Horses' emotions

Roxy's Mum

New Member
Jul 21, 2009
4,318
2
0
Dorset
Do horses have emotions? Or just moods?

I was thinking about it earlier - they can evidently feel happy, depressed, mourning, playful. But are these emotions as we typically feel as humans?

Can you imagine what it would be like if they could cry (wouldn't that be awful?) Or imagine if they were able to laugh!

Thoughts?
 
I'm not sure - I think they have emotions and moods - June us happy or moody but I have never seen her sad. She is cheeky or can be in a "bad" mood - I've defo seen her bored and that's when she turns "naughty" and by that I mean she does things she knows are not allowed for attention like pulling rugs off doors and kicking doors for attention. Also my mood affects her behaviour - for example If I'm upset she turns into a big cuddly monster - usually she won't stand for cuddles and kisses!!
 
I think it depends on what you define as an emotion as they can be happy/stressed/playful etc however when you hear owners talking about their horses "taking things personally" or "doing it just to annoy me" they don't do that.....they may do things for a reason, but not in the personal sense that many owners talk about.
 
I don't know, to me my horses are definitely creatures capable of emotion. In some ways it's a pity that horses don't cry more obviously, maybe that would have spared them an awful lot of cruelty.
 
Hmmm wouldnt it be great to be able to see what they are thinking/feeling.

It drives me up the wall somtimes not being able to know what my lad is feeling :giggle:

Ive never seen him look sad or miserable. Only scared Or just his normal cheeky chappy self.

My YO brought him in for me the other day because apparently he looked really miserable.
I just cant picture it myself...but hey ho :happy:
 
They are capable of at least looking resoundingly like they are sorry for themselves whether it is self pity or depression/sadness I couldn't tell you. I have a fab collection of emotional photos will pick the best out to show you - though I have an emotional/sensitive pony, she errs on the negative side of things compared to her neighbours (and not just banana man pony lol)
 
My horse "mourned" for days when her field mate was taken away. She was still safe in the sense that she had the rest of the herd there but she literally stood by the gate with her head hung low, which was completely out of character for her and she was not herself at all. So I would say she was feeling some sort of sadness or loss.

I do agree though that anthropomorphising isn't helpful for determining why a horse behaves in a certain way. But I guess I find it a bit arrogant to assume that humans are the only ones capable of more complex emotions. Just because an animal doesn't communicate in the same way as us does not mean that they are not experiencing the same kinds of emotion.
 
Pickle definitely sulks when he is told off lol OH laughs at him, he is being a bit nippy at the moment (Pickle not OH) and we are arguing about it, when he gets a rollocking he definitely looks miserable :D
 
Joy certainly has days where she's grumpier and more testing than others. Some days she's a dope on a rope, others she's more challenging. I can tell from how she behaves from the first moment she sees me.
 
Toby, although he is a gelding, has two days a month where he is vile. :frown: Not just to humans, but to his long suffering friend. Yesterday and the day before were his horrid days, but thankfully, this morning he seems a bit more lovable!!
 
Nervous/In secure
Dayatthefarm040.jpg


Contented
03012010033.jpg


Sad
29062010734.jpg

30062010737.jpg


Tired of life
16062010503.jpg


Argumentative/stubborn
freeze2.jpg


Curious
16052010185.jpg
 
Do horses have emotions? Or just moods?

I was thinking about it earlier - they can evidently feel happy, depressed, mourning, playful. But are these emotions as we typically feel as humans?

Can you imagine what it would be like if they could cry (wouldn't that be awful?) Or imagine if they were able to laugh!

Thoughts?

Yes, I think they have emotions though perhaps not quite the diverse range and scale that we humans do. For example, we often feel sad to a degree that we become depressed and it can affect our physical health - I am sure that this could happen with a horse, but would we wouldn't necessarily realise why they'd become ill, and a vet of course would only tell you that there was a physical cause and not a mental one. But, I don't think that the causes are as diverse as in humans. I don't think either Joe or Storm would get depressed and sad if they thought they were overweight - it really wouldn't bother them (that isn't probably a very good example but hopefully you get the jist).
What bothers humans doesn't bother horses, but that isn't to say that they don't feel emotions. I am not humanising them just looking at observations. I could tell that both our two felt quite scared (that is an emotion after all) when they moved home, because they'd been on a busy yard and then suddenly all the horses had disappeared!
Anyway, who knows what they are capable of feeling? Just because they don't speak the same language doesn't make them any less capable of having feelings.
 
