To put diagonals into perspective just lets say I learned to ride so long ago that they didn't even come into 'advanced' riding books and I discovered them only in later life when the dreaded 'exam' word emerged in my lessons.
Why do we do them. Convention says that it is better for the horses balance and that it enables us to apply aids at a more correct point but for years if I wanted to do any serious schooling I did sitting trot anyway.
Rising trot was origionally conceived for travelling over long distances for the comfort of the horse and rider not for schooling. In teaching I never teach diagonals until the rider has an effective rising and sitting trot which can move the horse forward with impulsion and rythm. There is simply no point in struggling to remain on the correct diagonal on an unrythmic trot as the horse will always place you on the diagonal most comfortable for them.
Why do we do them. Convention says that it is better for the horses balance and that it enables us to apply aids at a more correct point but for years if I wanted to do any serious schooling I did sitting trot anyway.
Rising trot was origionally conceived for travelling over long distances for the comfort of the horse and rider not for schooling. In teaching I never teach diagonals until the rider has an effective rising and sitting trot which can move the horse forward with impulsion and rythm. There is simply no point in struggling to remain on the correct diagonal on an unrythmic trot as the horse will always place you on the diagonal most comfortable for them.