A little update from us...

Mary Poppins

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2004
13,662
4,789
113
Visit site
I had really high hopes of posting positive news today as the vet came this morning, but the reality is that my dreams lie in shatters. As most of you know, Ben has been lame for over 2 years now. He had a bone scan and surgery after being diagnosed with severe cartilage problems in his stifles. We had 7 months full box rest after the surgery followed by 12 months of walk only exercise in the hope that time and gentle exercise would help him heal. The reality is that none of this has worked, and he is now lamer now than he has ever been. The vet today put him at 5/10th lame in trot and 2/10th lame in walk.

I have to face the fact that he will never get better and he has chronic and degenerative lameness. The last ditch option is to give him bute everyday to see if we can make him more comfortable. The vet doesn't want him to be retired completely as he thinks that the walking is helping him and doesn't feels that he would get worse if we gave this up. So the plan now is to give bute daily and hope that the lameness reduces. There is no more treatment that the vet can do. In addition to the surgery he has had 3 sets of steroid injections, none of which worked so I see little point in trying again. I have no more money to spend, the insurance is maxed out and most of his body is now excluded. I have to face that all I can do is to keep him comfortable and accept that he will get worse in time. So it will be a waiting game to see how long he will last.

I am completely heartbroken and feel like such a fool. Every time the vet comes I hope for good news. I never trot him up in between vets visits as I don't know what I am looking for and if I ask 5 people their opinion on his lameness I get 5 different answers. Today was pretty obvious that he was uncomfortable to trot and I just see the end creeping up on me. I simply cannot and will not watch him deteriorate further. If the bute doesn't work then rainbow bridge will be calling for him. And I will leave this horsey world behind me because it is just too painful to carry on.
 
@Mary Poppins I'm so sorry to read this. No-one could have tried harder than you have, please remember that and be kind to yourself.

I know from experience just how heartbreaking and hard it is to realise there's no longer any hope of fixing their problems, hell I'm in tears as I type, but you have the strength to carry on as long as you can keep him comfortable. Spoil him and love him while you have him, make the most of every single moment so that you have no regrets when the day comes. I found it helped to be up front with people because that way it cut down on the well meaning ideas on how to fix him, and if knowing the situation they still pushed I could tell them to go forth and multiply with a clear conscience!

I'm sending you hugs and strength and lots of love.
 
I am so sorry to read this, I often think of you and wonder how things are getting on. You have tried hard and I truly can empathise with what you've been through. I hope you can keep him comfortable and find a level that you both find acceptable. It is hard to accept and shorter than a miracle (which even though I am not particularly religious) at times I have prayed for for my own, you know that as an owner it's the sh*ittist and worst part of it all, having to potentially face the end of the road. Waffling on a bit here, but know that there are lots of folk on here that will be here for you and to listen - if you want to rant, cry, shout - just whatever. Sending you massive good kind thoughts - and all the luck in the world. xxxxxxxxxxx
 
@Mary Poppins I'm so sorry to read this. No-one could have tried harder than you have, please remember that and be kind to yourself.

I know from experience just how heartbreaking and hard it is to realise there's no longer any hope of fixing their problems, hell I'm in tears as I type, but you have the strength to carry on as long as you can keep him comfortable. Spoil him and love him while you have him, make the most of every single moment so that you have no regrets when the day comes. I found it helped to be up front with people because that way it cut down on the well meaning ideas on how to fix him, and if knowing the situation they still pushed I could tell them to go forth and multiply with a clear conscience!

I'm sending you hugs and strength and lots of love.
Thank you. Reading your post has made me cry all over again, but that is not hard as I have been in floods of tears all morning. It is hard to explain how I feel about him, he really is my stability in life. He is always there, always happy to see me and everyday he resets me so I can deal with everything else life throws at me. Without him I would be totally lost. But to see him hobble along in trot today made me realise how fragile he is and I can't keep him going just because I need him.

My big question now is how much difference will 1.5 bute per day make? Will it really be enough to turn such a lame horse sound? Hopefully it will remove the 2/10th lameness in walk and if so, I think that we will try and enjoy a summer of hacking out in walk, and then reassess as we come into winter. He is only 16 which doesn't seem old at all these days. I honestly don't know what I am going to do without him when the time comes. He is irreplaceable, I can't ever imagine finding another horse like him.
 
