backed and turned away?

Peace

pAin't Nobody's Bidness
Nov 12, 1999
3,730
0
0
South Carolina, US
Visit site
Just curious, but why do people do this? Over the years, I've read on NR of people backing horses at age three or so and then turning them away until they're 4 and ready for light riding.

Since in my country most people just start working them at two or three, I'm not familiar with the practice of backing and turning away. Can anyone explain to me why it is good practice to begin training and then suspend it? I'm sure there's a good reason, I'd just like to know what it is.:)
 
Turning away alows horses to mature both mentally and physically. Before about the age of 31/2 to 4 horses are not physically or mentally able to cope with what is asked of a ridden horse. But since being on nr is seems to be that this is different in others countries. I could never imagine even sitting on a 2/3 year old letting alone breaking them because they've just got so much growing left to do. Trying to school a horse of that age must be like trying to teach child thats just learnt to walk, to dance.
 
I want to teach Dolly the basics of being ridden, then turn her away for 6 months to let her rest and grow, and bring her back into work when she's 4.

It gives them a breather, rather than throwing them into ridden work, and keeping them there. Young ponies and horses need to adjust mentally, and in her 6 months off, I'm still going to do groundwork with her, and take her for walks with ridden horses, and on her own.
 
I believe that young horses are really like young children and that their education should be fun and interesting with not too many physical or mental demands on them. I feel that turning a horse away is benefical so that a consolidation period can take place, whilst they are still having fun.
 
It has been my experience that a horse, given time off to "digest" a concept, often finds it easier next time. It's been more visible to me when I work on a new concept that horse isn't getting, but several days later at the next session horse seems to be responding much better.

Being from the States also, I was unfamiliar with the concept of backing a horse and turning it away, but considering my experience with "breaks" allowing a horse to sort of mull something over and come to grips with it, it makes a lot of sense. You can expose the young horse to an idea briefly, but not in a demanding way. Then, when horse is ready for somewhat more real work, horse has grasped the concept, but without a great deal of stress attached.

You can easily overpower a young horse, especially a bright one, by asking too much before the horse has really *understood* the basics. If he's quick about catching on, he may be able to offer you more than he's ready for--and if you try to build on that, he may blow a fuse in his poor little brain. Jessica Jahiel has a good article on that:
http://www.horse-sense.org/archives/2000107.phtml

Essentially, like a child could, a horse can pick up the motions of something without really being comfortable with the idea--like being able to recite the times tables without any idea of what multiplication is. A horse could demonstrate ability to accept a person on his back, to walk and stop, and to turn, without really being comfortable with the idea. If you push it, as for too much riding time or too much more in the way of riding, you could overface the horse and make him scared; you could burn him out and make him unhappy with being ridden--or if you're lucky, horse will tolerantly keep plodding along and trying hard to figure it out. You really need a horse with an extraordinary temperament for that, though.

In your case, Peace, I would bet your little guy has come to grips with being ridden one way or another, and it does sound like he's in that last group :) It has still probably been a very good experience for him, to have you give him a long break. You said that when Cathy went to evaluate him recently, he acted as though riding was still just no big deal. That's the whole idea. You *did* sort of get a horse who was backed and turned away till 4 ;) His original backing might not have been the best, but hey, you've got a little star.
 
we had a little arab stallion (ok, colt, but by the time he left ne KNEW he was a stallion) come to our stable to be trained once. He was only two, but by the time we had finished his training he could do almost anything! Craig long reined him and taught him everything just from the reins so by the time he was ready to be backed Craig could just get on him and he's already know (he was turned out at three to be a baby, but never came back, i think the owner may have run out of money). Generally as a rule we won't back horses at 2, we are willing to train them, but we try not to sit on them. i think a lot of it is that it can just be easier to train a horse who's younger (they aren't so big), they may not be ready to do the stuff older horses do, but if they are somewhat familiar with it already it will be nicer when the time coms for real work. I notice it's always a bigger pain to traint he horse who was allowed to be a "baby" for 5 or 6 years than the one who really is still a baby, but getting work in now.
 
