Loan Dilemma

KP nut

I'd rather be riding.
Dec 22, 2008
6,539
5,379
113
Situation is this:

Quirky pony with potential but no competition record failed to sell in Spring and was offered up for long term loan as no jockey.

My friend took pony on a 2 year loan for her very talented 11yo daughter who's own BSJA pony is out injured for at least a year. Pony turned out to be very good, usually clear, fast against the clock, is in the PC and NSEA teams and has qualified for Hickstead in May.

Owners have suddenly announced they are selling her and offering her to my friend for triple what she failed to sell at in Spring. She may be worth that now - but certainly wasn't in Spring! Plus a lot of the pony's achievements are down to the rider - she is not an easy ride at all.

WWYD?
 
That's often the way when a good rider takes on a loan and educates/competes, then the owners get greedy. Happened to my friend, horse went back, still didn't sell, went into training then on loan to someone else, didn't do as well and my friend brought her (from the same owner) about 3 years later at a much more reasonable price but still not what she would have been before my friend put a lot of work in and got her a competition record.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KP nut
Most very successful competition ponies can be a challenging ride to your everyday child rider - I don't see the relevance? but if your friends want it they will probably have to pay a hefty price tag for something similar elsewhere regardless of who jockeyed the pony up through the ribbons. so its either pay up or send back I think.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
They can't afford to pay and yes they could just send back. But I don;t believe the owners truly want the pony back! It is the start of winter and they have no jockey. They could send to sales livery but it's a rubbish time of year to sell.. The relevance of the pony being quirky is it limits her market and makes her even harder to sell. She can only go to a very confident and capable young child.

They aren't saying they are ending the loan they have just said 'we are putting her up for sale' but have not asked for her back and she is still out competing. So my friends are tempted to call their bluff and just say no and see what happens.

On the other hand that does make life very uncertain for the child. This is why I hate loans. You have no control.
 
i think id go back to them and have a frank conversation if they really do want to buy. Id be saying that while you realise the pony is now worth 3k (for eg) it failed to sell at 1k and as the value has gone up due to your production of said pony i would offer 2k or hand back and let them ride it / sell it themselves again - which they will fail to do as they have no jockey so it will go back to being sold from the field ;)

ETA just seen your reply @KP , i would say no to doing any viewings if i were the loaner - offer to pay 2k or hand it back for them to sell themselves.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KP nut
if your friends want it they will probably have to pay a hefty price tag for something similar elsewhere regardless of who jockeyed the pony up through the ribbons. so its either pay up or send back I think.

They have always bought cheap and/or young to get the quality they can afford and have made the ponies/horses themselves.
 
i think id go back to them and have a frank conversation if they really do want to buy. Id be saying that while you realise the pony is now worth 3k (for eg) it failed to sell at 1k and as the value has gone up due to your production of said pony i would offer 2k or hand back and let them ride it / sell it themselves again - which they will fail to do as they have no jockey so it will go back to being sold from the field ;)

ETA just seen your reply @KP , i would say no to doing any viewings if i were the loaner - offer to pay 2k or hand it back for them to sell themselves.

They are absolutely not doing viewings! Or giving permission for their child to be used in ads. And in fact the pony is on privately rented land so not sure owners can even arrange to do viewings themselves. They have already made a lower offer which really would suit everyone but have been turned down. Sigh.
 
They could always make an offer based on what they think the pony is worth and bring up the fact that it didn't sell before for a lower price, sounds like the owners are a bit deluded.
 
well if it were me i would call their bluff and say thats all your willing to pay but if they want it to be sold they will have to take it home to do so
 
  • Like
Reactions: KP nut
This is really between the owners and the loaners, not you at all. If the loaners would like to buy but havent the money they need to tell the owners straight out and make an offer.
One cant judge at this point whether there will be other higher offers on the table - Nor can the loaners retrospectively ask for financial recognition of the work they put in. Those of us who share or school RS horses and ponies know we have no rights in the horses. Tho usually we can get an informal agreement of first refusal.
If you feel rich and generous you could buy the horse yourself. Put in a lowish offer if the loaners' offer is rejected. But unless you enter into the bidding there is nothing you can do. I was once offered a very ordinary but sweet RS TB mare for £10,000. There was another client who would have liked her too who could easilly have afforded that sum. But we both turned it down.
On the market the horse was not worth £10,000.
Every horse has a market worth - but it isnt realisable till someone puts the money on the table.

