Anthropomorphism in horses

I definitely think that anthropomorphism allows us to get closer to horses and other animals. And I don't really think in most situations that it's a bad thing, although we may get some of the emotions/ motivations wrong we probably get alot of them right or close enough. We can tell when they are scared and are there for them, give them lives that they enjoy as much as possible and provide things that they enjoy at the right times, food when they are hungry. If it's love they feel I don't know, I wouldn't really like to say it's not.

What about the phrase 'x tried really hard for me, he jumped his little heart out' so you think horses are capable of understanding that doing well in a competition will please their human. Do you think they can understand the difference between doing well and doing badly?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
This isn't anthropomorphism is it? That just sounds like being a good attentive owner. Which isn't to say that if you do treat them like a human you are not a good owner!

It's more saying, I am cold so they must be cold. Roadwork is boring for me so it must be boring for them. When actually with respect to the roadwork maybe it's actually alot more stimulating but when you ride them they sense your hesitancy/ boredom and response as though roadwork is bad. First thing that came to my head.
That was my point, that it isn't anthropomorphizing in all cases, but in your original post you interpreted someone saying similar without any further explanation as anthropomorphism. I was trying to point out that although some still say the words, they don't mean it quite so simplistically. And there are those who do too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse and MrA
That was my point, that it isn't anthropomorphizing in all cases, but in your original post you interpreted someone saying similar without any further explanation as anthropomorphism. I was trying to point out that although some still say the words, they don't mean it quite so simplistically. And there are those who do too.
Oh okay, sorry I misunderstood that. Yes I agree, I say loads of things like this especially about my cat. I know she follows me up the stairs because she finds all the animal smells interesting but I always tell everyone it's because she misses me so much. If that's what you mean
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jessey
Oh okay, sorry I misunderstood that. Yes I agree, I say loads of things like this especially about my cat. I know she follows me up the stairs because she finds all the animal smells interesting but I always tell everyone it's because she misses me so much. If that's what you mean
Yep exactly :)
 
This is really really interesting. How much do horses touch each other with no purpose? Genuine question as I'm not too sure. Do you 'groom him' like horses groom each other? Ales not fond of being stroked or me resting my hand on his face etc but just occasionally I get this right by scratching at his withers or neck and he will groom me back. Always find that quite special
That's reassuring! Charlie likes to be scratched pretty much anywhere, and if I get the spot right (just below the withers, underside of neck, bottom) I get tapir faces.
 
Oh and horses touching each other with no purpose? Well, here we go again, define "purpose". I think they definitely touch each other for no reason other than to say "It's OK, I'm here."
 
Jess is not one for being fussed, she's fine to groom and untangle and sew dragon masks to her bridle ;) but being stroked isn't her thing. She will choose to come and stand, passive and close, but will leave if I start fussing. I don't think it's because she doesn't 'like' me, it's just that isn't how she prefers to interact with me (or anyone else, the boys will chew on each others faces, she would nail them for that!).
 
  • Like
Reactions: carthorse
What about the phrase 'x tried really hard for me, he jumped his little heart out' so you think horses are capable of understanding that doing well in a competition will please their human. Do you think they can understand the difference between doing well and doing badly?

Our RI says make it easy for the horse to do as you ask - Horses (I think) like riders who make life easy for them. May be such horses do well? I think the way our RI teaches does that and horses like being ridden by her students. Both my shares have been on yards where she teaches, so it isnt anything unusual for them if I ride them.

The sad thing is that I had a higher opinion of a mare's intelligence with Maisie. My new share - well I have started to think that horses are not that clever after all. She is safe. She submits. And no, I dont believe they deliberately do things people say they do like look after you. Or take care with a new rider or child. Their priority remains to take in food and spare energy. When i was a beginner and mounted on a yard and had to wait, the horse always put its head down and made for the grass.

I always told horses my only advantage over them was my intelligence and education, but I didnt think they were quite as dim as they seem to me now.

They do recognise normal patterns - like the route or the gate out. They expect certain actions from us. Like anticipating picking up feet.

Does your teacher have any view on the intelligence of horses Ale?
 
This is an interesting way of looking at it. Our horse calls to us and we might say they love or care for us, when in reality the horse is thinking I depend on this person to survive. Or they could indeed love us, who knows!
The cob isn't vocal. So when I hear any sound from her I can generally work it out.
She's got the where are you neigh
She's got a feed me nicker when the hay is about to go out.
She's got the mare to its foal soft barely heard one. You need to watch the nostrils and pin your ears back.
She's got the squeal
She's got the grunt

What's interesting is she lives with a group and we can all name who neighed, which suggests the horse can hear what we do and say. When the know what car you arrive in etc. That's your neigh to them.
 
