Anthropomorphism in horses

Just bought this book.
"Warrior - the amazing true story of a war horse"
Written in 1938, my edition 2011.

Some horses have extraordinary characters, but all have characters.
 
If war horse stories are of interest, read Sgt Reckless' story, it's one of the most fantastic stories and her story is pretty relevant to anthropomorphism - https://edition.cnn.com/2018/05/15/sport/sergeant-reckless-warhorse-spt/index.html

For anyone without time to read it all, this is the bit that gets me;
Reckless played an important role during the Battle of Outpost Vegas in the final stages of the Korean War between US and Chinese armed forces in March 1953. During this five-day bloody battle, which is estimated to have cost the lives of 1,000 American and 2,000 Chinese soldiers, Reckless made 51 trips to resupply the guns with ammunition on one day alone. All in all, the small mare carried 386 rounds of ammunition, weighing almost 4,000 kilograms, by walking more than 35 miles through rice paddies and steep mountain trails. After unloading the ammunition, Reckless would carry the wounded soldiers back down to safety, despite getting injured twice herself. Astonishingly, Reckless did all of this mostly by herself whilst being under heavy enemy fire. She was trained to lie down when under fire and to avoid obstacles such as barbed wire.

Who are we to say they aren't intelligent, don't feel, or have decision making abilities.
 
They are all individuals with varying traits, differing levels of intelligence and different responses - anyone who thinks otherwise should stick to riding bikes because they have no business around horses. Personally I think it's silly to compare the horses we have around us to wild horses, so many generations of domestication and selective breeding means they're very different animals and while the very basic prey mentality is still there even that is less than it would have been. They're no more wild horses than our pet dogs are wolves.

Of course we look at their actions in the light of our own and the feelings we associate with those actions, what else can we use as a yardstick? Done with awareness I don't see why that should be a problem, and I suspect it's a two way thing. Is it any different to how we interact with other people? If you were to come up to me with tears running down your face and slumped body I'd assume you were upset because that would be how I'd feel if I was crying, but that means I'm projecting my emotion onto your actions.

My experience is that horses do differentiate between people and how they act around them, I've seen so many that will look after a small child or less capable rider yet fizz up and go for it with a better rider. Also the ones that know when their owner is upset of hurting and act very differently until they are right - depending on the individual horse this may or may not be a good thing! Is this so different to us looking at a horse and feeling something isn't right, that they aren't happy over something? Are they "anthropomorphising" us? If it won't get you into trouble Ale it would be interesting to know your lecturer's view on the argument being turned around.
 
Jessie - Thanks for that story.

it's silly to compare the horses we have around us to wild horses, so many generations of domestication and selective breeding means they're very different animals and while the very basic prey mentality is still there even that is less than it would have been. They're no more wild horses than our pet dogs are wolves.
That is exactly what my OH says when explaining why it is fine to like hacking. And not be afraid.
 
If war horse stories are of interest, read Sgt Reckless' story, it's one of the most fantastic stories and her story is pretty relevant to anthropomorphism - https://edition.cnn.com/2018/05/15/sport/sergeant-reckless-warhorse-spt/index.html

For anyone without time to read it all, this is the bit that gets me;
Reckless played an important role during the Battle of Outpost Vegas in the final stages of the Korean War between US and Chinese armed forces in March 1953. During this five-day bloody battle, which is estimated to have cost the lives of 1,000 American and 2,000 Chinese soldiers, Reckless made 51 trips to resupply the guns with ammunition on one day alone. All in all, the small mare carried 386 rounds of ammunition, weighing almost 4,000 kilograms, by walking more than 35 miles through rice paddies and steep mountain trails. After unloading the ammunition, Reckless would carry the wounded soldiers back down to safety, despite getting injured twice herself. Astonishingly, Reckless did all of this mostly by herself whilst being under heavy enemy fire. She was trained to lie down when under fire and to avoid obstacles such as barbed wire.

Who are we to say they aren't intelligent, don't feel, or have decision making abilities.

