Does The Trim Really Matter?

NFU they added in their policy about a registered farrier, so if she went lame and I claimed, I would have to have a farrier involved.
 
Yes it matters. Doesn't matter who is applying it but a good trim will keep a horse sound and a bad one...er... won't... Simples.

Exactly it doesn't matter who is applying it. I wonder why though that barefoot trimmers charge almost triple in some cases for doing the same job.
 
Last edited:
But a trim on a horse who cannot cope without shoes will not make him sound and it's unfair to put him through months of pain in an effort to be fashionable.
 
Exactly it doesn't matter who is applying it. I wonder why though that barefoot yrimmers charge almost triple in some cases for doing the same job.[/QUOTE



because people will pay for it, listening to the hype !
 
Exactly it doesn't matter who is applying it. I wonder why though that barefoot yrimmers charge almost triple in some cases for doing the same job.[/QUOTE



because people will pay for it, listening to the hype !

I don't think it's necessarily "hype". I paid, and still do, £20 more per horse to have my trimmer do the ponies feet. She has done their feet for three years - it's nothing about being fashionable or anything else for us.

Silver has behavioural issues, which no farrier was prepared to work with - though being quiet and patient with her is all she needed. Even now she shakes if she sees the farrier. She can be tetchy about picking up her feet, either due to skin sores or because her joints are stiff - trimmer is also a behaviourist and has worked through this with us.

Rascal is done by her naturally as silver was - he doesn't think he can stand up on three legs. Yes wedging him in a corner makes him stand up but what is the point as it terrifies him more? I didn't know how to fix his issues - I couldn't stop him falling over or panicking. Trimmer has worked with us both and now I do his feet and kids can pick them out without issue.

Nothing fashionable, nothing trendy - she purely fitted the gap in the farriery services available to me and I am much happier with the state of their feet now, i can handle both of their feet on my own and I am more knowledgable as a result of her. Win win :)
 
I don't think it's necessarily "hype". I paid, and still do, £20 more per horse to have my trimmer do the ponies feet. She has done their feet for three years - it's nothing about being fashionable or anything else for us.

Silver has behavioural issues, which no farrier was prepared to work with - though being quiet and patient with her is all she needed. Even now she shakes if she sees the farrier. She can be tetchy about picking up her feet, either due to skin sores or because her joints are stiff - trimmer is also a behaviourist and has worked through this with us.

Rascal is done by her naturally as silver was - he doesn't think he can stand up on three legs. Yes wedging him in a corner makes him stand up but what is the point as it terrifies him more? I didn't know how to fix his issues - I couldn't stop him falling over or panicking. Trimmer has worked with us both and now I do his feet and kids can pick them out without issue.

Nothing fashionable, nothing trendy - she purely fitted the gap in the farriery services available to me and I am much happier with the state of their feet now, i can handle both of their feet on my own and I am more knowledgable as a result of her. Win win :)

My farrier worked on my youngster before he had his first trim everytime he came to the yard ( for free) just working round him and getting him used to sights and holding his feet up/tapping etc etc

He didnt feel the need to charge me quadruple the amount? Not all farriers dismiss bad/scared behaviour. I wouldnt however expect my farrier to fix my horses problems they are there to trim or shoe not to deal with issues. Some are prepared to help some are not I dont hold it against either.

Really then you were paying your trim to also sort out/Help your horses behavioural problems to? In that respect maybe alot more makes sense as to why they can charge so much.

Im not anti barefoot, Ive used a trimmer myself to see what its all about, My horse had excellent feet though and she really couldnt find much to do! I went back to my trusted farrier eventually, which proved a good choice when I got my baba!:angel:
 
Last edited:
My farrier worked on my youngster before he had his first trim everytime he came to the yard ( for free) just working round him and getting him used to sights and holding his feet up/tapping etc etc

He didnt feel the need to charge me quadruple the amount? Not all farriers dismiss bad/scared behaviour. I wouldnt however expect my farrier to fix my horses problems they are there to trim or shoe not to deal with issues. Some are prepared to help some are not I dont hold it against either.

Really then you were paying your trim to also sort out/Help your horses behavioural problems to? In that respect maybe alot more makes sense as to why they can charge so much.

Im not anti barefoot, Ive used a trimmer myself to see what its all about, My horse had excellent feet though and she really couldnt find much to do! I went back to my trusted farrier eventually, which proved a good choice when I got my baba!:angel:

Yes there was definitely an element of behavioural therapy - took me over twelve months before I could pick up silvers feet happily - I was too scared and she took the piss royally as they do.

My trimmer covers a much larger area than the farriers here, so I guess fuel is a fair bit of it but otherwise I don't know why the price difference. That said if people are prepared to pay it... Then I guess they can charge it?
 
hmm...back to the old price question...

