loan clause

DeirdreBarlow

New Member
May 8, 2006
1,227
0
0
In a loan agreement, is it unreasonable to say. . .

If I want to take my horse back; I can do so immediately (ie, owner can turn up one day and say "I'm taking him home now").

If you want to give my horse back, you must give a month's notice first (ie, loanee must continue to pay for horse's livery, feed, shoeing (if in that time), hay etc for 4 weeks after giving her termintaing-loan notice).


I'd love to hear peoples opinions on this :) .
 
The BHS sample loan agreement does have that clause in it, so it can't be that bad! It does sound a bit mean, but then if the horse was in such a state that you'd need/want to take it away immediately, you wouldn't want to be prevented from doing so.
 
sounds one sided to me, but the owner has the upper hand, they own the horse

depends how much the loanee wants the horse
 
hm well in my experience of loans i worked an arab untill he was in showing condition i paid 160.00 a month and was giving only a one thing to do ride him and buy what ever i would like for him.i loved him and we even tried to purchase him then one day i saw someone riding MY horse and found out it was the owners daughter she wanted to start riding him after 3 yrs of not even comming to see him i wasn't even notified let me say i loved that horse so much that i never went back to that barn again and i didn't even notifiy any one that i was leaving just one i day i came with our SUV and said buh bye and that i bought my self a horse and you will not be getting my hard earned pay check again.i know what a bitch on my part but seriously they were users. so if thats what you were asking if the onwer can just one day go and take the horse away yep they can its "there" horse.
 
I did my loan agreement from the BHS website and it says I can remove her immediately only if I have concerns for her welfare, which I think is fair.
 
I loan my boy and in the agreement the owners can take him away if his welfare is at risk or he is not kept in acordance with the loan

(eg shoeing, worming, vaccinations kept up to date and limited grazing in spring are all covered in my agreement).

If I want to terminate the loan I give 30 days notice and if they want to terminate the loan in any circumstances other than welfare then they give 30 days.

I do not have a problem with this as his welfare will not be suffering with me I want the best for him just as much as they do.
 
You can write a contract any way you want .. it's an agreement between the two of you. It's up to the other party as to whether they agree to sign it or not. The more they want the horse, the more bargaining power you're going to have. Nothing really fair or unfair about it, as long as both parties understand what they're signing for.
 
I loan my boy and in the agreement the owners can take him away if his welfare is at risk or he is not kept in acordance with the loan

(eg shoeing, worming, vaccinations kept up to date and limited grazing in spring are all covered in my agreement).

If I want to terminate the loan I give 30 days notice and if they want to terminate the loan in any circumstances other than welfare then they give 30 days.

I do not have a problem with this as his welfare will not be suffering with me I want the best for him just as much as they do.

That seems like the ideal situation. :)
 
I loan my boy and in the agreement the owners can take him away if his welfare is at risk or he is not kept in acordance with the loan

(eg shoeing, worming, vaccinations kept up to date and limited grazing in spring are all covered in my agreement).

If I want to terminate the loan I give 30 days notice and if they want to terminate the loan in any circumstances other than welfare then they give 30 days.

I do not have a problem with this as his welfare will not be suffering with me I want the best for him just as much as they do.

Much better. I would never loan a horse where the owner had the right to take him back on a moments notice unless welfare was an issue. Been there, done that, and it was absolutely heart breaking. I didn't even get to say bye :(
 
I personally would never ever sign an agreement that had that clause in it!

However, I would, if the clause read as others have said, that the owner can take back the horse immediately if there are concerns for its welfare, not kept to the loan agreement etc.
Other than that I would expect both owner and loanee to give a months notice (or whatever period).

S
 
Nope, I would never sign an agreement like that. If the horse's welfare is at risk, then yes, but even so, I would hope that the owner is checking up on the horse occasionally, so a situation like that should never arise. In situations of abuse, then yes, the owner should be free to retain the horse... believe the clause that covers this in most standard lease agreements goes something like "Lessee is responsible for the welfare of the horse. Should the lessee be unable or unwilling to continue the care of the horse in a proper manner, the lessor is able to retain immediate possession of the horse"

It's not fair to say that you can retain immediate position of the horse with no clause attatched as to WHY you are taking the horse away - in that way, you are gving the rider no other possibilities or plans for another horse, and expect that same rider to give YOU courtesy of notice. Absolutely not - totally unfair.

Unless your horse is truly exceptional caliber (Ie a total schoolmaster), I also disagree that you have much bargaining power-the rider is also doing YOU a favor by keeping your horse exercised.
 
