Height Limit for Riding Pony

Claire1605

Active Member
Apr 25, 2008
2,602
7
38
Essex
I have had interest in sharing my part welsh pony. She is 12.2hh.

The person interested is 9 1/2 stone and 5'7".

Do you think this is too tall for said pony. I think pony will carry the weight OK as BC rides her and is a snip at 9 stone 5'3", but do you think 5'7" would be a bit much?
 
I would say it would depend on how the person rode and felt on the pony. If he/she was a balanced rider and felt OK riding your pony I don't think there would be a problem?
 
Ooh, I'd be tempted to say she certainly was too tall - sorry. It's not just the weight, it's the centre of balance. Ponies are stronger inch for inch pound for pound but you have to be realistic.

5'7 is taller than me and I wouldn't dream of riding a 12.2!! This is a personal opinion but I'd feel ridiculous :D - The smallest I've ridden at my height is 14hh and that felt odd as I felt I was far too heavy and at the time I was 9st (this was for a birhday gymkhana btw, I wasn't on for long doing old pc games). You have to take the pony's skeletal structure and musculature into account and how fit it is.
 
I have to admit, at 5ft 7inches myself I would feel uncomfortable riding something like an icelandic and my preference is for as short as I can get away with.
 
Thanks for your replies ladies.

I thought she might be too tall. Perhaps a more petite 5'3" like Bluntcrayon would be better.
 
I agree with the first post - its rider dependant.

Silver wont tolerate an unbalanced 6st rider, yet happily toddles about with me. She wont let an individual mount who she knows is unbalanced.

It is harder to balance the centre of gravity, but if they are a good rider it should be fine.

That said I would have more of an issue with the weight. I am just short of 8/.5st and wouldnt want more than that on madam really. Esp if they are going to be jumping Amee. That said Sil is much unfitter, fatter and I think shorter.
 
Yes I think i'd have to agree that she'd be too tall. If your pony was 13.2hh then i'd say go for it! :D But 12.2 is little :o

I've always been one debating of what height horse I can get away with because I am tall although only 9st, but as soon as I get on a horse my legs seem to shrink :rolleyes: and a lot of people are amazed how I fit them so well, when on the ground i'm so tall :D
 
I would say it is rider dependant - if she is competant and comfortable, and pony is happy, then go for it. I'm just shy of 5'11" and feel ridiculous on anything under 15hh but that's just me!!

She will, without doubt, look too tall, but I don't think she is too heavy.
 
I am 5'8 and USED to be 10 stone LOL ... used to ride 13.2hh ponies occasionally and felt huge on them ... but if it was a big pony (Fjord, Haflinger etc) probably would not have felt so big. Now I am a few stone heavier will not ride less than 15hh cobby types! I think they will look too tall, on 13.2hh ponies my legs did look as though they would touch the floor on occasion, obviously a wider horse will take up the leg well but I think I have to agree that weight wise will probably be fine, but height wise I honestly think the rider's legs will get tangled with the pony's!! :P
 
I have to disagree that 5'7'' is too tall for a 12.2. Agree completely with the comments that taller riders on smaller ponies can struggle with balance - BUT for a competent rider who is familiar with riding ponies, and who is a suitable weight for the pony to carry, 5'7'' and 12.2 is a perfectly doable combination.

I am 5'6'' and this pony is 12.1. In addition to schooling him once a week, I use him for escorting hacks (including day rides) and have competed him in dressage, showjumping and endurance. Do my legs come down below his belly? Most certainly. Do I look like I'm unbalanced on the pony and he is struggling to carry me? Most certainly not!

prelim2.jpg

piccoloblack.jpg

piccolocanterinarena.jpg

piccologoingup.jpg
 
I have to say, you too make a fab pair!:)

Though back to the question, am 5ft7 with long legs and a short body:p and i ride a 14.1 arab/ welsh mare even though i my feet normally come below her belly she can carry easily so if the pony can that should be fine i have ridden a 12.2 ex show pony before who was my mates sister pony just had a bit of a blast really and it was a one of but she could carry me. So aslong as the pony can carry you why does it matter if people say your too big yeah people might be am too big for my loan mare but i weigh about 7 and a half stone and she can still gallop around fields with me on her back :D
 
Joosie, you are clearly very lightweight (you look less than 9st) and balanced but you do look as if you're riding your little sisters pony :p. Men DO ride little ponies in andes, india, iceland etc but problems do occur I warn you!!

