Do horses have emotions? Or just moods?
I was thinking about it earlier - they can evidently feel happy, depressed, mourning, playful. But are these emotions as we typically feel as humans?
Thoughts?
I've read this thread through two or three times and I really don't know what I think. I'm struggling with the difference between emotions and moods as I see one causing the other, they are related as far as I'm concerned. So for me are we asking if horses
feel, and if they are capable of higher thought based on brain function. In that case I would say related to their basic needs being met, yes, they feel. Those basic needs of food, water, protection, love (in the sense that they are cared for by a maternal figure, herd leader?) If these needs are not met then they are sad in the sense physiologically it causes them not to produce hormones traditionally released when they receive food, water, comfort and protection, etc.
I've forgotton most of my psychology stuff from uni so this probably doesn't make much sense....really should go back and look things up.
What I'm saying is that while we clearly have higher brain functioning than horses, they have simplistic emotions and moods based on basic needs. We, being pathetically human have to over complicate life by being emotional and moody about all sorts of things...the fact that I had to get up early, the fact that I've got a horrible meeting with my horrible manager tomorrow, the fact that my colleague is grumpy and its making me grumpy. It all does boil back down to our basic needs for food, water and love so I guess we're not much different, we just take it to the next level, trying to get away from the chemical functioning because we have conscious thought.
I think it depends on what you define as an emotion as they can be happy/stressed/playful etc however when you hear owners talking about their horses "taking things personally" or "doing it just to annoy me" they don't do that.....they may do things for a reason, but not in the personal sense that many owners talk about.
Agree with this bnp.
I think as humans we tend to put our own emotions upon horses.
I do not think they feel love!
I think they are agricultural herd animals who 'depend' upon us humans to bring them food and water ( we serve a purpose)
If you look at dogs and how they respond to us, you can see a massive difference.
Even if you do not feed a dog or give it water and affection, it will still try and show you love and affection..........a horse would not do that!
I suppose it is like asking if a Cow (herd animal) feels love for humans?
I dont think so.
I think i've found this thread hard to respond to because of the experience I've had with my own horse. He's not particularly expressive and I've struggled to understand what he's thinking, feeling, doing at times. In our dark days when things weren't going to plan, I wonder if I projected my feelings on to him. E.g. He was running about squealing and I interpreted that as him not wanting to be with me, if it happened now I'd roll my eyes and just get on with it.
What I'm trying to say is that I agree with you in part CB, I think we put our own emotions onto animals and expect more than they are capable of. What I do wonder is that you sound like you're having a tough time of it just now, do you think your perception of the situation makes you interpret their behaviour as thankless? Sorry, hope this doesn't sound like I'm attacking, on the contrary I empathise having those feelings myself sometimes. Maybe its our particular horses, they don't express their feelings as readily as others do - sort of like people!!
Can you tell I've got work I should be doing but can't be bothered with. Apologies for the rambling.