Does anyone else find this horrifying????

killing is not a crime for a horse

Agreed; but behaviour does not need to be a 'crime' for it to be unacceptable to society in general, does it? Otherwise we would not bother ensuring the security of tigers and crocs kept in captivity, would we? We could just let them out to find their own food. How much cheaper and easier that would be than the paying the butcher's bill!

I honestly do not blame the horse.

Have you read ANY post on this thread which 'blames' the horse? I most certainly haven't.

However I remain certian in the believe that no horse is incurable when it comes to emotional problems.

And you have that belief after how many years of practical experience in dealing with problem horses, and what academic qualifications in neurology, ethology, psychology and veterinary medicine?

Surely a suitable NH home with an owner who is experienced and with the right attitiude and resources, could help?

Perhaps it could - as could many non-NH homes with the right attitude and resources (as long as the problem is not a tumour or other physical condition of the brain) - but where is such a home to be found? Your constructive input into this difficult question would be appreciated.


believe me - if I were the right person and not 17 years old with very little personal income, I would honestly take such a horse on!
x

If - if - if. If wishes were horses then beggars would ride.

By the way, what do you suggest the owner of this poor horse do with regard to personal liability insurance for a known-to-be-dangerous horse, were it to be kept alive? What would YOU do with regard to the question of insurance?
 
Do many, if any, on this thread have a degree in neurology, psychology (which I am doing next year) ethology or verterinary science? While I have mere A-levels in Psychology, I am very inetrested in equine psychology, research it often, keep rescue dogs at home, and have cared for and handled problem horses from ex-racehorses to youngsters and those with general 'bad' behaviour (being one of few people on these yards willing to work with the problem). I am in no way experienced, but I do have experience. And I'm just trying to help. :-)
You're right that a horse being a danger is not acceptable in our society and so somethign must be done about it. Just to clear ti up, I'm not accusing anyone of blaming the horse and my statement was not a reaction to anything anyone here has said.
I was thinking along the lines of perhaps a retirement centre or working, as I said, with input from, say, Kelly Marks or the likes? Every possible area should surely be looked into for possible answers.
I haven't read all of the other posts (can you tell?:-/) which would probably explain misunderstandings.
As for insurance, I accept that it sadly may not be possible if insurers aren't willing to take on such a liability.

x
 
As for insurance, I accept that it sadly may not be possible if insurers aren't willing to take on such a liability.

What if a horse, uninsured because of the extent of its behavioural problems, escaped from the field and hurt someone as a result of those problems? What if the owner sued you?

We're not talking about insurance for the horse here, we're talking about having insurance in place to protect others.

Another point: In making the decision to treat or PTS, we don't (or shouldn't) just consider the outcome - we consider whether the treatment itself might be too much for the horse to have to bear.

If you've got a horse with behavioural problems, and you keep it alive, you need to accept that you are potentially extending that horse's unhappiness. Just because it isn't a physical injury, causing physical pain, it doesn't mean it's right to put the horse through "treatment" if it's suffering mentally.
 
To be brutally honest Puzzles I think you're being unrealistic in many ways & showing a lack of experience with difficult horses.

Maybe in an ideal world this horse could be turned out in a herd on hundreds of acres & never put anyone at risk but the fact is that this isn't going to happen (also if there is a severe physical problem this may not be a kindness).

NH, Kelly Marks etc all depend on the horse being aware & rational. Having read the original post & the OPs subsequent remarks it doesn't sound as though this can be relied on & that's a HUGE consideration.

The OP has already tried rebreaking this horse & taking things very slowly but to no effect. She sounds very experienced & has had help. There are also significant problems handling the horse at times & there doesn't seem to be a pattern or trigger to the behaviour.

Ex-racers & youngsters are NOT problem horses, if you think the are then you're wrong, & bad behaviour is just that. Having read a lot of your posts I'm sure you're well meaning but I also feel that you overestimate your experience & ability. I wouldn't want to have you handle Jim without me being there & I wouldn't describe him as a problem horse - sharp, powerful, opinionated & over-reactive at times but not a true problem horse - because I suspect that given a little time you'd turn him into one. The fact that people like you say you'd be prepared to take on this horse if you had the time & money is one of the reasons why people like the owner feel the only responsible action is to PTS.

I'm now putting on my tinhat & running for cover - I may never dare show my face here again!!!!
 
Thankyou Carthorse i agree with you 100% you have said what i was afraid to in case of repurcussions.
 
Oh dear, I never meant anyone to upset anyone or make them feel bad about saying what they think. :mad: Damn my big mouth and miswording!

