Classical Dressage

dressagexreo

JaclynXReo
Jan 2, 2008
44
0
0
Minnestoa..
To me the term "classical dressage" has been used incorrectly. So many people believe that they are "classical"... So what is classical dressage? Does it mean quiet position? yes.. BUT it also goes back into the war times. Xenophon, etc. .. Dressage has been molded into this political game that creates people to treat horses like they are a machine. Dressage has created unfair riders, who and pulling noses in, and holding in front and trying to push something through behind.

.. If you agree with what im saying, next time you ride. Literally sit with all of your dead weight, heels down, legs back, shoulders broad head up, and think about thoes hind legs push them through, put weight into whichever stirrup of the side that the leg has to be sitting really long on the ground to lift the inside, or if your on straight side really just even your body and push the hind end through, and dont make a habbit of this, but put your hands forward, like someone is handing over an egg, and receive the gift. Receive the neck plopped into perfect upright position, and if he he runs, push your core at him, tell him to wait.. and keep receiving this wonderful gift your horse can give to you...
 
sit with all of your dead weight

put weight into whichever stirrup

Neither of these things have any place in the classical riding lessons i have on Andalucian Stallions.

Dead weight does not allow/makes it more difficult for the horses back end to move or lift it's back and there should be no weight in the stirups any weight transfer should take place in the seat bones.

To me what you are describing is not Classical Riding but perhaps it is and i am doing something different :o but i don't think so :)
 
No, that's not my understanding of Classical Riding either. Dead weight has no place on a horse whether it be Classical or Modern dressage.

Even within 'classical' there are various forms, we tend to follow the French school mostly which is, basically, balance before movement. The horse isn't pushed 'forward, forward, forward' but is worked slowly and with a view to the horse truly working in self carriage.

It's a huge subject so can't be boiled down to just one or two aids.
 
I'm with Chilli and Baymare on this one, "dead weight" and "classical" shouldn't be used in the same sentence and as for putting all your weight into the stirrups thats rubbish my instructor put emphasis on not doing this she didn't need her stirrups at all in fact she didn't need a bridle either and only schooled in one for competitions everything was done carefully and gently through her seat.
 
Unfortunately quite a few DO teach like this as they think that it's a way to get the horse to 'submit' :( Hold the reins and kick 'it' (why do they always say 'it'?) into a contact ...to the horse this must mean 'stop-go-stop-go-stop'.

Classical hasn't always been the most humane training method in the world though! You can ride classically and kindly but it hasn't always been so.
 
bay mare,


No, that's not my understanding of Classical Riding either. Dead weight has no place on a horse whether it be Classical or Modern dressage.

Even within 'classical' there are various forms, we tend to follow the French school mostly which is, basically, balance before movement. The horse isn't pushed 'forward, forward, forward' but is worked slowly and with a view to the horse truly working in self carriage.

It's a huge subject so can't be boiled down to just one or two aids.

the slow tempo is very much part of our system.. my trainers trainer is Jane Frizzel and she worked in the vienna spanish school of riding for most of her dressage training and this is what she brought back.

Klaus Bolkenhaul (spelling?) who is the trainer for the US and he was trained classical.. He is very much into the weight shifting, Look at pictures of him training the horses. If its a stiff horse, during tempies he is leaning ATON. It incourages the horses to fallow the outside leg and then your inner leg picks up the inner hind.

The dead weight shouldnt be used always but its a collecting aid. It encourages them to sit. Xenephon was classical, war time classical... They used this so they could use their hands during the wars.
 
I was never taught like this and if you dare try and ride like this in her company she would of told you to get off of the horse and come back when you have more understanding.

you missed that sentence, i said thats not good.. im against it and any good dressage rider should be ... please include all of my words not only some
 
Unfortunately quite a few DO teach like this as they think that it's a way to get the horse to 'submit' Hold the reins and kick 'it' (why do they always say 'it'?) into a contact ...to the horse this must mean 'stop-go-stop-go-stop'.

