A little update from us...

@Mary Poppins i am so sad for you reading this, I totally understand where you are, honestly I'm not far off selling up the others and just keeping Jess comfortable until that awful day then choosing a different path for myself, it is truly horrific and tares you apart, but I know I need to wait to make any final decision, I've been here before and survived...ish, as have many others here.

You have really done everything possible and diligently followed the vets advice to give Ben the best possible chance of recovery and if a couple of bute a day does the trick to keep him comfortable enough to walk out to keep his arthritis at bay then that is great, but we all know you will do the best thing by him when the time comes, no matter how hard it is for you, because you always have. There is no right or wrong decision from this point on, just bloody hard ones :(
 
My vet doesn't want him to be retired as he feels that our daily walking is best for keeping his arthritis at bay. He isn't a horse for moving in the field, and if I didn't ride him there is a danger he would completely seize up. If we can make him more comfortable with bute in the walk then at least I can ride him at walk guilt free over the summer.

The problem is still most definitely in his stifle as the vet said he can still feel inflammation from where the surgery took place. His left hind foot is wearing down unevenly which indicates that he isn't weight bearing equally on his hind legs, and that was blatantly obvious when he trotted up. He has always been barefoot on this hind feet, but it is coming up 2 years since his front shoes were removed. He is self trimming and maintaining his feet really well and I am pretty sure he is well over the transitioning phase.
Of course sorry I didn't mean to make you explain yourself, think my post came across all wrong. You've done an amazing job with him to even get him this far, so sorry it's not better news.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
I have a horse with arthritis she is actually just turning 11 . There is a risk of coilc Using bute long term but you can get stomach tablets. There is also a other drug that treat arthritis a forget the name of the drug I saw it online . Bute is worth it if it keeps him sound and happy
 
Last edited:
I'm so terribly sorry - it's incredibly hard to watch a beloved animal start to decline. You've obviously done a great deal, and explored every option, to make him comfortable. This is the part we take on when we first take them into our lives, but damn, it completely hits broadside when it comes. I hope the Bute gives you both a breather, to enjoy the spring and each other. He's a lucky lad, to be so loved. I know how rotten you must feel - thinking of you.
 
Of course sorry I didn't mean to make you explain yourself, think my post came across all wrong. You've done an amazing job with him to even get him this far, so sorry it's not better news.
Your post didn’t come across wrong at all. You are trying to help. I am now blubbing away at 3.30am! I just want him to be healthy again. x
 
Im sorry to hear this news @Mary Poppins. Such a shame. Hope you can continue with him for a while yet.
Time will tell I guess. I need to rethink his feed to make sure he eats it all and doesn’t leave any. He has various supplements for his feet and joints already but he doesn’t always eat it all. I have been so obsessed with keeping his weight down, but that doesn’t seem so important anymore now.
 
I'm so terribly sorry - it's incredibly hard to watch a beloved animal start to decline. You've obviously done a great deal, and explored every option, to make him comfortable. This is the part we take on when we first take them into our lives, but damn, it completely hits broadside when it comes. I hope the Bute gives you both a breather, to enjoy the spring and each other. He's a lucky lad, to be so loved. I know how rotten you must feel - thinking of you.
I am the lucky one having had the privilege of having him in my life. I found him when I was facing a very difficult time with my oldest son who was 4 years old at the time and seriously ill. For the first year or so I used to come to the yard and let all my emotions out to him. He was the best therapist I could wish for and helped me through some very tough times. We then purchased a little lorry and went out everywhere together. We did absolutely everything and had a blast. It was never about winning rosettes (although we have hundreds!) it was about having fun and facing the world together. It is with so much sadness that I have to acknowledge his decline in health. I will have the courage to make the right decision and as I know his lameness will deteriorate. The bones in his stifle joint are basically rubbing together and this won’t get better. But bute may well buy us some more time. We will see. x
 