I really wan't expecting to read this update :( I had thought with all you had done and were doing you would at least still have a hacking buddy at the end of the day. I really do hope that bute will keep him more comfortable but only you can judge if that comfort level is what you and he will settle with. so sorry it has not had a good outcome :(
 
  • Like
Reactions: Kite_Rider
I am so sorry to read this, I often think of you and wonder how things are getting on. You have tried hard and I truly can empathise with what you've been through. I hope you can keep him comfortable and find a level that you both find acceptable. It is hard to accept and shorter than a miracle (which even though I am not particularly religious) at times I have prayed for for my own, you know that as an owner it's the sh*ittist and worst part of it all, having to potentially face the end of the road. Waffling on a bit here, but know that there are lots of folk on here that will be here for you and to listen - if you want to rant, cry, shout - just whatever. Sending you massive good kind thoughts - and all the luck in the world. xxxxxxxxxxx

Thank you. It is nice to know you are thinking about me. I have distanced myself a little from New Rider and from the horsely world in general over the last year as I just find it all so painful. I feel that once I had everything I ever wanted and now it has all been taken away from me. Not many people can understand what Ben means to me (although I know you understand). I know that we all have to face end of life scenarios for our horses and pets at some point, but I always thought I would have Ben for many more years. He is only 16 after all. Thanks for the hugs, I do need them right now.

How are your teeth by the way? I had my rotten abscess filled tooth pulled out yesterday which just adds to my terrible week. I look and feel like I have been punched in the face and am now looking at the cost of dental implants. Only 2.5k!
 
One day at a time for now. The bute may help quite a bit and given the size of him and that, to be blunt, you aren't looking at long term risks, I wouldn't have a problem with giving a higher dose than that if he needs it. If he seems comfortable, even if he's not properly sound, I'd settle for that - you know him well enough to see if he's not happy.

You will cope, not least because you have to. Don't look to replace him, but try not to rule out having another that you could love for themselves rather than as a replacement Ben. You have so much to offer a horse, be it one you own or a share, that it would be a shame to say never. And they give us so much too and I'm sure Ben wouldn't begrudge you that xxx
 
Thank you. It is nice to know you are thinking about me. I have distanced myself a little from New Rider and from the horsely world in general over the last year as I just find it all so painful. I feel that once I had everything I ever wanted and now it has all been taken away from me. Not many people can understand what Ben means to me (although I know you understand). I know that we all have to face end of life scenarios for our horses and pets at some point, but I always thought I would have Ben for many more years. He is only 16 after all. Thanks for the hugs, I do need them right now.

How are your teeth by the way? I had my rotten abscess filled tooth pulled out yesterday which just adds to my terrible week. I look and feel like I have been punched in the face and am now looking at the cost of dental implants. Only 2.5k!

Oh heck I'm so sorry about your poor tooth - how horrible. Implants are expensive aren't they? I'm not sure on those, and how long they last either. Mr T had a wisdom removed just before Xmas and that was pretty awful. Sending you healing vibes aplenty. Mine (touch wood frantically) is much better but I now have an awful bacterial infection in my lower jaw gum which is really hard to shift - I'm having them deep cleaned at the surgery every two weeks :eek:
Try and take it easy - having a tooth out coupled with emotional stress is huge, I hope there are some people around you that can ease your burden. xxxx
 
One day at a time for now. The bute may help quite a bit and given the size of him and that, to be blunt, you aren't looking at long term risks, I wouldn't have a problem with giving a higher dose than that if he needs it. If he seems comfortable, even if he's not properly sound, I'd settle for that - you know him well enough to see if he's not happy.

You will cope, not least because you have to. Don't look to replace him, but try not to rule out having another that you could love for themselves rather than as a replacement Ben. You have so much to offer a horse, be it one you own or a share, that it would be a shame to say never. And they give us so much too and I'm sure Ben wouldn't begrudge you that xxx

He is initially have 3 bute per day for the next week, but when the levels are higher in his system I have to reduce this to 1.5 per day. I am not worried about the long term risks either. It is very likely that he isn't going to live into old age so I would rather make the time he has left as nice as possible for him.
 