Of course they do and in ways we probably can't imagine. It's that understanding that gets confusing through if we treat them like they are the same as us. For example I believe you are supposed to let them see the body if possible. But I know with the horses ends I have been with they were hidden away from their friends, covered with a sheet, is that just because it's maybe a bit easier for us that way?
When two were put down here, they were in an adjacent paddock.
The cob walked by and looked. No idea what she was thinking other than she stopped to look.
She stops to look at the views as well so no idea what she's thinking there either.

But when she wore the rug owned by J, another horse went for her and I had to take it off. She's never really been accepted in any rug.
 
Now, what skib said is interesting. Do the horses ever "take care" of a new rider or a child? Hogan is a "don't give a damn" personality, most of the time. I think he'd take the Mick out of any adult rider if he got the chance. But at Christmas, when I put my grandchildren on him, he metamorphasised into a little lead school pony. Didn't try to snatch the grass, didn't plant his feet - he was a wee gent. Perhaps it was remembered behaviour, or perhaps he did sense the vulnerability of his little passengers. I'd love to imagine it was the latter!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Trewsers
Oh and horses touching each other with no purpose? Well, here we go again, define "purpose". I think they definitely touch each other for no reason other than to say "It's OK, I'm here."
The next time the cob pokes me from behind I will ask her what it was for. :)
That's another thread.
I can interpret that poke with the nose in various ways. But after observing the personal space when they follow each other, I got a longer lead rope and solved it.
How long did it take you to fix that nf, oh only seven years, I tried "fixing" it first. ;)
 
Now, what skib said is interesting. Do the horses ever "take care" of a new rider or a child? Hogan is a "don't give a damn" personality, most of the time. I think he'd take the Mick out of any adult rider if he got the chance. But at Christmas, when I put my grandchildren on him, he metamorphasised into a little lead school pony. Didn't try to snatch the grass, didn't plant his feet - he was a wee gent. Perhaps it was remembered behaviour, or perhaps he did sense the vulnerability of his little passengers. I'd love to imagine it was the latter!

Aw, good Hogan. I remember putting my dad on Joe - my dad was 80 and never been on a horse in his life. J took him gently around the school, never a hoof wrong and it was a windy day. If it had been me or OH on board - totally different story!!! I like to think he was taking care of dad.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
It's an interesting thread. I have just got home from my therapy session where we were discussing how I feel a need to prove that horses who have been written off by other people are worth something. I have many examples. Ben wasn't wanted and was owned by 7 people within 3 years before he came to me. I have now owned him for over 8 happy years, but somewhere within me has been a need to prove to others (no-one in particular just people) that he can move nicely and he is just as good as the rest of them. I think that is what made me want to have lessons and enter competitions. But when I really think about this, am I trying to prove that Ben is good enough, or am I unconsciously trying to prove that I am good enough? I had problems in my childhood and sometimes didn't feel that anyone wanted me and I think that this plays out in the way in which I connect with horses. I think that I connect with Ben so deeply that I view us together as one. We are a team.

My old loan horse wasn't wanted either. When I met her she was depressed and unhappy, exactly how I was as a child. She needed someone to love her and so did I. We fulfilled that role for each other.

I think that human do unconsciously connect with animals based on their ability to fulfil our human needs. We therefore must view them in human terms to a certain extent. Ben, and all the previous horses in my care have never been 'just' horses, they are an extension of myself.
 
The sad thing is that I had a higher opinion of a mare's intelligence with Maisie. My new share - well I have started to think that horses are not that clever after all. She is safe. She submits. And no, I dont believe they deliberately do things people say they do like look after you. Or take care with a new rider or child. Their priority remains to take in food and spare energy. When i was a beginner and mounted on a yard and had to wait, the horse always put its head down and made for the grass.

I think it's sad that you are not finding your new share as intelligent as you thought Maisie was. Maybe Maisie was a particularly intelligent horse or perhaps she was more willing to interact with you on an emotional level than your current share.

I love my horse to bits, I think he is very clever and we have a good understanding (I think he understands me better than I understand him), but I don't get the same feeling about all horses. In fact our other horse Jack doesn't appear to be interested in emotional involvement with humans at all, he likes a scratch, loves a treat and will lick you all over if you let him (he has a salt lick permanently for this reason), but he just wants to be a horse at the end of the day. Although he generally has good manners, if something frightens him (eg the vet) he would have no hesitation in knocking you over to get out of the way.

Raf on the other hand goes out of his way not to hurt anyone (generally speaking, he doesn't like 'rude' people like a visiting farrier who tried to pick up a leg without introducing himself first - he didn't actually kick him, just waved his leg about a bit). And he has 'saved' me on many occasions when I have been coming off, despite being in a 'frightening' situation himself (collapsing mounting block, duck flying out of a dyke, touching an electric fence being three occasions that come to mind). When he felt me falling he stood stock still until I managed to scramble back up into the saddle. He's also ducked under me and scooped me back up when we've been cantering and he's spooked and I've lost my balance and been in danger of going out the side door. On the three occasions I have come off him he has been very upset (ok, that's anthropomorphising again, I mean head in the air, wild eyes, flaring nostrils). What I don't know is whether his desire to keep his rider on his back is due to his good nature (I don't think it's personal to me) or the training he had when he was being backed and ridden away. Probably a bit of both.

