2022 Hacking and Riding

How about asking him on the way home, is he more likely to go for it then? I deliberately don't canter towards home as I get rather more go than is useful, but on others I have as it can give some motivation - feed this way!!! Even if you just get a couple of steps from a voice aid you can praise like mad then let him trot again, hopefully he'll get the idea it's what you want. Stuff correct, anything will do to begin with, after all you can't fine tune what you don't have.
I have tried on the way home, but he just trots faster! I've noted that when he canters in the field, he nearly always goes on the left lead, so that's what I try for. Admittedly, I've left it for a while as we were getting nowhere, but will get back to asking more often - I agree - I don't care if its messy, just a couple of strides - anything will do!
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
It could be the chickening out that blocks the canter. I was told that horses dont canter if they feel the rider is unsteady or scared. Horses always cantered easily for me (once I had learned to canter) and I assumed it was because they knew I liked to canter.
As for fearing an explosion - That is why I ride canter transtions out hacking - 20 trot and 20 canter to prevent explosions. To reassure myself I am in control. Am lately not allowed to do that by YM, I secretly suspect it is because she cant be sure of controlling the canter of the horse she is riding behind me. Senior yard staff often ride the difficult horses and it is the bane of my life.
NButI notice too that when we leave the yard, YM asks me to ride first and then we trot a long long way. It is a matter of pride for me not to ask to pause to get my breath back. But I assum these long trots are designed to tire the horses a bit before we turn and canter. And sometmes after turning we just go on trotting whocich I assume is to prevent horses cantering at places they expect to canter.
I get what you're saying, but I don't chicken out when he's going normally, only when he's having one of his tantrums - at those times it's an achievement staying on! I trot him on in these episodes, because it's harder for him to buck in trot. The RS I went to before I got my own, had an Irish cob that they could not get to canter, even when ridden by their most experienced RI. No one ever wanted him in lessons or hacks! I hold my hands up that I knew he had quirks when I bought him, one of which was schooling- apparently he switches off completely or goes nuts, hence trying to do it while out hacking. He can be an absolute little gent (more now than he used to be), I just have to find the switch to turn on, like it turned on to trotting, for canter.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
It does sound like you're making really good progress with him Huggy :) He sounds quite similiar to Pete used to be - he's naturally quite an introvert and if you put too much pressure on him when he's worried/unsure/hesitant or in a 'shan't mood he explodes. P has more go than Hogan does naturally but he used to just switch off emotionally and mentally and you had nothing or you had a dangerous explosion. No amount of transitions to proving you had control or enjoying cantering as a rider would have helped. You'd have just been floored as he might be an introvert but he's sharp with it 🤣

It just took time and repition with P to learn he was safe and wasn't going to be pressurised by the rider and that I'd listen. I used to take him out in hand and switch up riding and leading him in one ride as I think it surprised him the first time 🤣

I will say, with P there is a fine line of not asking so he never has to try (he's a native pony after all 🤣) and asking too much that he shuts down. It's a hard line to read sometimes as it it's just a feel but I think you naturally know when you're attuned to them when to push and when to listen.

P's great yo hack now & we ride with (and largely keep up with) endurance riders now so don't give up hope or patience. P's a speedy introvert but he'd still floor you if you misread a situation and just kicked on blindly no matter what because you wanted to go faster or ask for more than he can physically or emotionally give you.

I presume you've had him checked out physically? But I do think unless you've ridden the type of horse I think Hogan might be, it can be hard to comprehend and under estimate their mental block when it happens.
 
It does sound like you're making really good progress with him Huggy :) He sounds quite similiar to Pete used to be - he's naturally quite an introvert and if you put too much pressure on him when he's worried/unsure/hesitant or in a 'shan't mood he explodes. P has more go than Hogan does naturally but he used to just switch off emotionally and mentally and you had nothing or you had a dangerous explosion. No amount of transitions to proving you had control or enjoying cantering as a rider would have helped. You'd have just been floored as he might be an introvert but he's sharp with it 🤣

It just took time and repition with P to learn he was safe and wasn't going to be pressurised by the rider and that I'd listen. I used to take him out in hand and switch up riding and leading him in one ride as I think it surprised him the first time 🤣

I will say, with P there is a fine line of not asking so he never has to try (he's a native pony after all 🤣) and asking too much that he shuts down. It's a hard line to read sometimes as it it's just a feel but I think you naturally know when you're attuned to them when to push and when to listen.

P's great yo hack now & we ride with (and largely keep up with) endurance riders now so don't give up hope or patience. P's a speedy introvert but he'd still floor you if you misread a situation and just kicked on blindly no matter what because you wanted to go faster or ask for more than he can physically or emotionally give you.

