Ending a loan

welshie1

New Member
Dec 10, 2007
40
0
0
:( Our fault, no written loan agreement but we loaned pony off another livery, at your yard where we keep our big horses. Big yard so you don't know everyone so we just went on word of mouth.

Pony isn't what we were told it was basically

Turns out its very spooky, hard to load, hard to catch, frightened the life out of the saddle fitter by rearing up and lashed out with its front legs at him. Can't wash it, it rears up and lashes out. Lashes out with its front legs a lot if I am really honest, which means its not suitable for young kids in my opinion.

We were told this was a totally bombproof pony, easy to load, suitable for a small child etc etc etc

When we said, he dumped a 4 year old on the road (not our child, and we weren't with him) the owners just laughed and said oh he does that sometimes :eek:

The owners just help themself to him, despite us having him on full loan and paying for everything (ie livery, food, bedding, dentist, tack checks, vet, jabs, insurance - ie as if we owned him - the lot).

We turn up, to find he's knackered as he's been out on a 3 hour hack. Happens a lot

Took him to a show and daughter missed her class as they just took him off the trailer and for a walk down the road :eek: (my Mum didnt' realise what was happening just wasn't ok and thought they were bringing him over to us, not taking him off site). Owner just helped herself to take him for her boyfriends daughter to ride. Daughter was in tears as she'd practiced so hard for this class. I challenged owner, and her attitude was - so what - its our pony :mad:.


I have started looking for one to buy - I am NOT EVER going to do a loan again as this is just too stressful.

The loan is up 1 August, we will have done the 6 months we verbally agreed

But I don't even want to keep him that long and just want to hand him back and say forget it

But it will cause really bad feeling on the yard and serious financial hardship for his owner as they are on the breadline and can't afford the 4 horses they have (including one they have on loan).


Do you think I'd be best just handing him back with a cheque for the livery? Insurance is paid upto 1 August anyway (by me). He's not due worming till July so I could pay for that too. He was trimmed a couple of weeks ago so he won't need doing for a while.


Complication is of course, small child loves the pony! BUT I can't have a pony that lashes out with its front legs, rears up and dumps small kids on the road.

Anyway, any more ideas how I can get out of this nightmare would be gratefully received


I've paid for him to be on full livery this weekend as I can't face chasing him around a field for 2 hours trying to catch him. They phone me once he's in his stable and then I call them, and they tack him up so we turn up and just ride, on lead rein, in the school. Its not why we took a pony on loan. Its meant to be fun, not a heavy heart every day.


Suggestions pleased as I feel trapped and to be honest, a bit depressed over the situation. Feel that the next few months can't go fast enough.
 
I think the owners are taking the p**s and I would not have kept the pony for as long as you have.

You should feel no obligation to keep him any longer as he is clearly not safe aroind your child, as the owners told you 'he is their pony' so he is their responsibitlity. If they cannot afford 4 horses then they will have to think about selling some or at least giving back the one they have on loan.

Loan agreement or not if you no longer want the pony then just give him back, when my horses last loaner was having problems she rang me on the Friday and I picked him up the next day. As an owner I have to expect that a horse can come back at any time with no notice!

You have done well to keep him as long as you have, the bad feeling on the yard will die down and it is no-ones business but yours, don't let a load of yard gossips influence your decsion
 
Im so sorry to hear that. It sounds like you were toally mis-sold the pony and dont get full use of it.

A pony that lashes out should certainly not be allowed around ponys, my little pony is an absolute angel on the ground but a bit quick when being ridden but NEVER naughty or nasty! and would never let any small child on hr without a lead rope, just in case!

If i were you I would hand pony back with maybe a small contribution towards livery or 1 months livery, but certainly not the lot. They didnt sort out a proper contract (and neither did you!!) so its down to them to sort out there mess not yours!!

Good luck!
 
thanks for your input

We have tried for so long now (well, since 1 February, seems like a lifetime)


We have had horses for over 30 years but always owners. This is the first loan we have ever done.

At first, we thought it was the pony just trying it on, new onwers and all that. Little ponys can be cheecky. Its becoming clear, this is how the pony is. Its not new owners.

He is fine in the school. Its where we had seen him ridden. The bad behaviour on the road came as a bolt out the blue. We were told he was perfect on the road and now we are being told he is spooky on the road. The lied really. Its had to come to terms with. I would never ever lie about a pony going to a small child (infant school age child).
 
Just be very polite thank them very much for loaning you the pony but say your daughter would really like a pony she can call her own rather than borrowed so you are going to give it back. Give them a month's notice regarding livery and then they can start looking for a new loanee.
 
Give him back- pay for nothing. No loan agreement so you can do whatever you want and as they have clearly taken the p*** out of you they deserve it.
 
Don't be put off by loans as you have had a really terrible experience with an irresponsible and downright ignorant owner :mad:
I've had loans in the past and they have been nothing like the experiences that you have described. I wouldn't feel guilty in the slightest about handing that pony back and I admire your stamina keeping him after you found out that you had been misled.
Loans aren't usually like that!
 
thanks

We weren't expecting it to be this hard. Just taking the pony when they feel like it has been a pain

And they loan it out to their friends without asking us too

Tomorrow its being used by their friend. I mean - WHY???? Had a text saying J is taking xxx out for a hack at 10am. Not is it ok, or do you mind.

We weren't sure if it was us being unrealistic having never loaned before and always been owners and this was normal way to carry on??? Seems not.

