Am i alone??????

To put diagonals into perspective just lets say I learned to ride so long ago that they didn't even come into 'advanced' riding books and I discovered them only in later life when the dreaded 'exam' word emerged in my lessons.

Why do we do them. Convention says that it is better for the horses balance and that it enables us to apply aids at a more correct point but for years if I wanted to do any serious schooling I did sitting trot anyway.

Rising trot was origionally conceived for travelling over long distances for the comfort of the horse and rider not for schooling. In teaching I never teach diagonals until the rider has an effective rising and sitting trot which can move the horse forward with impulsion and rythm. There is simply no point in struggling to remain on the correct diagonal on an unrythmic trot as the horse will always place you on the diagonal most comfortable for them.
 
wow guys i totally forgot about this post but after reading all your advice i think i may have something to work on for the next few lessons. :-D.

i think re the pain its because i get real uptight because basically think if i screw it up the other adults in my lesson(im a mid teen) will look down there noses(as they do) at me as i trot past on my unbent pony whilst there own(mines from the riding school) super drop dead georgeous wb who looks about ready to go to badminton!!

i also really worry that the ri would shout at me ( she never would but it COULD happen right?) and i will look like a big twit in front of the other peeps in my lesson. i have a huge fear of embarressment but unfortunatly i am acident prone!
sorry just re-read that and i sound like a i-don't -know-what.sorry.ta for listening
 
I have just edited my earlier post so it is easier to understand.

Yes, this is exactly what went wrong with me last week. Even though my teacher isnt cross and i was on my own. Yet as soon as I was asked to work on this (and altering the bend too) my mind went blank and my body rigid.

Since eml confirms that the best thing to do is try for a free rhythmic trot, why dont you ask your teacher if you can concentrate on that first? As soon as my horse was going nicely, I stopped worrying and then did the bends and diagonals fine.

The other solution is to go out hacking to practise your rising trot. Out hacking one can trot long distances and get a good rhythm going and experiment with changing diagonals. Most of my practising is done out on hacks - though you may want to wait till it is cooler. My escort was quite out of breathe yesterday after our trotting. Though I wasnt.

As to the history of all this. It is better for the horse if you vary the diagonal on which you rise.
But in the school historically, (eml, I've been reading some history) dressage masters decided, when the horse was going round the corners of the school, that it was best to sit as the inside hind leg of the horse touched the ground. Owing to the curve, the inside leg took a slightly shorter stride than the outside one. So the horse was better balanced to take the rider's weight with less sway.

This makes more sense to me than the UK explanation that one rises to get out of the way of the inside front leg as it come back. As I dont feel to be in the way of the horse's legs when I am sitting trot.

As eml says, rising trot eases the pressure on the horses back. And though these days one rises mainly out hacking (at least I do) and not in a dressage lesson, rising trot was used in dressage in the early stages of training horses in trot, to improve the gait. Both to help round up the back and improve the regularity.

Once I understand the purpose behind what the teacher is teaching me, it all gets easier. So rising on the correct diagonal is not something used merely to humiliate and frustrate people like you and me. There is a basic good reason behind it.
 
newrider.com