I presume you've had him checked out physically? But I do think unless you've ridden the type of horse I think Hogan might be, it can be hard to comprehend and under estimate their mental block when it happens.
Thank you - that all sounds very Hogan-like! He's a complicated little chap - unlike my straightforward Ramsey. He's been checked over and got a clean bill, teeth are good, back, legs and feet all fine. He canters beautifully in the field. We have made progress in many ways - he's lovely to handle now, very affectionate, responding well to voice aids and fabulous with our very difficult gate into the forest (ie it swings right back and we have do all sorts of contortions to shut it!) Also great with the ponies, cows and finally getting there meeting other riders. I want to persevere, but if canter never happens, he's still a lovely hack (most of the time!) and I wouldn't swap him. I might try a few in hand outings to shake things up a bit.
 
@Huggy it's good that he canters in the field, at least that shows he isn't one that's so trot focused he doesn't have a natural canter - some just don't, instead they have a whole load of trot gears and a gallop if all else fails! My first pony was very like that and it took someone pointing out to me he never cantered in his own time either for me to realise I was bashing my head against a brick wall.

From what you've said about Hogan I'd never suggest asking him while he's having, or verging on, a tantrum! The politest word for doing that would be stupid, and a waste of NHS resources springs to mind too 😂. When I said anything will do I was taking for granted that you'd be staying on and having a degree of control!

So many other things with him have improved, this is probably just something that is taking a bit longer. Maybe one day he'll just offer it and then you can praise him and he'll realise it's something you want, he's not the first cob to find canter hard and he won't be the last.
 
@Huggy it's good that he canters in the field, at least that shows he isn't one that's so trot focused he doesn't have a natural canter - some just don't, instead they have a whole load of trot gears and a gallop if all else fails! My first pony was very like that and it took someone pointing out to me he never cantered in his own time either for me to realise I was bashing my head against a brick wall.

From what you've said about Hogan I'd never suggest asking him while he's having, or verging on, a tantrum! The politest word for doing that would be stupid, and a waste of NHS resources springs to mind too 😂. When I said anything will do I was taking for granted that you'd be staying on and having a degree of control!

So many other things with him have improved, this is probably just something that is taking a bit longer. Maybe one day he'll just offer it and then you can praise him and he'll realise it's something you want, he's not the first cob to find canter hard and he won't be the last.
I'm appreciative of everyone's comments - one starts to doubt oneself sometimes, and I really love that little git, despite the 'quirks'. I'm sure we'll get there, and thanks to all for the encouragement.
 
I have not followed the canter thing so apologies if I say the wrong thing. Or something that has been said before or I otherwise put my foot in it!

Does he HAVE to canter? Some horses have a great trot and rubbish canter. Robins buddy is one. His canter is terrible, he is a cob. His go to pace is trot . Robins trot is good but his canter is better. His go to pace is canter. It makes me laugh so much when they set off up the field, Robin in his best canter and his buddy in his best knees to the chin trot. They keep up with each other.

Piper still manages to get round courses of jumps, goes xc and hunts and has no issues. Sometimes he does his cob trot, sometimes he does canter and sometimes a mix of both. Rider dosnt stress it and they are both happy. He does have a gallop when out hunting.
 
I suppose I got so used to Ramsey's push button responses, that it seems natural to ask for canter. I agree though, maybe its not essential, and if I ever get a proper one, and there's no joy in it, I'd be happy to trot into eternity! We have only recently achieved a lovely forward trot, and I'm happy to take that if the canter is a lost cause.
 
95% of the time he is lovely, not easy but lovely. 5% of the time he is horrid! Today was the 5%. It was the thin line of being firm without being too firm sj that he has an excuse to throw a complete wobbler. “I don’t WANT to _______” inset anything I am asking. “Robin pease do not charge off in trot with your head in the air” “fine I’ll tuck my chin on my chest and bounce”. How DARE I expect him to stay in, so he is out and even his buddy has said sod this and left him to it 😂

However we did get a nice walk trot and canter in the stubble so not completely all lost.
 
Calm before the storm I think they say.
She was a poppet with the lunging and was nosing at the grass as it's grown since our last visit.

Then on the way back we spotted the couple that have been feeding carrier bags full of apples to the horses! So I ask her to trot on as I started running in their direction. That must have been a funny sight, a woman jogging along with a horse. 😂 Just when you think you've seen everything, we come along.

_20221010_180031_copy_1375x927.jpg
 
Very cold this morning, but bright and sunny. His nibs still had a bit of attitude, but I trotted him out of it each time. In fact, we trotted almost the whole ride - I think some of the behaviour is definitely down to getting new grass. He's only on it part of the day, but it's enough to have an effect. I was pretty pleased with him today.
 
newrider.com