Classical hasn't always been the most humane training method in the world though! You can ride classically and kindly but it hasn't always been so.....

do you think that i think that holding the reins and kicking it is classical!?! because i said thats what NOT to do .. its unfair and im very against it.. you should put your hands forward and they should simply feel like a massage!
 
.. If you agree with what im saying, next time you ride. Literally sit with all of your dead weight, heels down, legs back, shoulders broad head up, and think about thoes hind legs push them through, put weight into whichever stirrup of the side that the leg has to be sitting really long on the ground to lift the inside, or if your on straight side really just even your body and push the hind end through, and dont make a habbit of this, but put your hands forward, like someone is handing over an egg, and receive the gift. Receive the neck plopped into perfect upright position, and if he he runs, push your core at him, tell him to wait.. and keep receiving this wonderful gift your horse can give to you..

this is what im saying is classical...
 
Unfortunately quite a few DO teach like this as they think that it's a way to get the horse to 'submit' Hold the reins and kick 'it' (why do they always say 'it'?) into a contact ...to the horse this must mean 'stop-go-stop-go-stop'.

Classical hasn't always been the most humane training method in the world though! You can ride classically and kindly but it hasn't always been so.....

do you think that i think that holding the reins and kicking it is classical!?! because i said thats what NOT to do .. its unfair and im very against it.. you should put your hands forward and they should simply feel like a massage!

I was answering HorseWhisp3r3r.

I think, though, that you're missing OUR point. Dead weight has no place in classical riding (or any riding). Dead weight anywhere is a dead weight on the horse's back. Dead weight stops the horse from lifting their back. Dead weight unweights them and makes them unbalanced. Dead weight will never lead to collection. Quite the contrary, thinking of 'sucking up' with your butt will slow the horse and at the same time lift your weight so that the horse's back can lift underneath you. The changes in weight are as subtle as the position of the seat bones, inclining the seatbone forwards results in the horse turning in that direction (this does move your weight, of course, and also moves your outside leg back slightly).

IMO you shouldn't be pushing your hands forward in the same way that you shouldn't pull back with your hands. Any giving and taking of the reins is done with the fingers, the squeeze, any big movements forwards or backwards are going to be magnified by the time that they reach the bit.

Pushing your core forwards = hollowing your back which restricts your back which means that you can't absorb the movement which means that you bounce. Whilst you core should be strong, your back needs to be supple and flex with the movement.
 
.. If you agree with what im saying, next time you ride. Literally sit with all of your dead weight, heels down, legs back, shoulders broad head up, and think about thoes hind legs push them through, put weight into whichever stirrup of the side that the leg has to be sitting really long on the ground to lift the inside, or if your on straight side really just even your body and push the hind end through, and dont make a habbit of this, but put your hands forward, like someone is handing over an egg, and receive the gift. Receive the neck plopped into perfect upright position, and if he he runs, push your core at him, tell him to wait.. and keep receiving this wonderful gift your horse can give to you..

this is what im saying is classical...

Can't speak for the others but what i am saying is that is not Classical as i am taught or what i get from reading books by Francois Robichon de la Gueriniere, Francois Baucher, Alois Podhajsky, Nuno Oliveira etc etc

To me its the term "classical" being used incorrectly, in many ways what you describe is the complete opposite to Classic Riding.

But like i said i could be mistake :) But i still don;t think so :D
 
I dont really think I understand what has been said properly but I have had a few lessons with Sue Barber (big classical rider/trainer round here) on her own horses and was never taught to sit dead weight???? And to watch her and some of the other staff who are very competant in this style they dont do these thing either. Even the youngsters who are learning!!

I dont get it :confused:
 
I think this has illustrated an interesting point - you have said people use the term 'classical' incorrectly, then gone on to describe a 'classical' riding which is far removed from what most of us who pursue classical training would imagine! It's all very different perceptions!

I tell people I train 'based on classical methods' because I emphasise strength, suppleness and self carriage. I try to sit quietly and correctly and use weight and seat aids to influence the horse; going for precise movements, correct outline and movement.