I'm looking for a loan horse at the moment, and to me that sounds reasonable, i would be prepared to sign a contract to say that if the horses welfare is at risk while the horse is in my care then it can be immediately removed (but they would have to have a valid reason for thinking the horse is at risk, and would have to prove it)
To me any prospective loannee that would agree to such a clause would have to be 100% certain that they can offer a good home to the horse and that they can provide a level of care that the current owner offers and expects.
Having that clause also gives the owner some added comfort knowing that they could go and remove the horse if its unfairly treated etc (it would be terrible to go visit your horse, see its not happy and not given the level of care etc you expected, only to have to wait 30days to remove the horse)
Of course every one will have their own opinion on this, i am just giving my opinion from someone looking for a loan horse ;)
 
I can remove her immediately only if I have concerns for her welfare, which I think is fair.

I personally would never ever sign an agreement that had that clause in it!
I would expect both owner and loanee to give a months notice (or whatever period).

Nope, I would never sign an agreement like that. If the horse's welfare is at risk, then yes.

I think you all have very valid points :cool: . But I suppose the question then becomes "what would be sufficient grounds to call it welfare concerns"?

Personally, I'd never loan a horse with that kind of agreement. But likewise - I'd never loan my horse out with anything less :rolleyes: .
The fact of the matter is, as much as I'd loathe being a loanee on such a contract, the owner is still the owner. And to say "if the horse's welfare is at risk" is a very vague description of circustances which could arise.

Supposing you visit your horse in his loan home and you witness the loanee wallop your horse (with whip) because she finds his grooming her too hard unacceptable?
You point out that he's not being naughty, and that even if he was - you don't approve of such a violent reaction. Maybe you even state that if you discover similar actions have been repeated, you'll consider it grounds to end the loan.
Loanee apologises, and promises not to do it again - but you sense she's taken none of it in.

Let's push things further, and say that this loanee is an experienced BHSAI, with a reasonably good local competition record. Add to this that (despite her smack) she's a very friendly, lovely lady - who you're sure didn't smack out of anger; just out of a belief that remotely pushy behaviour should be dealt with immediately and firmly.

You know she's not going to beat your horse. Not by any workings of the imagination. But you also know your horse, know how headshy he was when you first bought him, know he needs calm, quiet handling, and that afew weeks in that type of training regime will be seriously detrimental to him.
You explain all this to the loanee, but upon visiting again a week later, you notice her give him several hefty "telling off" boots for spooking at a pheasant leaping in front of his feet.
Horse spends the rest of the session very tense and noticeably very jumpy (despite being a non-jumpy sort).

What do you do?

I should probably mention that (whilst not my own situation), the scenario is very much real.
I won't say what the outcome was until afew have replied, but as I'm considering loaning Benjy out I'd like to hear opinions on this kind of circumstance.
 
I think what the owner should do then is first of all, make sure that the lessee is right for the horse - for example, I would never lease Storm to anyone who has a lack of confidence, because he tends to feast on it ;) So knowing that the horse is headshy, I'd explain to the new potential lessee what the deal was and expect her to head what I tell her - in regards to "disciplining" the horse, its a tricky subject, because some owners seem to believe their horses are absolute angels and deserve nothing - and then cry abuse as soon as someone has the guts to say "enough is enough, respect my space and don't be a moron" Personally *I* believe that pushy behavior should be dealt with firmly and quickly-NO horse gets in my space while I quietly accept it. HOWEVER, if its the situations that you've described (where the horse is just really acting natural to a spook) I'd take the lessee aside and explain to her that you don't like unwarranted attacks against the horse and exaplain to her that there might be a better approach that will work with said horse.

If she's still not listening, I'd give her notice. She isn't abusing the horse by any means, it just sounds like she's not the right match for said horse - it's no cause to remove the horse without informing her or giving her time to find another mount.
 
Last edited:
I think what the owner should do then is first of all, make sure that the lessee is right for the horse - for example, I would never lease Storm to anyone who has a lack of confidence, because he tends to feast on it ;) So knowing that the horse is headshy, I'd explain to the new potential lessee what the deal was and expect her to head what I tell her - in regards to "disciplining" the horse, its a tricky subject, because some owners seem to believe their horses are absolute angels and deserve nothing - and then cry abuse as soon as someone has the guts to say "enough is enough, respect my space and don't be a moron" Personally *I* believe that pushy behavior should be dealt with firmly and quickly-NO horse gets in my space while I quietly accept it. HOWEVER, if its the situations that you've described (where the horse is just really acting natural to a spook) I'd take the lessee aside and explain to her that you don't like unwarranted attacks against the horse and exaplain to her that there might be a better approach that will work with said horse.