Thank you for posting that link - what a lovely true story. What a brave and almost magical horse she was too. Amazing. And humbling.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy and Jessey
If war horse stories are of interest, read Sgt Reckless' story, it's one of the most fantastic stories and her story is pretty relevant to anthropomorphism - https://edition.cnn.com/2018/05/15/sport/sergeant-reckless-warhorse-spt/index.html

For anyone without time to read it all, this is the bit that gets me;
Reckless played an important role during the Battle of Outpost Vegas in the final stages of the Korean War between US and Chinese armed forces in March 1953. During this five-day bloody battle, which is estimated to have cost the lives of 1,000 American and 2,000 Chinese soldiers, Reckless made 51 trips to resupply the guns with ammunition on one day alone. All in all, the small mare carried 386 rounds of ammunition, weighing almost 4,000 kilograms, by walking more than 35 miles through rice paddies and steep mountain trails. After unloading the ammunition, Reckless would carry the wounded soldiers back down to safety, despite getting injured twice herself. Astonishingly, Reckless did all of this mostly by herself whilst being under heavy enemy fire. She was trained to lie down when under fire and to avoid obstacles such as barbed wire.

Who are we to say they aren't intelligent, don't feel, or have decision making abilities.
Oh this sounds like a must have read!
 
I tend to say a horse does or doesn't do something based on whether the rider has or hasn't done something.
So that puts the responsibility on us. If we think we have a dumb animal in front of us, that just shows our lack of intelligence imo.


@Ale you said

"What about the phrase 'x tried really hard for me, he jumped his little heart out' so you think horses are capable of understanding that doing well in a competition will please their human. Do you think they can understand the difference between doing well and doing badly?"

That comment is likely to be said because the rider knows what the horse enjoys and has chosen a venue and competition that they run well at.
In racing the trainers all know what ground and what courses the horse like, left handed or right handed being one.
I don't compete and I know mine is not competition material, so if you have a horse that loves his job then yes they possibly get it. Mine would love to spectate.
 
  • Haha
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna and Huggy
I just saw this pop up again and thought it was probably relevant to this conversation :)
 
What a great thread.
Some of the post here have really touched me, as for Belle, I like to think she likes being around me, not for scratches or cuddles, she will tolerate either but she wouldn’t ask for either.
If I go out into the paddock and sit down with a book say, she’ll be by my side in minutes, just grazing, away from her field mates. She gets along well with her buddies and likes to hang out with them, but, it’s always me she comes to graze with if I’m in there, she gets nothing, no treats, no fussing I’m just sitting yet she still wants to be near me.
She doesn’t do it with anyone else, just me, I take that as she likes my company, maybe as much as I like hers, who knows, one thing I do know is I love it.
Before anyone says oh she must be too humanised I’ll just say this, if I turn her out in the morning, quite often she’s first out, as soon as I walk away she’ll just meander off quite happily to graze, she doesn’t fuss that she’s alone, she doesn’t call to the other horses still in their stables so to me that implies she’s simply quite sure of herself, maybe content who knows, she certainly seems content.
She absolutely picks up on my mood or health and she absolutely takes care if I’m under the weather, I remember years ago trying to poo pick her paddock, I felt really poorly, weak as a kitten, faced with the hill in her field at the time I just wanted to go home but couldn’t leave it, Belle followed me up that hill, giving me the gentlest little nudges under my bum just to help me on my way, why I have no idea, other than she knew I was struggling and she ‘wanted’ to help.
I also remember the day Oscar made my cry, he was an ex racer, a bit hot and a bit aloof, he was a good lad on the ground but didn’t enjoy being touched or fussed, we were in our lii is title indoor school when one of the other liveries arrived with her friend and little boy who was autistic, he wanted to see the horse so they came into the school, Oscar walked right up to this little lad, who was shaking his arms about and shouting (normally Oscar would have had a mini meltdown at that) but no he walked right up to the little boy and rested the whole front of his face against the little boys chest, he stayed there for a good few minutes and the little boy just calmed down and hugged Oscars head, I was unbelievably touched by what I saw and I’ll never forget that, he instinctively knew what that little lad needed and responded with such gentleness it was quite incredible, so again they absolutely can sense our emotions.
 