The thing to remember and for the child rider to remember is what our old RI said - there are many horses in the world. A part of rideability and horse behaviour seems to me to depend on who has ridden it - and this same child might do equally well on a different pony.
 
I would send it back, whether as a bluff or to genuinely return because they can't afford it. Yes the child has done well but it was only a loan, so they didn't have the outlay that us owners had at the beginning and the child has had the benefit of a free ride all summer.

There are plenty of ponies out there. Suggest they start saving and buy one next time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frances144
I know it's nothing to do with me! I'm just interested in how people see situations like this. I personally feel the owners are being greedy and unreasonable to agree a 2 year loan on a pony then within 8 months try and sell from underneath the people who put all the money and effort in. After all the pony will still be worth a lot in another year when the loan comes to a planned end and my friend would then cooperate with a sale. In fact if the owners even just agreed to a 1 year loan to sell after Hickstead that would maximise the value and give the family time to find another pony.

That way the loaners could feel happy and lucky to have found someone able to demonstrate with pony's ability and dramatically increase her worth, and my friend could feel happy and lucky to be able to loan such a great pony and enjoy so much success with her, so everyone would be happy.

But perhaps I am just naive and people think it's fine to take the pony back anytime they like - after all it is their pony
But I think what will happen if that does happen is a replica of the situation @Jessey describes. The pony will lose value rapidly with no jockey. The child will suddenly lose a much loved pony and miss out on Hickstead. So everyone will feel dissatisfied with how it all ended which is a real shame.
 
you say pony was taken out on a 2 yr Loan, if that was only taken out in Spring, did they have a contractual agreement? if so then they may well have some legal rights and should take advice-- but at the end of the 2yr period the outcome would be the same return or buy , them putting all the work in is irrelevant they don't own the pony.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OwnedbyChanter
They do have a contract but like all loans it says loan can be ended whenever.

As I said above, they know the pony is not theirs and they will hand back a much more valuable pony than they took on. They are fine with that. They will have had the pleasure of her for 2 years and the owners would get a more sellable and more valuable horse. Win-win.

The way I see it, if loaners actually said 'loan available for 6-8 months for an unfit, out of work pony with no jockey' people would say 'oh right so I bring the pony back into work and get it fit and out and about then you sell it. Er no thanks!' So why is it ok to just do that sneakily when few people would agree to that up front.

Loaning should always feel like a mutually beneficial arrangement not a favour. You get a free pony, the owners get free pony-care! And in this case a valuable pony back at the end.
 
so not really a 2 year loan then - but if they have signed a contract knowing this to be the situation then they can hardly be surprised if they have produced the pony to an excellent level in a short period of time that the Owners want to take advantage of that - the situation could change the pony could sustain an injury or a limiting illness and be worth nothing - I can fully understand their frustration unfortunately in the competitive world the pony is only going to be worth the increased value for the period of time it is producing results at the higher level, there is a market out there for this type of pony especially with tickets - all the work has been done and a rider can be put on and hopefully reproduce the level of success, unfortunately many of them don't due to the lack of skill of the new owner/rider and said pony gets sold on through no fault of its own, such a shame it sounds as if the current rider/pony relationship is a good one I really do feel for the rider - suppose its a case of take a chance or call their bluff and if it does not work out then look for another but I would look to buy not loan - there will be many similar ponies out there with potential that for no reason other than a not so accomplished rider being unable to get results that will work for them.
 
I think if it were me, I'd explain to the owner it will be worth more after hickstead and try and do a deal to finish the season out and cut my losses there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: KP nut
Unfortunately not everyone will honour the original intention. It's a shame for the girl

In hindsight they could have tried to negotiate a percentage sell on clause if the loan ended early

Hope they manage to work something out
 
It is a shame for the child yes, however if they want the pony back I’d tell them to come and get it ASAP, it is their pony at the end of the day and while the loaners have done a great job if they cant afford to buy the pony at the price they have worked it up to it’s still down to the owner, if they don’t have a proper contract there isn’t much they can do about it really.
And no matter what you think is going to happen to the pony makes no difference, their pony they get to call the shots.
Life is unfair sometimes and there are a lot of not very nice people out there looking to make a quick buck at anyone’s expense.
 
newrider.com