I know when Buddy was diagnosed last year with ringbone and arthritis in his knees I was devastated. First reaction oh no, no more riding the old boy and laughing at his antics and then the awful one of maybe no more Buddy. He is lucky, he has got a bit more time, and is well but who knows, he is 25 now. I nursed Rose and lost her but all you can do is try. I will never forget the pain of losing Sasa when she was lost so unfairly so young due to vets cocking it up big time. You just have to remember all the good times and hold onto them, and him, for as long as he tells you he is happy. That's all we can do as an owner, it's never perfect, you never get it just so, you just have to accept that sometimes your best isn't enough. I learnt that with Sasa big time. Buddy at least has had a good life with me, and when he goes he will take my heart and I don't know if I will have the will to start again with another one. I feel so sad for you, it's just rubbish isn't it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers and Huggy
Time will tell I guess. I need to rethink his feed to make sure he eats it all and doesn’t leave any. He has various supplements for his feet and joints already but he doesn’t always eat it all. I have been so obsessed with keeping his weight down, but that doesn’t seem so important anymore now.
Do you feed sugar beet at all. I find that chunky isnt so keen on dry food, and with trying him on different suppliments now, which are powder based, they tend to end up at the bottom of the bowl. I use soaked sugarbeet which means the supplements cling to it, and he doesnt waste it. With your half hour walk out each day you are doing more exercise than chunky and he isnt putting on loads of weight. I know its about the hay and grass intake too. Oh and in my case the sugar beet is the pellet stuff not the speedi beet. Which has the reduced sugar. I put four of my handfuls in a bucket and soak for 24hrs. Thats for the two boys mind so for ben youd only need two handfuls. It gives enough quantity to mix supplements. Plus i feed linseed and a bit of mix for additional taste.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
I am so sorry to hear this, @Mary Poppins . A great big virtual hug to you. You know I went through a very similar process with Ziggy, always hoping and trying, hoping and trying, until I had to bite the bullet last year.

I think the only way through it is to see it the way a horse might. They don't look in to the future or anticipate anything. If he's sore, give him bute so he feels better. If he feels better he'll be content. Enjoy him and let his content rub off on you. When the bute doesn't work any more, then it's time. It sucks, it's not fair, but you have done all you could and loved and cared for him brilliantly. Never blame yourself. Enjoy his company whether you're riding him, leading him, or just being with him.

I really do feel for you. Sending love and strong vibes.
 
Do you feed sugar beet at all. I find that chunky isnt so keen on dry food, and with trying him on different suppliments now, which are powder based, they tend to end up at the bottom of the bowl. I use soaked sugarbeet which means the supplements cling to it, and he doesnt waste it. With your half hour walk out each day you are doing more exercise than chunky and he isnt putting on loads of weight. I know its about the hay and grass intake too. Oh and in my case the sugar beet is the pellet stuff not the speedi beet. Which has the reduced sugar. I put four of my handfuls in a bucket and soak for 24hrs. Thats for the two boys mind so for ben youd only need two handfuls. It gives enough quantity to mix supplements. Plus i feed linseed and a bit of mix for additional taste.
I use speedibeat at the mo and he sometimes scoffs it and sometimes leaves it. He would probably do better if I cut fresh grass and put the supplements and bute on top of that for him to eat.
 
I am so sorry to hear this, @Mary Poppins . A great big virtual hug to you. You know I went through a very similar process with Ziggy, always hoping and trying, hoping and trying, until I had to bite the bullet last year.

I think the only way through it is to see it the way a horse might. They don't look in to the future or anticipate anything. If he's sore, give him bute so he feels better. If he feels better he'll be content. Enjoy him and let his content rub off on you. When the bute doesn't work any more, then it's time. It sucks, it's not fair, but you have done all you could and loved and cared for him brilliantly. Never blame yourself. Enjoy his company whether you're riding him, leading him, or just being with him.

I really do feel for you. Sending love and strong vibes.
I often think of you and Ziggy. It was so cruel that he was taken away from you before his time. x
 
So sorry to read this, I know you couldn't have tried harder to get him mended. Presumably he's still hacking out in walk quite happily because I'm sure you would have noticed if he wasn't. I hope the bute keeps him comfortable and you can carry on enjoying life together for some time. Hugs to you and Ben x
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mary Poppins
I think of you and Ben often and this post has reduced me to tears. Your love for him is so pure and beautiful.

You have done everything possible and if Bute will help than so be it. I know you supported me with chanter and he was on bite from the age of 19. He went Bute one day a Bute substitute the next for years then when he went down hill he went to a Bute every day. The last year he was on two a day.

If it makes them comfortable than so be it. I take naproxen every day have done for years so I struggle to see why people have opinions of horses on long term pain relief.