What a great thread.
Some of the post here have really touched me, as for Belle, I like to think she likes being around me, not for scratches or cuddles, she will tolerate either but she wouldn’t ask for either.
If I go out into the paddock and sit down with a book say, she’ll be by my side in minutes, just grazing, away from her field mates. She gets along well with her buddies and likes to hang out with them, but, it’s always me she comes to graze with if I’m in there, she gets nothing, no treats, no fussing I’m just sitting yet she still wants to be near me.
She doesn’t do it with anyone else, just me, I take that as she likes my company, maybe as much as I like hers, who knows, one thing I do know is I love it.
Before anyone says oh she must be too humanised I’ll just say this, if I turn her out in the morning, quite often she’s first out, as soon as I walk away she’ll just meander off quite happily to graze, she doesn’t fuss that she’s alone, she doesn’t call to the other horses still in their stables so to me that implies she’s simply quite sure of herself, maybe content who knows, she certainly seems content.
She absolutely picks up on my mood or health and she absolutely takes care if I’m under the weather, I remember years ago trying to poo pick her paddock, I felt really poorly, weak as a kitten, faced with the hill in her field at the time I just wanted to go home but couldn’t leave it, Belle followed me up that hill, giving me the gentlest little nudges under my bum just to help me on my way, why I have no idea, other than she knew I was struggling and she ‘wanted’ to help.
I also remember the day Oscar made my cry, he was an ex racer, a bit hot and a bit aloof, he was a good lad on the ground but didn’t enjoy being touched or fussed, we were in our lii is title indoor school when one of the other liveries arrived with her friend and little boy who was autistic, he wanted to see the horse so they came into the school, Oscar walked right up to this little lad, who was shaking his arms about and shouting (normally Oscar would have had a mini meltdown at that) but no he walked right up to the little boy and rested the whole front of his face against the little boys chest, he stayed there for a good few minutes and the little boy just calmed down and hugged Oscars head, I was unbelievably touched by what I saw and I’ll never forget that, he instinctively knew what that little lad needed and responded with such gentleness it was quite incredible, so again they absolutely can sense our emotions.

Thank goodness we have a love button now! What a lovely post.
 
What a great thread.
Some of the post here have really touched me, as for Belle, I like to think she likes being around me, not for scratches or cuddles, she will tolerate either but she wouldn’t ask for either.
If I go out into the paddock and sit down with a book say, she’ll be by my side in minutes, just grazing, away from her field mates. She gets along well with her buddies and likes to hang out with them, but, it’s always me she comes to graze with if I’m in there, she gets nothing, no treats, no fussing I’m just sitting yet she still wants to be near me.
She doesn’t do it with anyone else, just me, I take that as she likes my company, maybe as much as I like hers, who knows, one thing I do know is I love it.
Before anyone says oh she must be too humanised I’ll just say this, if I turn her out in the morning, quite often she’s first out, as soon as I walk away she’ll just meander off quite happily to graze, she doesn’t fuss that she’s alone, she doesn’t call to the other horses still in their stables so to me that implies she’s simply quite sure of herself, maybe content who knows, she certainly seems content.
She absolutely picks up on my mood or health and she absolutely takes care if I’m under the weather, I remember years ago trying to poo pick her paddock, I felt really poorly, weak as a kitten, faced with the hill in her field at the time I just wanted to go home but couldn’t leave it, Belle followed me up that hill, giving me the gentlest little nudges under my bum just to help me on my way, why I have no idea, other than she knew I was struggling and she ‘wanted’ to help.
I also remember the day Oscar made my cry, he was an ex racer, a bit hot and a bit aloof, he was a good lad on the ground but didn’t enjoy being touched or fussed, we were in our lii is title indoor school when one of the other liveries arrived with her friend and little boy who was autistic, he wanted to see the horse so they came into the school, Oscar walked right up to this little lad, who was shaking his arms about and shouting (normally Oscar would have had a mini meltdown at that) but no he walked right up to the little boy and rested the whole front of his face against the little boys chest, he stayed there for a good few minutes and the little boy just calmed down and hugged Oscars head, I was unbelievably touched by what I saw and I’ll never forget that, he instinctively knew what that little lad needed and responded with such gentleness it was quite incredible, so again they absolutely can sense our emotions.
I would actually say that in a way this supports that we shouldn't anthropomorphise horses in some situations. I completely agree that horses feel things and comprehend what is needed in situations like this, maybe even more so than humans. Perhaps their thinking is actually at a higher level than us so we shouldn't put our own emotions onto them. I'm not sure what I'm saying makes sense but how many complete strangers to that little boy would have acted in a similar way to Oscar. Very few I would have thought would have known how to reassure and calm him and many wouldn't have acted. Yet horses just sense something and they get involved.
 
