backed and turned away?

Yeah, I know what you mean. Kinda like my horrible farrier who BREAKS a horse in three days. He really 'breaks" its spirit to. More like beating into submission, then climbing on...grrrrrrr :mad: some people...
 

I have broken-in yearlings for racing and riding before... of course when I say yearling I mean they were nearly 2 year olds (not that some people will think that's any better). The were backed and taught the aids at this age then turned away for a year.

I seriously have no problem with backing at this age as far as just sitting on them and walking around. At 3 they would be brought back in given their basic education, no galloping or jumping. They would go out again for a couple of months at 4 and then come back into serious work. We never had any problems with them breaking down in any way and we turned out some really good horses this way.

The only real problem I see is when young horses are galloped, jumped or ridden on tight circles before they are matured. I don't see how sitting on them and walking and trotting around are so cruel and awful.

 
When we produce them, we handle them well asap and then break them when they are 3 and then turn them away and start work on them again at 4. I find it really does help their bones etc. Someone I know is riding a 3yr old on the roads and everything. Personally, i think this horse isnt going to have the best bones and its joints etc may be ruined. I'm not trying to tell people that they are wrong breaking them in earlier but i would never break them in before they are at least about 3 and a hlaf years old.
 
how can you say there is know problems with his joints,bones, growth etc, at 2 he is still growing, you can see in his jonts and you cant see into the furture to see if he will suffer and problems then.i wouldnt want any weight on his back.

sorry i just like babies to have the chance to be babies
 
We have an Appy that is just over 3 at our stable, she is ridden a lot every day. No problems at all with her, and she's the sweetest to ride. And about my post earlier, I think it depends on the horse. So maybe you disagree with me, and thats fine. I don't agree thats its horrible, and remember, most of us aren't D.V.Ms really.
 
The people who are helping me train him have been breaking horses at the age of two like forever. And no joint problems have occured because of this. Like I've said before...we don't really do any real work until they are about 4yrs.
 

I don't know why I'm throwing my opinion into this discussion, I guess it's just to voice my own opinion and experience in the hope of learning something from it. I am not preaching anything and my beliefs are definitely open to change, or I wouldn't be voicing them.

As I have said my experience has been with breaking in young horses. This is how I was taught and is the way mentors of mine break in. I know that the horses have turned out sound because they have stayed in the same families and in the same schools and in the same competitive circles all their lives. These horses have been cattle horses, campdrafters, cutting horses, polo ponies, polocrosse horses and otherwise hard working horses who have still been competing at the highest level well into their teens with no problems and then being used as schoolmasters into their twenties.

That is just what I have seen, and that is why when people make a big deal about starting horses too early I raise an eyebrow, because I have been around this the whole time and seen no ill effects. I have on the other hand seen the ill effects of working young horses too hard and too fast... but this is not synonymous with breaking in (not in my book anyway).

So am I wrong to sit on a horse at 2 year old if I take things steadily? Am I the monster that alot of people here would make me out to be?
 
Originally posted by Shiny McShine



That is just what I have seen, and that is why when people make a big deal about starting horses too early I raise an eyebrow, because I have been around this the whole time and seen no ill effects. I have on the other hand seen the ill effects of working young horses too hard and too fast... but this is not synonymous with breaking in (not in my book anyway).

So am I wrong to sit on a horse at 2 year old if I take things steadily? Am I the monster that alot of people here would make me out to be?

Exactly...
 
i think that a horse shouldnt be backed before the age of about 3, even if you do take it slowly. breaking in a horse should be taken slowly at the age of 3 never mind the age of one or two. u wudnt send a child out to work at the age of 5 would you? even if it was only light work. People think that its horrible for children working in india at the age of 5, well isnt that the same for a horse thats broken in as a yearling or a two year old. My section d that is being broken in is nearly 4 and was only backed a week ago. havent dun ne trotting on him or circle work jus walking around the school on the lunge so didnt even have to turn him, have just come off the lunge and have started doing turning work with him. i only work him for about 5 - 10 mins a day about 3 or 4 days a week, now thats wot i call taking it slowly.
 
I think as has been pointed out, we all need to be aware of the trans-atlantic differences. In many countries, it is common to train horses earlier. If you think it's wrong - you're entitled to that opinion. However, I think you need to be aware that others may not share that opinion.
My two cents - it depends on the horse & the trainer. I've seen horses started earlier w/an intelligent trainer that are just fine at a later age. You also see horses that were asked too much too soon that suffer breakdowns (physical, mental, etc).
Anyway - just wanted to point out that we should all be cognizant of cultural norms before we outright condemn something. People wouldn't be on this board if they didn't care about their horses and want what's best for them.....
 
The thing with horses is I guess everyone has there own ways of doing things I think thats why heated debates start!

I wouldnt personally even sit on my girl as she is a cob and matures alot slowly... plus I think she would chuck me straight of lol!

anyway I think only worries were if they were being over worked and made to bend ect ect.. i guess maybe a potter about wouldnt do to much harm as long as rider was light and sensitive
 
newrider.com