I would go down the yes they do route, but not as we do.

When Jack was first ill he was being nudged up the bum by the herd leader who normally chases him. She must have felt something different to have done so, worried, concern, the herd was moving on without him. Loss?

His friend was very quiet the times he had colic, can they empathise? If they form pair bonds they must feel something to connect with that pair bond.

His friend was sniffing around the poorly area, licking and chewing head lowed. Did he think Jack had been attacked by a predator. Jack was depressed, he may have thought lion had got him at some point?

The herd has been very quiet generally, one is missing, but they will move on in life and deal with it, today is another day to them.
 
Slightly off topic but not entirely as its about the expression of emotion (the tricky bit of course!)

I read somewhere; 'if horses made the same kind of noises as dogs, we would never be able to stand to watch competitions'. I always found that really interesting - that if they were able to growl to express anger or fear, but more importanly to whine, cry or yelp when they experienced pain would we treat them differently?

Personally i think they feel emotion. Not on the level we do or with the same kind of level of thought attached but the basics - contentness, a family bond if not love, sadness, loss, fear etc then definately.
 
Annareeves - I am unsure how I feel about your comment reference dogs, On the one hand I completely agree my dogs yelp when they are hurting etc, but what about the horses that love to compete. and I really think that some do.

I put out some troting poles and a small jump in our indoor school and free schooled boy, no whip or lunge line I just let him trot around, He went to the poles and took him self over the jump, I never 'force' him to them. His ears where pricked and he looked to me like he was enjoying himself, When he stopped I just let him walk it off.

I think they have emotions and like others have said some times you can see when they are down (but I think this is more a phyiscal thing)

Vicki100 I would be completely livid if the YO brought my horse in when I was not there (unless of course she thought he was lame/sick and I would want a phone call at once for me to make the discussion):stomp:
 
Annareeves - I am unsure how I feel about your comment reference dogs, On the one hand I completely agree my dogs yelp when they are hurting etc, but what about the horses that love to compete. and I really think that some do.

Im not saying that isnt the case, Im sure lots of horses love the excitement of it, but we have all seen horses handled roughly. In a competition environment when there is lots of kicking on, yanking around and frayed tempers would we really be able to stand the noise?
 
When I think of the horses I have been close to in my life, then yes they certainly do have emotions. I remember when I first met my old horse. She was obviously sad. She had been overworked in a riding school and no-one loved her. After a few short weeks of me grooming her everyday and just being kind to her, her personality shone through. She started walking round with her head held high, she pricked her ears forward, she was interested in life and started to enjoy being ridden again. When I groomed her favourite spots she relaxed her whole body and stretched her neck forward.

Sometimes she was bullied in the field and was obviously scared. Once I went to get her in and another horse lunged forward at her. She stamped on my foot and in shock I shouted a number of un typeable 4 letter words! When I caught her she was actually shaking with fear - I guess she thought that I was cross with her.

While the emotions that she felt were probably more simplistic than humans, she definately had them. If people don't understand their horses emotions I think they are more likely to treat them like machines.
 
I think horses must have emotions to a degree because of the way they respond to our emotions - e.g if I'm ill or upset, Lily seems to know it and she will nuzzle me and be really sweet when normally she isn't really very affectionate at all :inlove:. If they didn't have emotions of their own I don't think they would be able to understand our emotions and respond to them the way they do.
But as someone else said, I don't think they worry about things the way people do like weight or appearance or whatever, but I've seen horses all ready for a show and they seem to know they look good and really show off, arching their necks and stepping out :giggle:
 
Im not saying that isnt the case, Im sure lots of horses love the excitement of it, but we have all seen horses handled roughly. In a competition environment when there is lots of kicking on, yanking around and frayed tempers would we really be able to stand the noise?

Oh you are so right it would break my heart. I hate to watch some of the things I have seen.
 
newrider.com