I certainyl need to get a few things straight as I seem to have phrased poorly ...
I absolutely agree that exracehorses and youngsters are not problem horses (just as I don't believe in 'naughty' horses, I don't see 'difficult' horses as being problem horses, but I won't blab on) - a sharp, powerful and opinionated horse is hardly a 'problem' horse, my view exactly! (only it must have been phrased poorly)
My point was so-called problem exracehorses (one a rearer and another a bolter) and problem youngsters (bucking, abused, bolting, uneducated) plus let me repeat that I don't at all think I'm experienced, only have had experience of these such issues - christ, I'm 17 and haven't even owned a horse! - nor did I say that I would be able to deal with this horse, only that someone out there might, who does have the experience etc.
And as I said earlier, I wouldn't think it right to keep a horse alive that was suffering physically or mentally with little hope of relief.
Perhaps I am just being overly optimistic as there are numerous problems surrounding keeping such a horse alive, but I am sure the OP will do what she thinks is best for her horse, and whatever she chooses I would never condem her for.

So I apologise for the previous mistakes. :)

x
 
Why do people think that NH is the answer to everything, I have met numerous horses who would not respond to it at all. There's also a video I have recently watched with someone doing NH training on an Arab. He is clearly annoyed and confused and wants to get rid.

A dangerous horse shouldn't be allowed to put other lives at risk, that's the bottom line. Though it's dubious future if it wasn't PTS is equally as worrying.
 
I agree Asima. NH is all well and good, but as with all training methods it should come with a warning - doesn't suit them all!!
For instance, I don't think that doing 'join up' with a horse who already trusts and has a good bond with their owner is a particularly great idea. It's confusing, and I've heard several NH fans admit to this.

The thing is though Puzzles, we all respect your appreciation for the horses' lives. But, every one of your posts suggests that you are less and less experienced with horses than we'd thought. Have you ever been bolted with? It is extraordinarily dangerous, so don't confuse it with being run off with. It sounds to me like the owner of horse has tried many of the 'somethings' you think could cure this horse, without success. It's terribly sad, but I honestly think she's be better of having him PTS before he causes an accident that can't be recovered from. I'd like to think that this 'home for life' exists for him somewhere, but as other posters have said, how do you know it truly will be a 'home for life'? If this horse was sold on from it's supposed home for life (for whatever reason - it could be the death of the kind person who took him in) to someone who had no idea of his bolting, can you imagine what could happen? It's too terrible to think about.

I know that someone also mentioned sending him to a sanctuary, but I don't think this is really an option. Me and my mum researched sanctuaries for my sister's horse at one point, but they tend to be full to overflowing with genuine rescue cases. Surely it's better that they put their time into helping horses who have a good chance of rehabilitation and who deserve a good home after a life of mistreatment? This horse hasn't been mistreated in his current home - it sounds like his owner has worked far harder than many people would to solve his problems before deciding to call it a day. I think she deserves credit for that.
 
I was thinking along the lines of perhaps a retirement centre or working, as I said, with input from, say, Kelly Marks or the likes? Every possible area should surely be looked into for possible answers.

I am sorry that you feel you must continue to display your immaturity and naivety by continuing with this sort of unconstructive suggestion.

As for insurance, I accept that it sadly may not be possible if insurers aren't willing to take on such a liability.

Oh good heavens above young lady - are you really so unaware of the difference between HORSE insurance and PUBLIC LIABILITY insurance?

I am also puzzled by your claim that you are going to be doing a degree in psychology 'next year'? As I understand it, degrees in the UK generally take three or four years, and most 17 year olds would only be able to say they are going to be studying psychology at uni next year, not that they are going to 'do a degree' next year, so you must be a really exceptional student and very certain of your academic abilities.

carthorse said:
The fact that people like you say you'd be prepared to take on this horse if you had the time & money is one of the reasons why people like the owner feel the only responsible action is to PTS.

I agree with your entire post, carthorse, but this paragraph is especially apposite. I'll join you in the trenches with my own tin hat!
 
First of all, NO ONE can promise a forever home. People get sick, they face financial crises, they die. Things happen. Horses do get sold frequently. I think a RESPONSIBLE owner is one that realizes that not everyone wants the burden of their potentially neurotic horse.

I leased a bolter. It wasn't an "oh, I'm going to run away with you merrily". It was a "holycrap, something must be chasing me, blind panic" that resulted in him crashing through two fences, me falling off and fracturing my arm in 4 places. I still continued to ride him-despite numerous warnings not to, because as someone aptly told me, once a true bolt occurs, its hard to break them of the habit-had him in training, and saw him try to take off with two EXTREMELY experienced riders. Now, 90% of the time, he was fine. We got through some competitions, did decently well. But progressively, he got harder to handle, the more he realized that he could now take off...it's very hard to stop a 1500lbs animal once they realize that they are much stronger than you. I stopped the lease. I later found out that he had thrown two more riders, one in which resulted in a broken neck (she lived though, thankfully) The owner is still trying to sell him-not admitting anything about his problems. I would have respected her GREATLY had she put the horse out to pasture or, had her circumstances changed, put the horse to sleep. No one should have to suffer with a horse who obviously has a few screws loose, to the point that he would rather endanger himself than listen to his rider.
Could a really physically strong person who had tremendous skills work through it? Probably. But tell me, what professional would want a known bolter of mediocre talent - and risk their own health - when they could find an equally talented horse who WANTS to work and learn.

