Arthritis advice please :(

orbvalley

Well-Known Member
Jan 15, 2008
2,007
1,572
113
57
France, South
Hi, Could anyone give me any advice on my 19year old retired (with navicular) PRE please. He's field lame on his front right, which is his "navicular leg". He's moving this leg from what I describe as "from his shoulder". He lives within his herd and is out 24/7 on grass. He's always been of a fragile mental natured horse and is always at the bottom of the hierarchy. This is the only herd that I've ever seen him settle into. I consequently don't feel as though taking him out of it in order to box him to a vets that can xray for further investigations a good idea. The only field x-raying vet here is one that I've had a bad experience of misdiagnosis with in the past.
So, I had an osteopath out to him this weekend to se if she could relieve some of his pain. Her opinion was that rather than his problem coming from his front right lame leg is that its coming from quite severe arthritis in his hips.
Does anybody think this sounds possible/logical? She was a nice lady and very caring towards my horse but I have no experience of osteopathy and no experience of arthritic hip symptoms. I do however think it very likely that his hips have some arthritis as they click when she was manipulating him...??
Any help, experiences or advice would be very welcome as he really has been a good friend to me if not my best one :(

Thank you in advance xx
 
I am sorry you are going through this, it's a shame when their bodies start letting them down as they get older :( sometimes there just isn't anything else you can do to keep them comfy.

I can't really offer you any advice as my personal thoughts are I wouldn't keep a field lame horse going, but I didnt want to just read and run.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
No advice to give but just to say I hope you find an answer to what must be a horrible emotionally painful time for you. x
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
Thats a shame there isn't another vet who will field x ray. I agree removing him from the herd would be emotionally draining for him and stressful if he's a bit fragile mentally.
As jessey suggests, could you get the vet out to give a once over? Lots of kind thoughts to you anyway, it's not nice when they start to show age related discomfort.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
The only vets that could come out to him are "general vets" and don't tend to diagnose on lameness..............
The nearest equine specialist is a 3.5hour drive away and thats without a box trailer. I think it would do him more harm than good to take him there.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
I think I'm in a bit of shock actually as I don't consider him "old" at only 19 despite his problems and "field lame" isn't generally seen over here as a euthanasia dilemma

I guess I kind of thought he'd live his retirement out to at least reach 30:(
 
Having just been told the historical damage to my spine is causing the pain and arthritis in my hips and knee I can quite believe that your osteopath is probably onto something.

I had a similar but not exactly the same issue with my old horse (21) and after a long and brutally honest discussion with my vet I decided that if the only way to keep him was stabled, probably on up to 6 bute a day (he was a very heavy horse) with occasional turnout on his 'good' days and all that at the risk he could go down in the stable and get cast and unable to stand anyway, as he was in the last few days kept out 24/7 - it was a relatively easy decision to make. But hurt like hell :(

I do agree with previous poster - I will never keep a horse going when it is no longer field sound.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
I think I'm in a bit of shock actually as I don't consider him "old" at only 19 despite his problems and "field lame" isn't generally seen over here as a euthanasia dilemma

I guess I kind of thought he'd live his retirement out to at least reach 30:(

yes that is exactly how I felt - in my perfect world he would amble happily around the meadows for at least another 10 years - so sorry you are going through this, I really do understand. :( x
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
It's personal preference. Some people chose to bute and give horses all sorts of meds to keep them around, Just because I won't medicate to keep field sound and if a horse of mine was field lame without meds I wouldn't bute them to keep them with me doesn't mean that you have to say good bye. Some horses seem to go forever, I'm blessed that I seem to have one such horse, still sound and happy on herbal supplements and rideable at 25. It's all about what you think is best for you're horse. I get some amount of abuse for my attitude towards medicating older horses just to keep them sound, just the same as I wouldn't put a horse of any age through a colic surgery, these are my choices and shouldn't be taken as the gospel on what others should do.

