MY Posting Trot Questions Thread!

wanabe

New Member
Apr 8, 2005
993
0
0
Pine Forests of Southeast Texas
There are many of these on this site and I think I've read them all! I've also read Galadriel's article on her site plus everything on the Web at large and I've not found anybody yet ask the question that's bothering me.

Galadriel (love that name, BTW, I was a HUGE LOTR fan in my youth!) comes closest to bringing up MY issue:

You are trying to post in time with the horse's trotting; thus, you let him push you up with one step, and you sit with the next step. You rise and fall once each per "stride"--that is, by the time the horse has moved all four legs and is ready to start over. Up, down, up, down, up, down rhythmically is your goal.

I've also done a lot of staring at the trotting horse animation on this site that I think Heather Moffet posted.

My question is this: If there is just ONE up/down PER STRIDE and yet the horse's back goes up/down TWICE per stride, then exactly when (in terms of the horses feet) does the down motion complete?

Here's another saying I got off the web that has to do with diagonals, but it seems to conflict with Galadriel: "You rise and fall with the shoulder to the wall." I can understand the rising part but if you complete your fall as that same shoulder falls, then you've got the whole rise and fall of the other diagonal still ahead of you in the stride because when the first diagonal completes it fall (when the horse places its feet down) the feet of the other diagonal appear to be passing by (in the air) going forward to begin a second rise and fall.

I've confused myself unless the posting trot consists of delaying the fall right on through until the second rise in the stride -- which might give a very smooth ride, indeed. I just don't know if that's physically possible or if that is what is meant.
 
Ok this is how I think of posting/rising to the trot!

The trot as you know is a two time what you want to think of is sit on beat 1 and rise on beat two (or vice versa depending on how you want to think of it) the diaganols: as you are going round the arena you want to think of rising out the saddle as you see the outside (closest to wall/fence) going forward and sitting as you see if coming back towards you! Thats how I think of it anyway hope it helps!
 
Wow. Maybe you are analyzing this too much?
Try posting when you are on a straight line or out on the trail that way you don't have to worry about the diagonal.
for right now don't worry about the feet. Just let the first bump lift you out of the saddle and gently come back down. 1-2-1-2...

Stop thinking- start riding. If you trust the horse or practice on a lunge line you could even close your eyes to concentrate more on the feeling of it?
 
Well -- I analyze everything too much -- that's why I got my university degree in Philosophy! :)

But, I want to know what I'm supposed to do before I begin my 2nd lesson.

Just to rephrase the question: if in one stride the horse goes up, down, up, down and I go up (I know, allow myself to rise) on the first "up", then what am I doing with the down, up, down that follow?
 
wanabe said:
if in one stride the horse goes up, down, up, down and I go up (I know, allow myself to rise) on the first "up", then what am I doing with the down, up, down that follow?
I think you're coming down on the horse's second "up".

You:............Up....................Down
Horse:..........Up.......Down......Up.......Down
H's Legs:......OF/IH in flight....IF/OH in flight

where OF = outside fore, IH = inside hind, etc

The precise synchronisation of feet and horse's back may not be entirely acurate (oh - and I might of got my diagonals back to front :o). What I'm trying to say (probably badly :rolleyes: ) is that the thrust that you feel that makes you rise comes from the horse pushing off his OF/IH. If you get the timing right, you'll time the "sit" so that you meet the horse's back at the crest of it's next rise (IF/OH pushing off) and follow it softly down.....

I hope that makes sense - you're making me analyse everything now, which is probably good for me ;):D
 
Tangle, if that's true (and I posted earlier I suspected this to be the case) then it's the "secret" of why the posting trot is so smooth! Why doesn't every article, then, explain this????

The Posting/Rising trot should be called the "Allow yourself to be thrown up by the horse and then delay the fall with thigh pressure until the horses back has come back up to your elevated seat level trot". Catchy! :D
 
The Posting/Rising trot should be called the "Allow yourself to be thrown up by the horse and then delay the fall with thigh pressure until the horses back has come back up to your elevated seat level trot". Catchy!

That's a good way to think about it. You get sent up as the inside hip rises (it rises as the horse steps forward with that hind leg) and you sit when the horse's outside hip has risen.
 
wanabe said:
Here's another saying I got off the web that has to do with diagonals, but it seems to conflict with Galadriel: "You rise and fall with the shoulder to the wall."

I thought I had that in my article somewhere :) actually--it might be in the "diagonals" article, though, which is separate from the simple posting trot article. To put it very, very simply, the inside leg is moving forward as the "shoulder on the wall" is moving back...so by the time you have risen and fallen with the shoulder on the wall, the whole stride is completed.

Sounds like you've managed to get the overall question answered anyway, though. As for "why isn't this addressed in every description of posting trot"...well, you'd be surprised how many *instructors* don't know the purpose of the posting trot. Many, many people are still taught to post by thrusting with the feet, f'rexample. In general a rider doesn't know WHY they're posting, a rider doesn't know WHY they use a specific diagonal, and so on.

