Height Limit for Riding Pony

Apart from not being able to get a treed saddle wide enough, we went treeless due to my concerns about "being on the cantle" - even though I was assured I wasnt, I still wasnt comfortable with it.

Its a tough line with little ones sometimes. We have dieted and dieted, and still the weight goes on. They are on a 20x30m paddock paradise, with the track about 4ft wide. All they have is burnt grass, yet still the weight goes on. She is able to carry me, but Im aware of her lack of fitness, so we only walk with odd intervals of trot, but mainly hill walking. She is 60kg over weight. She is lunged 3x a week, but she is lame so now not being ridden or lunged. I can't win!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If she is on lead rein, she tramples the lead... and totally ignores smaller riders. So sometimes situations limit the ideal.

That said, Amee is a nippy little thing, who looks quite fit and loves jumping - a perfect teenage PC pony - not a small kids pony though. I wonder if it was a 14year old at that height would opinions differ to the ipression of an adult at that height?

Its quite interesting, but as long as pony's fitenss, capabilities, tack and riders ability were considered height wise I wouldn't have a concern. I don't understand why the height would be the issue if the weight wasnt? To me I would be more concerned about the weight carrying?

:D


I'm not worried about the weight aspect up to around 9.5 stone as she carries 9 stone no problems. So just wanted to check the height thing. I wouldnt put anything heavier than 9.5 stone on her though.
 
With height you look ok but not greatly suited, if yoru tall but slim, a good rider and not jsut good in your thinkign but really a good rider and know abotu correct weight distribution hoe to use you weight etc then thats great.

However if your tall regardless of age and unbalanced and sitting out of the saddle then problems arise.

I wouldn't have 9st on a small pony either but thats my preference, my 13.1hh pony is very stocky but I won't allow more than 9.5st on him even though he could carry more easily but thats just me.
Then again I wouldn't have a short 6st person ride my horse if they were bad riders either lol
 
With height you look ok but not greatly suited, if yoru tall but slim, a good rider and not jsut good in your thinkign but really a good rider and know abotu correct weight distribution hoe to use you weight etc then thats great.

However if your tall regardless of age and unbalanced and sitting out of the saddle then problems arise.

I wouldn't have 9st on a small pony either but thats my preference, my 13.1hh pony is very stocky but I won't allow more than 9.5st on him even though he could carry more easily but thats just me.
Then again I wouldn't have a short 6st person ride my horse if they were bad riders either lol

LOL agreed :D

I just find the notion of "growing out of ponies" interesting in general. My cousin is 9....she has "outgrown" three in the space of just under two years.
 
The OP didn't ask how a 5'7'' rider would LOOK on her pony. She asked if they would be "too much" for her pony. That's not the same thing.

I wish I could say I was surprised by the comments about taller riders looking silly on ponies, but sadly I'm not. It doesn't shock me any more just how many people think the most important thing about a horse-and-rider combination is the way they look :rolleyes:

I also find it interesting that people who think tall people riding small ponies is fine are those that are the tall people riding ponies.

Well that kind of makes sense, does it not? The reason the tall people riding ponies think it's "fine" is because we KNOW it's "fine", because we do it! But I am obviously stupid for thinking that it's "fine" for me to ride ponies, when clearly, it's not fine at all. I look silly, therefore I must not do it.

I may look ok but look even better on my 14.2hh Pony.

Joosie you look ok on the pony, not good as you do look too long in the leg but ok yes ......... you would look great on a horse / pony that was more suited to your size.

That's it, then. I should stop riding ponies and not get on anything smaller than 16.2. I don't want to look stupid now do I :rolleyes:

but too tall for the pony, legs are below the stomach

Have you ever seen Mark Todd on a horse? :rolleyes: His legs are below the stomach on a 17-hander. I bet he doesn't give a crap any more than I do.

I am not a vain person, in or out of the saddle, and I do not give a RAT'S ARSE how I look on a horse. I don't care if I look "too big" or "too long in the leg" and that I would look "better" on a big horse. No doubt you would think that I look ridiculous on a Shetland (and you obviously would, since apparently I look ridiculous on a 12.1) but I ride them anyway because it's FUN. That's why I ride, because I enjoy it. How I look means nothing to me.

I do ride big horses too by the way. I just think ponies are better :p I apologise if I have come across as rude in this post but I'm sorry, the snobbery about adults on ponies REALLY gets my back up :mad:
 
It was not snobbery on my part, just my honest opinion based on the pics you posted, sorry if that upset you, but i still stand by what i say.

