Anyone feed mint?

I looked into the barefoot diet years ago when I first had Raf and I seem to remember the most important thing (at the time) was restricting the amount of grass eaten. I can't remember much about the diet, but I remember it seeming quite a challenge to a relatively new horse owner. Then I had the EP who cut his feet down to barely nothing and made him more sore each time she came (which she said was natural because she was having to re-shape his feet bit by bit and eventually we'd get to the desired result. She also had me hand walking him on a hard surface wearing boots with special pads inside to condition his feet. It was all very hard work and eventually I listened to my YO and got the vet to check his legs and she confirmed that his pasterns were starting to be a bit broken back, so that was that, end of our barefoot attempt.

I've always said I'd like to try again, using my farrier this time, but there never seems to be a good time. If he doesn't stay sound this time I might go down the same route as @Mary Poppins, but obviously I'm hoping for the stay sound scenario.

Your experience is completely the opposite to mine. I got a new farrier to pull Ben's shoes 10 weeks ago (the old one refused to do it and said it was madness and if my vet wanted to completely cripple Ben he could take the shoes off himself!). We have left his feet completely alone. No trimming, no interference. Nothing at all! I am lucky that my vet, my saddler, and some very good friends have been down this route before and completely support this approach.

The theory is that the feet will grow in such a way that will support Ben's movement. I have a friend who has 2 dales ponies. She doesn't ride them and they successfully self trim. I think that the concept that horses have to do miles and miles of road hacking to self trim is false. The foot will respond to the stimulus given. If the foot is trimmed every 4 weeks, it will continue to grow at that rate. If it is not trimmed, or the horse is not hacked, the growth of the hoof will slow. That is my theory anyway. Ben is hacking out for 7 hours per week on a mixture of tracks and fields, but this is mainly to help his lameness and arthritis. I don't have all the answers, all I know is that I am learning as I go along. And I know it is working of us.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bodshi
I suppose my puzzle is, if the diet is unbalanced this applies to the horse whether or not it has or hasn't got shoes.
But people only appear to consider the diet when taking shoes off. No right or wrong just an interesting observation that I have seen time and again.

All horses evolved to live on a low sugar, low starch, high fibre diet. We get told to feed for work done and I'm sure the putting on weight spring and summer and losing Autumn winter still applies. I read an article somewhere online that a scientist said the horse was less stressed if this happened because the survival instinct is at forefront. The metabolism works if it gains then drops, as oppose to us constantly trying to get weight off.

Shoes help and they can hinder. The transition from shoe to no shoe changes the angle of the hoof, the hoof is no longer prepared for a shoe.
I don't get that farrier just wants to make money because that's like saying your instructor doesn't mention about your saddle because they want to make money from your crap riding. My farrier will mention products which he has done, we use magnesium.

I agree that it is a very interesting discussion.

I guess the shoes mask any pain the horse will feel from being barefoot. Isn't this why people shoe in the first place? And yes, I do feel I am baking a cake. He has loads and loads of powder! But it is making a difference. His new growth of the hoof wall is much tighter and looks much more robust.
My issue with supplementation is the volume not it's use. I want a supplement that is barely noticeable in the bowl but very noticeable in the body.
My trimmer wanted me to feed so much that I felt like I was making a cake, not feeding a pony.
But because I cannot control my grazing completely, the trimmer said my yard was unsuitable for Barefoot. It might be.

Thanks for the question mp because it's giving us things to chat about.
 
I agree that it is a very interesting discussion.

I guess the shoes mask any pain the horse will feel from being barefoot. Isn't this why people shoe in the first place? And yes, I do feel I am baking a cake. He has loads and loads of powder! But it is making a difference. His new growth of the hoof wall is much tighter and looks much more robust.
 
I too am lucky enough to have a farrier who is more than happy to offer tips on supplements and general diet management that might be hoof related both for Dolly and the donks. And actually thinking about it I have had this very welcome input form other farriers over the years. I have also had farriers who have been extremely happy to care for some of my horses who have had no need to be shod and also for others I might have had who did need shoes. It was never a big deal, quite simply some where unshod, some weren't - and they were all kept in the same manner, same feed and routine. but then back in the day we all knew the huge dangers of too rich grass and ad lib sugar filled grazing for almost all horses, so nothing new or revolutionary there then?

