Let's chat about safety stirrups

@newforest out of interest why don't you like the Barnes Buckle? I've never used them, or even seen them in use, but I would have thought this is the sprt of thing they're designed for.
 
@Skib the only thing the wide tread does is ease pressure on the part of your foot that's in the stirrup by spreading it over a wider area. The bend comes from your ankle joint just the same as when riding in a narrower tread stirrup. They can make a big difference to comfort if you go on longer rides.

Yes, this is one of the reasons why I use endurance stirrups as they are a wider base. I think mine have shock absorbing pads in too.

I frequently sit & stand to canter for long periods of time on my hacks & training rides (and jump) and my knees thank me very much!
 
@newforest out of interest why don't you like the Barnes Buckle? I've never used them, or even seen them in use, but I would have thought this is the sprt of thing they're designed for.
It's not so much that I don't like them. It's more that they only fit onto the traditional style. I wouldn't be able to add them to the bow balance or the offse, or anything with a different shaped top.

When I rode side saddle I had the fitting that allowed the whole leather to break away with the stirrup.
I did think about the Whippy fitting, but it would be too expensive for a pair.
 
@newforest that's a shame they won't work with non-traditional styles.

I'm curious what the fitting was that went with a sidesaddle.

If you like your Bow Balance (I love mine) then I'd get cages to fit them since it gives a double approach to safety - the cage to stop your foot going forward and the shaped sides and flexibility to encourage a sidewards or downwards release. Plus comfort!
 
I am now wondering about these.
They are lightweight Polymer and come with the cage already on it.

I’d be exceptionally careful about cheap eBay stirrups, not these but there was some wider tread endurance ones that lots of people brought a few years ago and there were too many instances of them snapping in use or collapsing in on to the foot when the horse got too close to gate posts/fell.
Turned out it was just some shady factory churning them out and they had no idea the type of stresses they would be put under and had done zero testing, they just copied a design and made them in pretty colours!
 
The cheap options concern me I agree.

I have had an email back from the company who stock the Sprenger. They contacted Sprenger and the peacocks breaking point is 375kg which they say is low and do not recommend for an adult.

I am leaning towards a cage for peeve of mind because it's a closed ring.
I will have a good look today, but the seat doesn't lift off, it's all stitched together. There are I think two more Saddlers I could try to see if they will change it. It's possibly the not wanting to touch someone else's work, a bit like a farrier won't really want to do a horse as a one off unless instructed by a vet.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
@newforest that's a shame they won't work with non-traditional styles.

I'm curious what the fitting was that went with a sidesaddle.

If you like your Bow Balance (I love mine) then I'd get cages to fit them since it gives a double approach to safety - the cage to stop your foot going forward and the shaped sides and flexibility to encourage a sidewards or downwards release. Plus comfort!
I don't think I can that's the problem, you need to remove the tread.
The only types I know that I can add the plastic matrix cage to are the standard traditional types.
I am not going to ride until I have resolved this though, I have ridden enough to know that I want to keep the saddle pad thing. But because of that ring I don't trust the Spengers, in case.
 
I’d be exceptionally careful about cheap eBay stirrups, not these but there was some wider tread endurance ones that lots of people brought a few years ago and there were too many instances of them snapping in use or collapsing in on to the foot when the horse got too close to gate posts/fell.
Turned out it was just some shady factory churning them out and they had no idea the type of stresses they would be put under and had done zero testing, they just copied a design and made them in pretty colours!
That sounds like Amidale.
It's scary what crap appears on ebay.
 
that’s a shame the seat doesn’t lift, is this on the pad type one?
Yes. All the pad type ones are like this. Even looking into the top end of the market, without naming the brand, it's a closed ring.
The majority of treeless these days have moved away from these because it relies on the rider buying safety stirrups.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
I don't think I can that's the problem, you need to remove the tread.
The only types I know that I can add the plastic matrix cage to are the standard traditional types.
I am not going to ride until I have resolved this though, I have ridden enough to know that I want to keep the saddle pad thing. But because of that ring I don't trust the Spengers, in case.
Have you considered fabric Velcro on toe covers? I have some for winter riding for warmth (they have a little pocket to put hand warmers in but I find just keeping the wind off makes a huge difference), but I suspect they’d have enough of a blocking effect to stop your foot slipping through the pedal too far.
Just seen you can get them in hi viz too
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
This is the side saddle fitting we had.
It just slots into stirrup fitting, closes back on itself and stays put.
If you fall off this alongside the safety stirrup will release the leather as the stirrup is releasing your foot.
We didn't test that theory, but I learnt the emergency dismount when I was learning to get on.


_20230202_112658.JPG
_20230202_112642.JPG
 
Have you considered fabric Velcro on toe covers? I have some for winter riding for warmth (they have a little pocket to put hand warmers in but I find just keeping the wind off makes a huge difference), but I suspect they’d have enough of a blocking effect to stop your foot slipping through the pedal too far.
Just seen you can get them in hi viz too
That's an option isn't it.
I had seen Cashel but not these. It might give me enough peace of mind to think there is also this on there.
 
Wow I had no idea such things existed ! Stirrup toe cosies lol sorry but it just made me giggle a bit................I suppose if you were out in very cold conditions you'd be glad of them. I guess I never ride when it's that cold.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
Wow I had no idea such things existed ! Stirrup toe cosies lol sorry but it just made me giggle a bit................I suppose if you were out in very cold conditions you'd be glad of them. I guess I never ride when it's that cold.
My toes get chilly, it's not really about the cold, it's the wind chill
These will be useful to have.
In the winter I mainly walk with a bit of trot if the ground is dry enough. Which it usually isn't,so it's chilly with the wind.
 
newrider.com