I had a trainer who once told me that there are so many nice, GOOD horses in the world who are looking for a decent home and are willing to work with someone and can be reached, why waste time-and your health- on a horse who obviously wants nothing to do with you.
 
It depends...no more I can say really. I feel for that person too. If its too dangerous and would risk the lives or backs of other potential owners, then pts is maybe logical.
 
i agree with destroying horses in some certain circumstances....

some people are so blinded by "its a life you cant destroy it" - horses dont know that they go to sleep and dont wake up

a human life is more important that a horses - sorry but thats what i think............

sometimes i think people are more selfish keeping a horse alive, than admitting defeat and saying goodbye (pts)
 
I am sorry that you feel you must continue to display your immaturity and naivety by continuing with this sort of unconstructive suggestion.



Oh good heavens above young lady - are you really so unaware of the difference between HORSE insurance and PUBLIC LIABILITY insurance?

I am also puzzled by your claim that you are going to be doing a degree in psychology 'next year'? As I understand it, degrees in the UK generally take three or four years, and most 17 year olds would only be able to say they are going to be studying psychology at uni next year, not that they are going to 'do a degree' next year, so you must be a really exceptional student and very certain of your academic abilities.



I agree with your entire post, carthorse, but this paragraph is especially apposite. I'll join you in the trenches with my own tin hat!


O.W. - Is there any need to be quite so scathing in your replies??? One of the great things about this thread is that has turned into a really interesting debate, without getting out of hand or nasty, hence it is seven pages long and not been closed a lot earlier... everyone has their opinions - I totally changed mine (I put the first post up) and opinions always differ but there's no need to be quite so harsh of Puzzles.
 
I am sorry that you feel you must continue to display your immaturity and naivety by continuing with this sort of unconstructive suggestion.

At 17 I believed anything was possible if I set my mind to it. Only a further 30 years of creeping cynicisim has eroded the ideals I had in my youth. Puzzles should be applauded for her prinicples, because if each generation doesn't have noble ideals, then there is nothing to aim for or achieve and who's to say with a horse like this, what is possible in terms of rehabilitation unless those with exceptional patience and talent try.
That said, ultimately, the responsibility for the horse lies with the owner and if all reasonable alternatives are exhausted, then its a courageous woman who makes the decision to end the life of her horse if he is such a danger that it could put others at risk.
 
O.W. - Is there any need to be quite so scathing in your replies??? One of the great things about this thread is that has turned into a really interesting debate, without getting out of hand or nasty, hence it is seven pages long and not been closed a lot earlier... everyone has their opinions - I totally changed mine (I put the first post up) and opinions always differ but there's no need to be quite so harsh of Puzzles.

Continued repetition of the boring mantra 'every horse can and should be healed' and implicit condemnation of those who believe otherwise for whatever reason, seems to me indicative of a closed mind. Closed minds are deserving of scathing responses in my opinion.

Puzzles is also going to have to deal with a great deal more than a few scathing replies on an internet forum when she goes to university to study psychology. She will need to have some well-thought-out and cogent responses when her principles - wholly admirable though they be - are questioned at a much deeper level.
 
Closed minds are deserving of scathing responses in my opinion.
Did you bother to read Puzzles last post?

For goodness sake, get of your high horse and let Puzzles have an opinion.......just because she doesn't agree with your way of thinking doesn't give you the right to respond with scathing remarks.

This has been an interesting thread and it would be a pity if it's going to be spoiled by your rude and arrogant posts.
 
i noticed old woman all your remarks are aimed at puzzle , i presume you feel the same about me as it is my postings puzzle is backing up ,
well before you question my lack of experiance and knowledge ill fill you in

i have my BHS stage 3 , i studied equine medical diorders and equine internal medicine for 5 years , i have 25 years experiance of working with horses , ranging from racing yards , to a top dressage yard , yes she was on the british team , several years ,
i wont name her but you may of heard of salute or the diplomat,
one of the more promonant horses to go through my hands was clover boy who ended his carear with joe turi ,
if you wish me to name any more of my achievements just ask
 
This is beginning to p... me off.
1) Can people stop jumping on others from a great height.
2) Can other people stop being competitive and defensive about how experienced they are.
Lets just get something out of the debate and stop reading the post if people are annoying you that much!:mad:
 
Noooo Icegirl. This is a bit like the programme 'Question Time', bright and sparky debate. This is NR at its un-fluffiest. Some fluffiness is good, but like the 1000 + posts on the hunting debate, this thread is has some very interesting points from all angles. Must be the Irish blood in me coming out -love hearing people playing verbal tennis. Just as long as the ball stays within the line.:rolleyes:
 
yh

it does seem a bit out, but sometimes its the answer. Pehaps she should send him to a trainer, or if he is unrideable and she is still worried, mabe he could be trained as a driving horse- and then anyone interested must be told he cannot be ridden
 
newrider.com