Our little mare was diagnosed with severe arthritis to hinds 2 years ago- she had a bad attack and poor prognosis, would never be ridden and we had bute for her, she was taken in as a companion in anycase so ridden not a problem, 2 years on, shes off bute, she has nobute and Turmeric and a magnetic band on o/s hind, shes ridden by the kids, runs round the field like a loony , lives out 24/7, has a rug only in the worst of the winter wet/cold and is 20 years old, plenty of life in the old girl yet......... saying that for any of ours once the balance swings on the Welfare scale and we have no way of managing it for a good quality of life then we would PTS.