I don't know why I'm throwing my opinion into this discussion, I guess it's just to voice my own opinion and experience in the hope of learning something from it. I am not preaching anything and my beliefs are definitely open to change, or I wouldn't be voicing them.
As I have said my experience has been with breaking in young horses. This is how I was taught and is the way mentors of mine break in. I know that the horses have turned out sound because they have stayed in the same families and in the same schools and in the same competitive circles all their lives. These horses have been cattle horses, campdrafters, cutting horses, polo ponies, polocrosse horses and otherwise hard working horses who have still been competing at the highest level well into their teens with no problems and then being used as schoolmasters into their twenties.
That is just what I have seen, and that is why when people make a big deal about starting horses too early I raise an eyebrow, because I have been around this the whole time and seen no ill effects. I have on the other hand seen the ill effects of working young horses too hard and too fast... but this is not synonymous with breaking in (not in my book anyway).
So am I wrong to sit on a horse at 2 year old if I take things steadily? Am I the monster that alot of people here would make me out to be?