Does The Trim Really Matter?

I still don't get why a foot person wouldn't be able to tell from the foot in front of them what the workload was in the past month and if there were any issues? My farrier was better at spotting problems with Little Un I was aware something was brewing.

I agree that foot care needs to take a more wholistic approach though and is something that I've posted about before. I reckon farriers would offer a better service is they discussed management of the horse and how this affected feet.
 
I don't either Joyscarer, my trimmer always seems to have a good look at each foot before she starts and I presume a farrier tells from the wear on a shoe but when the farrier trimmed my pony he just seemed to get 'stuck in with his hoof nippers' straight away, my trimmer doesn't use nippers at all.
 
I don't either Joyscarer, my trimmer always seems to have a good look at each foot before she starts and I presume a farrier tells from the wear on a shoe but when the farrier trimmed my pony he just seemed to get 'stuck in with his hoof nippers' straight away, my trimmer doesn't use nippers at all.

But a farrier cannot start work without having a good look at the horse as a whole.

Just because he does not make a huge song and dance about it, and go through the theatrical caring, sharing, huggy hippy game does not mean he is not paying attention to the way a leg is made with the foot on the end of it.

Have you asked your trimmer why they never use nippers?
 
She doesn't use nippers as never need to take much off, she also doesn't rasp the sole which he did :) and I must say I was happy using the farrier had done for several years and my friends horses are still shod by him. Unfortunately my pony wasn't comfortable after he trimmed her and after 3 trims from him I changed to my trimmer and haven't looked back, and I must say my trimmer does not make a huge song and dance about it, and go through the theatrical caring, sharing, huggy hippy game either :rolleyes:
 
Why do you think they don't use nippers Wally? (I presume it is a leading question).

When and why would you use nippers?

Personally I don't sing or dance either...

Have you ever shadowed a professional trimmer? You seem to make some very odd, and if I may say so apparently biased and defensive comments about them.
 
Why do you think they don't use nippers Wally? (I presume it is a leading question).

When and why would you use nippers?

Personally I don't sing or dance either...

Have you ever shadowed a professional trimmer? You seem to make some very odd, and if I may say so apparently biased and defensive comments about them.

Eh? when did I say that trimmer's don't use nippers?

:banghead::banghead:
 
My memory isn't great so bear with me.

My first trimmer i believe was kc pierre he used to bring a rasp, loop knife and some other knife, forgotten the name but I own those as well. I also have the hoof testers.

He used to trim the frog and make the clefts bigger, level the sole by using this knife i cant recall and level the sole and finish with the mustang roll. No nippers in sight, he chose to take off any excess height by rasping only, hence why the frog was also made lower. He encouraged me to learn about what he was doing and maintain the foot in between. This i did but as soon as he came out I had never shortened the toe or quarters enough.
Basically the pony grew back what he kept taking off.

Second trimmer brought rasp and a fab hoof stand, knife and no nippers. Rasped the front but forget if it was mustang roll because forgotten who is was from. Left the frog alone and pretty much left the clefts. Always shortened the quarters and toe way back more than I had even though maintaining.

Current farrier nippers, rasp and knife, now he could rasp it like the other two but he nips some and leaves me with wall. Now I could be wrong and this is my simplistic understanding that the difference between the grass trim is that this gives the horse a wall to walk on. Current farrier doesn't touch my wall and he doesn't touch the outer by making it look pretty-his words. He leaves the frog and clefts alone.
I have minimum flare by trimmer standards because both my trimmers would whip the wall and quarters right back. As she didn't have a trimmer for eight months and I only shaped the first thing she did was grow a wall back! If a horse needs it, it grows it.
 
Last edited:
My farrier never needed to use nippers on Joy when she went shoeless as there was less to take off, just needed a tidy up.

I agree with Wally, my farrier just gets on with it, I can ask questions if I want and used to ask a lot, nearly 7 years on with one and 5 with the other and I've run out of questions.

It strikes me that a lot what we think we are getting in terms of service is all about perception. I've ridden out with barefooters and their horses feet are no more up for the terrain than Joy's were but they see the best of barefoot and that outweighed the reasons I decided to go back to shoes again.

Like Wally, i'll stick to shoeless where appropriate and I'd go shoeless in a heartbeat if the terrain and foot were coping well enough.
 
I would love to have Dolly unshod (I wont say barefoot because I really cant see any difference from just leaving the shoes off a horse or pony that can cope without them.

Does the trim make a difference, well when I tried Dolly without shoes yes indeed it does. I am sorry to say that the equine podiatrist I used really left a lot to be desired, and amongst other things had me forking out for a pair of hoof boots two sizes too big for her. To cut a long and very expensive story short, I gave up on having her unshod, she just could NOT cope and any trimmers I could get over here were worse than useless.

I went back to my farrier, and asked him to carry on with trimming, which we did for another 4 months but despite some improvement in her feet she was just never going to be an ideal candidate for shoeless, despite being on optimum diet etc..

Interestingly, roughly six months since she has shoes back on, the squashed heels and deep clefts in her frogs have disappeared altogether. Her feet are better than they have ever been since I bought her.

I just don't know really if I had managed to find a 'good' equine podiatrist if the trim would have been enough for her......but I did have an extremely well qualified remedial farrier (who also does do 'barefoot' trims- and has some of his own horses competing unshod), and he was horrified at the trim the 'podiatrist' had done on Dolly and he did say that despite all the hype, there are just some horses that will never cope barefoot and he thought Dolly was probably one of them.

