I looked into the barefoot diet years ago when I first had Raf and I seem to remember the most important thing (at the time) was restricting the amount of grass eaten. I can't remember much about the diet, but I remember it seeming quite a challenge to a relatively new horse owner. Then I had the EP who cut his feet down to barely nothing and made him more sore each time she came (which she said was natural because she was having to re-shape his feet bit by bit and eventually we'd get to the desired result. She also had me hand walking him on a hard surface wearing boots with special pads inside to condition his feet. It was all very hard work and eventually I listened to my YO and got the vet to check his legs and she confirmed that his pasterns were starting to be a bit broken back, so that was that, end of our barefoot attempt.
I've always said I'd like to try again, using my farrier this time, but there never seems to be a good time. If he doesn't stay sound this time I might go down the same route as @Mary Poppins, but obviously I'm hoping for the stay sound scenario.
Your experience is completely the opposite to mine. I got a new farrier to pull Ben's shoes 10 weeks ago (the old one refused to do it and said it was madness and if my vet wanted to completely cripple Ben he could take the shoes off himself!). We have left his feet completely alone. No trimming, no interference. Nothing at all! I am lucky that my vet, my saddler, and some very good friends have been down this route before and completely support this approach.
The theory is that the feet will grow in such a way that will support Ben's movement. I have a friend who has 2 dales ponies. She doesn't ride them and they successfully self trim. I think that the concept that horses have to do miles and miles of road hacking to self trim is false. The foot will respond to the stimulus given. If the foot is trimmed every 4 weeks, it will continue to grow at that rate. If it is not trimmed, or the horse is not hacked, the growth of the hoof will slow. That is my theory anyway. Ben is hacking out for 7 hours per week on a mixture of tracks and fields, but this is mainly to help his lameness and arthritis. I don't have all the answers, all I know is that I am learning as I go along. And I know it is working of us.