Positive and Negative Reinforcement

Thanks Jack.
Ok tonight I went up to the field to practice 'feel' a la Leslie. Printed off a trees worth of articles from her website last night, read them till I fell asleep then today I stood in the field trying to ask Charlie to give to pressure and flex his neck on either side. Ended up closing my eyes to I could feel a 'try' more acutely. Anyway, it went ok I think. He was flexing either side at any rate. He did lots of sighing and snorting which Leslie says is A Good Thing, but I'm not entirely sure why. Seemed to me he was a wee bit bored.... Lower lip was all droopy too so at least he wasn't stressed by the process.
?

Krissie, after reading Leslie Desmonds stuff, have you made any changes in the way you "try" to handle your horses? Did you like her ideas?

still a very thought provoking thread

indicators -- well, not to get too tied down in semantics, but I could use a whip to cause an irritating tapping that motivates my horse to want to move away from it (so the whip is an external motivator and, indeed an element of engative reinforcement) - I could use it to lightly touch the horse to indicate that I would like more effort from THAT spot there.... in which case it is an indicator and not a pressure point in itself...

I could point with the whip -- so it becomes an indicator of direction....

I could caress with the whip which becomes an indicator of a feeling....

so many things each thing can be...





the key is how to achieve that as a highly compettiive predatorial human being LOL

Cathy

:)Your example of "indicators" seem to indicate that some type of physical contact is present. I don't see an indicator that way. Mounted or on the ground, I always want any "indicator" to "indicate my intent" of an "ask or try". I should never need to make "contact" with a horse that still has it's life and spirit intact. My body language and physical actions, my mental energy and focus, are more than enough to cause most horses to respond. The types of horses that may need more pressure are likely the kind that have been overly de-sensitized to humans. Of couse this is the goal of many people that want a horse that is bomb proof and has no fears.

I cut a lot from fth's post, but left this sentence about humans being predators. I believe humans can be either preditor or prey depending on the circumstances etc. Take the rifle away from a lion hunter and the roles quickly reverse.

Amberlystar, I checked some of your links but could not find any video's showing horses being "clicker trained". Let me know if anybody has any good examples with horses, and the exclusive use of +r type training. Maybe the NH board could be renamed "Clicker training". :)


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
Krissie, after reading Leslie Desmonds stuff, have you made any changes in the way you "try" to handle your horses? Did you like her ideas?

Yes I loved her ideas. I love the idea of 'lightness' being something already within the horse.

As regards changes in handling - I can't (yet) see how to BE around a horse that will aid in releasing lightness.....I'm still at the stage of needing to DO stuff....

So I've tried a couple more sessions of 'doing' feel (as opposed to feeling feel I guess :D). I can move his head up and down and side to side. And then I tried the 'firm pull when leading' from the 'how to lead real free' article. The firm pull seemed a strange thing to do when everything else was so subtle & soft. And maybe my timing was off (probbaly) but he didn't really respond to that. He was ok at leading anyway, but a bit reluctant at times, so needed some chivvying. I decided to try the firm pull to see if he would increase pace without the rope coming tight on him, but he didn't. But yes I like the approach, though I need to have it operationalised for me. I plan to get the True Horemanship Through Feel book.
 
I love this idea of "feel" - that you are so intune with the horse you are as one essentially.

I have been following this thread, and although feeling a bit out of depth at times, I have found it really interesting as I am trying to become more thoughtful about what techniques I "employ" with nurturing Silver - trying to work out if I need to asscertain leadership, whether she is dominant in fear, and above all to try and improve my damn listening skills!

This means I have been quite fussy about what I have been doing - and perhaps not everyones choice of methods - I have justified to myself why I chose those. For example, I am in two minds about using join up as although I know she comes to me, and I have used it with success out in the field when having catching problems - however I do not like the idea of sending her away - I do not want a relationship wherby she does my bidding as she is "in fear" of me - however, I wonder with her biting and kicking and bolshy behaviour whether I have to ascertain the dominance/leadership.

I have contemplated getting someone in to help, but I worry that they might use something I do not want used - I summed it up by accident the other day - I love, and I mean it, even though it has me in tears some days and hysterics another, just how expresssve she is - I just wish she was a little politer at expressing herself!

Although, partly I think she is not as polite as she has given up being polite as nobody listened until she became aggressive, and I have to confess to not being a great listener as I have never been "bought up" this way around horses eg. horses that bit when girthed were grumpy - never thought of as an indication of pain etc.

So... to the feel. How would you even begin with feel with a pony like Silver?

I can be kicked for something as simple as skipping her out, yet other times its more obvious eg. she does not want me to wash her tail as the water is cold (resolved with warm water) - I find it very difficult to reason with her - the only way to sort of reason with doing an activitiy is to have her on a lunge and just be persistant until she stands or stops kicking/biting, however even this has flaws as she will drag me off to munch grass.
 
"Your example of "indicators" seem to indicate that some type of physical contact is present."

oops my mistake -- I think the examples I used can lead to that conclusion but you are spot on - -I like my first indicator to be my thought and energy....

the physical contact is close to the last stage for me.....


and I love your point about the hunter without a gun...

I do think a LOT of humans understand a lot about being prey -- I think our challenge is managing our ability to switch between prey and predator rather than finding a stable centre in which we can ground ourselves...

Cathy
 
Yes I loved her ideas. I love the idea of 'lightness' being something already within the horse.

