thanks guys
just on a side note, two weeks ago they said they wanted us to keep the pony on long term loan as they were so happy with everything we have done and are doing with him and how well they think the loan has worked out

Well I guess it has from their point of view
I was very non comittal at the time and said we'll see how it goes. I wish I said no at the time
The owners are delighted, we are devestated
what a pickle of a situation
and compensation, I meant just because I don't dislike them (I actually like them, despite all this hassle), and a few rugs isn't worth a whole load of hassle on the yard. They were all good value on Ebay so its not the end of the world. I can walk away from them and not feel aggreived.
I won't bother with the saddle restuff. At least all their leather tack will be going back clean and soft! Plus the sythetic stuff is actually clean. And I replaced the broken girth so they can keep the new one as that's for the pony's sake, not theirs (sort of how I feel over the rugs too!). At least he's got a good wardrobe and tack now.
I may ask at Pony Club before we commit to buy. You never know, someone may have a beloved family pony they want to go on loan to a good home
Wish me luck for next weekend. They are away till then.