Most of the more accurate articles you'll find about posting trot are trying to give a broad overview for those people who are still thrusting with their feet. You're digging for much more detail.
 
Yes, but I know from taking dance lessons that breaking things down and analyzing is how I can learn. My wife, OTOH, wouldn't even listen to the instructor -- she would just glance at the move we were learning and know how to do it. :rolleyes: (A third group couldn't learn EITHER way and would soon drop out.)
 
Dear Mr Wanabe Philospher

I think I may know where your "mistake" is which gives your confusion about "rise and fall with..."

As one shoulder goes foward, the other goes back. I think you are thnking of it as if one diagonal acts. and then the other, and then the first. But actually both are cycling at the same time, just 180 degrees apart.

An illustration - give your self room to swing your arms ;) And start with both arms down by your sides

Now. Swing one arm up and foward in an arc, past your ear and back down. Now do the same with the other arm.

Thats the way I think you're thinking of it..

Now, swing your first arm up and as it passes your ear, start the other arm. As the first arm is coming down, the second is coming up ;)

So this is two "beat" but both arms are continuously in movement.
 
Yes, both sides continually in motion but not doing the same thing at the same time (I know you didn't suggest that.). There's a definite "up down up down", not just an "up down" (speaking of the horses back) during one stride. The rider, OTOH, is only going "up down" during that same cycle, therefore the rider is going on a slower cycle. In dance class we would have been taught the timing by being told to say something like "up AND down AND" or "up PAUSE down PAUSE" and I may try that in tomorrow's lesson.

And I'm not a philosopher! I found out very quickly after graduation that there aren't many philosphy jobs out there. :D So instead I became an IT geek. :)
 
Y'all are starting to scare me. :eek: I just realized that if I try to think about what I'm doing at the same time as I visualize what all four of the horse's feet are doing, I short-circuit completely. :p Feeling dizzy now. :o

I think of it like the cha-cha - it's a syncopated "one-and-two-and" kind of rhythm, only instead of moving my hips side-to-side they go forward and back. :)

edit - cross-posted with wannabe - that's exactly it! The AND part comes when you're at the "top" of your rise (or farthest point forward - it's sort of an arc you're describing as your hips/thighs rotate with your knee as the center point). That's the syncopated beat.
 
Last edited:
Peace said:
Y'all are starting to scare me. :eek: I just realized that if I try to think about what I'm doing at the same time as I visualize what all four of the horse's feet are doing, I short-circuit completely. :p Feeling dizzy now. :o

Yeah, me too. I only have time to get my own 'parts' to move right. If I also have to *THINK* about the horse's I will be lost! :)
 
wanabe said:
Yes, both sides continually in motion but not doing the same thing at the same time (I know you didn't suggest that.). There's a definite "up down up down", not just an "up down" (speaking of the horses back) during one stride. The rider, OTOH, is only going "up down" during that same cycle, therefore the rider is going on a slower cycle. In dance class we would have been taught the timing by being told to say something like "up AND down AND" or "up PAUSE down PAUSE" and I may try that in tomorrow's lesson.

And I'm not a philosopher! I found out very quickly after graduation that there aren't many philosphy jobs out there. :D So instead I became an IT geek. :)

Welcome to IT geekdom (am IT project manager) :D

Mmmm - I'm concerned about you saying the horse's BACK goes up and down. Just to check - you're talking about the rider feel of up down aren't you ? Cos the rider is going up and down as the WHOLE BODY goes up and down. (I have this image of a very wobbly spine when I think of just the back doing it :rolleyes: but its a Friday so forgive me ;) )

But you are right that in rising/posting you are sitting for one up-down and rising for the other up-down.

There is a problem when you try and take this description down to 2D motion as it ignores the other dimension. As the horse moves, the mid-section (the barrel) of his body will move from side to side to allow the hind leg through and under. So you do get this "going backwards on a bicycle" effect in your hips.
 
I've read a bit about the side-to-side stuff but I thought I would leave that for later. I wonder if everyone who does the rising trot does that or if it is an "advanced technique".

"Manager" -- uhoh! Hmm, I better get back to work! :eek:
 
Nah. you don't have to think about it - it just happens ;)

And as for rushing back to work, where do you think I am right now, when I'm writing this ;) (Should say am on contract not perm)
 
wanabe said:
Yes, but I know from taking dance lessons that breaking things down and analyzing is how I can learn.

I certainly wasn't being critical of your urge to analyze :) just making a comment that you're looking for more than most people do. I understand the need to analyze; what I studied was physics. (grin)

Wanabe, I'm not sure if you've read further than the posting trot at the moment. It seems to me that the "Kinder Way" description of the *sitting* trot might be helpful to you--or perhaps "Enlightened Equitation" (also by Heather Moffet). For you, I think EE would be a very, very enjoyable read.

Sitting trot and posting trot can complement each other, and the sitting trot explanation goes into the area you're attempting to analyze.
http://www.newrider.com/Kinder_Way/The_Paces/sitting_trot.html
 
newrider.com