There are many of these on this site and I think I've read them all! I've also read Galadriel's article on her site plus everything on the Web at large and I've not found anybody yet ask the question that's bothering me.
Galadriel (love that name, BTW, I was a HUGE LOTR fan in my youth!) comes closest to bringing up MY issue:
I've also done a lot of staring at the trotting horse animation on this site that I think Heather Moffet posted.
My question is this: If there is just ONE up/down PER STRIDE and yet the horse's back goes up/down TWICE per stride, then exactly when (in terms of the horses feet) does the down motion complete?
Here's another saying I got off the web that has to do with diagonals, but it seems to conflict with Galadriel: "You rise and fall with the shoulder to the wall." I can understand the rising part but if you complete your fall as that same shoulder falls, then you've got the whole rise and fall of the other diagonal still ahead of you in the stride because when the first diagonal completes it fall (when the horse places its feet down) the feet of the other diagonal appear to be passing by (in the air) going forward to begin a second rise and fall.
I've confused myself unless the posting trot consists of delaying the fall right on through until the second rise in the stride -- which might give a very smooth ride, indeed. I just don't know if that's physically possible or if that is what is meant.
Galadriel (love that name, BTW, I was a HUGE LOTR fan in my youth!) comes closest to bringing up MY issue:
You are trying to post in time with the horse's trotting; thus, you let him push you up with one step, and you sit with the next step. You rise and fall once each per "stride"--that is, by the time the horse has moved all four legs and is ready to start over. Up, down, up, down, up, down rhythmically is your goal.
I've also done a lot of staring at the trotting horse animation on this site that I think Heather Moffet posted.
My question is this: If there is just ONE up/down PER STRIDE and yet the horse's back goes up/down TWICE per stride, then exactly when (in terms of the horses feet) does the down motion complete?
Here's another saying I got off the web that has to do with diagonals, but it seems to conflict with Galadriel: "You rise and fall with the shoulder to the wall." I can understand the rising part but if you complete your fall as that same shoulder falls, then you've got the whole rise and fall of the other diagonal still ahead of you in the stride because when the first diagonal completes it fall (when the horse places its feet down) the feet of the other diagonal appear to be passing by (in the air) going forward to begin a second rise and fall.
I've confused myself unless the posting trot consists of delaying the fall right on through until the second rise in the stride -- which might give a very smooth ride, indeed. I just don't know if that's physically possible or if that is what is meant.