Oh heck I'm so sorry about your poor tooth - how horrible. Implants are expensive aren't they? I'm not sure on those, and how long they last either. Mr T had a wisdom removed just before Xmas and that was pretty awful. Sending you healing vibes aplenty. Mine (touch wood frantically) is much better but I now have an awful bacterial infection in my lower jaw gum which is really hard to shift - I'm having them deep cleaned at the surgery every two weeks :eek:
Try and take it easy - having a tooth out coupled with emotional stress is huge, I hope there are some people around you that can ease your burden. xxxx

Ooh that sounds nasty. The abscess in my tooth just got too unmanageable for the root canal and despite the tooth coming out I am on anti-biotics again to try and shift it once and for all. Bloody teeth - why do they cause such problems? Ben also has to have some dental work done, I think he is demonstrating sympathy for me.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
I am so sad for you, been there. I just hope beyond hope that you can keep him comfy even if he can't be ridden, and that you can buy him some more time. Buddy is on 1/2 sachet twice a week, but like you if he was really really sore, he would be on high dosage. All you can do is keep him as free of pain as possible and see how he goes. It's utterly heart breaking, I hoped so much for good news.
 
I am so sad for you, been there. I just hope beyond hope that you can keep him comfy even if he can't be ridden, and that you can buy him some more time. Buddy is on 1/2 sachet twice a week, but like you if he was really really sore, he would be on high dosage. All you can do is keep him as free of pain as possible and see how he goes. It's utterly heart breaking, I hoped so much for good news.
Thank you for your kind words. I hoped for good news too. Fingers crossed the bute improves things, at least for the summer. I have cried my heart out and now am feeling a little more optimistic. Glad to hear Buddy is doing better.x
 
I am very sorry to hear that . If you have tried everything and the only other option is bute than I think it’s time to put him to sleep. I now it very hard to do but sometimes it the better option at least he would not be suffering anymore.

That's a sweeping assumption that Danilon or Bute isn't worth trying don't you think? I think MP will be giving it her best shot and weighing it all up carefully. Lots of horses use long term bute in their older years and it works very well. Ben isn't that old but if it keeps him comfortable it's a good thing.
 
Thinking of you, have to do what is best and always trust your gut in these situations. Make sure you talk to someone about how you're feeling too. And take care xx
 
Thank you for your kind words. I hoped for good news too. Fingers crossed the bute improves things, at least for the summer. I have cried my heart out and now am feeling a little more optimistic. Glad to hear Buddy is doing better.x
Bud's great. We had similar issues with Rose and cushings, we bought her one final summer but then years before she ws given a week to live and lasted another 10 years. they can always surprise you
 
Sorry my post sound like all hope is lost and I really don't think that. He may do alright just in the field if he doesn't improve on bute. Or perhaps the bute will do the trick and you'll have many more years plodding about together. You have to do what is right for you both. How long has Ben been barefoot just out of curiosity, could he still be adjusting to that too?
 
Sorry my post sound like all hope is lost and I really don't think that. He may do alright just in the field if he doesn't improve on bute. Or perhaps the bute will do the trick and you'll have many more years plodding about together. You have to do what is right for you both. How long has Ben been barefoot just out of curiosity, could he still be adjusting to that too?

My vet doesn't want him to be retired as he feels that our daily walking is best for keeping his arthritis at bay. He isn't a horse for moving in the field, and if I didn't ride him there is a danger he would completely seize up. If we can make him more comfortable with bute in the walk then at least I can ride him at walk guilt free over the summer.

The problem is still most definitely in his stifle as the vet said he can still feel inflammation from where the surgery took place. His left hind foot is wearing down unevenly which indicates that he isn't weight bearing equally on his hind legs, and that was blatantly obvious when he trotted up. He has always been barefoot on this hind feet, but it is coming up 2 years since his front shoes were removed. He is self trimming and maintaining his feet really well and I am pretty sure he is well over the transitioning phase.
 
newrider.com