Thinking of you always
 
So sorry to read this, I know you couldn't have tried harder to get him mended. Presumably he's still hacking out in walk quite happily because I'm sure you would have noticed if he wasn't. I hope the bute keeps him comfortable and you can carry on enjoying life together for some time. Hugs to you and Ben x

The problem I have is that everyone tells me how great he looks in walk and question why I only walk with him. He is definitely stronger through his body and can walk with more energy than he ever has. However sometimes I catch a look at us in the mirror and his right hind looks wooden and stilted if that makes sense. Sometimes, maybe 2 times per ride he does stumble over his back legs and his left hind hoof is wearing down unevenly which is another sign. He was never lame in walk before and the vet said that it was slight but I feel bad that I thought he was doing ok. My physio came just before Christmas, trotted him up and said that he was practically sound and couldn’t understand why we were not trotting. I religiously stuck to the vets plan (I always do) but in light of the physio report I had convinced myself that I would have him back. I even provisionally booked camp for September!!

It was such a shock to see him so lame in trot and I feel like such an idiot for thinking he was getting better. As I said, I don’t trot him up myself as I am clueless about lameness. I said this to my vet and he said that is why I have him out because he is the expert and I shouldn’t be expected to assess him myself.

But crying for England and getting upset won’t help, so I am picking myself up and carrying on. I still have him, he still has me and we will cope with this together.
 
I think of you and Ben often and this post has reduced me to tears. Your love for him is so pure and beautiful.

You have done everything possible and if Bute will help than so be it. I know you supported me with chanter and he was on bite from the age of 19. He went Bute one day a Bute substitute the next for years then when he went down hill he went to a Bute every day. The last year he was on two a day.

If it makes them comfortable than so be it. I take naproxen every day have done for years so I struggle to see why people have opinions of horses on long term pain relief.

Thinking of you always
Thank you so much. Yes I am coming to terms with using bute. So many people take medication to keep them going, there is no reason why a horse can’t do this. Of course, as others have commented, the long term risks of bute need to be considered, but quite frankly, with his level of lameness he is not going to live out his years as he should have done, and a shorter pain free life is preferable.

It helps to hear success stories and thinking of how you helped Chanter has made me smile. You loved him in the same way as I love Ben so I know that you really do understand. We will have to play around with the dose he has. He is on 3 per day to start with but will go to 1.5 per day from Tuesday. He is a big horse so needs more than the average. I split this into 2 feeds and he has certainly been very happy to be fed twice over the last few days. He still has the sparkle in his eye and while I know I will have to make ‘that’ decision sooner rather than later, I am hopeful that we will at least have this summer to ride round the farm and relax together.
 
Thank you so much. Yes I am coming to terms with using bute. So many people take medication to keep them going, there is no reason why a horse can’t do this. Of course, as others have commented, the long term risks of bute need to be considered, but quite frankly, with his level of lameness he is not going to live out his years as he should have done, and a shorter pain free life is preferable.

It helps to hear success stories and thinking of how you helped Chanter has made me smile. You loved him in the same way as I love Ben so I know that you really do understand. We will have to play around with the dose he has. He is on 3 per day to start with but will go to 1.5 per day from Tuesday. He is a big horse so needs more than the average. I split this into 2 feeds and he has certainly been very happy to be fed twice over the last few days. He still has the sparkle in his eye and while I know I will have to make ‘that’ decision sooner rather than later, I am hopeful that we will at least have this summer to ride round the farm and relax together.
I find that adding in large quantities of mint powder helps, I buy it in bulk and put in a bit with each dose. I mix it in with the Lmix so it disappears and the mint helps the fussy ones - Buddy eats anything....we use Danilon and he seems to eat it fine. You could counteract the bute with adding in some ulcer guard type stuff to keep his tummy settled. Given his prognosis pain free and quality is the thing isn't it?
 
Sorry, I missed this on Friday but just want to say how sorry I am that you haven't had a better outcome after all your dedication and patience. We have all watched and waited with you, with our fingers crossed, so now we're all naturally gutted with you too. Try not to think about the future. You still have time with your boy - you can still ride him..... and for a long while there was a question mark over whether even that would be possible, so all is definitely not lost yet!! Get lots of between the ears photos of pretty views and sunshine to keep your spirits up and make lots of fab memories to balance out all the sad ones. Good luck with the Bute.... I hope it makes an amazing difference to our darling Ben. Lots of love xxx
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
. . . You could counteract the bute with adding in some ulcer guard type stuff to keep his tummy settled. Given his prognosis pain free and quality is the thing isn't it?

While this sounds like a good idea be a bit careful, the better ones work by coating the stomach and will reduce how effectively the bute is taken up and the others are just a waste of money. The majority of horses don't have any problems with bute even if they're on it for years, and the ones that have problems probably aren't going to tolerate it whatever you do.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cortrasna
newrider.com