Anthropomorphism in horses

I'm ashamed to admit that I actually grieved more for Ramsey than I have even for family members. When it comes down to it, we choose our horses, our love for them is far less complicated than our love for another human being, and therefore our grief when they die is somehow a cleaner, purer grief. If we do credit them with 'human' traits, is that so bad? Surely all we're really doing is trying to bridge a gap between species. I don't understand Hogan, he doesn't understand me, but I think we're both trying at least, and I'm enjoying the experience, I hope he is too.

I think they also allow us to see people more clearly. When I watch someone interact with a horse, or even talk about them, I sometimes see a very different person to the one that's on the surface. Talking a good line is easy, but horses are such adept readers of body language it's almost impossible for us to lie to them and so by watching them we gain some of their insight. And there's an honesty and peace about horses that I haven't found in any other animal, @Huggy maybe that's why our grief can be so intense when we lose them?

I wonder if some human traits are actually traits common to all animals with a certain level of intelligence, particularly those that are by nature social ones? In some areas is there really that much difference between us?
 
I try to treat my horses as horses and look at their behaviour and reactions from that perspective as best humans can understand it, but they are my babies, I love them, care for them and fight for them as such.

I think we have to anthropomorphise a little or they are just objects but we shouldn't be treating them as human either, it's about balance and conversation like this is great for helping us stay grounded in that.
 
human traits are actually traits common to all animals with a certain level of intelligence, particularly those that are by nature social ones? In some areas is there really that much difference between us?
Indeed because we are animals too. But tho we are social animals we are not prey animals who live in herds - primates behave differently.
 
That flight instinct is an incredibly obvious difference - a horse never looks behind at what frightened him, a human always does. Horses' instincts make them run first, look later, ours make us look to assess the threat, then run if appropriate. Even if someone came up behind me, yelling "I've got a knife and I'll going to kill you!" I'd probably still look first, then run.
 
I'm ashamed to admit that I actually grieved more for Ramsey than I have even for family members. When it comes down to it, we choose our horses, our love for them is far less complicated than our love for another human being, and therefore our grief when they die is somehow a cleaner, purer grief. If we do credit them with 'human' traits, is that so bad? Surely all we're really doing is trying to bridge a gap between species. I don't understand Hogan, he doesn't understand me, but I think we're both trying at least, and I'm enjoying the experience, I hope he is too.

Don't be ashamed. I totally understand this - when J died I thought I would die of crying and the grief was overwhelming, I'd felt nothing like it. Mr T was distraught and he grieved more for him than for his father passing away. It's not something that other people who don't have pets understand, but I so know what you are saying there. (I know that might sound unfeeling and harsh about his father but it's the truth).
 
That flight instinct is an incredibly obvious difference - a horse never looks behind at what frightened him, a human always does. Horses' instincts make them run first, look later, ours make us look to assess the threat, then run if appropriate. Even if someone came up behind me, yelling "I've got a knife and I'll going to kill you!" I'd probably still look first, then run.
I look round if she stops to poop on a ride. :oops: but it tells me how things are working and whether the spring grass is here yet, that's my excuse.
To add to that she will on occasion spook at the same poop on the way back, clearly not joining up the dots.
Now where she is funny is when she looks round because I look round to check if the cars have passed if we have moved into a layby. I don't think about what she's thinking, other than she wouldn't move out the way unless I directed her.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
I think we as humans are often really bad at over thinking everything.
I like to think that horses and our connection with them is just something that we are incredibly lucky to feel and experience.
I don’t really think it matters too much if we do anthromorphasise. As long as they are loved and cared for does it really matter?
I sometimes wonder if my logic is maybe a little bit too simplistic but that’s just the way I am.
 
That flight instinct is an incredibly obvious difference - a horse never looks behind at what frightened him, a human always does. Horses' instincts make them run first, look later, ours make us look to assess the threat, then run if appropriate. Even if someone came up behind me, yelling "I've got a knife and I'll going to kill you!" I'd probably still look first, then run.
I would agree with you, but if something makes Charlie spook he invariably turns round to have a look at it, and ideally goes up to sniff it! I hope he always stays so curious and brave.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kite_Rider
The point was SOME human traits, not all, the quote by Skib was incomplete and therefore very misleading. If people want to quote, and by all means do, then do it accurately and not cutting out words to make it say what they want. Clearly there are some differences, and big ones at that, but I think there are also a lot of similarities.

@Skib if you're going to quote please keep it in context and complete rather than omit a word that changes the whole quote significantly.
 
I think we as humans are often really bad at over thinking everything.
I like to think that horses and our connection with them is just something that we are incredibly lucky to feel and experience.
I don’t really think it matters too much if we do anthromorphasise. As long as they are loved and cared for does it really matter?
I sometimes wonder if my logic is maybe a little bit too simplistic but that’s just the way I am.
It could matter I guess, if it's harming them. I have to do a slide about anthropomorphism and look at not only the positives but also the negatives.