However I do recognise that in this day and age, for their own reasons, horse owners will only feel they are doing the best for their horse if they adopt a total barefoot stance and follow their chosen acolyte word for word - such is human nature in the horse world when things generally go pear shaped ;)

As I recall, please forgive me if I am wrong, MP had absolutely no contact or input or interaction with her farrier, as she stated herself this was 'just how it is' on her yard' so I do feel it might be a tad unfair to just say the farrier may have done Ben and MP a great disservice in how he shod and cared for Ben's feet. Quite possible I guess that his incompetence totally fecked Ben up - but also it is very possible it had absolutely nothing to do with it - and after all he had zilch feedback from the owner/rider of the horse so why would he even dream their was an issue with Ben's feet at that stage?
 
I agree @newforest, I hate the cake baking feeling but I'm still battling jess' feet not being the best, her horn is great and very strong but she still suffers with thrush at the drop of a hat which many believe is diet related but it could also be her cushings/immunity. I'll find out this winter if this year's changes have made a difference.

I don't see that you can decide never to shoe a horse again or that one trimming theory/methodology should sway someone completely to believe that is the only way to do things, it's narrow minded to believe one thing is always right for every horse. Shoes have their place, trimming has its place, self trimming has its place, the skill is knowing which fits where.
 
I agree @newforest, I hate the cake baking feeling but I'm still battling jess' feet not being the best, her horn is great and very strong but she still suffers with thrush at the drop of a hat which many believe is diet related but it could also be her cushings/immunity. I'll find out this winter if this year's changes have made a difference.

I don't see that you can decide never to shoe a horse again or that one trimming theory/methodology should sway someone completely to believe that is the only way to do things, it's narrow minded to believe one thing is always right for every horse. Shoes have their place, trimming has its place, self trimming has its place, the skill is knowing which fits where.
Yes that’s a fair point. I am just relieved to see an improvement in Ben and I want it to continue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
I agree @Jessey
Speaking personally, I tended to view shod or unshod as both perfectly good options and I tended to leave horses as they came to me. The shift for me has been the evidence that hooves adapt to work and that protecting them with shoes leads them to lose their own ability to be protective- the same way clipping stops a coat from working properly. When you think of how crucial hoof health is for a horses survival it is no surprise they have evolved to be pretty good at their job and that our interference might make them more vulnerable not less. So I am now shifting toward viewing unshod as the default/preferable option with shoes used only as needed. But I am never fixed on any one point of view and always open to new information, evidence or ideas.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
Well that’s is all good for thought...... however after reading all the above I realise that this is against all of my horse owner principles.

To take a horse that lives out 24/7 and bring in to keep of the grass as it is bad for the hoof would then result in other issues for me. Albi does well on grass during the summer he does not need any hard food unless we are away competing. He weight is good and no ulcers. He gets freedom to a field to walk around all day to play and interact.

To bring in means giving hay as he can’t be left with nothing at all and he will stress and start to crib. Movement is restricted which is not good on the joints.

To me I would be taking a very health unrestricted 24/7 rountine with no hoof issues and causing him extra stress a change of diet and restriction

Thank you all for the information but it is not very for albi and I

However if I got another youngster that arrived unshod I would try to keep it that way. But if I felt it need shoes I would shoe.
 
I agree that it is a very interesting discussion.

I guess the shoes mask any pain the horse will feel from being barefoot. Isn't this why people shoe in the first place? And yes, I do feel I am baking a cake. He has loads and loads of powder! But it is making a difference. His new growth of the hoof wall is much tighter and looks much more robust.

But surely a balanced diet would have this effect anyway with or with out shoes on
 
How does self trimming work if a horse has no access to different terain? Surely turned out 24/7 in a field they'd just grow slippers? I will ask my farrier this question too. Am curious because our girls have access to stones and sand and field - but need trims every ten weeks. Any longer and they look all wrong and feet look overgrown.
 
Well that’s is all good for thought...... however after reading all the above I realise that this is against all of my horse owner principles.

To take a horse that lives out 24/7 and bring in to keep of the grass as it is bad for the hoof would then result in other issues for me. Albi does well on grass during the summer he does not need any hard food unless we are away competing. He weight is good and no ulcers. He gets freedom to a field to walk around all day to play and interact.

