"NH" and "Traditional" Methods

true true

there are some old terms that I use soemthimes and people dont understand what I'm getting at them after discussion we get the the point that we mean the same thing :)

I do like your ideas on things tho and it has been refreshing to see so many people trying to understand horses and open to ideas and discissions on it :)

Well said! This could have turned nasty (very close!) but none of us mean any harm and it's great to learn. Good going! :D

x
 
But what if the answer you get isn't one you can work with?

If the reason your horse wont do something is because it has never been taught properly, then teach it.

What if it knows exactly what is required of it? (e.g. does it instantly if it knows there is a chance of a food reward?)

I think the 'why' approach is all very well in principle, as long as you can get an answer that means you can do something....

IMO the reality is everyone tries to do the same two things.

1) Communicate to the horse what they want it to do.

2) Persuade/force the horse to do what’s asked if it does not have a relationship with the handler/rider where the horse want's do what’s asked of it or has been trained/conditioned/brainwashed to respond.

Everyone knows a horse can feel a fly anywhere on it's body so anymore force than that to comunicate is about persuading/forcing the horse or it being the lightest the human can manage.

Different schools of horsemanship/people choose different approaches, pretty much all are successful (Including tieing to a post and hitting the horse until it stops reacting to the hits, it's very effective) and people are drawn or choose the one they are most able to succeed with/feel comfortable with.

"if your horse isn't doing what you want it to do then you are either asking the wrong question, or asking the question wrong".

This a good example of NH clinicians coming up with a good tag like which is not entirely true or true at all, sadly i have found big names in NH that i was into do this all the time.

If this was true no one would ever need to, as they say "Turn up the heat", "use escilating pressure", "Make the right thing easy and the wrong thing difficult" etc.
 
Last edited:
(Including tieing to a post and hitting the horse until it stops reacting to the hits, it's very effective) and people are drawn or choose the one they are most able to succeed with/feel comfortable with.

I am fairly sure that this is not a method I would find myself being drawn towards

is there any point in hitting an animal until it stops reactiong

I feel if I was to try this with my mare, she would pretty much be so confused she would probably make good attempts to kill me as soon as she got the chance. you would end up with a snapped post and a rather large gash on your head were she boxed you back :)

:D

is this a practice used these days and what exatly are the methods behind it?? what does it achive ???

just intrested :)
 
I am fairly sure that this is not a method I would find myself being drawn towards

is there any point in hitting an animal until it stops reactiong

I feel if I was to try this with my mare, she would pretty much be so confused she would probably make good attempts to kill me as soon as she got the chance. you would end up with a snapped post and a rather large gash on your head were she boxed you back :)

:D

is this a practice used these days and what exatly are the methods behind it?? what does it achive ???

just intrested :)

Still used today in parts, but i don't think pictures are going to be appreciated.

It's based on fear and desesnitisation, once it's over the horses are treated as well if not better than those of any other method, it about dominance and submission just like some forms of NH, NH in it's history has parts that are pretty rough too.

It's traditional Gaucho breaking, pretty sure your mare would pass through the program successfully.

Gauchos' were renowned as some of the most skillfull horseman alive, not so much now as they were but they are still highly skilled.

Just to add it's not my thing at all but it is effective.
 
Last edited:
my mare ........... when she goes nuts about something you have to work with her, try and make her and you wont get anywhere ...........not at all, she is the most intresting horse and the one I respect the most out of all the horses I met

I never won the battle to be in charge........but we found a level where we met half way and man when she rides its like riding pure silk :) she behaves like she is joined up, but I never did join her up...explain some one if you know why cos I dont :)

she would probably have hurt them and took buildings down in the process had she had been subjected to that

although she is a sweety if you know how to handle her

what did it achive tho?? submission ??

and what was the next step ??

I dont get how whipping a horse would do any good , do you know their reasons behind it :)
 
Still used today in parts, but i don't think pictures are going to be appreciated.

It's based on fear and desesnitisation, once it's over the horses are treated as well if not better than those of any other method, it about dominance and submission just like some forms of NH, NH in it's history has parts that are pretty rough too.

It's traditional Gaucho breaking, pretty sure your mare would pass through the program successfully.

Gauchos' were renowned as some of the most skillfull horseman alive, not so much now as they were but they are still highly skilled.

Just to add it's not my thing at all but it is effective.

yeah I seen these natural people some times, not naming names, but off camera, out of site in secret they get pretty wicked with some of the **** they do and keep it very underwraps

like yeah I seen some and thought yeah those bits I wont be using :)
 
This is a NH version a guy has come up with, but you can see the post and how the horses were tied.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UkMDKndqBDs&feature=related

In the traditional way they would hit them until they were exhusted and mentally boken, shut down in some ways and then jump on, turn them loose and ride them.

They would basically have a string of semi wild horse they would just jump on and ride.

As for your mare, south america is a VERY macho society, gauch's own horses are the wildest most difficult horse they can find, it's part of being a man, i don't think they would have a problem the more dangrous the better and if they can't break them the horse dies while they try. They would have then used the carcase and just got another wild horse to start the porcess gain with, in the hay day of the Gaucho wild horse on the pampas were 10 a penny they had little value.
 
Last edited:
be about right I rekon mine would have died :D

but like so acient but i guess it worked so they went with it generation after generation

not one forward thinker out of them all

shoking stuff

but yeah I saw ...........mad ........i dont like it :D
 
Totally off the topic of NH, there is, sadly, no need to use macho 'qualities' to brutalise a horse physically and very thoroughly indeed.

Look at what is still happening in the gaited horse showing world in the US, and the despicable, extreme 'training' methods used by some breeders/show producers to enable sored horses to pass inspections and win prestigious prizes.

It may seem unbelievable to most of us, but such is the nature of horses that many can be trained/conditioned to accept severe pain unflinchingly, if they learn that a visible response on their part will result in even more extreme agony.

Again, pictures would not be appreciated, but there are plenty of reliable links available to anyone who googles.
 
Thank you. :) So would I! I suppose it depends on how you define "leadership": it doesn;'t have to be about telling someone what to do, but rather guiding them.
Ah, ok - that sounds good to me! :) It's just that I suspect many people's definition of leadership would also include an element of commanding or giving instructions (the 'alpha'/boss idea).

It may help to think of a role model in your life that you know, look up to and admire who you respect so that you try hard for them; perhaps a previous/current teacher or one of your parents/guardians. You know that they will keep you safe and will protect you before themselves, so you trust them. You know they will never ask you to do anything they don't think you're capable of. If you do as they ask, it is because you admire and respect them and want to be like them, rather than because you have to or you fear the consequences. This is how I see good leadership to be like, and I think a similar relationship can be transferred across between horse and rider. Good leadership should should be about choice.
It should be, I agree - for humans and horses. Thinking of leadership in your terms stands a much better chance of a favourable outcome. The only place where I don't think it translates directly (though it does in spirit) to horses is admiration and respect, because they don't have those same thought processes and attitudes.
 
It should be, I agree - for humans and horses. Thinking of leadership in your terms stands a much better chance of a favourable outcome. The only place where I don't think it translates directly (though it does in spirit) to horses is admiration and respect, because they don't have those same thought processes and attitudes.

I agree. :)

I think their primary concern is personal safety and security, and having their basic needs in terms of relationships, food, shelter, etc met.

x
 
newrider.com