Horses' emotions

I think as humans we tend to put our own emotions upon horses.
I do not think they feel love!

I think they are agricultural herd animals who 'depend' upon us humans to bring them food and water ( we serve a purpose)
If you look at dogs and how they respond to us, you can see a massive difference.
Even if you do not feed a dog or give it water and affection, it will still try and show you love and affection..........a horse would not do that!

I suppose it is like asking if a Cow (herd animal) feels love for humans?
I dont think so.
 
Yes that's what i mean.

A mare and a foal has a strong bond that she calls and calls when taken away, doesn't sound like the mare feels nothing. So if horses do not feel love, what does it feel?
 
I think NF is saying that if you dont think they feel love, then what does a mare feel for her foal?

:)

Oh i see!!

Yes, of course horses feel love.
I was meaning that horses may not feel love for us as humans.

This is the trouble with chat rooms, it is hard to get the point across in a clear way.
 
I think they are agricultural herd animals who 'depend' upon us humans to bring them food and water ( we serve a purpose)

If dogs are capable of extending their pack instincts to include us, why shouldn't horses be capable of the same thing? Do you really think having a bond with your horse is merely about food and water and nothing more? Sounds rather bleak to me, and I can't say that's my experience. A horse that looks to you to sort things out for them in a tight spot, or goes the extra mile for you isn't doing so because you give them dinner every day, I think it's because they trust you and know they can depend on you.
 
I think horses DO have similar emotions but not the same worries. Eg. Mine like competing but they don't 'worry' about being placed or what others will think. They also show jealousy of one another but dont neccessarily think "such and such is getting more fuss then me" but more "I want that fuss".

Harvey very very clearly shows emotions on his face and body language, especially his face. Not just the usual ones either but a LOT o different ones that perhaps i you didn't know him you wouldnt neccessarily notice.

General expression changes a lot in a horse anyway. Harveys general facial expression has changed a lot since I bought him. (and he hadnt been ill-treated physically).

So yes I think they do

Also I DO think horses see us as invididuals and not just people that bring food and water etc. Harvey is very much a one person horse (Piccolo loves everyone!) and for that reason is tollerant of others, particularly if I am there but can be difficult and seem upset if someone different to me or my family looks after him for any real length of time on their own even at his own yard.
 
If dogs are capable of extending their pack instincts to include us, why shouldn't horses be capable of the same thing? Do you really think having a bond with your horse is merely about food and water and nothing more? Sounds rather bleak to me, and I can't say that's my experience. A horse that looks to you to sort things out for them in a tight spot, or goes the extra mile for you isn't doing so because you give them dinner every day, I think it's because they trust you and know they can depend on you.

As you said , they trust and depend, but i dont think they 'love'.
 
I guess it depends on one's definition of love. Love in the sense that as humans we love our close ones & are in love with our OHs?

I think I would say horses do 'love' people and other horses, but maybe in their own way which is different to ours? And maybe in the horse sense of things 'love' is perhaps too strong a word.

But when I go to see Roxy & she comes over to the gate to see me, or is waiting for me, whinnies at me etc it's not because I'm bringing her in or feeding her as I do neither. I'm guessing (and hoping?!) it's because she sees me as her leader; somebody who makes sure she is okay, puts right the wrongs, makes her feel safe & secure. The same with her field buddy. Whether this is love in how we might define it, I'm not sure - probably not. But I guess in their own horsey way, this is how they show their love for their buddies and leader.

And just like in humans, this can change; when a horse goes to a new home it (hopefully) learns to love its new owner and field buddies. And I suppose to a degree, depending on the situation, they also mourn the loss of their 'loved' ones who are no longer with them.

(ETA: Hello CB, how the devil are you?! We do miss you on here you know! :wavespin:)
 
This is a really old photo but it always makes me giggle (I know it shouldn't) but it proves that horses can go in the huff and get upset about things:
SP_A0446.jpg


What was the cause of this I hear you ask?.... The 2nd row of tape because prior to this, the cheeky minx was limbo-ing under the fence and at times was about through it!