If you are happy then do not listen to anyone elses views, it's your hobby and your pony and thats all that should matter.
 
It was not snobbery on my part, just my honest opinion based on the pics you posted, sorry if that upset you, but i still stand by what i say.

If you are happy then do not listen to anyone elses views, it's your hobby and your pony and thats all that should matter.

I agree, no-one on this thread has been nasty, they have just given their opinions.

Why post pics on a thread like this if you are going to get upset about what people say. And you must have been aware that not all of the comments would be positive.

IMHO I am fine with adults on ponies but I do think there are limits. Often to accomodate the adults the ponies have too long a saddle for their short backs and many riders are unbalanced. I was actually watching a couple at a show yesterday and there was a tendancy for the saddle to be too far forward interfering with the shoulder as well.
 
I agree, no-one on this thread has been nasty, they have just given their opinions.

Why post pics on a thread like this if you are going to get upset about what people say. And you must have been aware that not all of the comments would be positive.

IMHO I am fine with adults on ponies but I do think there are limits. Often to accomodate the adults the ponies have too long a saddle for their short backs and many riders are unbalanced. I was actually watching a couple at a show yesterday and there was a tendancy for the saddle to be too far forward interfering with the shoulder as well.

Yes really difficult to get saddles right. Ive gone on pony's opinion for this as Im "fortunate" enough to have a pony who tells me where to stick it if she is uncomfy - but very few people are - or its "naughtyness".

Treed was just ridiculous for us. And current treeless looks long on her, and overlaps her shoulder - but its actually the pad underneath that is large.

Its particularily important to get the saddle right, when there is larger weight on a smaller distribution area.
 
That's it, then. I should stop riding ponies and not get on anything smaller than 16.2. I don't want to look stupid now do I :rolleyes:

Sorry but I laughed at that comment, I mean come on that's like saying anything under 16.2hh is a pony lol

And yeah, if your unbalanced and sitting out the saddle you shouldn't be riding a small pony.. you say you do it for fun,, great yoru having fun but me,, I'd be thinking "just how much fun is this for the pony"

We all have our opinions and when posting a question of any kind we need to be open to positive and negative criticism as it will come.

Me, I take on board the parts I want. If something upsets me, I then question myself "why" is it because I don't want to hear the truth? Is it because the person is right and I don't like hearing what I have been doing ain't that great after all?

Either way I take opinions as they are and learn from them, no good getting upset as at the end of the day the only person effected would be me..

So don't take everything personnally, everyone just places their opinion and that's all it is. ;);););)
 
And yeah, if your unbalanced and sitting out the saddle you shouldn't be riding a small pony.. you say you do it for fun,, great yoru having fun but me,, I'd be thinking "just how much fun is this for the pony"

So you assume the pony is NOT having fun simply because its rider's legs finish below its belly :confused: Why does having a rider who is 5'6'' rather than 5'2'' mean it will suddenly stop enjoying its work?

Personally, I think "how much fun is this for him/her" EVERY time I ride, be it on a Shetland or the 12.1 in my photos or a 15hh cob or a 16.2 warmblood.

What do you think the pony in my photos enjoys more? Being ridden round and round the arena for an hour by a kid who is the "perfect size" for him, or going out galloping around the hills with me and my long legs?

I am NOT an unbalanced rider. I have seen many, many riders on big horses who look EXTREMELY unbalanced and/or don't fit in the saddle. Being on a pony doesn't automatically turn someone into a bad rider :confused:

If something upsets me, I then question myself "why" is it because I don't want to hear the truth? Is it because the person is right and I don't like hearing what I have been doing ain't that great after all?

I didn't take offence at your comments because they hit a nerve. I took offence because I thought they were rather shallow and unkind.
 
This all seems rather pointless, the origional thread is being hijacked, and Joosie, you must understand that not everyone will say the same things, we wont all agree and thats fine.

Horses/ponies and questions about weight/height will almost always be an emotive topic, not everyone likes to see riders who are too tall on ponies, that is just how life is!

It does not mean anyone is rude or shallow and i am sure Demson was not intending to do that, but people can comment on your pics, you put them there to be viewed?!:confused:

Imagine the response you may have got if you had put pics of you riding on your Shetland!:eek:

To be honest Joosie, the fact that you are upset by the comments suggests that you realise yourself that maybe you are too big for the pony.

I am saying no more on the matter now as i dont want to get pulled into a debate about adults riding ponies to be honest.
 
