If a farrier thinks it's hard to find a good farrier in his area then its no wonder plenty of punters are willing to pay a lot more for what is ostensibly the same service. It's nice to be able to dismiss barefoot trimming as some sort of hippy fad, but it has been around for quite a while now and isn't about to disappear any time soon, if anything the opposite is happening judging from the fact that articles relating to the subject keep appearing in national magazines these days.
It is very important for a horse to have correctly balanced feet under it - but shoes only allow that for a week or two and then growth begins to throw the whole hoof out of balance. You only have to compare how much better a horse walks away from the farrier's van compared to the way it walked towards it. Factor in a bit of crap farriery, or a horse whose conformation means it might have a different idea to the farrier about what balance it needs but it stuck with it and the idea of barefoot horses suddenly having less downtime doesn't seem quite so daft, even without thinking about concussion. Reduced downtime is one of the things the barefoot / booted Houston Mounted Police Unit found was a benefit, and it was the reason the well known american barefoot advocate and farrier Pete Ramey, who ran a trekking facility and experimented with barefoot, decided to stick with it. It's also the reason barefoot or barefoot and booted are so popular in the endurance world, most of the horses who placed in the recent super tough 100 mile Tevis Cup ride in the USA were booted, not shod, including the winner.
Shoes are fine, but they come with their own set of drawbacks, which might never bite you on the bum if you have a solid native with good feet, but may do with more problematic types struggling with poor hoof form, overreaching, shoe loss, vague unspecified lamenesses and navicular to name but a few. It's fine to decide your horse can't cope barefoot, but what if it can't cope shod?
I've got a 'can't cope without shoes' horse, but I don't shoe her and she is never expected to be uncomfortable ever. Boots give her better protection on rough surfaces and she's more comfortable out of them because she's allowed to build up sole material if she wants to. Because growth and wear are more or less in balance her feet stay right for the job on a semi permanent basis with a little light trimming now and again. The boots work too, even racing another Tb up a big stubble field in 5th gear