Without wishing to stereotype, I think there is differences in breeds, just as with dogs, according to what the purpose of the breed was. Arabs of course have a long history of living alongside their human masters so you would expect the breed to be pretty tuned in to us humans. (Although over breeding to produce monstrous looking show horses might put paid to this).

I was told that horses have the intelligence of a three year old child, which I think is pretty impressive! I'm not sure it applies to all horses though!
 
Hogan though, really doesn't seem to give a damn - his god is food, not me. Perhaps what i saw in Ramsey was trust (and now I'm emotional). Hogan, (rightly, its early days)hasn't come to trust me yet. Does it depend on the owner's attitude? I know people who enjoy their horses, look after them well etc, but love them? No, I don't think so. And when I look at their horses, I don't see what I fondly imagine I saw in Ramsey. So, do horses maybe reflect back the love, or whatever, that their owners put out to them?

How long have you had Hogan? There is no set time limit, but it took me a over a year to love the cob. I liked her else I wouldn't have got her, but after the loss of J, I need to allow myself permission to love another. I felt guilty for months and even now sometimes I miss him because she would have loved him.

Mine is a complete strumpet and that's not a mirror of me, she came like that! ;)
The horse will reflect us or be an extension of us. You are the one training, handling and educating them. We will possibly be attracted to the type of horses that will reflect that back?
Mine is independent, she is seen grazing acres away or nearby, her choices.
However she hacks out on her own, but prefers company. I don't prefer company I spend time on my own. So I am independent-like her.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
How long have you had Hogan? There is no set time limit, but it took me a over a year to love the cob. I liked her else I wouldn't have got her, but after the loss of J, I need to allow myself permission to love another. I felt guilty for months and even now sometimes I miss him because she would have loved him.

Mine is a complete strumpet and that's not a mirror of me, she came like that! ;)
The horse will reflect us or be an extension of us. You are the one training, handling and educating them. We will possibly be attracted to the type of horses that will reflect that back?
Mine is independent, she is seen grazing acres away or nearby, her choices.
However she hacks out on her own, but prefers company. I don't prefer company I spend time on my own. So I am independent-like her.
I've had him 2 years this June. But as the saying goes, he had me at hello. Because he's the polar opposite to Ramsey, I think my initial approach was too much how I would deal with my sweet obliging old boy, and that was never going to work with Hogan. I learned quick smart that lovey dovey phase could only come after firm guide lines were set. Certainly in the early days, I loved him more than he did me! I think he'll get there - we have a bond now, and mutual respect - hopefully that's the foundation for affection to grow. The strange thing is, the family jokes that Ramsey was the equine equivalent of my 6 year old grandson - sweet, kind, sensitive and loving, and Hogan is the equine equivalent of my 2 year old grandson - stubborn, temperamental, independent and oh, so funny. Now there's anthopomorphism for you!
 
Horses can definitely take care of us, or not, as suits them.

I fell off Ziggy and hurt myself several times, but he never hurt me intentionally and in fact would go out of his way not to hurt me - spooking towards the scary thing rather than flattening me, for example, doing his very best to jump over me rather than step on me when I stupidly flung myself under his feet, and scooping me up with his neck when I was half way down his shoulder. He was also invariably kind to small riders, walking smoothly and doing a little tiny trot, whereas his attitude to new adult riders was "stop me if you can".

This is such an interesting thread, there are loads of things I could comment on but that's the one that's front of mind at the moment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Huggy
I think it's sad that you are not finding your new share as intelligent as you thought Maisie was. Maybe Maisie was a particularly intelligent horse or perhaps she was more willing to interact with you on an emotional level than your current share.

What do people think about the age of the horse being a factor on what we interpet as intelligence?
Did I think Maisie clever because I met her when she was 6 and in her first week on our hacking yard? So everything was new to her and she was at an age when horses learn stuff? And I was in my first year ofr Mark rashid so taught her lots?

Whereas my new share is 13 and has been on the yard for years and knows the hacking. She has learned some of my habits from me (like to trot if I open my thighs and relax my hands) but I reckon she is on auto pilot. Once I diverted from the normal track just by 10 yards to get her to listen to me and it worked.

Hogan is the equine equivalent of my 2 year old grandson - stubborn, temperamental, independent and oh, so funny. Now there's anthopomorphism for you!
This is what our RI said teaching me how to hack my first share. That hacking is like taking a two year old child on the streets. You are the responsible adult.
 
newrider.com