And it's really interesting.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
I try to treat my horses as horses and look at their behaviour and reactions from that perspective as best humans can understand it, but they are my babies, I love them, care for them and fight for them as such.

I think we have to anthropomorphise a little or they are just objects but we shouldn't be treating them as human either, it's about balance and conversation like this is great for helping us stay grounded in that.
This is what I agree with. Without it there is a danger of horses being kept like they are robots. Too much and it could be that we keep them in lives that don't suit them. Both only a possibility but it is there
 
Mark Rashid, who taught me, disliked anthropomosphism in particular the human treating of horses with food as a reward. As a result I must be about the only person in my RSs or yards who has never given a treat.

Some one here when I asked why Ella contiually broke off feeding to touch my arm, suggested it was because she was looking for a treat. The staff and other clients treat the horses I ride. I never do.

However I read something about yoga and breathing yesterday.
I learned to breathe slow and deep for natural childbirth and then again from Rashid to use when riding.

Maybe horses are sensitive to rates of breathing in other herd horses and in humans? I dont know. Maybe horses know the heart rate and breathing of others in the herd?

What do people thnk
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrA and Huggy
I think they probably are aware of our breathing rate but eml who used to moderate on here said something along the lines of they could smell / sense sweat too and that it was pheromones? And they could differentiate between the sweat on a hot sunny day from a rider working hard and the nervous one. I am guessing she was right about that. When we think about it (as I often do) they are totally focused in the here and now and don't plan. They have a rough idea of the when it's feeding time etc and when it's lights out etc but on the whole they don't plan - and they are in the moment. And I think as such because of this they are finely tuned to the slightest thing -be that breathing or movement from their handler. They don't daydream like we do either I shouldn't think.
 
I still think we are translating as best we can their world into ours.
They are not wild and I try not to compare with in the wild xyz happens. For a start in the wild there is a stallion, there are no geldings and there are no humans.
The human will surely affect brain development, just as much as our own environment affects ours.
 
@Trewsers mine daydreams but only when she's hacking. ;)Seriously though if I allow her she will stop at one vantage point on the yard to look at the horizon away from home and out hacking one towards home.
Why?
Checking for predators, looking at other horses, being a nosey moo, daydreaming about galloping into the sunset with a stallion :p
Sometimes we just don't know.
 
Big negative - over feeding. Have come across people who feed their horses (and other peoples) with endless treats, grass and hard feed. Result - fat, cresty, nippy horse, heading for, or already having EMS. People do it with dogs and children too. They equate the giving of food to giving love.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrA
Ramsey used to gaze into space while hacking, unless I reminded him we were working. I don't think he was checking the land - just dreaming! He was (or seemed) a very secure little horse - if he was lying down in the field, I could sit next to him and he'd just nuzzle. Hogan - never seen him chilling in the field, and if he looks around while hacking, he almost seems to be looking to pick a fight with the scenery. This is such a good thread! We're all looking at our horses and examining their different traits - and ours!
 
  • Like
Reactions: MrA and Trewsers
Big negative - over feeding. Have come across people who feed their horses (and other peoples) with endless treats, grass and hard feed. Result - fat, cresty, nippy horse, heading for, or already having EMS. People do it with dogs and children too. They equate the giving of food to giving love.
In the extreme I believe its a mental health condition. They feed in order to make incapable and then 'look after'
 
Big negative - over feeding. Have come across people who feed their horses (and other peoples) with endless treats, grass and hard feed. Result - fat, cresty, nippy horse, heading for, or already having EMS. People do it with dogs and children too. They equate the giving of food to giving love.

I use treats as a bribe for the girls - specially Chloe, gingernut biccies are the only thing that keep her still whilst T and me deal with her sore legs (she has ongoing skin issues due to Cushings). I am stingy with Zi and treats though - he gets one after being ridden and last thing at night. Too many and he mugs me constantly which isn't good.
 
Big negative - over feeding. Have come across people who feed their horses (and other peoples) with endless treats, grass and hard feed. Result - fat, cresty, nippy horse, heading for, or already having EMS. People do it with dogs and children too. They equate the giving of food to giving love.
Yes I saw a guy on tv who said parents instil comfort eating in their children by offering them a sweet or a tasty treat to distract them when they're upset. I'm certainly guilty of doing it with my own children when they were little. But then sweets were still a treat when my kids were little, not something you got every day. When I was little you only got part of a sweet - my mum used to cut mars bars up into slices and we'd have a slice as a treat. As a child my mum got cocoa powder and sugar mixed in a twist of paper if she was really lucky!

Is it just a human thing to show love with food? Some species of birds feed each other when courting, maybe other animals do too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers and Huggy
newrider.com