I'm going to post something that I've been thinking for a while. I know that you don't know me, but please don't take it the wrong way.
You seem like a nice guy that really loves his horse. You don't have any horsey support or back-up at home and are fairly novicey. You are currently using NR as your back-up, but also seem to be very easily swayed by what people are saying. There's a phrase somewhere along the lines of 'nothing of use ever gets achieved by a committee'. Since I've read through your dilemmas of 'I'm going to sell her' or 'I'm never going to sell her', it seems to me as though the last thing you need is 20 people telling you 20 different things.
As a novice it takes a while to be able to 'prioritise' your problems. Some are serious, some aren't. Some need sorting immediately, some just need putting on a 'to do' list. You're not superman and you have your horse at home. You've been on here a while now, and it looks as though you've found people you trust. I apologise again if I'm speaking out of turn here, but my advice would be to stop posting quite so much on the general board because you are getting loads of people pointing out things that 'aren't quite perfect'. Use the friends that you've come to trust to watch your back and make sure you aren't making any serious mistakes, and while you're waiting for that livery yard place just chill out a bit, enjoy your horse and stop asking for advice from people that are going to point out every little imperfection because it WILL stress you out.
FWIW, I've seen hundreds of healthy horses in worse-looking fields, and she isn't in terrible condition. Chill!
Hope you take this in the sense its meant. I'm not trying to stop you posting or anything, just think its doing you more harm than good.