You get what you pay for and if you feel you ain't getting enough for what you pay, then stop doing it...

Anyone with the necessary skills and equipment can trim a well behaved horse's feet in 20 minutes... easy.

and if that same horse just happens to already have good robust feet, it is comparatively easy to keep it sound with a minimum of knowledge.

but when things are not right or go wrong, one way or another, that is when the skill set really comes into play and if all a person has to offer is a set of shoes (at a good price normally) or a rasp in the belly them maybe that is why you are only paying them £10 -£20 for a trim...

I have absolutely nothing against farriers or trimmers but if they provide the service I do to my clients, and they have a range of horses on their books that have the range of problems that some of mine do, then they need to allow an hours consultation time, per horse, over all... and by the time you've factored in travel, admin, advice and education and other costs, in order to make a living (that is, on average, a quarter of what most farriers earn) they need to charge.... well, what most good barefoot trimmers charge.. funny the way that works out eh?

What only becomes evident over time is that if you think of it as paying for your horse to be kept sound (rather than paying for a trim or for shoes) the barefoot option often works out cheaper.

And the other thing that people notice after a couple of years... vet's bills are fewer and further between...

Overall you get what you pay for. If the service is comparable many farriers should be charging more, and many many more horses would be better off without shoes...
 
But a trim on a horse who cannot cope without shoes will not make him sound and it's unfair to put him through months of pain in an effort to be fashionable.

This I agree with and I did have lots of disagreements with my then instructor about working him through discomfort. Discomfort is a problem especially when I spent time longreining on the roads. Ended up with boots as he just wasn't happy bare with either type of trim, terrain or supplentary feeding, had boots not been around I would have shod.

You used to be looked down on for not having shoes, perhaps its more acceptable not to use shoes as oppose to it being a fashion. Some people are discovering they don't need them, but then some people religiously refuse to use shoes. I would only ever put fronts on because her backs are so dam hard, and we just just don't do enough. She is in light work.
 
We have 9 horses regularly shod all round. Touching wood. Most of our vet bills are for microchips for foals.

Cannot remember what we had a vet for last time it was so long ago. YES, I remember 2 years ago for a foal with a sore eye. getting on for 3 years ago now.

3 out of the nine we have had from 3-4 year olds. Not one has had a lame day.
Omne is now 22, one 20 and one 19. All hale and hearty and sound as bells. I fail to see how going barefoot reduces vet bills, now that is an amazing claim!
 
Good for you Wally.

Just genuine, unsolicited, anecdotal, feedback from clinets. Mostly with horses which had previously had recurrent shoulder, hock, suspensory ligament, navicular syndrome, side bone, ring bone, arthritic, back, joint, etc etc problems...

You have to remember that a lot of people who end up going down the barefoot route do so because they have horses that have problems in the first place. If like you they have no problems there is no need to go looking for answers.

and I guess, like you , I'm just lucky...

; )
 
Last edited:
I love my trimmer, Panda's feet are now great, when my trimmer comes she assesses Panda's workload, diet etc, asks how she's been, any problems etc. After the trim she gives me an assessment chart, noting any problems or potential problems, she also checks her pulses, assesses her weight, watches her trot up and back. Panda is always sound after her trim, which wasn't the case with my farrier, she wasn't lame, just not comfortable. My friend uses the farrier for her horse and the cob we share, quite happy with his work, i just feel whereas my oldie was fine with a 'pasture trim' Panda needs something more to enable us to do all we do. I'm quite happy to pay what I do - cost is slightly more than a half set but she travels over a very large area. Most farriers in my experience put shoes on and don't ask any questions other than 'any problems?' I've never been asked what workload, diet, asked to trot horse up or anything else and although my friends Farrier does mention if he thinks horse is carrying too much weight I can only think the majority don't as I would hope that there wouldn't be so many clearly overweight horses around.
 
Why would my farrier need to ask what workload I do? One look at the feet will tell him what he needs to know and I'm perfectly capable of weight taping and condition scoring.
 
Why would my farrier need to ask what workload I do? One look at the feet will tell him what he needs to know and I'm perfectly capable of weight taping and condition scoring.

I realise you are quite capable, but if you look around you it's blatently obvious many people aren't - WHW and many vets make this point too, as to the work load I meant as my pony was footsore just walking down from the yard I guessed he'd 'presumed' pasture trim and that I didn't intend on hacking out for hours and competing.
 
LUCK???


Now I have coffee all over my new laptop - that wasnt very lucky!
 
When my farrier comes as part of the chit chat about weather, I tell him if I have noticed problems and what work we are doing. He knows this anyway from her feet but its just conversation.

In the two and half years of owning her I have known go footsore, first whenever she came into season she was sore and second when she was on all the steroids and box rest. Other than that she has been OK.
 
newrider.com