If she's still not listening, I'd give her notice. She isn't abusing the horse by any means, it just sounds like she's not the right match for said horse - it's no cause to remove the horse without informing her or giving her time to find another mount.

Hmmm, interesting.
Firstly I'd say that with regards to any situation, you can only ever try your best to ensure the horse is in the right home.
NR is filled with people (from novice to experienced ;) ) who bought a horse after a thorough trial and discovered it wasn't suitable for them. And not always (not even mostly) because the horse was mis-advertised by the owner.
In this case the loanee had the horse for a 2 week trial at his present yard, loaner and loanee hacked out together most days in that time, and loaner insisted she try him in various difficult situations (ie, she knew he always acted up in the sj field - so she took them both in there and observed).
The loanees behaviour only came into effect when she'd had him at her own yard for a couple of weeks.

Secondly, I agree the topic of punishment is difficult. But I can vouch for the owner that the initial smack for his nibbling her was out of line (it was a full on wallop, and he'd done nothing more than been grooming her shoulder and got a bit carried away).

And lastly, I'd disagree about giving the loanee notice. I'm NOT suggesting she waltz in and say "you're absuive, I'm taking him home" :p !
But for a sensitive horse, a months worth of over-zealous repremanding would be very negative to his behaviour. You risk that when loaning a horse - but you'd be daft to know how the style doesn't suit him and continue to let it happen (even for a month).
Personally, I recommended she remove him without a month's notice. Specifically, that she have a non-argumentative chat with the loanee (explaining the situation), and apologise for any inconvenience caused.

But interesting to read what others think :) .
I reckon I'm still thinking I'd go with the clause :o .
 
Put yourself in the lessees position though. You've said that she's a lovely lady who wouldn't want to abuse the horse on purpose. You have a horse who (I'm assuming) she is riding fairly decently (otherwise she shouldn't be loaning him to begin with) and is generally treating him fairly.

Now I can't comment on what the situation is - if she's full out smacking whaling on the horse for each and every little misdemeanor, then you have a bit of a problem. If she's disciplining him OCCASIONALLY, ie, if he started to bite her while he was grooming her, that IS acceptable, in my opinion. If she is actually hurting the horse through her actions (ie making his mouth a lot harder, making him finch everytime she walks up to him, whatever), then you might be able to pull the horse. If not, then I don't see any grounds to remove the horse without giving her notice (and it doesn't have to be a month either. you can write in the contract 2 weeks if you desire)
 
Last edited:
Put yourself in the lessees position though. You've said that she's a lovely lady who wouldn't want to abuse the horse on purpose. You have a horse who (I'm assuming) she is riding fairly decently (otherwise she shouldn't be loaning him to begin with) and is generally treating him fairly.

Now I can't comment on what the situation is - if she's full out smacking whaling on the horse for each and every little misdemeanor, then you have a bit of a problem. If she's disciplining him OCCASIONALLY, ie, if he started to bite her while he was grooming her, that IS acceptable, in my opinion. If she is actually hurting the horse through her actions (ie making his mouth a lot harder, making him finch everytime she walks up to him, whatever), then you might be able to pull the horse. If not, then I don't see any grounds to remove the horse without giving her notice (and it doesn't have to be a month either. you can write in the contract 2 weeks if you desire)

Hmmm :cool: .

Having been in the lessers position I do agree, it's a bit unnerving :rolleyes: .

But the way I viewed it then, and the way I still view it now - is that even without that clause in the contract, I very much doubt the loanee could do much about the situation if the owner turned up and said "I'm taking him back" :rolleyes: . Whether the contract clearly stated a months notice would be given or not.

If I loaned a horse, and one day the owner turned up and took him, and the contract detailed the "months notice rule" - I don't see what real power I'd have.
It would hardly be worth dragging the matter through legal proceedings - paying out expensive solicitors bills and taking up endless amounts of time.
By the time anything came of it, the owner and loanee could basically say just about anything. Even with witness statements, so much time would have elapsed (and horses being the tricky live things that they are) - I can't imagine any ruling would be brought about to the loanee's benefit.
There would have to be overwhelming amounts of evidence (ie, video footage of every single dealing the loanee had had with the horse) for them to win any kind of compensation.
Certainly in all loan cases I've known which have ended (for one reason or another) - there has too much doubt for any real outcome to be had should the matter move in legalities.

So I don't honestly believe that the "no notice in case of welfare issues" offers any real amount of security.
Personally, the more I think of it - the more I think it's one of those the-illusion-of-fairness terms.
It's a shame and I'm not saying I like it :p , but I can't see how it protects the loanee under normal circumstances.
 
newrider.com