So all that waffle just to say - yes I do think the trim matters very much in some instances.
 
My trimmer does use nippers :giggle:

Had a fascinating conversation with a farrier today, who's work I have seen is consistently good.

We started talking about how he was shoeing the feet he was doing, and then the woes of local farrier and he concurred it is very hard to find a good farrier where we are.

We then chatted about me rolling madams feet - and that "trimming was a piece of piss"... (I was rasping her feet at the time)

I then said its not that straight forward hence I have a trimmer... And he got cross!

It tickled me, he agreed few good farriers locally, he said that trimming is "a piece of piss" and yet detested barefoot trimmers.

An interesting conversation ensued but a positive one :)
 
My 'barefoot' horses (basically they're simply unshod) are trimmed by my farrier. we had a long chat about farriers vs trimmers with the farrier once. he had a look at a horse done by a well known and respected trimmer - and had no qualms about it at all. he then went on to say that he 'didn't like the flaneur that comes with it' (our farrier is very much down to earth!) and that your average farrier had several yards to visit on any given day, trimming and/or shoeing a lot of horses at a reasonable price, whilst trimmers charge quite a lot for a simple trim and spend hours on end but achieving a similar (if not the same) result in the end. farrier was also dismayed he spent all these years training and that anyone can call themselves a 'trimmer' after a weekend course ...

but - I would still prefer a good trimmer to a rubbish farrier if it came down to it. luckily I have a great farrier :)
 
If a farrier thinks it's hard to find a good farrier in his area then its no wonder plenty of punters are willing to pay a lot more for what is ostensibly the same service. It's nice to be able to dismiss barefoot trimming as some sort of hippy fad, but it has been around for quite a while now and isn't about to disappear any time soon, if anything the opposite is happening judging from the fact that articles relating to the subject keep appearing in national magazines these days.

It is very important for a horse to have correctly balanced feet under it - but shoes only allow that for a week or two and then growth begins to throw the whole hoof out of balance. You only have to compare how much better a horse walks away from the farrier's van compared to the way it walked towards it. Factor in a bit of crap farriery, or a horse whose conformation means it might have a different idea to the farrier about what balance it needs but it stuck with it and the idea of barefoot horses suddenly having less downtime doesn't seem quite so daft, even without thinking about concussion. Reduced downtime is one of the things the barefoot / booted Houston Mounted Police Unit found was a benefit, and it was the reason the well known american barefoot advocate and farrier Pete Ramey, who ran a trekking facility and experimented with barefoot, decided to stick with it. It's also the reason barefoot or barefoot and booted are so popular in the endurance world, most of the horses who placed in the recent super tough 100 mile Tevis Cup ride in the USA were booted, not shod, including the winner.

Shoes are fine, but they come with their own set of drawbacks, which might never bite you on the bum if you have a solid native with good feet, but may do with more problematic types struggling with poor hoof form, overreaching, shoe loss, vague unspecified lamenesses and navicular to name but a few. It's fine to decide your horse can't cope barefoot, but what if it can't cope shod?

I've got a 'can't cope without shoes' horse, but I don't shoe her and she is never expected to be uncomfortable ever. Boots give her better protection on rough surfaces and she's more comfortable out of them because she's allowed to build up sole material if she wants to. Because growth and wear are more or less in balance her feet stay right for the job on a semi permanent basis with a little light trimming now and again. The boots work too, even racing another Tb up a big stubble field in 5th gear ;)
 
that anyone can call themselves a 'trimmer' after a weekend course ...

They can in theory, but I do think that's a bit of a red herring. I've certainly never come across anyone plying for trade as a trimmer who hadn't spent a considerable amount of time and money training with one of the umbrella organisations. I'm sure they're out there, but would you let someone with no credentials and no track record near your horse with a rasp (or nippers??), I wouldn't.

There are duff trimmers out there, just as there are duff farriers, and nobody is immune from talking through their bottom either :D
 
But a trim on a horse who cannot cope without shoes will not make him sound and it's unfair to put him through months of pain in an effort to be fashionable.

I cannot agree more. We had one such horse at my previous yard who was practically crippled.

And yet its fashionable 'trimmer' found that totally acceptable:help::help: I personally found it quite sickening - much as I would any horse that was being treated badly.
 
And yet its fashionable 'trimmer' found that totally acceptable

I don't, and none of the trimmers I've personally come across would either. There's no reason or need for any horse to be left uncomfortable, and it only leads to abcesses, body problems and behavioural issues.

Was this a few years ago? Sounds like a Strasser trimmer.
 
I don't, and none of the trimmers I've personally come across would either. There's no reason or need for any horse to be left uncomfortable, and it only leads to abcesses, body problems and behavioural issues.

Was this a few years ago? Sounds like a Strasser trimmer.

There are still stressed trimmers going :cold: where I used to be, she had her horses trimmed once a year - the trim was so severe it took a whole twelve months for two field ornaments to regrow hoof to the point of log and flared and chipping!!!!

Interesting point about how long the shoe fits for - I was asking the farrier this today - I am confident if madam was shod, that in winter we would comfortably go 6-8 weeks without trouble - however in summer, her toes are bought back every 2-3 weeks else her feet flatten out. Would shoeing her this regularly be detrimental? (I likened it to bleaching your hair and weakening it... He nearly wet himself!)
 
newrider.com