In light of claires post, she doesn't know how well balanced her prosective rider is so it is best to err on the side of caution. What about saddle size and comfort? Some saddles for big riders are a problem for short backs, it ends up on the shoulders to make up for being too long in the cantle. Not everyone is comfortable with long stirrups as in Joosie's photos.

A lot to consider.
 
Last edited:
I also find it interesting that people who think tall people riding small ponies is fine are those that are the tall people riding ponies.

The previous post about the saddle is a good point, a correctly fitted saddle for a small pony is often to small for an adult. You can tell from viewing from the back when the adults backside is spilling over the sides of the saddle and they are sitting right back on the cantle. I have seen this countless times and yeah I have to admit every adult I have seen ridign a pony is unbalanced and not a good rider. This is why I probably disgree about adults riding ponies way too small for them.

I am only 5'2" and my little pony is 13.1hh and stocky and though I am told I look ok on him I still feel too big. I may look ok but look even better on my 14.2hh Pony.

Joosie you look ok on the pony, not good as you do look too long in the leg but ok yes. Your riding position looks great and you look very slim so lightweight which is a good bonus and the pony looks relaxed and supple on the flat and jumping so good on ya but you would look great on a horse / pony that was more suited to your size.
 
hehe i'm not tall, and i'm not totally agreeing lol. Just think its rider and pony dependant :) and sometimes thats not given a chance. Silver was a notorious rearer but doesn't now. Often it is a wrong combination, but sometimes needs to be given a chance :)
 
I would feel silly riding a pony, I am tall with long legs, my horse is nearly 16h.
I also think Joosie has a good position and is lightweight, but too tall for the pony, legs are below the stomach and the pony looks short backed, I am sure its not, but when people are to big for the pony, it gives this illusion.

Still, each to their own as they say!;)
 
That's the thing, I think height, leg length and weight and balalnce are one thing but I what I so often see (and have to bite my lip quite often) is ridiers being squashed into saddles that are too small for them. That obviously doesn't apply in Joosie's case but IRL is all too much of a common site :(
 
Another thing to point out is that the rider being squished into a saddle way too small for them then applies the central weight all on one spot rather than distributed as it would be with the correct pony / rider combination.

Also over time the horse could develop back problems that may appear later on in its life.

I know some people only get to ride the little pony as they have no other pony to ride but they need to think of the pony and not of their own enjoyment which a lot of people do. It may be fun for them but is it really fun for the pony?

Its different for propblem ponies but again these ponies with issues can be helped in other ways without an unbalanced unsuitable rider.

Hey if anyone in Northampton does need a pony to ride contact me as I have two that are fat and need exercise which at the moment I can't offer due to a back operation.

The 14.2hh is offered on loan and details are on here on another post
 
Another thing to point out is that the rider being squished into a saddle way too small for them then applies the central weight all on one spot rather than distributed as it would be with the correct pony / rider combination.

Also over time the horse could develop back problems that may appear later on in its life.

I know some people only get to ride the little pony as they have no other pony to ride but they need to think of the pony and not of their own enjoyment which a lot of people do. It may be fun for them but is it really fun for the pony?

Its different for propblem ponies but again these ponies with issues can be helped in other ways without an unbalanced unsuitable rider.

Hey if anyone in Northampton does need a pony to ride contact me as I have two that are fat and need exercise which at the moment I can't offer due to a back operation.

The 14.2hh is offered on loan and details are on here on another post


Apart from not being able to get a treed saddle wide enough, we went treeless due to my concerns about "being on the cantle" - even though I was assured I wasnt, I still wasnt comfortable with it.

Its a tough line with little ones sometimes. We have dieted and dieted, and still the weight goes on. They are on a 20x30m paddock paradise, with the track about 4ft wide. All they have is burnt grass, yet still the weight goes on. She is able to carry me, but Im aware of her lack of fitness, so we only walk with odd intervals of trot, but mainly hill walking. She is 60kg over weight. She is lunged 3x a week, but she is lame so now not being ridden or lunged. I can't win!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If she is on lead rein, she tramples the lead... and totally ignores smaller riders. So sometimes situations limit the ideal.

That said, Amee is a nippy little thing, who looks quite fit and loves jumping - a perfect teenage PC pony - not a small kids pony though. I wonder if it was a 14year old at that height would opinions differ to the ipression of an adult at that height?

Its quite interesting, but as long as pony's fitenss, capabilities, tack and riders ability were considered height wise I wouldn't have a concern. I don't understand why the height would be the issue if the weight wasnt? To me I would be more concerned about the weight carrying?

:D
 
newrider.com