Too fat for a pony?!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Most of the UK natives will laugh at your weight, and scuttle off not knowing you are up there. Old woman, don't forget to aff the weight of that enormous pack saddle to your 20 stone stag! :D :D

I did mention the heavy bulky packsaddle and all its rigging, but only in passing, as i didn't want to unnecessarily annoy people who think a full-grown Highlander is being ill-used when asked to carry a 12-stone adult.

shandy84 said:
perhaps you should get a step for tacking/mounting, I need one for mine and have no problems using it

At the age of almost 70, having arthritis and being barely 5ft tall, I do of course need - and have - a mounting block for my 15.1hh mare. As I usually ride 10 -15 miles a day and often more, over rough countryside with gated roads and cattle-grids to negotiate, I would love you to explain to me just how I can carry this mounting block round the countryside with me. it seems much more sensible to me to eventually replace my mare with something at least 2 hands shorter, and who I will be able to mount without having to clamber up gates and walls and trees like an arthritic monkey.
 
clamber up gates and walls and trees like an arthritic monkey.

LOL, Oldwoman you have now managed to create in my head this dreadful image of you, stoppit! :D :D
 
At the age of almost 70, having arthritis and being barely 5ft tall, I do of course need - and have - a mounting block for my 15.1hh mare. As I usually ride 10 -15 miles a day and often more, over rough countryside with gated roads and cattle-grids to negotiate, I would love you to explain to me just how I can carry this mounting block round the countryside with me. it seems much more sensible to me to eventually replace my mare with something at least 2 hands shorter, and who I will be able to mount without having to clamber up gates and walls and trees like an arthritic monkey.[/QUOTE]
I don't know if it would help you but I have a thing that fits into the stirrup but folds up pocket sized for when I'm out riding. Its basically 2 weighted flattish bars with webbing straps that hold them together, not a brilliant description, sorry. You slid it sideways into the stirrup and as the weighted bars are wider than the stirrup it doesn't fall out then you use the lower bar as a stirrup to mount. I needed it for remounting from the floor, as I'm not very agile anymore, when I had a 17'2 that I rode sidesaddle. I had just pressed submit when I remembered where I bought the stirrup mount! They still sell them on Robinsons website and they're £5.50.
 
Last edited:
Old Woman personally I don't dismount when out and about hence no requirement for a step out of the yard but there are portable stirrup extensions you can buy from Robinsons etc.

I have a traditional native breed from the UK and she is in enormous pain due to being ridden by people too large for her because I also followed the bandwagon of she's a native so she'll be fine, some aren't able to carry massive weights some are, but personally I would put the welfare of the horse before my own wish to convenience myself with a smaller horse.
 
I would put the welfare of the horse before my own wish to convenience myself with a smaller horse.


As would we all, but there are a lot of smaller horses out there perfectly able to carry a larger person and totally unsuitable for a child.
 
bevy, I know the thing you mean, and I am afraid it does not work for me - as the stirrup + extension has to be so low down for me to get my foot up to it, I am then too low down to be able to even scramble ungracefully up to the saddle and 'get my leg over'. Some sort of portable winch system, or a folding rope-ladder, might work with it, but a smaller horse is a much simpler proposition all round!
 
I also followed the bandwagon of she's a native so she'll be fine
Nobody has said anything of the sort on this thread.

some aren't able to carry massive weights some are
Who are you to accuse people of 14 stone and thereabouts being 'massive' weights? Because that is the sort of weight we are talking about. Utter piffle!

but personally I would put the welfare of the horse before my own wish to convenience myself with a smaller horse.
And what has anyone said that makes you feel that anyone is considering not putting the welfare of the horse before their own convenience?
 
I am only telling of my own experience that not ALL british natives are suitable for larger weights, I also acknowledge that some are, however people were quick to slap chelseas suggestions because she is not british she is however in relation to some british native breeds correct.

I would suggest that there are few native breeds that would happily carry the 16stone of the OPs OH easily, I did not say that no pony would be suitable but do feel it would be against the best interests of the pony to push its weight limits to the max as you then end up with a pony in pain which is the situation I find with my mare, you see I don't speak from inexperience with regards to british native breeds.

However a well conformed mature but not old pony of the breeds already suggested are the most suitable for this situation. I however do not see the real difference between riding a 14.2hh highland and a 15.1hh cob both will be as difficult to mount realistically as there is very little in the height.
 
I'm 5ft4 (.9!) and my pony is 14hh and I'm about 89kg. Her loaner is much lighter than me, but she seems to work well with both of us.

The pony herself :D (14hh and of some fell/dales sort).
hall5.png


Me riding
Rosehill-logpilejump.jpg


She honestly can cope well, but as she gets older and I visit her, I'd like to be lighter. Just to make her life easier.
 
I am only telling of my own experience that not ALL british natives are suitable for larger weights...

Now you are being ridiculous! Where and when on this thread has anyone said that 'all' native breeds can carry a 16 stone tall man? I would suggest, nowhere and never! I don't think the OP stated her husband's desire to strap rollerskates to his feet while he sits astride one of Wally's Shetlands ...