When a horse is with an autistic child there is an adult handler present as cue giver. Plus. Horses in a herd tolerate youngsters like foals frisking around.
If what you say is true tho, it means horses like me and tolerate my mistakes only because I am old. Our RI says that. But I think they like the way I smell. It is Genetic. Because horses liked me when I was young and my grandfather was besotted by horses. We always let them sniff us, dont we .
As for language. Horses like being talked too. That was known in the FWW . So domestication of horses as ridden animals was possibly built with anthropomorphism.
 
I would actually say that in a way this supports that we shouldn't anthropomorphise horses in some situations. I completely agree that horses feel things and comprehend what is needed in situations like this, maybe even more so than humans. Perhaps their thinking is actually at a higher level than us so we shouldn't put our own emotions onto them. I'm not sure what I'm saying makes sense but how many complete strangers to that little boy would have acted in a similar way to Oscar. Very few I would have thought would have known how to reassure and calm him and many wouldn't have acted. Yet horses just sense something and they get involved.
The human makes judgements. Complete strangers to that boy would have seen a noisy brat being allowed to potentially scare the horses. Unless you have an autistic child/work with them / you won't see it in anyone else's.
The horse simply responded without that initial judgement. That's why animals are used for therapy, because they just are.
 
I have found some parts of this thread difficult to read, mostly because I STILL carry some degree of grief for two in particular, of my many horses over the years. It is a privilege to read some of your experiences and also sadness you have felt when you lost the horses you felt closest to.

My point is, when reflecting on why I found losing those two horses (as in PTS) so very difficult and still do is that I truly felt I had a 'friendship' bond with them and a close bond at that.

Yes I am certain in a lot of people's opinion I probably did anthropomorphise my relationship with them and my pleasure and delight at how we connected and seemed to know each others mood instantly and respond appropriately to it can't be denied. I am just not entirely sure though that I was interpreting those interactions with those particular horses incorrectly though?

Why because I felt they knew my every mood and responded to it, why because I saw and recognised their own grief at losing close companions, why because they reacted to a very wide range of words and phrases, why because I saw sadness, happiness, joy, willingness, love,grief, depression etc. in those horses does it mean I am attributing human characteristics to them?

I am not doing that in my view...I am just seeing them and enjoying them as an animal that can and does share more characteristics and emotions that we as such supposedly very superior species can and do share. Not always of course, like people you will meet some who you will never connect with or have a long and rewarding relationship with.

Those who might remember my posts back in the day relating to previous horses I have owned and sold on will know I give all horses I buy the approximate 6 month rule - if there isn't a connection within that time - and yes I mean a deep emotional and equally rewarding connection - then up for sale they go. If I have people come into my life that I dont have any connection with I move on, and I do the same with horses. They deserve better than no emotional attachment from me and I deserve better than paying out huge amounts of money and effort attending to the needs of a horse that wouldn't give a shite if I never showed my face again :)
 
I have found some parts of this thread difficult to read, mostly because I STILL carry some degree of grief for two in particular, of my many horses over the years. It is a privilege to read some of your experiences and also sadness you have felt when you lost the horses you felt closest to.

My point is, when reflecting on why I found losing those two horses (as in PTS) so very difficult and still do is that I truly felt I had a 'friendship' bond with them and a close bond at that.

Yes I am certain in a lot of people's opinion I probably did anthropomorphise my relationship with them and my pleasure and delight at how we connected and seemed to know each others mood instantly and respond appropriately to it can't be denied. I am just not entirely sure though that I was interpreting those interactions with those particular horses incorrectly though?

Why because I felt they knew my every mood and responded to it, why because I saw and recognised their own grief at losing close companions, why because they reacted to a very wide range of words and phrases, why because I saw sadness, happiness, joy, willingness, love,grief, depression etc. in those horses does it mean I am attributing human characteristics to them?

I am not doing that in my view...I am just seeing them and enjoying them as an animal that can and does share more characteristics and emotions that we as such supposedly very superior species can and do share. Not always of course, like people you will meet some who you will never connect with or have a long and rewarding relationship with.

Those who might remember my posts back in the day relating to previous horses I have owned and sold on will know I give all horses I buy the approximate 6 month rule - if there isn't a connection within that time - and yes I mean a deep emotional and equally rewarding connection - then up for sale they go. If I have people come into my life that I dont have any connection with I move on, and I do the same with horses. They deserve better than no emotional attachment from me and I deserve better than paying out huge amounts of money and effort attending to the needs of a horse that wouldn't give a shite if I never showed my face again :)
I connected with mine when I met her.
I put my hand on her face and felt a tingle go all the way up my arm. I looked round at the owner and said did you feel that and my friend started crying.
I have no idea what that was to this day, but I haven't ever felt that before or since.
 
