Thanks for all your good wishes.
The problem with Ben is that he has no cartilage at the base of the femur bone. I know this because it was found to be significantly damaged and therefore removed in the operation. The hope was the scar tissue would form and replace the cartilage which is why he had to be on box rest for so long as movement prevents the scar tissue from forming. The scar tissue has formed on the left stifle and this is now mended. But on the right side there doesn't appear to be any scar tissue where it needs to be. There is still swelling around the joint and he is still lame on it. With no cartilage and no scar tissue, the end result will be bone rubbing against bone which will eventually turn into a bone bleed and quite literally cripple him. He has had all the ultra strong injections to try and make his body heal plus PRP, but these haven't worked either.
So while I do appreciate people saying that he will live out happily in the field, I am not prepared to watch him deteriorate, especially when I know exactly what the problem is and I know that once he starts to deteriorate he will just keep getting worse. Before his operation we tried him on 3 bute per day and this didn't make any difference at all.
The vet wants him to gently move now to see if movement may help his body to get that scar tissue formed. It really is a last resort as we have tried everything else. It seems unlikely to me because everywhere I read tells me that box rest is needed for scar tissue. The vet says that it is possible that he could mend himself and/or he may be able to cope better because the left stifle is now fixed. But I don't want to hang onto that possibility and I need to stay realistic. So my plan is to stay as optimistic as I can, do some horse agility, in-hand showing and walk hacks while he is happy to do this. He will have 6 weekly check ups from the vet, and 6 weekly check ups from the physio and as soon as that deterioration starts to show, I will say goodbye to him.
I do appreciate hearing other people's good news stories and it is great to hear that lots of horses are happily retired. But Ben's problem is different, I have researched it so much and once that bone starts to rub on bone it is one of the most painful things to go through. Ben is so stoic, he put up with significant pain before I realised how bad things were, but just because he can put up with it, doesn't mean he has to. I would rather he had a shorter and pain free life and I feel happier having made a plan. I have an excellent vet and physio and we are all working together for his bests interests. As soon as we agree that we are on downward spiral, then I will make the call. Maybe it will be months, maybe it will be years. Who knows how long he has left?