I would suggest that there are few native breeds that would happily carry the 16stone of the OPs OH easily,

And I would suggest that of the native breeds which are commonly around 14hh, the height desired by the OP, the majority of them are indeed very suitable weight carriers for the OP and her OH.

Lets see - Highland, Fell, Dales, Wesh Sec D, New Forest, Connemara ... at least the first four out of the six (ie MOST) are indeed excellent weight-carriers. I understand the Irish Connemara Society is trying to move away from the more showy, sports pony type, back to the traditional type who would have happily carried a farmer out hunting for a day or two a week, and there is a section in the NF breed show, I believe, for weight-carriers, although possibly not 16 stone.

you then end up with a pony in pain which is the situation I find with my mare, you see I don't speak from inexperience with regards to british native breeds.

Quite - I can clearly see that you speak from experience with ONE individual pony who is a member of ONE of the native breeds. I am an Englishwoman. An Englishwoman won Miss World once - does that make me a raving beauty? One of them won the Nobel prize, too - does that make me an egghead? :D I wish!

I however do not see the real difference between riding a 14.2hh highland and a 15.1hh cob both will be as difficult to mount realistically as there is very little in the height.

I am not tall enough to reach into standard-height wall hung kitchen cabinets. By having them hung a mere TWO INCHES - half a hand!- lower, it is realistic for me to be able to reach into them easily and safely. The difference in height is small, the difference in ease is large.
If the OP is going to be looking at a pony of 14hh- 14.1hh, we are talking about a 4 - 5 inch difference, which I assure you can make the difference between 'ease' and 'difficulty'.
 
The difference between a 36" pony and a 42" (6 inches) is HUGE. really it is. I would NEVER ask Whiffy 36" to pull the 4 wheeler with 4 folk in it on her own. But Andy at 41.5 can do it all day.
 
My pony is a newforest personally very few I meet I would suggest being ridden by someone 16stone or thereabouts it borders on cruel for some breeds to be ridden by excessively heavy people.

I mean to be honest between as in my example a 14.2 and a 15.1 there is very little difference the OP is not a sufferer of arthritis or any dehabilitating injury to make her mounting harder, so why risk back pain in a pony when there are horses out there that are suitable (obv as already stated larger Fells, Highlands should be fine) or loose weight before purchasing the horse so you know you are well within the relms of its capabilities. I personally wouldn't risk a ponies health in this way
 
Last edited:
I am 14 stone and I have a 15hh cob who carries me just fine. He is not nearly as heavy as your average highland - who could carry me, my luggage, a picnic and (this one's for you Old Woman) a strategically strapped on milk crate for mounting:).

Original poster - please dont be put off by certain members on here who know (or think) they know it all:)
 
A Highland would do your job fine. Get yourself over to the Highland pony Enthusiasts web forum where you will be made very welcome and could talk to lots of Highland owners, many of whom will be on the chunky side themselves.

Fab ponies Highlands, as are Dales, Welsh, Fells, Exmoors........etc Aren't we lucky to have them?
 
I am not far off the OP weight and I have a 14hh Welsh D x who carries me without batting an eyelid. (wouldn't want anything bigger being only 5ft tall I'd have no hope of mounting up on anything taller)

I also used to own her mother who was a welsh D standing at 14.1hh and she was built like a tank and would easily have carried both OP and her O/H with no trouble.

I think it's about time people stopped trying to make us larger ladies think we are too big for ponies....most of our larger native breeds were bred to carry full gown men over all terrains so they shouldn't struggle at all with us ladies of a fuller figure!!
 
I'm sorry but I agree with Shandy. 16stone, plus a saddle and clothes will probably be thereabouts 17stone. Do I think this fair on the pony's size you have in mind? No. If you want the pony to be in discomfort, which I very much doubt you do, then go ahead and buy a pony of that size but you are going to get in a whirlwind of back problems and joint problems.

There are horses out there 15-16hh who wouldn't hurt a feather, who wouldn't barge or be difficult to handle. I suggest you have a good look at horses who are taller and more capable to carry weights such as those of you and your husband at ease.
 
I mean to be honest between as in my example a 14.2 and a 15.1 there is very little difference the OP is not a sufferer of arthritis or any dehabilitating injury to make her mounting harder, so why risk back pain in a pony when there are horses out there that are suitable (obv as already stated larger Fells, Highlands should be fine) or loose weight before purchasing the horse so you know you are well within the relms of its capabilities. I personally wouldn't risk a ponies health in this way

There is no way the OP is risking the ponies health - just coz one TB is slow does not make the breed unsuitable for racing so just coz your pony can't carry weight doesn't mean others of the same breed can.

And just to let you know, there is a huge difference between a 14.2 and a 15.1 - not just height but in the way they ride and personality as well and extra height does not equal extra weight carrying ability. I have expereince of this every day as I ride my ponies ranging from 13.1 to my 15.3 warmblood
and everything inbetween and that little inch makes a hell of a lot of difference.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
newrider.com