I love that post Cortrasna. As a RS rider I discovered something different. With Maisie, true, it was love at first sight.
But I had known my old share for many years as the lesson horse with whom I struggled at lesson after lesson. True that I looked after her leading and grooming on the ground but I could not have forecast our eventual partnership.
As an RS rider one makes the most of what one has got. And sometimes "good enough" is good enough. I would go bananas if Ella disappeared now.
 
I love reading all these posts and find it wonderful that so many of us can understand our horses and have connections with them where we can relate to their emotions. But I also find the other side incredibly interesting too. Using Ale as an example here, when he first began misbehaving in his ridden work it was always just being put down to him 'being cheeky'. I do think lots of us get it very right but I also think lots of us (and I'm including myself in this) get it very wrong.

We do, I think, on occasion see what we want to see instead of looking at the bigger picture. Do horses feel guilt for example, is that something they are capable of? If a horse kicks you and then runs away is it indeed feeling guilty or is it just remembering a time in its life when it kicked a horse or human and got reprimanded for it?

Even just silly little things, like I was jumping Brodie the other day and he kept trying to run out at the jump. I thought to myself well he obviously doesn't want to jump today but of course I have to persevere to go over one so he doesn't know that running out equals stopping. Anyway after trying other jumps and moving things about I realised it must have been sunlight bouncing off a puddle past the jump that was distracting him. Well that's the best conclusion I could come to given that he would jump the same jump the other way and a jump right next to it that was larger with no problems. I won't ever really know but it's hard to know exactly what he was thinking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
I’m struggling with this thread. On the one side is the I’m cold so my horse is cold. Which I just don’t get at all. The other is putting our emotions on a horse.

I am not in the I’m cold my horse must be corner just the oppersite in fact, the storm is coming my whole yard is leaving in. Ginger and Edward are out and will remain out, it’s just wind they have hay in deep troughs and a hedge.

As for emotions I can see when they aren’t 109% that’s my job as an owner. When I am bad/ill etc I don’t ride as ginger is a handful and I don’t want the battle. He is always an angle on the ground.

When I have put my oh on him he has been a dream i get on after and he goes back to knob. So yes I think they know who is on board just as when I’m tired he does not test me as much.

All I know is they are amazing creatures I don’t want to fully understand them as humans when we understand something we ruin it
 
I'm ashamed to admit that I actually grieved more for Ramsey than I have even for family members. When it comes down to it, we choose our horses, our love for them is far less complicated than our love for another human being, and therefore our grief when they die is somehow a cleaner, purer grief. If we do credit them with 'human' traits, is that so bad? Surely all we're really doing is trying to bridge a gap between species. I don't understand Hogan, he doesn't understand me, but I think we're both trying at least, and I'm enjoying the experience, I hope he is too.
 
I love reading all these posts and find it wonderful that so many of us can understand our horses and have connections with them where we can relate to their emotions. But I also find the other side incredibly interesting too. Using Ale as an example here, when he first began misbehaving in his ridden work it was always just being put down to him 'being cheeky'. I do think lots of us get it very right but I also think lots of us (and I'm including myself in this) get it very wrong.

We do, I think, on occasion see what we want to see instead of looking at the bigger picture. Do horses feel guilt for example, is that something they are capable of? If a horse kicks you and then runs away is it indeed feeling guilty or is it just remembering a time in its life when it kicked a horse or human and got reprimanded for it?

Even just silly little things, like I was jumping Brodie the other day and he kept trying to run out at the jump. I thought to myself well he obviously doesn't want to jump today but of course I have to persevere to go over one so he doesn't know that running out equals stopping. Anyway after trying other jumps and moving things about I realised it must have been sunlight bouncing off a puddle past the jump that was distracting him. Well that's the best conclusion I could come to given that he would jump the same jump the other way and a jump right next to it that was larger with no problems. I won't ever really know but it's hard to know exactly what he was thinking.
Sometimes we over think though looking for a solution to a problem we haven't got.

When mine was younger I got too close to her bottom. She double barreled me and I face planted. I had a nice sandy hoof print on my pelvic bone. I got up to have a cob sniffing where the print landed. Was she thinking bullseye or oops.
No idea, I just carried on the session keeping away from the bum that day.
 
newrider.com