As far as Im concerned what you have described is just riding properly (minus the 'dead weight' and 'weight in the stirrups', which Ive never come across), not specifically 'classically'!

xxx
 
I think this has illustrated an interesting point - you have said people use the term 'classical' incorrectly, then gone on to describe a 'classical' riding which is far removed from what most of us who pursue classical training would imagine! It's all very different perceptions!

I tell people I train 'based on classical methods' because I emphasise strength, suppleness and self carriage. I try to sit quietly and correctly and use weight and seat aids to influence the horse; going for precise movements, correct outline and movement.

As far as Im concerned what you have described is just riding properly (minus the 'dead weight' and 'weight in the stirrups', which Ive never come across), not specifically 'classically'!

xxx

I tell people I train 'based on classical methods' because I emphasise strength, suppleness and self carriage. I try to sit quietly and correctly and use weight and seat aids to influence the horse; going for precise movements, correct outline and movement...

i agree with this 110%... My trainer, whos trainer came from vienna spanish riding school are really big on position, and if you sit quietly in place the horse should find its frame in that package.. Maybe im using dead weight and weight in stirrups in a way that comes off wrong..

I mean that sitting deep quietly but heavy so the horse can sit.. we dont use dead weight 100% of the time but maybe 40% in quick little spurts to encourage the horse to sit.. our core is used forward but our butts underneath us. and our core is also used in short little spurts.. We are creating our horses to be so well trained that a slight lift of our tonge is a half halt..

as for weight in the stirrups, its not extreme weight.. but simply training weight. we take our left leg of the horse on curved lines, and put a little more weight to the inside so the horse is encouraged to stand up on the outside and lift the inside... on straight lines we are completely centered and in alignment...
 
First of all, you have to understand that "classical" dressage is regional. The Germans ride a heck of a lot differently then the French and the portuguese did, yet the majority of them ride under the classical label.
(although today I would argue that the styles have been blurred together)

There is no "classical dressage" that is uniquely 100% correct. Some use the Training Scale, others use baucherism. Also keep in mind that originally, classical dressage was initially used for baroque breeds-while the principals of riding apply to every horse, the application of aids will be different.

In the end, whether you use classical dressage, or just good riding, the result is to have a good seat in the saddle, a balanced and engaged horse and enjoy yourselves.
 
i dont agree with that.

Dressage originated in greek war. The greeks trained their horses to be able to do these movements in battle. Not all the competition movements at grad prix but most were used in war. Pirouettes, flying changes. Piaffe was created just naturally where a horse would want to go forward and the rider would with their seat hold them in place. This is classical dressage, because THIS is where dressage came from. How these people ride is how it was originally taught. Xenephon was well known for it. Why do you think we wear coats and Bolkenhal (sp) wears a full army uniform? im not sure of the actual word but i think its levade.. where the horse would be trained to be head someone.. THIS is dressage. This is classical, these people had flawless positions because any little movement makes a difference. Simply lifting your tounge should make a huge difference..
 
dressage is the art of perfecting the natural gait. It is the perfect walk, the precise trot, and the even canter. Long, patient training culminate in a work of art. Mutual appreciation leads to obedience, where delicate interchanges of subtle signals render obvious yet invisible communication.

Xenephon, noted greek historian and military leader, created the art in greece in 400 bc. Xenephon stated an exact principle: "If one induces the horse to assume that carriage, which it would adopt of its own accord when displaying its beauty, then one directs the horse to appear joyous and agnificent, proud and remarkable for having been ridden" then he went further to say, "if the rider is not in harmony with the nature of the animal, then it will perform as a burden with no display of pleasure."

thoes of you who believe that a light seat creates the horse to sit more in the hind end.. please tell me how you get the horse to sit and collect?
 
I wasn't talking about a 'light' seat but a seat that isn't heavy and a seat that CAN lighten to allow the horse to lift his back.

Squeezing the butt can be used to halt, collect or half halt. The action of the squeeze naturally slows the horse (unless they have been deadened to the seat by a driving or heavy seat). Working a horse slowly (not pushing them forwards, forwards, forwards) in a counted walk, for example, is a great way of achieving collection. Anja Beran used the counted work (with laterals) a lot and her horses work superbly.
 
newrider.com