talking about by saying up and down twice for each stride?
 
Galadriel -- I noticed yesterday that you had a physics degree and was envious because that was my original major which I changed after I decided my math skills weren't good enough to ever be a *good* physicist. :(

EE is one of the 3 books I've purchased and read but it's not for a beginner, I think. I'll have a reread in 6 months.

Laura Jeanne - I didn't know the definition of a stride until I read Galadriel's article. It COULD have been just 1 diagonal pair making a complete cycle but instead is defined as both diagonal pairs making a complete cycle. But, they don't happen together (obviously) nor in opposition (that is, when one diagonal is all the way forward (maximum UP) the opposite diagonal isn't at the the point where the hooves are striking the ground (maximum DOWN). Instead they are out-of-phase by 1/4 cycle. That creates an UP, DOWN, UP, DOWN during the time the stride is being completed. I think it really helps to find that trot animation that Heather Moffett has on this site. Then you can see what is going on in terms of how the horse's back rises and falls in relation to what the feet are doing and what the diagonal pairs are doing in relation to each other. My head is hurting now, too! :)
 
Well, I don't know what you said exactly- but I'm saying that the stride is both sets of legs moving once each (fist one diagonal pair and then the other). So when the first set moves, it's like you hopping on one foot where you can feel a distinct up and down movement and when the other set of legs move (you hopping on the other foot) it's the second up and down movement.

I have a video that shows a person doing posting trot in slow motion and you can see it perfectly.

I'm kind of with Peace- I just can't think about it when someone else is trying to describe it!!
 
I'm not sure exactly what I said, either. :D

laura jeanne said:
... but I'm saying that the stride is both sets of legs moving once each (fist one diagonal pair and then the other). So when the first set moves, it's like you hopping on one foot where you can feel a distinct up and down movement and when the other set of legs move (you hopping on the other foot) it's the second up and down movement.

Exactly. And the posting trot consists of NOT going up-down-up-down during the stride, as an untrained rider would, but rather using thigh pressure to slow the rider's movement down to just up-down with the up matching the horse's up but the down occurring at the time of the second horse's up -- thus making for a smoother ride. At least that's the theory! I'll try to apply it in about 13 hours when I have my second lesson. :)
 
I didn't read everybodies response in this thread, so pardon me if I'm only repeating somebody else here. The the origional question: it sounds like you've gotten a really complicated idea of posting trot into your head, when it doesnt have to be. Nevermind how many times you rise in the time all four of the horses legs go. Simply make sure that when you've risen off of the horses back, their inside foreleg has come back undernieth them in the stride. So basically you rise as their inside foreleg goes undernieth of them, and you sit back down as they reach forewards with that inner foreleg. It's that simple. =)
 
wanabe said:
Just to rephrase the question: if in one stride the horse goes up, down, up, down and I go up (I know, allow myself to rise) on the first "up", then what am I doing with the down, up, down that follow?

Again to add about the whole 'striding' thing that I didn't in my previous post:

Think of it this way. In a horses walk as well as a gallop, there are four beats. In a canter, there are three beats. And in a trot, important in this case, there are only two beats.
This means that because the horses legs are moving in diagonal *Pairs* together, the 'stride' only takes one up, and one down until you begin the next stride.
A word equation:

One stride=two beats=up+down

Lets say you are riding around an oval-shaped ring, always turning left. This means that when the horses left diagonal goes forward (left foreleg, right hindleg), you rise up. Then, when the right diagonal (right foreleg, left hindleg) goes foreward, you sit back down.

Again, in this case, you need to be off the horses back when its left left is benieth it, and sitting when the horses leg is reaching foreward for ground.

Make sense?


And a note for you, Wanabe: Although it's fine to consider these things if your having trouble with them, it really does sound like your over analyzing this movement. It in itself is very simple to do, the only trick is being able to "feel" the correct diagonals as you rise. This then leads to being able to double bounce when changing directions to stay correct.

I don't know, but I never had a problem with the paces of a horse, I had mor eproblems with the dressage aspect and getting those more precise movements. In my opinion, I wouldn't bother to do a sitting trot in the saddle, I would do it bareback, as it will teach you to balance yourself MUCH faster than using a silly little saddle. I wouldn't advise the sitting trot for you at the moment if it's only your second riding lesson (but if you've ridden before go right ahead, don't get me wrong) because alot of beginning riders don't have the balance to make it an easy task for the horse. Try strapping on a very loose backpack, fill it with about 20 pounds of books and run around with it flapping all over the place. It sucks.


But anyway, enjoy riding, don't turn it into math =P that's a fast way to make it much less enjoyable. Everything will come to you sooner or later.
 
newrider.com