I can remove her immediately only if I have concerns for her welfare, which I think is fair.
I personally would never ever sign an agreement that had that clause in it!
I would expect both owner and loanee to give a months notice (or whatever period).
Nope, I would never sign an agreement like that. If the horse's welfare is at risk, then yes.
I think you all have very valid points

. But I suppose the question then becomes "what would be sufficient grounds to call it welfare concerns"?
Personally, I'd never loan a horse with that kind of agreement. But likewise - I'd never loan my horse out with anything less

.
The fact of the matter is, as much as I'd loathe being a loanee on such a contract, the owner is still the owner. And to say "if the horse's welfare is at risk" is a very vague description of circustances which could arise.
Supposing you visit your horse in his loan home and you witness the loanee wallop your horse (with whip) because she finds his grooming her too hard unacceptable?
You point out that he's not being naughty, and that even if he was - you don't approve of such a violent reaction. Maybe you even state that if you discover similar actions have been repeated, you'll consider it grounds to end the loan.
Loanee apologises, and promises not to do it again - but you sense she's taken none of it in.
Let's push things further, and say that this loanee is an experienced BHSAI, with a reasonably good local competition record. Add to this that (despite her smack) she's a very friendly, lovely lady - who you're sure didn't smack out of anger; just out of a belief that remotely pushy behaviour should be dealt with immediately and firmly.
You know she's not going to beat your horse. Not by any workings of the imagination. But you also know your horse, know how headshy he was when you first bought him, know he needs calm, quiet handling, and that afew weeks in that type of training regime will be seriously detrimental to him.
You explain all this to the loanee, but upon visiting again a week later, you notice her give him
several hefty "telling off" boots for spooking at a pheasant leaping in front of his feet.
Horse spends the rest of the session very tense and noticeably very jumpy (despite being a non-jumpy sort).
What do you do?
I should probably mention that (whilst
not my own situation), the scenario is very much real.
I won't say what the outcome was until afew have replied, but as I'm considering loaning Benjy out I'd like to hear opinions on this kind of circumstance.