Let's chat about safety stirrups

newforest

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2008
33,227
17,910
113
Namely the following three brands.
Your thoughts, experience, views alternatives if you have any.

Acavallo Arena
Tech Venice
Mountain Horse

Question, do you actually need the boots to go with the mountain horse model, if yes, take that off the list.

No free jump
No barnes buckle
Don't worry if you need to go and Google the above, I hadn't heard of them either until I started looking.

I love my Bow balance, but I don't believe these to be considered safety types.
 
I haven't used any of them so can't comment. Like you I have the Bow Balance but my understanding is the shape of the sides and the flex means they are a safety stirrup as the should release your foot in a fall.
 
I have just looked up the info again and yes it does mention safety as they offer more due to the four way movement.
As I am riding in a saddle with closed rings, my brain pops up with the not totally happy that they are.
 
I’m with you on that, if they are safety because they flex my brain says they could flex to let your foot wedge through and get stuck too.

I haven’t used any of them, nor felt them and I have to feel a stirrup to know if I’ll like it as I don’t like lightweight ones.

If I were buying and reviewing I think I would rank the tech Venice last, the release hinge is at the bottom so likely to get mud in it potentially jamming it and they need routine maintenance, plus they’re damn expensive.

The other 2 I think it would depend on budget and personal preference, the mountain horse are the most budget friendly and have the classic look and the mechanism is simple, the acavello have the modern look and are slightly more pricey but not stupidly so and their hinge is at the top so you won’t tread dirt into it.
 
I have to say I'd be very uneasy about a saddle with closed rings, I really don't like that.. How do you feel about no stirrups? Or could you get a saddler to change the stirrup bars?
 
Namely the following three brands.
Your thoughts, experience, views alternatives if you have any.

Acavallo Arena
Tech Venice
Mountain Horse

Question, do you actually need the boots to go with the mountain horse model, if yes, take that off the list.

No free jump
No barnes buckle
Don't worry if you need to go and Google the above, I hadn't heard of them either until I started looking.

I love my Bow balance, but I don't believe these to be considered safety types.
Can’t comment on the others but the Mountain horse ones used to have a matching tread pattern on the sole of the boot, so your feet stayed put, but I never had the boots, couldn’t afford them back then, my old share horses owner used mountain horse everything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
If I didn't already use endurance caged stirrups I'd use the Acavallo safety stirrups as found them really comfortable when I rode in them.
 
I have not kept up to date on safety stirrups and the modern ones designed for jumping. Though competitors on our yard do have them, they dont use them when hacking.

Many years ago my winter boot was caught in the RS stirrup when I was bucked off a RS pony disturbed by the escort's large horse doing a lot of bucking beside him. So I decided to hack in my own stirrups.

I tried and disliked peacock stirrups and bent leg stirrups. I wanted symetrical stirrups and one from which I could easily kick my feet free in a fall. In the end I brought Sprenger System 4 (straight) stirrups. I have two pairs, The larger size fits my big winter boots.

However I did first buy a cheaper look alike pair for winter. Once in use, the feel of the cheaper ones was different as the springs were more flexible. My Sprengers feel the same as standard metal stirrups and the firmness is important as I use the stirrup for both mounting and dismounting. I dont take them nor use them in RS school lessons. And once riding, I cant tell the difference which I guess is the whole idea.

My RI warned me that the Sprengers might weaken over time but I am not that worried because mine are only used once a week and they have not rusted as they live in my riding bag, kept indoors. I just take them to the yard and fit them on the saddle of any horse I hack.

When I started to share Ella the YM insisted on inspecting everything I had - hat, boots, stirrips and remarked that I had the best of everything. I never had the expense of owning or buying a horse, so my money went on the clothes and tack.
 
I have to say I'd be very uneasy about a saddle with closed rings, I really don't like that.. How do you feel about no stirrups? Or could you get a saddler to change the stirrup bars?
I asked a saddler who makes a different type to mine and they won't touch it because they didn't make it.
Other saddlers won't touch as it's treeless.
I can't go without stirrups as she's too wide and it's unconfirmed and I ache.

I think my best option is going to be caged. I think my brain is probably going to come up with what if the stirrup pings open. I hadn't thought of the maintaince, unless it's a simple send away like you do clippers.
 
  • Sad
Reactions: carthorse
If I didn't already use endurance caged stirrups I'd use the Acavallo safety stirrups as found them really comfortable when I rode in them.
I can see myself having a pair of the cagged again. They would reduce some of the weight on the saddle and I am familiar with them.
 
Is your stirrup plate velcroed in under the seat? Could you order the Freeform stirrup plate instead and switch it out? Pretty sure those are the’e’ shaped bars.
I am going to have a really good look at it today and see if I can do something with it.
I have a spare stirrup plate as the Sensation comes with that option.

I have seen Sprenger peacock style stirrups that I liked the look of I would be happy with. Apart from them being in Australia. 😂
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
I can see myself having a pair of the cagged again. They would reduce some of the weight on the saddle and I am familiar with them.
My advice would be stay away from the cheap aluminium styles you see on ebay, as I don't think they'd give in an accident if they were ever hooked on something.

I have EZ-Ride and can rate them, although they are not pretty like the Acavallo ones!
 
  • Like
Reactions: newforest
I am going to have a really good look at it today and see if I can do something with it.
I have a spare stirrup plate as the Sensation comes with that option.

I have seen Sprenger peacock style stirrups that I liked the look of I would be happy with. Apart from them being in Australia. 😂

These ones? EU based rather than Australia!

 
Word of warning, the peacock stirrups have a max weight. I think 9 stone (apologies if I am being offensive) but perhaps it is 8 stone. We used them in the riding school on the smaller ponies.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
I have Acavello Arena Alupro stirrups which I changed to after a couple of falls when showjumping. I came from just normal cheap stirrups and I've had them over a year - I use them for all my riding. I haven't found any downsides. I have had a couple of falls and in at least one the stirrup opened to let my foot out. The other plus I have found is that the foot rest is offset out of the back and this has encouraged me to not ram my feet so far through

I was *very* iffy about spending that much on stirrups, but if they broke I would buy another pair
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
My advice would be stay away from the cheap aluminium styles you see on ebay, as I don't think they'd give in an accident if they were ever hooked on something.

I have EZ-Ride and can rate them, although they are not pretty like the Acavallo ones!
I have the old metal EZ rides without a cage, everyone I meet locally thinks they’re western at first glance as they’re big and bulky, but oh so comfortable on my knees!
 
I have the Mountain Horse safety stirrups and have only ever used them with my normal riding boots. Mr trews had some and he also had the corresponding special boots. He wasn’t keen on the locked in feeling and said it took some getting used to. I haven’t bought any new stirrups for a lot of years so they may well have changed design. But they definitely also work with ordinary riding boots.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
Word of warning, the peacock stirrups have a max weight.
I think it is 9 stone. I stopped riding in them. However, the yards where I found them were places offering group hacks or trail rides when we were on holiday. I guess they preferred safety stirrups as lots of non riders go on trail rides.
 
I used to use peacocks. But I learnt on here that they had a weight limit. I learned to ride as an adult and I was not overweight at 10 stone. They used them in the riding school. But I have since learned that that is over the recommended for using them.
I even bought my own when I got Storm. Then later switched to the MH ones.
 
newrider.com