Box rest hell finally ends!!

Would he not be able to have a low dose of bute? Or is it that you feel any pain is a reason to not go on?
I agree that pain is unacceptable but with careful management it might be controllable to a degree.
He’s your horse at the end of the day and if you feel that any ache is unacceptable then obviously that is your choice, whatever you decide will be the right thing for you.
I was simply trying to look on the bright side that’s all.

Yes pain is controllable to a degree - it isn't always straight forward at first and can take a week or two to get things right, but it can be done. @Mary Poppins it is of course your choice and you will do what you feel is right for him - but don't be quick to think that his pain (horrible word I know) cannot be managed. And yes, I do understand it is easy for me sitting here giving my two penneth because I keep mine here at home and it is much easier in some ways than being on a yard. I can decide what and when with regard to management. I totally respect and understand anyone who may not wish to go down the same lines as I have with mine.
 
Well what a difference a bit of turnout makes! I caught him, led him in, tied up outside his stable and then rode for half an hour. The personality transformation is amazing, he is back to his normal self. This makes me feel lots better and I think we just need to take each day as it comes. The fact that I no longer feel he is going to kill me when I lead him makes me much happier.
 
Well what a difference a bit of turnout makes! I caught him, led him in, tied up outside his stable and then rode for half an hour. The personality transformation is amazing, he is back to his normal self. This makes me feel lots better and I think we just need to take each day as it comes. The fact that I no longer feel he is going to kill me when I lead him makes me much happier.
The classic horse owners rollercoaster! So glad things have picked up
 
The classic horse owners rollercoaster! So glad things have picked up

It is the biggest rollercoaster ever! Until yesterday I really couldn't do a thing with him. It was a challenge getting in and out of the stable sometimes. And now after just 2 hours turnout yesterday and 3 hours turnout today, he is like a completely different horse. For the first time in a very long time I felt completely confident to get on him. What would we do without the highs and the lows?
 
People say this, but to me, if he is trotting up lame and compensating for his injury, he will be in pain regardless if I am riding him or not. If he was sound when not in work that would be different because it would be the work that was causing the lameness. But he is lame regardless, and lameness means pain.
Don't give up yet, I know it's so hard and you really have been to hell and back. And I can honestly say that we were all hoping for better news today. But at least the vet thinks there is still chance for him to improve.

Maybe my story will give you a little hope? Don't take this as preachy or telling you what to do though. Ale was retired to his field over 2 year's ago now and I've shared so many precious and wonderful moments with him in that time. Ale was diagnosed with arthritic fetlocks, arthritic stifles that had shape changes and either sacroiliac injury or again arthritis. This isn't to forget his previous very bad check ligament tear. He was very lame behind, I don't think the vet ever gave me a score but he was dragging his hinds and very straight legged, not tracking up, not even close. And lame on a fore also where the arthritis was at its worst. He was in pain while being ridden but the vet said he may deteriorate without it due to muscle loss. This was a chance I thought it was worth take as I couldn't bear riding him.

He's out in his field 24/7. He moves around so much which I think is really beneficial for him and he hasn't lost very much muscle. He seems like a happy pony and if he's in pain he certainly doesn't show it. He rolls happily, lays down, prats about and charges around when the mood takes him. He improved very quickly once out, you'd have to look at him fairly hard to see much is wrong with him now. He tracks up again but his hinds do have a slightly unusual action. He no longer drags them except for on a very tight circle. I know a day will come where he will deteriorate and then I'll have to day goodbye, but I think the best thing you can do is watch you horse and see what their behaviour tells you.

Hopefully you do get the chance to spend more time with Ben, ridden or otherwise. In the meantime as a pick me up I highly recommend grabbing a blanket and a good book and spending half an hour reading in his field with him. If you're anything like me you won't read much of it though as you'll be too busy either watching your horse or they will come over and try and help you ;)
 
People say this, but to me, if he is trotting up lame and compensating for his injury, he will be in pain regardless if I am riding him or not. If he was sound when not in work that would be different because it would be the work that was causing the lameness. But he is lame regardless, and lameness means pain.

I am in pain every day but it doesn't stop me walking the dogs, riding the horse, working full time, planting the garden, painting like crazy. I just know when I have to stop. A lame horse can also just be a mechanical thing, something not working right, but they can learn to cope and be a field ornament if their temperament is ok. Rose was a cheerful invalid, till the day she was pts. She was a wrecker, arguer, pain in the ass, but she managed.
 