Thanks, guys, that does make a lot of sense.:) I suppose it is easier, when it comes time for riding, if they're already familiar with the concept. And it sounds like a good way to make sure their initial experiences are positive and don't seem too difficult.

Thank you, galadriel, for calling Quanah a "star" (I'll have to tell him you said that, he'll like it:) ). I am incredibly lucky to have found such a preternaturally calm horse. Cathy says it's partly that he's got a sweet nature, and partly that he's incredibly lazy.:p That's ok with me, though - I've got more patience than confidence at this stage.:)

Oh, BTW, I totally agree that horses shouldn't be worked too young. Quanah did start working at two (although only as a beginner's trail horse), and I remember when he first came to our barn Cathy thought he might be showing signs of incipient joint problems. He's seemed fine for the past year and a half, though, so maybe no damage was done.
 
Last edited:
Really good question! I often wondered at that myself! Do you guys honestly thing that they go away and think about being ridden when they are turned away? Just a random question!I'm not sure if they would, but maybe they do! Its a common practise in NZ too :)
 
Originally posted by Cochise
Do you guys honestly thing that they go away and think about being ridden when they are turned away?

Considering that, as much as I adore them, I don't think horses *really* "think"...no. I don't think they sit around and discuss it with their buddies and neighbors, etc ;) I do think that exposing them to a concept, and giving them time to get used to it without asking anything else, makes it easier for them to accept the idea.

Like I said, I have experienced something similar, in much shorter-term. Teaching a concept that a horse tries hard to understand, but just doesn't "get"--next session, he seems to understand much better. Giving him time to get away from the pressure makes it easier to work on the concept again later.

So say I'm working a horse on really flexing, rather than just moving to the right or left. It's a tough concept for a horse new to it. I work at it until I've gotten something even vaguely close to what I'm after; I reward the horse, stop right there, and let horse be done for the day. Next session, horse has some idea what got him such a great reward last time, and the pressure of the whole last session is gone; we're starting at the beginning. Horse had time to recognize what it was that I was asking for, and had time to relax after a tough session of trying to figure it out. Horse, being a generally willing creature, attempts to give me what got him a reward last time. I ask for what I got at the end of the last session, and I'm likely to get something very close to what I'm looking for.

So I don't think he really *thinks* about it, but I do think giving him time to digest it helps us both.
 
This is one of the very few occasions on which I'm going to disagree with you, Galadriel ;) . I actually do think horses have the intellectual capacity to mull things over in their heads and reach conclusions (albeit sometimes the wrong ones) all by themselves. They have incredibly good memories and, I'm certain, a fair degree of reasoning power, and I for one think we might be batting on a sticky wicket, so to speak, by underestimating them.

But you know me - I like to play safe :D .
 
Well I have ridden a 12.3 or so hh yearling colt, saddle, halter with lead rope and lunge line. Its fun, but bumpy. You can't squeeze too hard or the horse will bolt or too lightly, as he won't get the message. I walked and trotted in a small circle for about 15 mins last summer.
 
They had trained him to. It was a dark bay Welsh I think. Unfotunately, his hormones were driving him crazy, if you know what I mean, so he was sold. He could walk and trot on command, and halt. Thats about it. He would be maybe 13.2 - 13.3 when he grows up.
 
I am breaking my horse at two years old. He has learned everthing very quickly so far. And truely seems to understand what I'm asking. We don't do very much work, but I work with him 3 times a week, and his mind hasn't blown yet, and his joints are fine. I think that if you do it right, a horse can be broken at a young age. However I will not be doing any real work until he is three or four. I guess what we are doing now would be called "backing" but we don't use that term, and he won't be "turned away."

Oh, and a yearling is way to young to be riding. But I guess I can't say anything, because many of you would say the same about a 2 yr. old.
 
newrider.com