Classical Dressage

i dont believe that a heavy seat can deaden them.. again we dont sit heavy the whole ride. its used simply as a collecting aid... to get the horse to sit , and lift their front end.
 
well, thats true.. agreeing to disagree..

i guess that just goes to show how many different ways there are to ride classical, or not classical...

basically to me you are classical .. wether it be classical greek, classical german, french... etc.. but to me the only thing completely NOT classical is using hands as side reins.. i see this wayy to much, and the only country that will ever do that is America.. which is where im from...:( but our barn wont do that.. jam in front and push behind.. thats a big no.
 
my interpretation of classical dressage is spanish riding school dressage

that is classical dressage.. understand that spanish riding school of dressage in vienna is DEAD ON CLASSICAL.. again.. xenephon created that riding.. for war.. that is dressage.. not competition.. that is what i look up to.. that kind of riding... although i do competetive, i try to use classical in the competetive ring..
 
i dont believe that a heavy seat can deaden them.. again we dont sit heavy the whole ride. its used simply as a collecting aid... to get the horse to sit , and lift their front end.

But how can a heavy seat be used for collection? If the seat is heavy then there is nowhere for the horse's back to go. Yes, they may brace against you to start with but ultimately they will hollow their back against you. They cannot collect correctly if they are either braced in the back or hollow.

IMO a heavy seat will deaden the horse to the aids simply because a heavy seat causes a heaviness on the horse's back which the horse will eventually ignore. It's a bit like having the leg on all the time, the horse eventually gets used to it and ignores it.

Which classical trainers do you follow?

As StormArion says, though, we'll have to agree to disagree because I don't know of any true classical trainer or system which uses a heavy seat as part of their training or aids.
 
Xenaphon did not invent dressage, he is credited with defining cavalry tactics as an art, the types of moves used in those days and the 100’s of years before in which cavalry existed is far removed from the 16th century European cavalry drills which Dressage has evolved from.

Xenaphon is only referenced because it is the oldest written document on horsemanship, if the book by Simon of Athens (who actually was a horse trainer rather than a general) which predates him by 300+ years was still around no one would even mention him, does anyone know who wrote the second oldest book on horsemanship ?

Balkenhol was a Police man.

If you’re interested in finding out what Classical Riding really is about and you are in the US you can’t go wrong IMHO with Dominique Barbier http://www.dominiquebarbier.net/ or Paul Belasik http://www.paulbelasik.com/Index.htm
 
I think my Portuguese Classical Trainer would fall onto his knees with despair if I ever rode with a 'heavy' seat. I know my Portuguese Classically trained horse would have the biggest strop of his life if I rode him with 'heaviness'.

The only explanation and feel I have of using a 'heavier' seat is that moment of stillness and collection in my lower spine as I work through transitions. I would not describe it as a heaviness though, definitely not. I always aim for an absolute lightness in my seat/hands/legs/collection with absolute suppleness and quietness.
 
But how can a heavy seat be used for collection? If the seat is heavy then there is nowhere for the horse's back to go. Yes, they may brace against you to start with but ultimately they will hollow their back against you. They cannot collect correctly if they are either braced in the back or hollow.

IMO a heavy seat will deaden the horse to the aids simply because a heavy seat causes a heaviness on the horse's back which the horse will eventually ignore. It's a bit like having the leg on all the time, the horse eventually gets used to it and ignores it.

Which classical trainers do you follow?

As StormArion says, though, we'll have to agree to disagree because I don't know of any true classical trainer or system which uses a heavy seat as part of their training or aids.


honestly, how many pounds do you think it takes to effect the back of a horse? umm theres over weight people riding dressage and i dont think that it makes the horse not lift its back.

i dont believe in a heavy heavy seat. its another aid.
and for the 3rd time, a heavy seat wont deaden the horse as would overuse of spurs, whips, etc.. its an aid, meaning its used when needed. its simply another collecting aid.
 
Xenaphon did not invent dressage, he is credited with defining cavalry tactics as an art, the types of moves used in those days and the 100’s of years before in which cavalry existed is far removed from the 16th century European cavalry drills which Dressage has evolved from.

Xenaphon is only referenced because it is the oldest written document on horsemanship, if the book by Simon of Athens (who actually was a horse trainer rather than a general) which predates him by 300+ years was still around no one would even mention him, does anyone know who wrote the second oldest book on horsemanship ?

Balkenhol was a Police man.

If you’re interested in finding out what Classical Riding really is about and you are in the US you can’t go wrong IMHO with Dominique Barbier http://www.dominiquebarbier.net/ or Paul Belasik http://www.paulbelasik.com/Index.htm

i understand Xenaphon did not invent dressage.. i might have worded it wrongly.. i know he was a big part in dressage..

im interested in what your saying. you seem to have a very clear understanding of dressage's history, and where it originated, i admire people like that.

Balkenhol was a policeman yes but he is very classical. He uses weight aids, etc.
 
dressage is the art of perfecting the natural gait. It is the perfect walk, the precise trot, and the even canter. Long, patient training culminate in a work of art. Mutual appreciation leads to obedience, where delicate interchanges of subtle signals render obvious yet invisible communication.

Xenephon, noted greek historian and military leader, created the art in greece in 400 bc. Xenephon stated an exact principle: "If one induces the horse to assume that carriage, which it would adopt of its own accord when displaying its beauty, then one directs the horse to appear joyous and agnificent, proud and remarkable for having been ridden" then he went further to say, "if the rider is not in harmony with the nature of the animal, then it will perform as a burden with no display of pleasure."

thoes of you who believe that a light seat creates the horse to sit more in the hind end.. please tell me how you get the horse to sit and collect?

This is completely 100% true.. i study this
 
I suspect this may simply be a case of confusion due to semantics. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think Jaclyn is talking about slumping heavily onto the horse's back, but adjusting the weight distribution by rolling her pelvis back a little and having her seat aids further back and down as an aid for a movement, not as a continuous position.

As people have said, there are different routes to the same destination in riding. I am taught, and therefore ride collection differently, but it doesn't mean Jaclyn's approach is incorrect.
 
Last edited:
honestly, you're sounding like one of those irritating religious nuts bent on converting people.
be happy with how you ride. you obviously interpret classical dressage far differently then how we do

LOL just what I was thinking.
It's just an argument of semantics and interpretation.

Each to their own and whatever works for their horse :D.
 
I suspect this may simply be a case of confusion due to semantics. Correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think Jaclyn is talking about slumping heavily onto the horse's back, but adjusting the weight distribution by rolling her pelvis back a little and having her seat aids further back and down as an aid for a movement, not as a continuous position.

As people have said, there are different routes to the same destination in riding. I am taught, and therefore ride collection differently, but it doesn't mean Jaclyn's approach is incorrect.

exactally... thank you for helping me explain it.. im bad with my words
 
To me classic dressage is more about the goal aimed for. There is more than one road to Rome, but we need to know it is Rome we are aiming to get to.
 
newrider.com