Thanks for all your good wishes.

The problem with Ben is that he has no cartilage at the base of the femur bone. I know this because it was found to be significantly damaged and therefore removed in the operation. The hope was the scar tissue would form and replace the cartilage which is why he had to be on box rest for so long as movement prevents the scar tissue from forming. The scar tissue has formed on the left stifle and this is now mended. But on the right side there doesn't appear to be any scar tissue where it needs to be. There is still swelling around the joint and he is still lame on it. With no cartilage and no scar tissue, the end result will be bone rubbing against bone which will eventually turn into a bone bleed and quite literally cripple him. He has had all the ultra strong injections to try and make his body heal plus PRP, but these haven't worked either.

So while I do appreciate people saying that he will live out happily in the field, I am not prepared to watch him deteriorate, especially when I know exactly what the problem is and I know that once he starts to deteriorate he will just keep getting worse. Before his operation we tried him on 3 bute per day and this didn't make any difference at all.

The vet wants him to gently move now to see if movement may help his body to get that scar tissue formed. It really is a last resort as we have tried everything else. It seems unlikely to me because everywhere I read tells me that box rest is needed for scar tissue. The vet says that it is possible that he could mend himself and/or he may be able to cope better because the left stifle is now fixed. But I don't want to hang onto that possibility and I need to stay realistic. So my plan is to stay as optimistic as I can, do some horse agility, in-hand showing and walk hacks while he is happy to do this. He will have 6 weekly check ups from the vet, and 6 weekly check ups from the physio and as soon as that deterioration starts to show, I will say goodbye to him.

I do appreciate hearing other people's good news stories and it is great to hear that lots of horses are happily retired. But Ben's problem is different, I have researched it so much and once that bone starts to rub on bone it is one of the most painful things to go through. Ben is so stoic, he put up with significant pain before I realised how bad things were, but just because he can put up with it, doesn't mean he has to. I would rather he had a shorter and pain free life and I feel happier having made a plan. I have an excellent vet and physio and we are all working together for his bests interests. As soon as we agree that we are on downward spiral, then I will make the call. Maybe it will be months, maybe it will be years. Who knows how long he has left?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lissie and Jessey
Ah, now I understand. Yes, I've seen this on the Supervet show with dogs. You need to ask Noel Fitzpatrick if his cartilage transplants have ever been tried on horses!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
Ah, now I understand. Yes, I've seen this on the Supervet show with dogs. You need to ask Noel Fitzpatrick if his cartilage transplants have ever been tried on horses!

That would be amazing if that could happen! It doesn't help that Ben is a very big and heavy horse. There is a lot of body to carry around on that joint. I guess that dogs are much lighter and they don't have so much weight on their joints?

I guess if he were human he would have some kind of knee transplant? I think that people who have knee transplants have a similar issue with the cartilage wearing away between the joints? People who have knee pain like this often say is it excruciatingly painful and my vet says that it is the same with horses. As soon as the bone rubs on the bone it is really dreadful.
 
Thanks for all your good wishes.

The problem with Ben is that he has no cartilage at the base of the femur bone. I know this because it was found to be significantly damaged and therefore removed in the operation. The hope was the scar tissue would form and replace the cartilage which is why he had to be on box rest for so long as movement prevents the scar tissue from forming. The scar tissue has formed on the left stifle and this is now mended. But on the right side there doesn't appear to be any scar tissue where it needs to be. There is still swelling around the joint and he is still lame on it. With no cartilage and no scar tissue, the end result will be bone rubbing against bone which will eventually turn into a bone bleed and quite literally cripple him. He has had all the ultra strong injections to try and make his body heal plus PRP, but these haven't worked either.

So while I do appreciate people saying that he will live out happily in the field, I am not prepared to watch him deteriorate, especially when I know exactly what the problem is and I know that once he starts to deteriorate he will just keep getting worse. Before his operation we tried him on 3 bute per day and this didn't make any difference at all.

