Loan Dilemma

Like @Jessey, I would say, "Not long to wait until Hickstead, and summer is a better time to sell anyway. Why not leave her with us until then?" and if they don't bite, say it's on their own heads and hand her back.

It is a shame but I can tell that you know it happens all the time, alas.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KP nut
I have a supplementary question - what is a 2 year loan? If it is a loan than can be terminated at any time, what is the significance of it being for 2 years? Or is it the price that is fixed for two years rather than the loan itself?

Jesse's idea of riding Hickstead (whatever that is) sounds good except if the pony doesnt shine at Hickstead simply qualifying and the prospect of great things to come might be of more value than an actual result?
 
They have always bought cheap and/or young to get the quality they can afford and have made the ponies/horses themselves.
So why didn't they buy when this one was for sale in the first place at the low price?
Probably because they were not actually looking and the offer of a ride is an attractive prospect. The pony will also do well in other hands though, competitions riders of any age can ride quirky ponies. So they either decide to send back and move onto another ride- if this rider can ride well they will be offered others or return.
 
The relevance of the pony being quirky is it limits her market and makes her even harder to sell. She can only go to a very confident and capable young child.

The point I was making is that to prospective purchasers of a successful competition pony despite a hefty price tag, and that is proving itself a little super star isn't the same as selling your average everyday child's all rounder for local level competitions etc. In my experience, over here anyway - children that are competing at the level that this pony seems capable of can pretty much get anything around a course successfully and wouldn't be in the least put off by a few little quirks - they almost expect it in talented ponies and I suspect a lot of them enjoy it ;) . So if aimed at that market it is unlikely to put many of them of, as it would for Mr or Mrs Average buying for their very average child rider.


If the child is as talented as you say and parents don't have the finances to purchase either this pony or another one equally capable, it could be worth their while advertising or spreading the word within that community of competition ponies and see if anyone will offer her a ride?
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrC and carthorse
Unfortunately this sort of thing isn't unusual & while it's a shame for the child she can't be sheltered from the real world forever & there are worse lessons than this.

I would stop riding the pony now & send it back asap, I wouldn't get involved in anything to do with the sale in the meantime. If I liked the pony but honestly couldn't afford the new price then I'd keep an eye on things & if it's still unsold in a couple of months go back with an offer. If I could afford it I'd chalk the loss up to experience and buy at around the asking price - while I'd have been involved in making it worth that I'd now know what it could do so it wouldn't be the gamble that it was when I took it on.
 
The problem with loaning is that there is always the risk of the pony being sold underneath you. I would keep the pony until the loan was officially ended by the owner and returned as per the contact. I would expect there to be a one month notice period either way. I wouldn't allow viewings whilst the pony was in my care, it would need to be returned to the owner to do this. And then they would have the problem of trying to sell a pony with no jockey. Ponies don't generally sell in November, so at the very least, the child would have another 3 or 4 months with the pony anyway and at that point perhaps their own pony may be ready to ride again?

It seems to me as the owners are trying to call their bluff by threatening to remove the pony unless a high price is paid. It's not ethical to do this, but some people just see £££ and want as much as they can get, even if they know they are not being fair to the child in question.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KP nut
Sadly this kind of thing has been going on donkeys years. When I was 14 we were approached at a show and asked if we would consider a young green pony to do novice stuff with as the adult owner couldn't get to jump ( she didn't have the confidence a carefree teen has) We took said pony named Libby on loan and within quite a short space of time she worked her way up and was doing weekly unaff indoor showjumping through winter to get her going, I became quite attached to her and we were often in the placing. Suddenly without warning she was sold whilst at a show, and without realising the new owners told a good friend of ours as I entered the ring to jump a intermediate course they had just bought her, they had paid £2300 for her. The loan didn't end well and I remember been quite upset as we had no inkling she was selling her until she sold. There was nothing we could do, she ultimately wasn't ours to keep however unfair it seemed, some people sadly are just unreasonable. x
 
newrider.com