As regards changes in handling - I can't (yet) see how to BE around a horse that will aid in releasing lightness.....I'm still at the stage of needing to DO stuff....
But yes I like the approach, though I need to have it operationalised for me. I plan to get the True Horemanship Through Feel book.

“True Horsemanship through Feel” is my bible of horsemanship. It’s a how too book, but it isn’t. It tells you all you need to know, but it doesn’t. You can read it over and over, and always find some “deeper truth” to explore. It’s a book about horses and how they “like to feel” with humans. :)

http://www.amazon.com/True-Horsemanship-Through-Feel-Second/dp/1599210568/ref=pd_bxgy_b_text_b

One of the things I really find useful about “lateral flexing” (on the ground) is the visibility the method allows the human as the horse “gives”. When you “ask” for flexion from the ground, you can feel the resistance in the horses neck and must wait until you “see the give” before “releasing”. “Wait for the give”, is a big part of good horsemanship.

I love this idea of "feel" - that you are so intune with the horse you are as one essentially.

I have been following this thread, and although feeling a bit out of depth at times, I have found it really interesting as I am trying to become more thoughtful about what techniques I "employ" with nurturing Silver - trying to work out if I need to asscertain leadership, whether she is dominant in fear, and above all to try and improve my damn listening skills!



So... to the feel. How would you even begin with feel with a pony like Silver?

I don’t think anybody should feel out of their depth in this conversation.:) These things we are talking about are the “foundation” of good horsemanship. This is where it all starts, with feel, the first time you “touch” a horse it begins, but most of us miss “feeling it”. I would begin with Silver the way I would with any horse, “one step backwards” and remember to “exaggerate the release” when she “trys”. Make her a promise that “from this day forward, I will reward her every try” and then strive to live by that goal. She will recognize the change in you quickly. Of course she will also need to “test you” completely on the subject. ;)

"Your example of "indicators" seem to indicate that some type of physical contact is present."

oops my mistake -- I think the examples I used can lead to that conclusion but you are spot on - -I like my first indicator to be my thought and energy....

the physical contact is close to the last stage for me.....


and I love your point about the hunter without a gun...

I do think a LOT of humans understand a lot about being prey -- I think our challenge is managing our ability to switch between prey and predator rather than finding a stable centre in which we can ground ourselves...

Cathy

Here we are again, :)talking about some kind of balance. This ability to “switch between predator and prey” sounds amazingly like some other phrases we’ve mentioned. Pressure and Release, Approach and Retreat, Whoa and Go, Predator and Prey, and the list grows.

Trainers have told me, and horses have taught me it’s true, that I must always balance the de-sensitizing exercises with sensitizing exercises. It’s been my experience that many horse people are fearful of the horses energy when it is excited and being asked to perform at speed. This results in these handlers depending on very “low stress” type of methods with their horses.

Clicker training certainly appeals to those folks but I still believe it has a lot of flaws in the basic premise of what is positive and what is negative energy. I listen and read as people speak of the +r, -r subject through human eyes, and watch them grapple with the meanings, and I think of a horse and it’s simplicity. The horse is always aware of all energy, ours and any other energy that is present in their ‘senses’. The ‘simple’ little horse can make sense of it all, instantly.

Since I rarely use “physical” pressure or contact when sensitizing a horse I must be clear in my “intentions” when I ask for a response. Be clear in what you ask, and quick with the answer (release), always striving for improvement in both. It becomes a language between horse and human. The intent of pressure can be a stick of any color. :p

Intent, "haven't yet, but I might", :D

MVC-322S.jpg



I’ve written too much, but I hope that people come to realize that Parelli and Marks are not the only “game in town” and other concepts might be worth taking a good look at. These Leslie Desmond articles are a good place to spend some time reading and might inspire some folks to post their own ideas on feel.

http://www.lesliedesmond.com/index.php?id=27


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
For what it's worth, here are my answers - as you will see they're not so very different from yours or Yann's...

Reward, as per usual, I find myself with some questions that I find myself considering,

Does your horse reward you?
Constantly. :) I really mean that. Horses are pretty much the most rewarding things in my life.

By being a horse. It is even more rewarding if he is a happy horse.

How do you reward your horse?

By being pleasant to be around, the sort of person they feel comfortable about being with, understanding, sensitive to needs & wishes, worthy of trust etc.

But also... with praise, rubs, rest, titbits and allowing them to do what they want. :D

What can I offer him, that he will understand “clearly”, and that he can always count on me to provide?
He can count on me to be calm, confident, certain, clear, consistent, capable, considerate, careful, couthie.

(Do I get a Parelli Award for gratuitous alliteration? :p)

Where will I find it?
Within me, of course.
 
I often find myself questioning how/if a horse show's appreciation of "doing a job well". Does a horse find more purpose in a bigger challange than a small one?

I like to find those times when the horse is in the "unknown" and completely dependent on me to provide what's needed to move forward. Think of that moment approaching a lake, or the blue tarp, a big jump etc. Right then is when you will find the truth about reward and it's meaning. When a horse trusts us enough to "take that step", despite the horses fear of what's ahead, that's when I find my reward.

I only hope the horse feels the same way in the same instant. :) This thing I call "trust" isn't abstract, it's real, and without it neither the horse or rider will get very far.


Keep on, keepin on

Jack
 
newrider.com