SP_A0445.jpg


Clearly I spoiled the fun. She literally stood and huffed like that as soon as the tape went up. I love how the clouds add to the effect!
 
They definitely trust and depend on us for food but I have a feeling there is more than that.

Before feeding Ziggy would like to be pushy and bargy to me (except he knows he is not allowed to be) and he takes his frustration out on Mattie, squealing, kicking out and biting. He is really really eager to get his noms.

After feeding on the other hand he seems very chilled and content. Recently he has started whickering to me in the half hour or so after he has finished his herbs, looking at me with soft eyes and ears pricked and calling. He seems to like it when I go over and fuss him. The human interpretation of that behaviour could be gratitude, or affection, or the sort of contentment which a friend adds to. It makes me feel good, anyway.
 
I think they can extend herd behaviour, although madam is independent, and seeks confidence from me, she is fiercely protective of me and gets jealous. When she's not in the mood she's not jealous, but she doesn't like tickles and fuss, but she will stand over me an threaten pig to stay away if he comes near for fuss. She also would never hurt me unless I pushed her enough, she threatens a lot, and quite viciously but never quite gets me.

She was a nightmare when pig first arrived, territorial and protective over me, she would charge him teeth bared and kick him until he moved away.
 
Do horses have emotions? Or just moods?

I was thinking about it earlier - they can evidently feel happy, depressed, mourning, playful. But are these emotions as we typically feel as humans?

Thoughts?

I've read this thread through two or three times and I really don't know what I think. I'm struggling with the difference between emotions and moods as I see one causing the other, they are related as far as I'm concerned. So for me are we asking if horses feel, and if they are capable of higher thought based on brain function. In that case I would say related to their basic needs being met, yes, they feel. Those basic needs of food, water, protection, love (in the sense that they are cared for by a maternal figure, herd leader?) If these needs are not met then they are sad in the sense physiologically it causes them not to produce hormones traditionally released when they receive food, water, comfort and protection, etc.
I've forgotton most of my psychology stuff from uni so this probably doesn't make much sense....really should go back and look things up.
What I'm saying is that while we clearly have higher brain functioning than horses, they have simplistic emotions and moods based on basic needs. We, being pathetically human have to over complicate life by being emotional and moody about all sorts of things...the fact that I had to get up early, the fact that I've got a horrible meeting with my horrible manager tomorrow, the fact that my colleague is grumpy and its making me grumpy. It all does boil back down to our basic needs for food, water and love so I guess we're not much different, we just take it to the next level, trying to get away from the chemical functioning because we have conscious thought.

I think it depends on what you define as an emotion as they can be happy/stressed/playful etc however when you hear owners talking about their horses "taking things personally" or "doing it just to annoy me" they don't do that.....they may do things for a reason, but not in the personal sense that many owners talk about.

Agree with this bnp.


I think as humans we tend to put our own emotions upon horses.
I do not think they feel love!

I think they are agricultural herd animals who 'depend' upon us humans to bring them food and water ( we serve a purpose)
If you look at dogs and how they respond to us, you can see a massive difference.
Even if you do not feed a dog or give it water and affection, it will still try and show you love and affection..........a horse would not do that!

I suppose it is like asking if a Cow (herd animal) feels love for humans?
I dont think so.


I think i've found this thread hard to respond to because of the experience I've had with my own horse. He's not particularly expressive and I've struggled to understand what he's thinking, feeling, doing at times. In our dark days when things weren't going to plan, I wonder if I projected my feelings on to him. E.g. He was running about squealing and I interpreted that as him not wanting to be with me, if it happened now I'd roll my eyes and just get on with it.
What I'm trying to say is that I agree with you in part CB, I think we put our own emotions onto animals and expect more than they are capable of. What I do wonder is that you sound like you're having a tough time of it just now, do you think your perception of the situation makes you interpret their behaviour as thankless? Sorry, hope this doesn't sound like I'm attacking, on the contrary I empathise having those feelings myself sometimes. Maybe its our particular horses, they don't express their feelings as readily as others do - sort of like people!!

Can you tell I've got work I should be doing but can't be bothered with. Apologies for the rambling.
 
newrider.com