Anthropomorphism in horses

Mark Rashid, who taught me, disliked anthropomosphism in particular the human treating of horses with food as a reward. As a result I must be about the only person in my RSs or yards who has never given a treat.

Some one here when I asked why Ella contiually broke off feeding to touch my arm, suggested it was because she was looking for a treat. The staff and other clients treat the horses I ride. I never do.

However I read something about yoga and breathing yesterday.
I learned to breathe slow and deep for natural childbirth and then again from Rashid to use when riding.

Maybe horses are sensitive to rates of breathing in other herd horses and in humans? I dont know. Maybe horses know the heart rate and breathing of others in the herd?

What do people thnk
Maybe they are, that would be a really interesting thing to find out, perhaps there have been studies carried out that look into this but I haven't heard of any.
 
Big negative - over feeding. Have come across people who feed their horses (and other peoples) with endless treats, grass and hard feed. Result - fat, cresty, nippy horse, heading for, or already having EMS. People do it with dogs and children too. They equate the giving of food to giving love.
Perfect example yes, we overeat to fill some void perhaps but horses should not need this. How interesting I had not thought of this, may borrow this for the slide if it's okay
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
We and horses are the same - taking any food available. Horses are geneticaly set to maximise energy input. i.e. food
Stephen Pinker in How the Mind Works 1997 wrote about human genetic gearing to maximise calory content - from stone age conditions. It opened my own eyes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
Yes I saw a guy on tv who said parents instil comfort eating in their children by offering them a sweet or a tasty treat to distract them when they're upset. I'm certainly guilty of doing it with my own children when they were little. But then sweets were still a treat when my kids were little, not something you got every day. When I was little you only got part of a sweet - my mum used to cut mars bars up into slices and we'd have a slice as a treat. As a child my mum got cocoa powder and sugar mixed in a twist of paper if she was really lucky!

Is it just a human thing to show love with food? Some species of birds feed each other when courting, maybe other animals do too.
Oh my mum did the cutting up mars bars too! OH was completely flummoxed by it, and it's a family joke now, because to this day, I still only eat half a mars at a time! I treat Hogan to a carrot now and then, but only now and then,as he is totally food driven, and he'd be unmanageable and even more of a thug than he already is. I think it is quite a human thing, to perceive food as a bribe or reward.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bodshi
Mark Rashid, who taught me, disliked anthropomosphism in particular the human treating of horses with food as a reward. As a result I must be about the only person in my RSs or yards who has never given a treat.

Some one here when I asked why Ella contiually broke off feeding to touch my arm, suggested it was because she was looking for a treat. The staff and other clients treat the horses I ride. I never do.

However I read something about yoga and breathing yesterday.
I learned to breathe slow and deep for natural childbirth and then again from Rashid to use when riding.

Maybe horses are sensitive to rates of breathing in other herd horses and in humans? I dont know. Maybe horses know the heart rate and breathing of others in the herd?

What do people thnk
It certainly seems that people think that horses react to breathing rates. I've lost count of how many sources have advocated singing to regulate your breathing if you're nervous on a horse. I still sing if I get twitchy, or sense the horse getting nervy. It does seem to work - most of the time!
 
Some one here when I asked why Ella contiually broke off feeding to touch my arm, suggested it was because she was looking for a treat. The staff and other clients treat the horses I ride. I never do.
I suggested she might be looking for a treat, the fact that you don't treat her doesn't mean she won't associate a persons presence in the stable with getting a treat. I rarely ever feed Hank treats, not because I can't manage his enquiries for more, but my friends toddler can't and he will expect treats from every living being if he even gets 1 a week from me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy and Skib
Oh my mum did the cutting up mars bars too! OH was completely flummoxed by it, and it's a family joke now,

The reason my (our) parents sliced Mars Bars was that sweets were on the ration during and after WW2. I was at secondary school before they came off. Mars bars had to be shared between several children.

There were two ways to slice Mars Bars - to cut across like slicing thin slices of bread, or to cut thicker slices and then cut them in half vertically. I prefered the thin slices.
 
The reason my (our) parents sliced Mars Bars was that sweets were on the ration during and after WW2. I was at secondary school before they came off. Mars bars had to be shared between several children.

There were two ways to slice Mars Bars - to cut across like slicing thin slices of bread, or to cut thicker slices and then cut them in half vertically. I prefered the thin slices.
Yup - thin slices here too! A whole one actually makes me feel a bit queasy! My mum was a single parent of 4, which through the 60's meant a lot less help than she'd get now. We had sugar sandwiches too! Ooh - and spam fried in batter - yum. Sorry - totally off topic!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bodshi
I was spoilt then as I got the whole sweet.
Though once a week it was either smarties or milk gums.
It certainly seems that people think that horses react to breathing rates. I've lost count of how many sources have advocated singing to regulate your breathing if you're nervous on a horse. I still sing if I get twitchy, or sense the horse getting nervy. It does seem to work - most of the time!
It works for my lunging as well. I have lunging music set up if I feel like it. It gets me more active and she's on the end of rope and she responds as well.
They feel our tension and see our body language, we can't lie to a horse.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
I was spoilt then as I got the whole sweet.
Though once a week it was either smarties or milk gums.

It works for my lunging as well. I have lunging music set up if I feel like it. It gets me more active and she's on the end of rope and she responds as well.
They feel our tension and see our body language, we can't lie to a horse.
I remember milk gums! You can't get them now I don't think. :(
 
My mother used to delegate cutting up the Mars Bars to me. There were 3 of us so it was tricky. I perfected it so that the boys (my brothers) found it hard to choose.

The middle slice had to be a little thicker than the end slices, to compensate for having less chocolate coating....
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Jessey and Huggy
My mother used to delegate cutting up the Mars Bars to me. There were 3 of us so it was tricky. I perfected it so that the boys (my brothers) found it hard to choose.

The middle slice had to be a little thicker than the end slices, to compensate for having less chocolate coating....
Hilarious that this is where this thread has ended up!
 
The thread coming here fits perfectly.
It centres on two of things we as humans have in common with horses - the search for calories. And adjusting to the herd.

And look how all of us remember the exact way the food the food tasted and the way it was shared and the preferred sections - with a parent (herd leader) controlling it. Ever seen a group of horses in a compound when we replenish their hay - which horse gets which heap and which tries to push all the others off each heap as forked out?

I remember the slicing of Mars bars even tho I cant remember really significant things like my own wedding service.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
Don't know if this is emotion or what but present mare although driven and ridden was essentially a brood mare she had about 5 foals no more breeding and she came to me on loan but she is very gentle with people and other animals especially small people ie children and if I have a cuddle or am bending down she will put her head and neck round me and pull me close. None of my other mares did this maybe because they didn't have foals who knows.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrA and Huggy
she is very gentle with people and other animals especially small people ie children and if I have a cuddle or am bending down she will put her head and neck round me and pull me close. None of my other mares did this maybe because they didn't have foals who knows.

This interests me a lot. Because most people suggest that women are drawn to horses as a subsitute child. But I first met horses when I was an unmothered war time child. Horses were subsitute mothers. They loved me.
 
Stables for example. Are they designed with horses in mind or us? Is 12ft by 12ft really big enough. Think about a rabbit for example, if they were kept in an equivalent sized hutch it would be awful. Has research actually been done into that or did someone just decide.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
newrider.com