The vet wants him to gently move now to see if movement may help his body to get that scar tissue formed. It really is a last resort as we have tried everything else. It seems unlikely to me because everywhere I read tells me that box rest is needed for scar tissue. The vet says that it is possible that he could mend himself and/or he may be able to cope better because the left stifle is now fixed. But I don't want to hang onto that possibility and I need to stay realistic. So my plan is to stay as optimistic as I can, do some horse agility, in-hand showing and walk hacks while he is happy to do this. He will have 6 weekly check ups from the vet, and 6 weekly check ups from the physio and as soon as that deterioration starts to show, I will say goodbye to him.

I do appreciate hearing other people's good news stories and it is great to hear that lots of horses are happily retired. But Ben's problem is different, I have researched it so much and once that bone starts to rub on bone it is one of the most painful things to go through. Ben is so stoic, he put up with significant pain before I realised how bad things were, but just because he can put up with it, doesn't mean he has to. I would rather he had a shorter and pain free life and I feel happier having made a plan. I have an excellent vet and physio and we are all working together for his bests interests. As soon as we agree that we are on downward spiral, then I will make the call. Maybe it will be months, maybe it will be years. Who knows how long he has left?
Whatever and whenever you decide, it's very apparent everything you do is in his interests. He's had a rough time, but damn, he's lucky to have you. Virtual hugs.
 
I've lurked on all your posts but never logged in until today, I just wanted to wish you the very best with Ben. I was the same with mine, bute was making little difference to him and I wasn't happy to keep him going on even though I was being told all the positive stories, at the end it is you and your vet who know the full details and whilst something positive still might happen, I think your plan to enjoy the shows, hacking and get out and about within his limits are brilliant. Enjoy the time with him, it's clear from every post that you have his welfare at the front of every decision made for him. I did the same last year with my lad and I have no regrets with my decision (it's taken me a long time to accept that).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
There was an article this week on using capsicum, very hot pepper, to inject into knee joints to basically stop the joint pain. I am sorry his case is so complicated and yes it does sound very hard to fix.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
I've lurked on all your posts but never logged in until today, I just wanted to wish you the very best with Ben. I was the same with mine, bute was making little difference to him and I wasn't happy to keep him going on even though I was being told all the positive stories, at the end it is you and your vet who know the full details and whilst something positive still might happen, I think your plan to enjoy the shows, hacking and get out and about within his limits are brilliant. Enjoy the time with him, it's clear from every post that you have his welfare at the front of every decision made for him. I did the same last year with my lad and I have no regrets with my decision (it's taken me a long time to accept that).
It must have been so hard for you to make that decision. It is very brave to make away their pain before it consumes them but something that I feel very strongly about. The old saying about ‘better a day too early than a day too late’ is very true for me. We will now live on the 6 weekly cycle of monitoring and I am going to do everything I can to enjoy the time we have left together.xx
 
That sounds horrible!

it's very effective at numbing nerve pain. when Leo almost took my thumb off, I have a lot of pain there as it never healed and the doctor suggested doing that with it as it would make it less sensitive. For people injecting it directly into the knee joint stops the endless pain and while the joint will still need replacing at some point, it at least gives you more quality time. I had a knee revision 3 years ago, the same knee is beginning to go again, it isn't bad enough for a total knee replacement just hurts so I would be quite happy if they could remove the pain rather than take lots of pain relief daily and then have it replaced where it really needs it. My surgeon said that I wouldn't really feel it was worth the recovery for the gain I would make right now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
it's very effective at numbing nerve pain. when Leo almost took my thumb off, I have a lot of pain there as it never healed and the doctor suggested doing that with it as it would make it less sensitive. For people injecting it directly into the knee joint stops the endless pain and while the joint will still need replacing at some point, it at least gives you more quality time. I had a knee revision 3 years ago, the same knee is beginning to go again, it isn't bad enough for a total knee replacement just hurts so I would be quite happy if they could remove the pain rather than take lots of pain relief daily and then have it replaced where it really needs it. My surgeon said that I wouldn't really feel it was worth the recovery for the gain I would make right now.
You know what Ben feels like then! Knee pain is horrible and it's good to find something which fights the pain.
 
Also it's not disloyal to think about other horses perhaps as well, I had the companion pony and whilst I had deliberately got her on loan as I knew L didn't have years on him, she's with us on indefinite amount of time. I've enjoyed having her, she'll not be with us for years and years but it has got me excited about a future with another one down the line, despite me being all consumed with L at the time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
newrider.com