If the ride will stress him then I wouldn't do it unless I desperately had to, it is a shame that he has so many issues, must be heartbreaking for you. You have my sympathies as I dread the day Kia starts to break down in front of me, it is inevitable and makes me sad :(
 
I'd agree hauling him 3.5 hours doesn't sound like a good idea, has it come on suddenly? If it has I might try a short course of bute and see how he goes, maybe 3-5 days, just enough to let things settle then reassess 5 days after he's off it, perhaps he just did something silly with the herd?
 
Please don't think I'm adverse to peoples different opinions on this subject. I understand that we're all different thats why I posted on here for different opinions :)

He's been field lame since around February:oops::(, it used to come and go before but this time its not going. I hoped that with the summer months he'd get better but obviously he hasn't. I only see him once a week so I was kind of kidding myself that I was just seeing the unlucky periods:oops:
 
I was at the vet today with my 12 year old Springer, Molly. She has very severe arthritis in her left hock which has been treated for the last 3 weeks with a K Laser http://www.klaser.co.uk. She was much better today with considerably increased range of motion - but the reason that I mention this @orbvalley is that my vet commented on her front paw, which are both very arthritic, and how the right front paw was much worse affected because of the compensatory strain on it caused by her favouring her left hind leg and foot.

So I think it's possible that front limb lameness could be caused by rear end arthritis, as that is definitely the case in my dog.

The thing is that arthritis is really hard to help. I would recommend the laser therapy based on my dog's experience, but I've no idea if that kind of therapy is available where you are in France.

I do feel for you, 19 does not seem old and yet for some horses it is.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
@Jessey I don't know what "no but" is?? he doesn't get a supplementary feed at the mo, since being in his happy herd he's gone from anorexic to a big fatty:oops: I know this doesn't help with his joint problems but can't bring myself to restrict his grass intake when its for sure the only time in his life he's had enough to eat and drink:(
The osteo lady did speak about a few different supplements I could try but I have yet to have the report in order to buy them.

Having spoken to my Husband this evening we have mostly come to the conclusion that being "field lame" is not at least for the moment a reason for euthanasia, our reasoning being that humans limp and still live happily enough , also we have 2 old dogs (14yrs each) they have their health problems: ones deaf the others nearly blind, but they still live happily enough despite these handicaps.
As said before no offence nor argument to anyone else in the same awful situation but with differing opinions.
 
It's very hard. I've had a similar dilemma with a pony I cared for: he came on loan and pretty immediately came up lame behind when worked but was ok in the field. After various examinations the vet said he was unlikely to ever be sound and suggested euthanasia was the only option. He was still field sound at that point so we decided to try 'No Bute' which is a herbal remedy containing Devil's Claw (Harpagophytum procumbens) which has been found to have anti-inflammatory effects. I was very sceptical but it worked a treat and he went on to have another 4 ridden years. His condition was suspected to be congenital degeneration so eventually he did have to be PTS but he was totally sound for a fair few years on the No Bute and noticeably uncomfortable if we ran out or reduced the dose. He was a native who got fat on fresh air so we fed a token sprinkle of chaff with (I think) 15ml of liquid. If you did want to try this then a quick search using the botanical name came up with it here:

https://www.lepaturon.com/no-bute-articulation-cheval-rekor,fr,4,NOBUTE.cfm but it's much, much more expensive than in the UK (it would be about €20 here).

or you can get it in dried form e.g.
http://www.equi-well.com/31-a-base-d-harpagophytum

The other thing I did was learn equine massage techniques and give him regular mild massages with the agreement of the vet and physio. I did a course but found this book was an excellent starting point: http://www.cavaletticlothing.com/shop/accessories/books-dvds/sports-massage-for-horses/

The best of luck finding something to keep him comfortable. You know and love him best.
 
I've seen Devil's Claw very effective in mild arthritis in dogs and horses. Horses like the taste of the liquid, dogs don't!

This is the brand I have used: http://naturallyanimals.co.uk/shop/search.php?q=devils+claw&searchbutton=Go!

It's interesting having a bag of the dried root as a diagnostic aid. It doesn't taste good, but horses and even dogs will choose to eat it sometimes if they think it will help them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
Bosweilla is meant to be very effective too, and less long term side effects, white willow is also anti-inflamatory, some folks have good results with tumeric paste too, its worth trying to see which if any will help :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: orbvalley
newrider.com