Last edited:
QUOTE=joosie;2552713

So you assume the pony is NOT having fun simply because its rider's legs finish below its belly :confused: Why does having a rider who is 5'6'' rather than 5'2'' mean it will suddenly stop enjoying its work?

Can you quote where I actually say this as it seems your adding things here

I am NOT an unbalanced rider. I have seen many, many riders on big horses who look EXTREMELY unbalanced and/or don't fit in the saddle. Being on a pony doesn't automatically turn someone into a bad rider :confused:

Again you add text that has never been said, but heck correct me if I am wrong by quoting my actual wording as I don't recall saying YOU were out of balance.


I didn't take offence at your comments because they hit a nerve. I took offence because I thought they were rather shallow and unkind.

Then you need to read correctly what I say as this post you have wrote mentions things I have not even said
 
This all seems rather pointless, the origional thread is being hijacked, and Joosie, you must understand that not everyone will say the same things, we wont all agree and thats fine.

Horses/ponies and questions about weight/height will almost always be an emotive topic, not everyone likes to see riders who are too tall on ponies, that is just how life is!

It does not mean anyone is rude or shallow and i am sure Demson was not intending to do that, but people can comment on your pics, you put them there to be viewed?!:confused:

Imagine the response you may have got if you had put pics of you riding on your Shetland!:eek:

To be honest Joosie, the fact that you are upset by the comments suggests that you realise yourself that maybe you are too big for the pony.

I am saying no more on the matter now as i dont want to get pulled into a debate about adults riding ponies to be honest.

Thanks for that, I did say in my post that my comments were just my opinion and as I mentioned when I post a question or other I am always open to feedback whether positive or negative as from both I learn loads, I never take offence in any form or for any reason.

If I thought I would get offended at any comments then I simply would not post, anyway drifting from the original topic which was not intended.

I stick to everything I have said and that includes people with long legs or that are tall riding very small ponies look ok but not great and a big no no is if they are unbalanced and splurging out of the saddle from all angles lol
 
Last edited:
Just for the record, in your photos joosie, that saddle does look abit too far forward on his shoulder and quite long for that pony...

*hides*
 
That's a fair comment nani. When those photos were taken he didn't have his own saddle and was ridden in the one we had that fit him well enough at the time. He does now have his own saddle, which fits far better than the other one and is neither too big for his back nor too small for my mahoosive size 6 bottom ;)

Demson, I didn't say you said those things outright, but was what you appeared to be insinuating. I can't help but be sensitive when I am told that I shouldn't be riding a certain horse because of the way I look on it :rolleyes: But I agree, nothing more should be said on the matter.

As I have already said, I am not being sensitive because I "know" that I am "too big" for the pony. Everything I have attempted with him, we have achieved. As far as I'm concerned that means he is most certainly NOT too small for me. You should see us out on hacks winning gallop races against 16hh-ish Thoroughbred types and flying over ditches that the big horses stop at... trust me, I do not inhibit the pony's way of going ;)
 
That's a fair comment nani. When those photos were taken he didn't have his own saddle and was ridden in the one we had that fit him well enough at the time. He does now have his own saddle, which fits far better than the other one and is neither too big for his back nor too small for my mahoosive size 6 bottom ;)

Demson, I didn't say you said those things outright, but was what you appeared to be insinuating. I can't help but be sensitive when I am told that I shouldn't be riding a certain horse because of the way I look on it :rolleyes: But I agree, nothing more should be said on the matter.

As I have already said, I am not being sensitive because I "know" that I am "too big" for the pony. Everything I have attempted with him, we have achieved. As far as I'm concerned that means he is most certainly NOT too small for me. You should see us out on hacks winning gallop races against 16hh-ish Thoroughbred types and flying over ditches that the big horses stop at... trust me, I do not inhibit the pony's way of going ;)

I never even insinuated anything and yopur post came about making statements of wording I never said. You may know what you mean but others reading will think differently, after all I know what has been said and still thought you were adding text that hadn't been mentuioned.
I also never once said that you shouldn't be riding your horse and if you go back on my post I say that you look OK on the pony, not great but okay..

So again your insinuating and adding wording that hassn't even been said.

This is how arguments occur as people forget what was actually said and make up their own stories.. And please no... don't think I am accusing you of picking an argument because I am not, In fact I am pleased to see that you are talking this through sensibly and not arguing.

My main issue with people in general (NOT YOU) is when they are unbalanced, pull on the reins to try and balance themselves and then rock all over on the horses back. The horse gets upset and rightly so, reacts and then gets either a whip or a boot... This is a scene I have witnessed so many times..
 
newrider.com