We kinda expected to treat it like it was one of ours. We have replaced all its rugs as they were all torn and damaged, had the tack all adjusted so it fits, the saddle is being restuffed after half term. We've replaced all its buckets and haynets. Its now had its feet sorted out, its back sorted. We bought it travel set, it didn't have one, so was travelled without leg protection. Spent a fortune to make its life better. Feel the owner is just using us to pay for their pony and provide everything for it and they get to use it when they want. Feel used

Sorry i am outpouring months of upset here :(

So how should a loan normally work??? We've not done one before so we just don't know what to expect I guess.
 
Sounds to me like they want someone to pay for the pony while they use it. I'd give them a month's notice out of pure politeness then leave well be.

I wouldnt write off loans though - just make sure you get a written agreement. The sample one on the BHS website is a good place to start.
 
2 weeks notice

if nothings in wirintg - tuff!!!!


some people are horrible!!!

dont let it put you off loans thoug - although i personally wouldnt loan cos i know i could never give them back.....!!!!

:D good luc and dont worry about it!
 
not a nice situation but simple to rectify:

give pony back
dont pay for anything - verbal agreements count for nothing
take what ever you have bought with you - it will do for your new pony! it belongs to you not them.

dont give them anymore money! they have taken you for a ride (no pun intended:rolleyes:)
 
You poor thing! Sounds like a pure nightmare! I would tell them verbally that you no longer want the pony right now and stop paying for everything: stop the insurance and take away any tack/feed/equipment/rugs you paid for. If apony is on full loan, the owners have the right to visit with notice to check its welare and that's about it. They have no right to ride or lend it out!!! I'm gobsmacked. My loan just ended and between taking her on and giving her back, the owner saw me twice-once to sign the loan agreement and once to see her ridden. That's what a loan means: you are 'loco parentis', full charge etc. Not all loans are bad, tho so don't dismiss it as an option but do what everyone suggests and get a written agreement with a trial period first. Frankly, I'm a little fed up of the loaning thing: you treat them like your own but the owner can give notice and try to interfere sometimes (not that mine did!) so I'm going to look to buy instead.:)
 
Don't pay for the saddle to be restuffed just give the pony back.

When I had a loan I paid for everything except the horses insurance as the owner kept that on. She would also have paid any vets bills although I would have expected most loaners to foot that bill.
I had sole use of the horse but she was always on the end of a phone if I had any problems and she would pop over and see him but never interfere. I never had a written loan agreement either but we were mutually happy with each other. She provided all his rugs and stuff and if they became worn I would just find another new one in its place.
So really I just paid for his field, food and shoes. The livery was DIY.
I only gave him up when I had to transfer areas with my job and she asked my if I would take him with me but unfortunately I hadn't anywhere for him to stay and I was moving house so it was all a bit awkward for me to juggle a horse as well :( I did miss him as he was lovely.
 
i would agree with not getting the saddle re stuffed and making sure you take with you what you bought the pony. I think a months livery just out of goodwill should stop anyone on the yard being funny with you, although it isnt any of their bussiness anyway.

Its a really horrid situation though, i hope you find a nice new pony soon :o
 
Welshie dont give up on all horses that are up for loan. Just make sure that you have an agreement written out.

Mine is on part loan and although I've not got a written agreement I verbally stated when putting him on loan that if there was a show on the day my loanee rode him then we would sort another day our for her.

I've had three ponies on loan and no problem with owners. Like everything else there are good ones and bad ones
 
thanks guys

you are making feel a bit better as I was wondering if my expectations were just too high and this was normal when you loaned a pony

seems my gut feeling was right :(

I do feel we are being taken for a ride (and no pun intended there either)

Still not sure we want to loan again. Full ownership is easier as its all down to us, good bad or ugly.

I'll let them keep most of what we bought as compensation. Apart from the bridle. He still has his horrid one he came with so I'll take back our nice English Leather one.

They are back from holiday on Saturday so I'll give them notice then.
 
The way you have been treated is apalling :eek:

I have a pony on full loan and her owner and I have only met once. I will have had her for a year at the beginning of July and and have never, ever experienced that level of total disregard. We pay for everything, same as you. I can say that if the above happened to me, I would have ended it in a flash!

Please don't let this put you off loaning, not all owners are bad people when it comes to this!
 
Last edited:
Sounds to me like they want someone to pay for the pony while they use it. I'd give them a month's notice out of pure politeness then leave well be.

I wouldnt write off loans though - just make sure you get a written agreement. The sample one on the BHS website is a good place to start.

Ditto this suggestion if you don't want to cause any ill feeling at the yard although personally if it was me I'd hand it back right away!
 
OMG!!!! :eek:

She is competely taking the p***! :mad:

Do not let your emotions get in the way. This pony is not suitable and whether you feel sorry for it or not you need to hand it back, NOW. The owner should not be interfering with the care of the pony at all (unless concerned for its welfare which is obviously not the case) and most definitley has no right to lend the pony out for other people to ride! You are paying for the pony's upkeep, you are loaning the pony so therefore only you should be able to say who rides it.

Don't stand for it anymore.

Tell the owner you are not happy with the pony being used by them when you are paying for its upkeep. Perhaps the owner isn't aware that loaning a pony out means they do not do anything with the pony? :rolleyes:

If the owner refuses to stop then stop paying for its upkeep, take back anything you bought for the pony and give it back. You are totally being taken advantage of. :eek::mad:
 
I'll let them keep most of what we bought as compensation.

Compensation for what?!!! :eek:

You are not in the wrong here! The owner is! You have every right after this experience to hand the pony back. The owner should be giving YOU compensation for taking advantage of your trusting and kind nature and generally taking the P***! :mad:
 
newrider.com