To bring in means giving hay as he can’t be left with nothing at all and he will stress and start to crib. Movement is restricted which is not good on the joints.

To me I would be taking a very health unrestricted 24/7 rountine with no hoof issues and causing him extra stress a change of diet and restriction

Thank you all for the information but it is not very for albi and I

However if I got another youngster that arrived unshod I would try to keep it that way. But if I felt it need shoes I would shoe.

See Storm arrived with no shoes on and I just kept her that way. It never entered my head to change her diet or routine. J on the other hand, could never go without shoes - vet and farrier were in total agreement on that and that was fine, we managed okay (found one of his lost shoes years later in a corner of the field!!)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
I'm not sure about the self trimming side of things either. Cally was in full work, out eventing, hacking on roads etc. Her feet were like blocks of oak. She still needed trimming. Or at least it looked to me like she needed it. Perhaps what we view as a healthy hoof shape/size is too narrowly defined?
 
I know that I will never look back and will never shoe another horse again.

The theory is that the feet will grow in such a way that will support Ben's movement. I have a friend who has 2 dales ponies. She doesn't ride them and they successfully self trim. I think that the concept that horses have to do miles and miles of road hacking to self trim is false. The foot will respond to the stimulus given. If the foot is trimmed every 4 weeks, it will continue to grow at that rate. If it is not trimmed, or the horse is not hacked, the growth of the hoof will slow. That is my theory anyway. Ben is hacking out for 7 hours per week on a mixture of tracks and fields, but this is mainly to help his lameness and arthritis. I don't have all the answers, all I know is that I am learning as I go along. And I know it is working of us.

Never say never MP - You may one day have a horse and a situation where if you wish to ride shoeing is your only option.

Also if horses self trim left to their own devices why are there so many rescue horses with Aladdin’s slippers?
 
Self trimming is the horse wearing down what it's grown.
I don't know any that can do that and actually stay balanced though. Maybe some can. But mine is base wide and doesn't.
I keep my eye on her but the farrier does pop out and balance.

It grows the more the more we do and when the grass grows-I believe?
 
Never say never MP - You may one day have a horse and a situation where if you wish to ride shoeing is your only option.

Also if horses self trim left to their own devices why are there so many rescue horses with Aladdin’s slippers?

The Aladdin's slipper is something I can't work out either. Ours were trimmed last week, and had gone eleven weeks and were really ready for doing, Storm's did look long! So I am puzzled over self trims
I am def going to quiz my farrier next time.
 
The Aladdin's slipper is something I can't work out either. Ours were trimmed last week, and had gone eleven weeks and were really ready for doing, Storm's did look long! So I am puzzled over self trims
I am def going to quiz my farrier next time.
If they are neglected for 15 years they can end up like this.
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/...ears-found-with-3ft-long-hooves-10473164.html

My guess is is a combo of no movement and no nutrition. The hoof perhaps grows weird to try and support what's happening above? The slipper horses are not worked out even fed most likely.
If the horse doesn't move muscles deteriorate and get used to survive. That effects movement and therefore growth.
 
Fed mint didn’t do anything cinnamon is better for feet than mint and adds a pleasant taste.

It’s amazing how people Pooh-pooh barefoot until it suits them to have a go. Also thinking it will save you money is another reason people try it.

Until a horse has issues folk won’t try it, shoes or not as long as a horse is happy and in no pain it doesn’t matter to me. Horses for courses, but the problem solvers and bandwagoners that called us long term barefooters the BF Mafia as we were seen to be pushing it a lot that are now trying it out and singing it’s Praises do make me chuckle.

I don’t feed a specific barefoot supplement. I just feed a standard and add cinnamon and VitE. Kia’s been rockcrunching for over 12 years now. He has fronts on at the moment as due to his age he isn’t growing as much quality foot anymore but again his feed remains the same whether shoes on or not.
 
We pulled Jack’s shoes when he was retired but he got sore in his fronts and so we put shoes back on them. He’s still unshod behind and although he gets trimmed by the farrier his hind feet have changed shape quite a lot - not the angle of them, but they’re not as round as they used to be.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
newrider.com